Ghost of the Innocent Man

by Benjamin Rachlin

  De Torres, rising shakily for cross-examination, decided he would address the photographic lineup first. Since Carrie didn’t recognize any of the photographs shown to her nine months earlier by police, none of them should count as evidence, he argued. This would render Carrie’s first identification of his client inadmissible in court, a ruling certain to undermine Grimes having been implicated in the first place. It would also mean Carrie’s only remaining identification of Grimes was the one she could make in person. This de Torres felt sure he could discredit, having just now himself been identified wrongly as her attacker. He asked Carrie whether she recognized the lineup Johnson had held a moment earlier.

  Carrie admitted she hadn’t, but insisted it didn’t matter. “I know the man that beat me,” she told him.

  “Did you recognize any of the photographs you were just shown as the same photographs you were shown by Officer Bryant?”

  “Well, they look the same,” Carrie said. “They were in little blocks like that.” De Torres, unpersuaded, pressed for details. “If you had been through what I had been through,” Carrie scolded him. “They had just brought me from the hospital.”

  “You said that the person who assaulted you took off a shirt,” de Torres noted, changing course. “A green shirt. Did you notice any tattoos, or any marks on his body?”

  “No.”

  “Did you notice any other marks anywhere else on him, other than the mole?”

  “No.”

  This would be valuable later, de Torres knew. For now he had seen enough. “Your Honor,” he urged, turning toward Judge Griffin, “the admission of the photographs, and her identification, should not be allowed in evidence. She does not have the ability to match any photographs with anyone that is here in the courtroom. I think that the photo lineup, and any testimony concerning that, should be suppressed. It should not be admissible in this case at all.”

  Judge Griffin considered this. “All right,” he said. He instructed the court reporter to mark down that a full examination had been conducted, in the absence of the jury, regarding the photographic identification of Willie Grimes. “Based upon the foregoing, the court concludes State Exhibit One”—the photographic lineup—“is hereby excluded from evidence in this trial. However, the witness had ample opportunity to observe the defendant in her home on the night in question, for a considerable length of time. This was sufficient to form a reliable impression of him. The witness had a high degree of concentration, her attention was focused on him, and her observations are a reasonable and accurate description of him. Her certainty is firm and unequivocal. It is now therefore ordered that the defendant’s objection to the photograph identification is allowed. But the identification of the defendant by the witness is competent to be received in trial.”

  Whether Judge Griffin had noticed Carrie’s identification of the wrong man, de Torres couldn’t tell.

  Jurors filed back into court, where Judge Griffin decided they had seen enough for the morning session and recessed for lunch. When they reconvened at two, Johnson decided to let his co-counsel, Jay Meyers, present to Carrie their final questions. Meyers wanted to confirm the presence of a knife. Then, before the jury, he asked whether Carrie could see her assailant in the courtroom today. “Yes, sir,” Carrie told him. Meyers asked that she point the man out. Carrie indicated the defense table. “Right there,” she said.

  “Objection,” de Torres intervened.

  “Overruled,” Judge Griffin told him, and turned toward Carrie. “Let the record reflect that you are pointing to whom?”

  “The one in the red shirt there,” Carrie said.

  “Let the record reflect that the witness pointed out Willie James Grimes,” Judge Griffin announced.

  “That is all,” Meyers said, and sat down.

  Officer Gary Lee, of the Hickory police, had worked the second patrol shift that Saturday in October, from early afternoon until midnight. After receiving a radio call, Officer Lee had arrived to Carrie Elliott’s address at 9:22, where he and a partner first noticed the broken storm door. As his partner secured Carrie’s apartment, Lee radioed patrol cars within reach to warn them of a potential suspect. To do this, he needed to ask Carrie for a description of her assailant. Later he recorded this in his initial crime report.

