Broken: A Mountain Man's Romance

by Mia Ford, Bella Winters

“I would expect nothing less of you,” I said, chuckling. “I choose Dare.”

  “Are you sure?”

  “Absolutely, give me your best shot.” I smiled.

  “I dare you to strip down naked and do twenty pushups while keeping an egg balanced on your ass,” she said triumphantly.

  “Is that the best you can do?” I teased. “I thought you were a beast at this game.”

  “I’m just warming up, baby, so take it all off and get to pushing,” she said, snapping her fingers. “Or are you too scared to show your physical prowess to the group?”

  “When have you ever known me to be shy when it comes to getting naked? I have always said that clothes are an unnecessary societal norm.” I laughed. “Hell, I work out naked all the time. That is why we have a gym in the house.”

  She smiled at me as I stood up and started to take off my clothes. I could see Kristin and Jessica’s eyes widen as I lifted up my shirt and purposely flexed my muscles in the light of the fire. When my pants dropped to the floor, there was a collective clearing of the throat and shift in seating. I liked how it felt to have their eyes on me again. It had been a really long time.

  “I’ll get the egg,” Kristin said, jumping up and running toward the kitchen.

  I stood there completely naked, listening to Kristin rummaging around in the fridge. When she rounded the corner holding an egg proudly in her hand, I smiled and assumed the position, looking up into Amber’s eyes as I lowered myself to the ground. Kristin walked over and gently placed the egg on the small indention that my ass made when I was flexing, making sure it was balanced before I began. I lowered myself to the floor and then pushed myself back up, looking over at Jessica with a coy smile. Up and down, I took my body, moving as slowly and intentionally as possible to give them a show. I kept my body stiff and my ass tight as I worked up a sweat next to the fire. Kristin started counting out loud, and Amber, Matt and Jessica joined in with the countdown. I was pretty impressed at the fact that the egg didn’t really roll around very much, and at the end of it, as my ass released, Kristin reached down and caught the egg before it could roll off.

  As I reached that twenty pushup mark, everyone started applauding and cheering me on. I laid there on my stomach until the egg was fully secured and then pushed myself up and onto my knees. The muscles in my arms were twitching slightly since I hadn’t done pushups in God knows how long. Most of my upper body mass came from fucking my wife and holding her up in the shower every morning. Kristin clapped loudly, nodding her head in approval. She dropped down on her knees and wrapped her arms around my neck, pushing her body against mine. She winked at me as she came in close and pressed her lips against mine, kissing me passionately in front of everyone. Her tongue flickered inside of my mouth, and as she pulled back, she sucked hard on my bottom lip, bringing my cock to full attention. I knew she did that on purpose, and now, I had a raging hard-on.

  She pulled away and smiled, wiping her lips and sitting back down by the fireplace. I shook my head and walked over next to her. Amber and Jessica were staring at me, moving their eyes up and down my body, mostly stopping at my rock-hard cock. I wanted to fuck both of them, so feeling their hungry eyes on my body was not helping me rid myself of my erection. Eventually, I just accepted that it was inevitable at that point and went with it. I sat down on the floor, cross-legged, not even giving a damn about putting clothes back on. I figured with this kind of game going, it would only be a matter of time until I was naked again. I grabbed my pants and draped them over my lap, covering up my boner and breaking the trances Amber and Jessica had that were focused on my cock. I would find it comical except for the fact that I wanted to fuck them, making it hard to ignore my dick as it pulsed between my legs. I was definitely not used to not being immediately taken care of.

  “Alright, Amber,” I said with a smile. “Truth or dare?”

  I tried to hide a laugh when I looked up to find her sitting there with flushed cheeks and glazed-over eyes. She almost had the same look that she did after an all-night fuck-a-thon when she had experienced orgasm after orgasm. Only this time, she had yet to come, at least for me that was.

  “Earth to Amber.” I laughed.

  “Huh?”

  “Truth or dare,” I said, smiling.

  “Oh, uh, truth,” she replied.

  “Are you sure?”

