by Kiel Nichols
Giving them both an impish smile, she said, “Can I play with you boys?”
Derek grinned. “You bet, sweetheart. Whose team do you want to be on?”
“Why don’t you share me?” she asked silkily.
An expectant pause followed that statement, and then Jake said, “The pitcher needs a refill.” He turned to head back to the bar to tamp down on his libido, and his jealousy.
He only nodded his assent when Derek called out, “Get another glass for Lily, too.”
While he waited for the pitcher to be refilled at the bar, he took deep breaths to try to get his erection under control.
* * * *
“Laying it on a bit thick, aren’t you, doll?” Derek asked.
“I’m trying to get his attention and have him stop looking at me like a child.” Lily did a quick turn. “How do I look?”
“You look smokin’ hot, and you know it, especially with those headlights peeking out.” He gestured to her breasts.
Lily looked down and gasped. “I didn’t think about that.”
Derek grinned. “It’ll drive him crazy.” Then he paused before adding, “You know I’m not having a ménage with you guys, right?”
Lily flushed even harder. “I know that,” she said. “But Jake doesn’t.”
“It’s not that you aren’t gorgeous,” he said, feeling the need to explain himself more so she didn’t think he was rejecting her. “Tom would kill me.”
Lily looked at him sharply. There was something in the tone of his voice. “Derek?” Derek flushed to the roots of his hair, making Lily gasp. “Oh, Derek,” she said in sympathy. “Tom?”
When Jake walked back in, Derek shrugged. “It’s fine. Now what, doll?”
After one more sympathetic look, she said, “Now I get my man.”
She spun away from Derek, putting his problems out of her head for the time being. She pasted on a naughty grin and, when she heard Jake place the pitcher on the table, said, “Who gets me first?”
* * * *
Jake had finally talked his full boner into a semi and returned to the poolroom. He saw Lily and Derek whispering together. She was just a few inches away from him, and he was leaning down as though they were whispering sexy secrets to each other. Jake decided he’d leave after one game of pool. There was no way she was going to watch them flirt then leave together. Just the thought made him want to hit something.
“Why don’t you break?” Derek asked Lily. “You do know how to break, right?”
Lily bit that full lower lip, and Jake’s semi turned into a full erection again. He couldn’t get the fantasy out of his mind of those full lips wrapped around his cock.
“Not really,” she said huskily, but loud enough for Jake to hear. She got into position, and Derek snuggled up behind her, her sweet ass against his crotch. She wiggled a little as she set up the shot and then hit it. She hit the ball too softly, and it barely broke the rack
Derek guided her to reposition behind the cue and said, “Nice and hard now, doll.”
Derek stood back while she took the shot. He was looking at her ass, and Jake could see that his friend was sporting the same wood he was. From his vantage point, Jake could see down her shirt. While her cleavage wasn’t impressive, the sight of the inside curves of her breast made him harder than a spike.
Since she didn’t get any of the balls in, she walked over to Jake. “It’s your turn. Where do you want me?”
Jake’s jaw tightened. He walked her to the cue ball and told her what to hit and how. She was totally misaligned, and he knew if he was ever going to get the hell out of here, he was going to need to get her to hit a ball in. He reached around and repositioned the stick. She purposely rubbed her hip over his erection.
“Jesus, Lily,” he whispered to her. “What are you doing?”
Lily whispered his ear, her hot breath teasing him. “I’m just playing with my favorite guys.” Then she stroked the pool cue.
Jake jerked back. He took two steps back and watched as she aligned the ball correctly and took her shot. The three-ball went into the side pocket. Jake could see why Derek’s eyes were on her ass. When Lily was bent over, her skirt rode up high enough that he could almost see her crotch.
Jake aligned and took the next shot. Although he got the seven-ball in, he hit it too hard, and he sunk the cue ball as well. Derek took the cue ball out and set up. Just as he was about to take the shot, Lily passed behind him and rubbed his ass. His involuntary jerk threw off his aim, and he missed.