  Johnson, the assistant district attorney, having reassumed lead responsibility from Meyers, wanted to know the details of that description. “Black male, approximately six feet tall,” Officer Lee recalled. “Weighing between two hundred and two twenty-five. Approximately thirty-five years old. Dark skin and bushy hair.” This amounted to nearly all he and Carrie had discussed that night, since Carrie had been “real distraught,” Lee remembered, and his role was simply to learn the barest version of what had happened and whom to look for. Carrie had also told him that, once her assailant vanished from the apartment, she had crawled toward the back door, locked it, and groped for the telephone. But she couldn’t think of the phone number for the police. Instead, she called her son, whose wife answered. It was she, Carrie’s daughter-in-law, who phoned the police. All this Officer Lee marked in his report, as well as the fact that he’d canvassed the surroundings of Carrie’s apartment and consulted with neighbors to the north and east. No one had seen or heard anything helpful. On item 34 of that report, “Can suspects be ID’ed,” Lee had checked the line beside yes.

  Secure with this timeline, Johnson turned his witness over to de Torres. De Torres asked Officer Lee whether, in Carrie’s account of her assailant that night, she had described what the man was wearing. She had, Lee remembered. Jeans and a green shirt. “Did she indicate anything to you about the mole on his face?” de Torres asked.

  “Not at the time,” Lee answered.

  “That is all,” de Torres said.

  While Lee was canvassing Carrie’s neighborhood that night, Officer Susan Moore, also of the Hickory police, had arrived at the apartment to find Carrie agitated with “evidence of bruising that was starting to appear on her upper arms.” Officer Moore proposed to drive Carrie to Catawba Memorial Hospital, but Carrie declined the offer: Carrie’s son and daughter-in-law had arrived at the apartment by then, and she felt more comfortable traveling with them. Moore agreed to this, then drove behind them to the hospital, where a lengthier interview revealed further details of the assault. Because Moore had departed so soon for the hospital, she hadn’t spent much time at Carrie’s residence—less than five minutes, she estimated. She had barely talked with Gary Lee at all. But she remembered hearing his radioed description of the suspect: a black male, age thirty-five, six feet tall, two hundred pounds or more.

  De Torres, on cross-examination, was curious; during Moore’s interview with Carrie at the hospital, had Carrie mentioned her assailant having a knife? “No,” Moore told him, though she thought it was possible Carrie simply hadn’t thought of it. In Moore’s view, Carrie had been “very distraught.”

  The emergency department physician that night at Catawba Memorial Hospital was Bert Crane, who confirmed the bruising on Carrie’s arms and left shoulder. His records showed Carrie had arrived at the hospital at 9:51. In addition to the bruising, Crane’s examination revealed a painful headache, from Carrie having been pinned during her assault, and a laceration of her posterior vaginal fourchette—a one-inch tear in the vaginal wall. The laceration was recent, Dr. Crane noticed. He agreed Carrie’s injuries matched her description of the preceding hour, and conducted a formal rape examination. This involved collecting samples of Carrie’s head and pubic hair, and vaginal swabs. These Crane packaged into a rape kit and turned over to the police, along with a cardboard box of clothes Carrie had worn during and after the assault. Then he stitched Carrie’s tear and scheduled a follow-up for the coming Monday. By midnight Carrie was discharged, wearing fresh clothes her children had brought her and wrapped in a blanket lent by one of the nurses. Now, in court, her rape kit was introduced as State Exhibit Two. Dr. Crane recognized this as the same one from the hospital, with
his signature on its label. De Torres didn’t have any questions.

  From the hospital, Carrie’s family had driven her to the Hickory police station, where she met again with Officer Moore and her partner, Officer Jeff Blackburn. The pair of them led Carrie down the square department hallway and into a private room, to provide another full account of her assault. The details of this matched what she had shared earlier at the hospital and, before that, at the scene with Gary Lee. Officer Blackburn showed Carrie a lineup sheet with photographs of six men, but she didn’t recognize any of them. Then, rising, Blackburn asked Carrie to compare the suspect’s dimensions to his own. Carrie considered him for a moment, then replied that her assailant had been heavier and a little bit taller. Blackburn himself was six feet tall, a hundred and ninety-five pounds. This too was consistent with what Carrie had reported earlier. That their suspect was a little over six feet and more than two hundred pounds fit Carrie’s previous assessment exactly.

  De Torres wanted to know whether, during this late meeting at the police station, Carrie had mentioned any mole, or scar, on her attacker. Blackburn admitted she hadn’t.

