Mallets Aforethought

by Sarah Graves

  Synopsis:

  Jacobia “Jake” Tiptree left her high-powered career for a dilapidated fixer-upper and the dream of a quiet existence in the quaint town of Eastport, Maine. But she found that no matter how carefully you remodel your life, murder can take up residence anywhere.

  It’s Eastport’s most notorious landmark: the old Harlequin House. Named for the disgraced physician Chester Harlequin, it was used as a hideout for gunshot gangsters and their molls during Prohibition’s heyday. Now fixer-upper enthusiast Jake Tiptree and Harlequin’s only living descendant, Ellie White, are refurbishing the mansard-roofed mansion to host the local Historical Society’s upcoming gala. But when stripping down old wallpaper reveals a secret door to a room containing not one but two corpses, Jake and Ellie once again find home repair leading to homicide.

  One of the bodies is a skeleton dressed in 1920s flapper chic. But the other is that of real-estate mogul Hector Gosling, and in his pocket is a paper bearing the single word “Guilty.” The less-than-scrupulous tycoon has been poisoned, and when it’s learned that the offending substance is the poison that Ellie’s husband George has been using to kill red ants, he is immediately taken into custody. Then it develops that George had recently accused Gosling of a scheme to scam George’s vulnerable old aunt out of her life savings — and George out of his inheritance.

  With George held for murder, Jake and a pregnant Ellie swing into action. In between Ellie’s Lamaze sessions, baby showers, and CPR classes taught by Jake’s ex-husband Victor, the two amateur sleuths must sift their way through a trail of seemingly contradictory clues. Then another corpse surfaces and suddenly Jake and Ellie realize they must find this killer fast. A clever culprit is not only building an airtight case against Ellie’s husband. He — or she — is planning to nail everyone who stands in the way.

  Mallets Aforethought

  Sarah Graves

  The seventh book in the Home Repair is Homicide Mysteries series

  Chapter 1

  The body was all withered sinews and leathery skin, seated on a low wooden chair in the tiny room whose door my friend Ellie White and I had just forced open. Slumped over a table, one arm outstretched, the body wore a sequined chemise whose silver hem-fringe crossed its mummified thigh.

  Masses of bangles circled the knobby wrists and rings hung loosely on the long bony fingers. From beneath black bobbed hair the hollow eye sockets peeked coyly at us, the mouth a toothy rictus of mischief.

  Or malice. A candle burnt down to a puddled stub stood in an ornate holder by the body’s arm. A tiaralike headpiece with a glass jewel in its bezel had fallen to the floor.

  Ellie and I stood frozen for a moment, neither of us able to speak for the horridness of the surprise. Then:

  “Oh,” breathed Ellie, sinking heavily into the window seat of the dilapidated parlor we’d been working on. It was Saturday morning and around us the aging timbers of Eastport’s most decrepit old mansion, Harlequin House, creaked uneasily.

  Only the wind, I told myself. Outside it was blowing a gale. But the fact brought little comfort, since after a century or so without maintenance, the old mansion’s skeleton was probably less sturdy than the body we were staring at. Being sealed in the room had apparently preserved it like some denizen of King Tut’s tomb.

  “A woman,” Ellie added, her voice still faint with shock.

  “Yes,” I responded, sniffing the air curiously. Thinking… something. I just didn’t know exactly what, yet.

  The parlor was lit by a couple of lamps we’d brought from home, the power in the house having been turned on only the day before. This morning was meant to be a work party but it seemed the storm had discouraged all but the two of us. Around us lay damp swathes of stripped wallpaper and the scrapers and putty knives we’d been using to pull down chunks of cracked plaster.

  It was behind one of those cracks we’d first found the faint outlines of a hidden aperture, and of course a secret door had been irresistible. Who wouldn’t want to learn what lay behind it, where it might lead?

  But now I reentered the chamber cautiously. Its air smelled of the dust to which its occupant had partially returned, and of something else, the faint whiff I’d caught earlier: not dusty.