Jake was frustrated. This game was going to take all night, and he didn’t think he could take it. As Lily went over to the side table to take a sip of her beer, Jake spoke in a hushed voice to Derek.
“We are not doing this. I know you play these types of games with Tom, but we’re not taking Lily together,” Jake stated firmly.
Lily heard him. Enough was enough, she thought. It was past time to lay it on the line. She stalked up and said from behind him. “You might not want me, but I’m sure I can find someone who does.”
Jake turned on her. “Why are you doing this? Are you trying to turn into the town whore?”
Derek pushed him, but before he could say anything to that insulting comment, Lily said in a furious tone, “The town whore? I’d have to have sex first.”
Both Derek and Jake froze. Derek turned to Lily and took her arms gently, “You’re a virgin, honey? Why didn’t you tell me?”
Lily’s face flamed. “It doesn’t matter,” she said. “I won’t be after tonight.” Then she looked at Jake, still frozen, and said, “If you don’t take care of it, I’ll find someone who will.”
“The hell you will,” Jake roared. He bent down and threw her over his shoulder.
Her skirt had ridden up, and her ass was at Derek’s eye level. “Christ,” Derek said, “she’s not wearing panties. You can’t carry her out of here like that.”
Jake put his hand up to feel what Derek was talking about. He felt the edge of the skirt against her bare ass. Derek took his jacket and threw it over her butt.
Jake turned to him. “You’re not coming.”
Derek didn’t answer. Instead, he walked around to where Lily’s head was hanging over Jake’s shoulder and took her face. “Are you sure, Lily?”
Jake’s hand was still on Lily’s ass, and her breathing was choppy. “Yes, Derek, I’m sure,” she whispered.
“I’m taking her home, and then I’ll be back,” Jake said to Derek, making it clear he had no intention of doing what she wanted. He turned and stalked out of the bar, Lily placidly hanging over his shoulder.
* * * *
Derek didn’t think he’d see Jake again tonight. He just hoped Jake was going to be gentle with Lily. He may never have seen him in action, but he’d heard that Jake had enough kinks to make things uncomfortable for a virgin. Although his cock disagreed, he wouldn’t have wanted to be the one to take Lily’s virginity. For one thing, Derek liked things a little rougher than a virgin could handle. For another, Tom would kill him.
There was a nearly full pitcher of beer left. He decided to have another then head home. He had just poured himself a beer when Tom came in. He was freshly showered, wearing jeans, and a chambray shirt. Derek’s cock that had finally softened after Lily had left sprung to life again.
A boner for the sister then for the brother. I’m so fucked up.
“What’s up?” Tom asked.
“Not much,” Derek said. “Jake just left.” He didn’t mention Lily.
“Want to play?” Tom asked, gesturing to the pool table.
“Sure,” Derek replied, reaching for the stick. The double meaning behind his words was lost on Tom.
“I’ll rack,” Tom said, and Derek watched the play of Tom’s muscles as he did just that. Derek sighed and resigned himself to a set of blue balls.
Chapter 5
Jake dumped Lily in the passenger seat of his truck.
“I have my car—” she began but didn’t get to finish
as he stepped back and slammed the door.
Jake climbed into his side, and she tried again. “I have my car and only had a couple of sips of beer. I can drive home.”
“No,” Jake said implacably as he backed out of his spot. “I’ll pick you up tomorrow, and we can come get your car.”
Lily didn’t like the sound of that. “I thought you’d stay the night.”
“I’m not having sex with you, Lily.” His voice sounded a little desperate.
Lily put her hand on his and slid it softly up toward his cock. Jake’s foot flexed, shooting them forward. The muscles of his jaw tensed. “Stop doing that.”
Lily shrunk back in her seat. Her house was only five minutes from Starkey’s, but the ride seemed to take forever.