  Two days after her rape, at a few minutes past noon on Monday, Carrie and her daughter-in-law returned unexpectedly to the police station to visit Sergeant Steve Bryant, supervisor of criminal investigations for the Hickory Police Department. Sergeant Bryant recognized Carrie from the previous Saturday, though he hadn’t met her then, and he knew the HPD still had no suspects in her case. Carrie was visiting to share a conversation she’d had with her neighbor Linda McDowell—the same neighbor she had mistakenly guessed was knocking at her door the night of the assault. Since then Linda had stopped by Carrie’s apartment to say she’d heard what had happened, and how sorry she was. The two of them got to talking. Linda thought she recognized Carrie’s description of her attacker. She might know who the man was, Linda allowed, though she refused to give his name to anyone but the police, not even to Carrie herself. Carrie wanted Sergeant Bryant to know this. She also wanted to tell him two additional details she’d remembered from her assault: that the man’s speech had been slurred, as though he were drunk, or spoke with a lisp, and also that he had a mole. Carrie had recalled these facts during her conversation with Linda. She was certain of them. Sergeant Bryant recorded the details in his notes and assured Carrie he would include them in his investigation.

  At four that afternoon, his phone rang. It was Linda McDowell. She knew the man who had assaulted Carrie, Linda told Bryant, but she didn’t want to say his name over the telephone. She also wanted to know if she would get a reward. Recently she had seen advertisements for a local program called Crime Stoppers, and she expected that, if she provided this man’s name, she was entitled to a prize.

  Sergeant Bryant invited Linda to the station. She was there twenty minutes later, at four thirty. Once Bryant had promised the Crime Stoppers reward, a thousand dollars, Linda revealed she knew a man who fit Carrie’s description exactly. He went by either Willie Grimes or Willie Vinson. He also had a street name, Woot. He had a mole on his face—on the left side, Linda thought, though she wasn’t certain. She had seen Willie on the Saturday of Carrie’s rape, wearing a green shirt, in that same neighborhood, Little Berlin. She also knew his address.

  At six fifteen that evening, Sergeant Bryant drove out to Claremont, twenty minutes east on I-40, where Carrie was staying with a sister-in-law. When Bryant arrived, Carrie told him she might have been wrong earlier that afternoon about the placement of her attacker’s mole. It might have been on the left side of his face, not his right. In either case, it was near the corner of his mouth. She was positive. She just couldn’t remember which corner. Bryant showed her a new lineup, different than the one she had seen two days earlier at the police station. In position number two, he had included a photograph of Willie Grimes. This photograph Bryant had discovered on file from a drunk-driving charge in May 1985—before now, one of Grimes’s only two grazes with the law. (The other was also for driving under the influence, three years earlier, in 1982.) For fifteen seconds Carrie considered the new lineup. Then she pointed at Grimes. “This is the man,” she said, and began crying. “This is the man who raped me.”

  Bryant asked if Carrie was certain. She was, Carrie confirmed, though in person Grimes’s hair had been shorter. “I will never forget his face,” she told Bryant. Then she added that Grimes had really hurt her and that, because of the way he had contorted her legs while on top of her, she was even having trouble walking. “What happened to me that night,” she said, “was the worst nightmare I could imagine.”

  De Torres, listening to Sergeant Bryant’s testimony—except for the fact of the Crime Stoppers reward, which Bryant had never been asked about, and never mentioned—realized he had forfeited a valuable argument. Because Carrie had floundered privately to recognize anyone in the photographic lineups, de Torres had succeeded in preventing their introduction to trial. But he knew that, in the lineup Sergeant Bryant had shown to Carrie in Claremont, Grimes was the only man with a mole. This was a problem. Given Carrie’s gradual insistence on her assailant having had a facial mole, any lineup shown to her ought to have included several men who matched this description, or else naturally Carrie would choose the only man who did. It was important this detail be disclosed to the jury, de Torres knew, since it likely had factored into Carrie’s identification of Grimes. De Torres, though, couldn’t say anything about it. The district attorneys had already tried to introduce both lineups at trial, and de Torres had prevented it. Now by his own urging they were inadmissible.