  Not in the slightest. The lamplight barely reached the back of the little room. As my eyes adjusted to the gloom there, I made out the shape in the corner.

  And identified it, wishing I hadn’t.

  “Let’s get out of here,” I said, exiting hurriedly.

  “Don’t worry, I’m fine,” said Ellie, misunderstanding me. “I just felt strange for a minute.”

  Her speedy recovery was little more than I expected. Ellie wasn’t usually much daunted by dead bodies, antique or otherwise. Her shaky reaction to this one I put down to the fact that at the moment she was as pregnant as a person could be without actually wheeling into the delivery room.

  “Help me… oof!… up.” Gripping my hand, she struggled to her feet. “I swear this isn’t a kid, it’s a Volkswagen.”

  “Only a little longer,” I comforted her distractedly, still staring into the hidden room.

  “It’d better be,” she retorted. “If this baby doesn’t come soon I’m going to start charging it rent.”

  There were two bodies in there.

  “Lots,” she emphasized, “of rent.”

  One old body. And a new one. “Ellie, have you ever heard any stories about another door into this room?”

  She could have, if one existed. An ancestor on Ellie’s mother’s side, Chester Harlequin, had owned the house in its heyday.

  “No.” She peered puzzledly at me. With her red hair softly framing a heart-shaped face, green eyes above freckles the color of gold dust, and a long slim body blooming out at the middle like some enchanted flower, Ellie resembled a storybook princess and was as tough as Maine granite.

  But she was in trouble now and she didn’t even know it.

  Yet.

  “I’d never even heard of this one,” she added. “I have seen photographs of this parlor, though, back when—”

  Her gesture took in the ramshackle interior wall where the door had been concealed, its trim removed and panels smoothed over by a coat of plaster topped with the same fusty vines-and-grape-leaves pattern as the rest of the ornate old chamber.

  “—the wallpaper was new,” she said. “Last time this room was redone was sometime back in the twenties.”

  Although when it was hung, that paper had probably looked ultramodern. In its time Harlequin House had been a showplace, with parquet floors, marble mantels, and chandeliers so grand and numerous that the house for a while was dubbed “the crystal palace.”

  Why someone had also walled a body up in it was a question I supposed might never be answered—not after more than eighty years. Which I guessed was truly how long the woman had been dead; the state of the plaster, the wallpaper, and the body’s own costume all testified to it pretty convincingly.

  Yet there were no additional obvious entrances to the room, and the inner walls were all of unplastered boards. Any break in them, however well repaired, would have been clearly visible. In short it appeared that the room had been sealed since the first body was entombed. So how’d the second one gotten in there?

  “I know her,” Ellie said suddenly. “I’ve seen old pictures of her wearing the dress and the tiara. It’s Eva Thane, the woman my Uncle Chester was… So that’s what happened to her.”

  “Ellie, wait.” She’d gotten her wind back and was about to reenter the room, her shock giving way to the curiosity that was among her most prominent character traits.

  “Why?” she demanded impatiently. “I want a closer look at . . .”

  Then she understood, or tho
ught she did. “But you’re right of course, a flashlight will help.” She drew one from her smock pocket.

  The windowless room was enclosed on all sides with a center hall at its rear, kitchen to its left, the parlor plus a vestibule and coatroom to its front and right. The house was so huge that a square of missing space wouldn’t be missed, especially tucked as it was to one side of an enormous black marble fireplace.

  Ellie aimed the flash past me and sucked in a surprised breath. “Him,” she exhaled, recognizing the dead face instantly just as I had, despite the unpleasantness of its disfigurement.

  But having been unnerved once, Ellie was not about to show faintheartedness a second time. “Well,” she continued briskly, “this certainly isn’t going the way we planned.”

  Which was an understatement. Begun just today, the Harlequin House fix-up was supposed to be a labor of love. Assisted by a small army of local volunteers, we were to ready the old dwelling for a gala put on by the Eastport Historical Society, and in doing so perhaps up the chances that someone—anyone!—might actually take the place off the Society’s impoverished hands afterwards.