  “Yeah,” she scoffed. “I’m not good at pushups.”

  “Okay then,” I said, trying to decide what question to ask her. “Are you turned on right now?”

  I knew that it would cause her to be embarrassed, but for a girl like Amber, you had to push her to the edge before she threw herself into something. Once she did, though, it was all or nothing for the girl, and she could get pretty damn wild. Amber’s eyes widened with the question, and her mouth dropped open. Matt reached around her from behind and cupped both of her breasts, looking as if he were studying his subject

  “Yep, her nipples are definitely hard,” he said, nodding and squeezing her tits.

  “Whatever,” Amber said as she slapped Matt’s hands away and started to laugh nervously. “Hard nipples don’t prove anything when there is a damn blizzard going on outside of this cabin. Who knows? I could just be getting cold again.”

  “With that fire?” Matt laughed and pointed at the huge flames.

  “Personally, I think that you should just admit it,” Kristin said. “I mean, this is the weekend of truths, right? It’s okay. You are in a safe space.”

  “I am not falling for that bullshit again,” Amber said, laughing. “You got me once, but you won’t get me again. I have been honest this whole time, but this is where I guess I am going to have to fail at Truth or Dare. Besides, there is no way for you to actually prove that I am turned on.”

  “I don’t know,” Matt said, putting his arms around her again and sliding his hands toward her crotch. “I am pretty sure I can think of a way to find out.”

  “Alright, alright, Jesus,” she said, slapping Matt’s hand away and scooting forward. “Yes, I am turned on. Incredibly so, actually. My panties are sopping wet, and my tits are rock-solid. There, are you happy now? I have professed my horniness to the world.”

  “Yes,” Kristin said, satisfied. “I am happy now.”

  “Okay, it’s my turn now,” Amber said. “Austin, I think it’s time you got in on some of this fun. You have been way too quiet. What do you say? Truth or dare?”

  “Truth,” he said, leaning up in his chair.

  “Really?” Jessica groaned and rolled her eyes. “You seriously need to step out of that red, white, and blue bubble and live a little. Become a more adventurous man, and do something crazy for a change. I promise there are no secret cameras here.”

  “Truth,” Austin repeated, shaking his head.

  “Alright, have you ever had a threesome before, with or without Jessica?” she asked, wiggling her eyebrows. “And you have to be honest because we all have been.”

  “No,” Austin said, shaking his head. “Honestly, I have never had a threesome before. I don’t even think I have come even remotely close to having a threesome. One girl was always too much for me to handle, especially this fireball. I never wanted to add another to the mix.”

  “Have you ever thought about it?” Amber was pushing him.

  “I’ve already answered my question,” Austin said, frowning.

  “I think the man does protest too much,” Kristin said, laughing.

  “Jessica,” Austin said, shrugging his shoulders. “Truth or Dare?”

  Chapter 21

  Jessica

  It was really starting to irritate me that even after all the talking we had done, Austin was still refusing to take a chance. He was sticking to the safest route possible in every game and not opening up at all. I had a few drinks at that point and was feeling more than a little warm and really good. Fuck it. I might as well admit it to myself. I was also aroused as hell. Watching Jason doing those pushups had my juices rushing down betwe
en my thighs, and I could feel my mound pulsing, making it a little bit uncomfortable for me to sit still. I wanted to get laid, to get fucked really hard and really good, and not just by Austin, by the whole crew.

  “Alright, let me see, Truth or Dare,” I replied, mulling over the decision in my head. “I choose Dare.”

  I wanted to show Austin that having fun and being a little daring was not a bad thing. I was really hoping that he would push the envelope and ask me to do something a little crazy. I knew he had it in him. It was just getting it to come out that was the problem, especially with as uptight as he had to be all day, every day.

  “I dare you to run outside into the storm, grab a handful of snow, and shove it down your pants,” he said, chuckling. “All the way. Not just down the front.”

  I looked at him for several moments with a smirk on my face. He could tell that I was up to something, and I loved the concern that flooded him. I stood up and looked around at the others, deciding that it was now or never.