Lily remained silent the entire way. She’d gambled, and she’d lost. The only good thing about tonight is that she’d learned the truth about Derek’s feelings for her brother. The only other thing she’d done was humiliate herself.
She opened the door then drew on her courage to look at him. “I’m sorry I pushed you,” she said in a little voice. “I should have known you would never want me.” She climbed out of the truck cab.
* * * *
After Lily had thrown out her parting line about not him wanting her, Jake stayed behind the wheel for another moment trying to regain some sense. How could she think he didn’t want her? She may have been a virgin, but she wasn’t a sheltered innocent. He thought about her running her fingers through her slick pussy and stroking.
He watched her walk to the door and turn the key. Her shoulders were slumped. He’d done that. He would get out and make her understand, and then he would leave.
Jake slammed out of the truck and strode to the door. When he got close enough, he could see the tears she held back. He pushed her into the house and took the keys out of the lock.
“Don’t tell me I don’t want you,” he roared after he slammed the door. “You know damn well what a boner is.”
Lily looked confused, and Jake knew he’d been sending her confusing signals. “You’re a guy. Just because stimulus makes blood flow to your penis doesn’t mean it has anything to do with me specifically.” At that moment, she sounded like the professor she was.
Jake knew it was a mistake, but he walked up to her anyway. He took her wrist and laid her hand on his jean-covered cock. He groaned when she squeezed and ran her hand over the length of him.
“Jake…” she began.
“I’m not going to take you, Lily. You’re a virgin and my best friend’s sister.” That reminder to both of them had Jake taking a step back away from her touch. It almost killed him to do it.
“I wasn’t kidding, Jake. I’m not going to stay a virgin much longer. If it’s intimidating to a man to have sex with a virgin, I’ll take care of it myself and just not tell him.”
Jake was turned on at the thought of her with a dildo in her pussy and outraged she would think of losing her virginity so carelessly at the same time.
He grabbed her arms and gave one hard shake. “Don’t you dare. You should wait until you find the man you love, the man you’re going to spend forever with.” The thought of another man touching all her fire made Jake angry all over again. He gave her another shake.
“Why would it matter to you? I don’t want forever. I just want to have hot, sweaty, dirty sex.”
At her words, Jake’s cock cramped as though it were trying to get harder. A tingle started at his balls. Fuck, he was going to come just from her words.
“Lily—” Jake began.
Lily interrupted him, “I understand that you’re not interested in me. Tonight is your last chance. I won’t throw myself at you again.” She stepped away, drew herself up to her full, albeit tiny, height and said in a cold, emotionless voice that was belied by the single tear that rolled down her cheek.
She walked toward the staircase that led up to her bedroom. Pausing on the second step, she grabbed the bottom of her shirt and pulled it over her head. “Come to bed,” she said, “or get out.”
* * * *
Lily couldn’t believe her nerve. She knew she was setting herself up for heartbreak.
She had just turned to head to her bedroom when she heard his boots pounding up the stairs. Up to that point, she wasn’t sure he would follow. She vowed that, no matter what happened after tonight, she’d make enough memories to last forever.
As soon as she entered the room, she unzipped the side of her skirt. Looking over her shoulder to be sure he was watching, she pushed it down, bent over, and pulled the skirt from under her. She knew her ass was in the air, and going by Jake’s growl, he liked the view.
She started to straighten.
“No,” Jake said harshly. “Stay there.”
Lily spread her legs to keep her balance and peeked at him through her knees. He was rubbing his cock through his jeans. After a moment, he stepped forward and reached out a shaking hand. He ran a work-roughened hand from the small of her back, over the globes of her ass, and finally down the crack until his fingers touched her pussy.
“Oh, my God,” he said reverently, “You’re so fucking wet.”
He slid his fingers on her, and she pushed back. She felt the denim of his jeans against her leg.
“Jake,” she said hoarsely, “take your clothes off.”