  And the first corpse, I thought, might even have helped. A long-dead flapper from the Roaring Twenties could have been just the hook this old money-pit needed to snag the attention of a buyer with cash vastly exceeding common sense.

  But the newer body was of more than historical interest.

  Way more. “We have a problem, don’t we?” Ellie said.

  She was starting to catch on. Eva Thane’s antique corpse dropped off her mental radar as a new and more unpleasant light dawned.

  “ ’Fraid so,” I agreed unhappily. The dead man was Hector Gosling, Eastport’s most irascible real-estate mogul as well as the current president of the historical society. His face was smudged with grime, as were his clothes, a condition that would have been unthinkable while Hector was alive. But even filthy and hideously exaggerated as it was now, that furious teeth-baring grimace was an all-too-familiar expression.

  Combined with his position, however—feet and head on the floor, midsection arched tautly, agonizingly up like a drawn bow—Hector’s look didn’t say fury or anything like it.

  What it said, unfortunately, was strychnine.

  I am the type who goes more for structural guts than shelter-magazine glory, so if Harlequin House had been mine I’d have started renovation with the underpinnings, the wooden sills and the foundation. At the same time I’d be tearing off the roof, all the trim, and the chimneys and siding. All the windows would come out, too, as would the wiring, plumbing, and heating. Inside, I’d pull down every last bit of the cracked, ancient plaster, and fix all the lath.

  Only when the house sat four-square on its footings with its mechanicals updated, its windows made weathertight, insulation layered onto it, and its new trim and clapboards coated with oil-based primer and paint would I even give a thought to wallpaper.

  Whereupon I would reject it. These old houses have been smothering in garish floral patterns and gloomy scenic designs for long enough, in my opinion. They need paint in a nice light color scheme, off-white woodwork, and freshly sanded floors.

  But as I say, the house didn’t belong to me. So for a little while Ellie and I went on puttering and pondering, deciding what we would say when we summoned the authorities.

  And what might need doing afterwards.

  “I mean, George and I have a problem. But mostly George does,” Ellie said. “Or he might have.”

  At last we gathered our tools and arranged them on some newspapers at the center of the room. I’d acquired the “clean up as you go along” habit soon after I bought my own old house and began repairing it.

  “Not,” she added, “that anyone will believe he could’ve . . .”

  “Of course they won’t,” I agreed hastily.

  But privately I wasn’t so sure. Ellie’s husband George was your go-to guy for nearly everything in Eastport. In our little town on Moose Island, seven miles off the Maine coast, George was the man you called if you had bats in the attic, a bad drain, or a pet parrot scared by Fourth of July fireworks into a copper beech tree.

  But George was also Hector Gosling’s worst enemy. Or next-to-worst, after whoever’d murdered the old schemer in this awful manner. Strychnine—the very idea made me shudder.

  “Anyway, I guess we’d better call Bob Arnold,” Ellie said. It was sinking in now, what this discovery could develop into.

  Although, in the call-the-authorities department at least, we were in luck. If anyone knew George’s good character better than Ellie, it was Eastport’s police chief Bob Arnold. So George might still catch the break I already thought he might be needing.

  “I mean we can’t very well just wall Hector up again. Can we?” Ellie asked, briefly hopeful.

  Actually we could have. Powdered lime for Hector, quick-set plaster for that door, fresh wallpaper, and in a few hours we could be sitting pretty in the corpse-concealment department.

  And nobody would ever deliberately go looking for Hector the Objector, so called because no matter what anyone ever wanted to do, he could be counted upon to come up with a dozen reasons why they couldn’t or shouldn’t.

  That is unless they wanted to unload parcels of real estate at fire-sale prices. But . . .

  “No,” I replied grudgingly. “We can’t take the chance. If we hadn’t wrecked the door getting it open, we could say we’d never gotten it open and never seen him. But people will know we’ve been working in here. So now if anyone else ever does find him, we’ll have an awfully hard time explaining ourselves.”