  “I’ll do one even better,” I said.

  I started taking off my clothes, pausing and smiling at Austin’s shocked look. I pulled my shirt over my head, tossed it to the side, and unhooked my bra, letting my firm tits bounce out. I slowly took my pants off, bending over and giving everyone a view as I stepped out of them. I tossed my panties in the pile and ran for the door, enjoying the appreciative glances I was getting from the rest of the group. Austin might be shocked, but I knew that he was secretly enjoying this. I stopped at the door and flung it open, racing out off the porch and into the snow before I could feel the cold hit me hard. I was really hoping that everyone was watching from the window when I threw myself back down into the frosty wonderland. I moved my arms up and down, creating a naked snow angel.

  As soon as I stopped, the cold hit me in the face like a ton of bricks. I jumped up and screamed, running back into the house and closing the door. As I turned around, everyone erupted into applause and cheers. I ran over to the fire and huddled down next to the flames, smiling over at Kristin who was shaking her head in approval. Austin stood up and threw another log on the fire before looking down at me.

  “Why did you feel the need to above and beyond?”

  “Because I want to have fun,” I said, exasperated. “I want to live a little, get a little wild, make some memories that we will not be able to forget.”

  “And catch pneumonia in the process,” Jason said, laughing, but quickly shutting up at the look on Austin’s face.

  He shrugged his shoulders and walked back over to where we were sitting. He picked up my clothes and handed me the pile, sighing before turning and walking back to his seat. The fire had already warmed me, so I pulled on my panties but left the rest of my clothes off. I wanted to be more adventurous, really break out of the comfort zone that I had built for myself living in the suburban life that Austin and I had created. I knew that the whole idea of getting wild turned Austin on. I could see it in his eyes. At that point, all I had to do was convince him to give it a try, to loosen his metaphorical tie, and to let himself act on the fantasies that I knew were blowing through his mind, even if he wouldn’t admit it. It was now my turn, and since I was trying to get Austin out of his shell, I decided to just go all out and risk it. The worst that could happen was Austin got upset and stopped playing the game. At least, then I would know where he stood.

  I knew right then and there that there was only one person that I could enlist to help me with this, and that was Kristin. She was all about breaking people out of their shells. I could tell she had been holding back with Austin out of respect for me, but now it was time for her to let it all go.

  “Kristin,” I said coyly. “Truth or Dare?”

  “Dare,” she said, predictably.

  “Perfect,” I replied. “I dare you to kiss Austin, with tongue.”

  Austin’s eyes widened, but he didn’t move as Kristin came forward. She moved close, her body prowling like she was a cat. She wrapped her arms around his neck and pulled his head down to hers, kissing him passionately. It was a long, slow kiss that was so hot that it left me breathless and panting by the time she pulled away from him. I knew she was exactly the girl to get Austin to open up. Kristin had always been an excellent kisser, and I was hoping it was going to have the effect on my husband that I was really hoping for. The good thing about trying to get my husband to be more adventurous was the fact that I had at least two really open people with me that could do a little convincing of their own.

  When they finally broke apart, I could see Austin’s massive erection pressing against his pants. It was throbbing and pulsing, and I could tell that he really liked the taste of Kristin’s lips. Not that I blamed him. She was fucking smoking hot all the time. Good, now I just had to make Austin acknowledge the fact that he was finding Kristin and the whole situation completely desirable. I had to get him to say out loud that he wanted to go with this, that he was just as turned on as everyone else, instead of holding it all on the inside.

  It was now Kristin’s turn, which I loved because she really knew how to push the envelope. She looked around the room, her eyes bouncing between Amber and Matt. Finally, her gaze stopped on Matt, and she smiled.

  “Matt, I choose you,” Kristin said, pointing at him. “Truth or Dare?”

  “Dare,” Matt said without hesitation.

  I scanned his sexy body and stopped at his crotch, noticing that he too now had a massive erection. He was the only one in the room that I hadn’t experienced in some way, and I was curious about how big his dick really was. I caught Kristin glancing over at me as she thought about his dare, and I kind of hoped that she dared him to do something to me.