Jake stepped back, and Lily heard the rustle of clothes. The blood was rushing to her head, so she stood up to watch him undress. She turned, and his eyes latched onto her breasts. She knew she wasn’t well endowed, but his hot gaze indicated he didn’t mind. In a moment, he was naked, and her nipples pulled into an immediate pucker. He stepped forward, stroking his cock, his eyes locked on her.
Suddenly nervous, she bent to unzip her boots.
“Leave them on,” he demanded. When he reached her, he picked her up and carried her to the bed. The feeling of his hot, hard body made her breath catch.
After Jake laid her on the bed, he began running his hands from her collarbone to her hip, missing all the important bits.
Lily shifted impatiently. On his next pass, he ran his palm over her breast, his callused hand rasping over her sensitized nipple. He didn’t linger but continued on his journey. His hand slid over the skin of her pubis. Lily spread her legs.
Just when she thought he was never going to get moving, he bent his head and took her nipple into his mouth. The hard suck made her arch her body. Jake answered the demand by running a finger over her slick opening. Before she could process that sensation, he pushed a finger into her.
Lily let out a little scream. Jake slid his finger out of her, and Lily was afraid she’d scared him off, but he just rasped her clit a few times, gathered up more of her body’s moisture, and then pushed two fingers into her.
It was too much, and Lily imploded. She hadn’t even realized she was close. The pleasure and discomfort of his penetration just sent her over the edge. Jake kissed her, forcing her mouth open and thrusting his tongue inside. He pulled his body over hers. Because he was so much taller than she, Lily couldn’t feel his cock resting against her like she’d like. She tried to squirm onto him, but he wouldn’t let her move.
Finally, she reached between their bodies to stroke his cock. He jerked his hips back away from her touch and started kissing his way down her body, pausing to suck on her nipples.
“Jake…” She practically wailed as the feel of his hard nips and sucks on her nipples resonated deep inside her pussy.
“I want you ready,” he said, and resumed his journey. When he reached her legs, he kissed the tops of her thighs above the boots. She had forgotten she still had them on. Jake unzipped the boots, kissing his way down the skin as it was exposed. Finally, he pulled off her sock and drew her big toe into his mouth.
Lily couldn’t believe her toes were an erogenous zone. She felt a gush of moisture dripping down the crack of her ass at the sensation. When he did the same with the other leg, Lily stated thrashing and moaning almost constantly.
<
br /> Finally, he turned his attention to her pussy. He pushed Lily’s legs back, exposing her to his gaze. Before Lily could get self-conscious about the new position, Jake licked the drip of her arousal from the tiny rosette of her ass, over her opening, and up to her clit.
Lily screeched. She couldn’t help it. Clearly loving her response, Jake did the same thing again, this time pausing to rim her ass and her pussy before biting lightly on her clit.
Lily twitched like a microburst. All it would take to send her careening into another orgasm would be a few firm strokes.
* * * *
Jake knew how close she was. She was as relaxed as she could be. He crawled up her body and pushed in. He thought he’d be able to enter her in one thrust, but he couldn’t push past her innocence that easily.
Faced with the proof of her virginity, Jake had to ask her one more time if she was sure. He didn’t know if he could pull back if she asked him to, but he would try. He wasn’t going to take what she wasn’t willing to give.
She didn’t give him a choice. She grabbed his ass and impaled herself much harder than he would have. As soon as she did, she started to come in hard contractions that milked his cock. Jake felt the pressure in his balls explode. She was so wet and tight. He tried to pull out, aware he didn’t have a condom on. He hadn’t wanted to break her hymen with a latex-covered cock and increase her pain, but he didn’t expect her to come on the first thrust. Evidently, a little pain was a major turn-on for Lily.
Jake knew he had to pull out so he could come on her stomach, but she still had his ass in her grip, and she was gyrating on him, lost in her own pleasure. Jake stopped fighting it and jerked his hips, causing his cock to shift inside of her. Lily was practically wailing, the spasms of her pussy unrelenting.