  Oh, it would have been lovely just to walk away and forget him. Poison was too good for Hector, and as for a decent burial, any hallowed soil you tried putting him in would only spit him right back out again the way you would a bad clam.

  “We had better just let Bob get the process in motion,” I told Ellie. State police, medical examiner, crime lab van from Augusta: the whole, as Chief Arnold tended to call it, dog-and-pony show.

  “All right.” Ellie sighed. “We should find George, too, let him know what’s going on.”

  Give him a heads-up, she meant, before some state cop began surprising him with pointed questions. Not that he wouldn’t have all the answers sooner or later, but George always mulled things over a while before supplying any and hesitation would make him into an even better suspect.

  Of course he would be cleared eventually; maybe even soon. But until then I thought he could be in for an uncertain time.

  “He’s at the marine tech center this morning,” Ellie added, “helping drop in new pilings for the dock, and the granite slabs for the boat ramp… mmph!”

  An odd look came over her face. “A Volkswagen,” she gasped wincingly, putting her hand on the fireplace mantel and leaning against it, “that kicks like a mule.”

  As we stepped from under its portico, the windows of Harlequin House peered dourly down at us through a mess of fallen gutters and sagging trim, its mansard roof rotten and the breaks in its wooden gutters home to generations of pigeons. Hunched arm-in-arm we dashed together under wind-whipped maples, unkindly shoved along by gusts bearing rain in overflowing buckets.

  Power lines swung wildly overhead as we rushed through the storm-lashed streets. “I guess,” Ellie gasped, “they won’t be putting that dock in today after all.”

  “If this keeps up they won’t even have to demolish the old one. Yeeks,” I finished, nearly blown off my feet. “You okay?”

  “Fine,” she replied grimly.

  For a woman who was carrying the equivalent of a compact car she was moving right along; when I was waiting for my own son, I was lucky if I could move from a chair to the couch. But she just kept putting one foot in front of the other, and much as I dislike the damage they cause I adore these storms. They’re the closest I’ll ever get to being on the ocean in heavy weather.

  So I risked a glance back toward the bay where rows of white shingled cottages faced br
avely into the gale, shutters rattling and weather vanes aimed stiffly northeast. The sign over the Happy Landings Café swung on its chains as the wind rose to a banshee howl. Gouts of heavy spray burst massively upward, racing waves battered the breakwater, and the stinging rain tasted of sea salt, as trudging forward again we at last caught sight of home.

  My home: the big white 1823 Federal house loomed suddenly out of the storm at us, its many-paned windows gleaming a golden welcome from between green shutters. Water gushed from its downspouts, streamed down its brick chimneys, and sheeted along its clapboard sides as if someone had opened a spillway above it. But thus far it didn’t look as if the sump pump had gone on. No water, I saw with relief, poured from the pipe leading from the cellar window.

  So one thing was going right, anyway. In the driveway a heap of old truck parts hunkered atop mismatched tires.

  “He’s here,” Ellie managed breathlessly, seeing the vehicle.

  George, she meant. We staggered up the porch steps and into the back hall, shedding our wet jackets and sodden hats as my black Labrador, Monday, danced and wagged her tail in joyful greeting.

  “Hi, girl.” I patted her silky head, then reached to bestow equal attention on our red Doberman, Prill, who demanded nothing, adored everything, and received her petting with solemn gravity.

  George was at the kitchen table drinking a cup of coffee and listening to the radio’s report of the storm’s unexpected power. Wearing a green flannel shirt, faded overalls, and battered work boots, he got up quickly when he saw Ellie.

  “Hey, hey,” he said, frowning a sharp question at me as he took charge, guiding her toward a chair. “You look all in.”

  He was the one who appeared exhausted, his chin stubbled and his eyes deeply shadowed with fatigue. He’d been working harder than usual lately to buy things the baby needed and to pay doctor bills, and the strain was beginning to show.