  “I dare you to take off Jessica’s panties using only your mouth,” she said, folding her arms. “That means you have to put your arms behind your back, and no cheating. I’m sure Jessica will lay down for you to make it easier.”

  Matt looked at Kristin and then over to Amber for her approval. Amber smiled at him and nodded, obviously just as into this as Kristin and I were. Personally, I was more than excited to feel his head down between my legs, even if it was only to take off my panties. I was already extremely aroused, but when I glanced over at Austin, I saw concern written all over his face. The poor guy was still struggling with his inability to let it all go and just be free to enjoy the circumstances. I couldn’t be upset with him. That was how he lived his life, cautious and safe, and although it was one of the traits that I admired the most in him, I needed him to forget about all of that for a while. I walked over and kneeled next to Austin, kissing him on the cheek and whispering into his ear.

  “I love you very much,” I said. “Just relax, sit back, and enjoy the show, knowing that all I can think about is fucking your big cock.”

  As I stood up to walk away, I ran my hand over his erection, listening to him groan softly. I smiled and looked over at Matt, who was drawing closer. I sat down on the low table and spread my legs apart to give him access. He put his hands behind his back and smiled up at me as he inched forward to the table and began to bend over. As his mouth drew close to me, I could feel his breath warm on my mound. I knew right then that my panties were going to be completely soaked through. He moved farther, up dragging his chin across my pussy, making me flinch slightly. He managed to grip the waistband of my panties in his teeth, and slowly and carefully, he tugged my panties off, until he could pull them off of my feet. I could barely move, wanting to feel his mouth just plow through my juicy pink pussy. At that point, everyone began clapping breaking the silence that was between Matt and me. Austin, however, sat there not clapping, and I wondered what he was thinking.

  Matt held my panties up in the air victoriously, winking at Amber before turning back toward me, taking a whiff of them, and handing them back to me with a very sexy look on his face. Instantly, our eyes locked, and I could feel the spark of electricity shoot from the tip of my toes, up into my chest. I hadn’t had that feeling from anyone other than Au
stin in a really long time. I had learned long ago there was difference between the spark of lust and the butterflies you got with an emotional attachment. That feeling with Matt was most definitely the spark of lust trying to take me over completely. He could see just how wet my panties were, letting him know that having him that close to me was something that I didn’t mind in the least. The entire day had been a culmination of events that had brought me to that point, and I was starting to get a little woozy from the amount of lust that was boiling up in my stomach. I imagined Matt walking forward, whipping his cock out, and fucking me right there on the table in front of everyone. I was yearning to feel his dick, to know just how much he filled me up, and to know what Amber got to feel every time he fucked her.

  My eyes scanned Matt’s body and landed on the hard cock inside of his pants. The thing was huge and practically throbbing against the material. It was screaming to him to let it out to play, and I was more than willing to be his playland for a while. He smiled and reached his hand down, pulling me off the table and back onto my feet before turning and walking back to Amber. He kissed her gently and then looked back over at me, watching my breasts as they bounced. As I walked back over to the couch to sit down next to Austin, I couldn’t wait to find out what was going to happen next. Things seemed like they were just heating up.

  Chapter 22

  Austin

  I watched as my wife walked back over toward me, her beautiful naked body on display for everyone. She sat down, and I handed her part of the blanket, but all she did was cover part of her leg. I could tell that she was really enjoying pushing the envelope. I wasn’t sure how to feel about another man being that close to my wife, even if it was Matt, and even if his wife was sitting across the room watching. At first, I felt a fit of jealousy and possessiveness that I had never felt before in our marriage. Up to that point, I had never really had any reason to feel jealous or possessive because we rarely let single people into our circle of friends. Then, however, I could see how turned on Jessica was. Watching her writhe and suffer under the grasp of Matt’s mouth was actually pretty fucking hot. I thought to myself that maybe Jessica was right. Maybe I should relax for once and do something that I knew I wanted.