  Instead, jurors heard testimony by Officer Steve Hunt, a criminal investigator in his early thirties, already a thirteen-year veteran of the Hickory police. Hunt himself had grown up nearby in the projects, with eight siblings, a single mother, and his grandmother, who mostly looked after them, since his mother so often was out working one of two jobs. He still cried when he talked about that neighborhood. At five or six years old he had decided to become a police officer; just two years out of high school he’d started on patrol, one of the few black officers on the Hickory force. “I was in the projects,” he would tell people, “but the projects were not in me.” By 1987 he was an investigator.

  Because Hunt was in the habit of switching on his radio while off duty, he heard the call about Carrie that Saturday even though he wasn’t working. He decided to pass by Carrie’s address.

  At one o’clock Sunday morning, a few hours after the assault, Hunt steered down Center Street, perpendicular to Carrie’s apartment. On the pavement he came upon an apple core. Remembering something from the radio about fruit having been taken from the scene, he doubled back to Carrie’s apartment for a look around. On the grass just south of her doorstep he discovered two banana peels, ten or so feet apart. These he left untouched in the yard. The apple core he brought with him to the Hickory station, where, without examining it for fingerprints, he tossed it into the trash. To one or two of his colleagues he mentioned the banana peels he’d seen, but no one went back to retrieve them. The next day, Monday, October 26, when Carrie recognized a photograph in Sergeant Bryant’s lineup, Steve Hunt was put in charge of the case.

  The following day, Hunt visited Grimes’s address, where he lived with a girlfriend.

  Grimes wasn’t home. That afternoon, though, Hunt tracked Grimes down and took him into custody. He fingerprinted Grimes and booked him. In the paperwork, Hunt marked that Grimes was six feet two inches tall, a hundred and sixty-five pounds. In the section for “Scars/Marks/Tattoos,” he recorded that Grimes was missing two fingertips, from the middle and index fingers of his right hand. Especially noticeable was Grimes’s middle finger, where the entire final joint was gone. Carrie had never mentioned either of these. Grimes had a mole, though, near the left side of his mouth. And he was wearing a green sweater. Hunt confiscated this sweater, along with the rest of Grimes’s clothes, and replaced them with a gray jumpsuit for Grimes to wear in his cell.

  De Tor
res, at trial, asked where Grimes’s clothing had gone, because it would be valuable to test for evidence. As far as de Torres knew, this had never happened. “I have no idea,” Hunt told him. That clothing had been turned over to the jailor, and no one had seen it again.

  Because for nearly a decade Jack Holsclaw had served as Hickory’s only evidence technician, his shifts were unusually civilian-like for a police officer: five days a week, from eight thirty to five. For the same reason, however, he remained on call at any hour. The Saturday of Carrie’s assault, he had been phoned at home. When he arrived at Carrie’s address, sometime after nine thirty, only Officer Blackburn was still there, everyone else having left already for the hospital or the station. By then someone had replaced the chain on Carrie’s storm door.

  Holsclaw’s responsibility was to “process the crime scene,” he explained to the court, which meant to gather any items he thought might prove relevant to the case as well as to take a series of photographs. From the kitchen table he collected two bananas and an apple, since Officer Blackburn had mentioned the attacker stealing fruit. From the bedroom he removed a pair of underwear. On the bedspread he found several hair samples; these he sealed inside a plastic bag. Holsclaw also examined the front door for fingerprints but couldn’t find any. Back at the station, though, he lifted two prints from the bananas. A week later, Holsclaw was able to examine them, and to compare them with fingerprints from Willie Grimes, who by then had been arrested. The prints didn’t match. Holsclaw and his colleagues guessed this meant the prints probably belonged to Carrie Elliott. Officers had never taken prints from her, though, so no one ever checked. Neither did Holsclaw think to compare the prints with those of any officer who had visited the scene. Even Steve Hunt, who had booked Grimes himself and then learned a week later of the fingerprints, never followed up to see if each set matched. It was news to him now, hearing Holsclaw testify, that the prints recovered from the scene didn’t belong to Grimes.