Coming Back to Me

by Caroline Leavitt

  Table of Contents

  Title Page

  prologue

  chapter one

  chapter two

  chapter three

  chapter four

  chapter five

  chapter six

  chapter seven

  chapter eight

  chapter nine

  chapter ten

  acknowledgments

  PREVIOUS BOOKS BY

  about the author

  READING GROUP GUIDE

  Copyright Page

  For Jeff Tamarkin

  and Max.

  I love you.

  prologue

  Gary and the baby sit at the Tastee Diner. Otis is only three weeks old and lies swaddled in a soft blue-striped blanket on Gary’s lap. This is what Otis knows: the red leatherette seats; the soft blur of sound coming from a jukebox in back, which is usually something by Patsy Cline or Dolly Parton, something country; Gary; and for three whole days, Molly. Three days so far, Gary reminds himself. So far.

  Every night Gary orders the same thing: black coffee and a cup of hot water to warm Otis’s bottle. Otis is always in a new outfit. Today he’s wearing blue and gray stripes with a matching hat and booties. Four changes every day because he christens each and every thing with spit-up and formula and rivers of drool. It doesn’t matter. The supply of clothing is endless. Every day presents arrive in the mail, packaged in silver, laced with ribbon, tied with cards, wishing them luck, sending them prayers. Otis looks great in whatever Gary puts on him. Stripes, polka dots, and, Gary’s personal favorite, a tiny red stretch jersey printed with black singing Elvis Presleys. Otis is small and creamy as a pearl and already he has the same mop of black hair that Gary does, the same huge slate eyes as Molly’s. He’s got lashes so long they leave faint shadows on his cheeks.

  He’s so brand-new, yet he has what Gary would call wise eyes, making Gary feel it is perfectly okay to talk to the baby as if he were an equal.

  “So, what would you do if you were me?” he asks, bending his face down, breathing in the clean powdery scent. Otis regards him gravely and yawns deeply. Gary’s neighbor, Emma Thorton, a deeply religious woman who goes to church three times a week, has already told Gary with great authority that newborns come into the world knowing everything. “Only gradually does the world take that knowledge away from them,” she insisted. “It’s a mysterious, sad thing.”

  Gary laughed when she told him. “The world probably has to take it away or they’d go insane,” he said, and then he felt a vague sort of shame when Emma’s face telescoped shut.

  “This is not a joke,” she said. “It’s true. Who knows what wisdom we could learn if we could only speak the language of children? ‘And a little child shall lead us,’ that’s what Jesus said, after all. It’s in the Bible. It’s true.”

  Gary nods, but he doesn’t know what is true or not true anymore. God. The universe. He looks for order and can find none. How could he when his life has no framework anymore, when nothing makes sense to him?

  Gary used to have a married couple as friends, atheists who raised their daughter, Stella, not to believe in anything more radical than herself. No Santa. No Easter Bunny. And certainly no God to make sense of things. When Stella was five, a bright, pretty girl with a storm of mustardy curls, he had asked her, “So, now that you’re a big girl, what do you miss most about being a baby?” All the adults had waited, smiling at Stella as she peered up at Gary, her eyes shimmering with thoughts.

  “I miss talking to God,” Stella said finally, nodding her head for emphasis.

  “Excuse me?” said Stella’s mother, startled, but Stella turned busy, plucking at the hem of her dress, twisting one damp finger into her curls. “Who do you talk with?” Stella’s mother asked her again, but Stella popped her finger in the side of her mouth, making a popping sound. “Cluck, cluck, wuss a bus the duck!” she sang. At the time Gary had thought Stella’s—and her mother’s—response was hilarious. Now, though, he thinks a little differently. He thinks if he were Stella’s parents, her response would have stopped him in his life, just for a moment. He would have pivoted. He would have somehow been changed. He’s lapsed Jewish, but he would have been willing to try religion, to see just what might happen. You never know, he thinks, and depending on where you are in your life, that statement could either ease you or put you in torment.

  Gary doesn’t know what he believes, but he’s willing to give anything a try now. He doesn’t know what possessed him, but yesterday, on his way to the grocer for more formula, Otis bundled in the blue denim Snugli, a soft, sure weight against his heart, he had walked into a church. It was filled with rows of pews in deep, dark woods, and brilliantly colored stained glass, and a few chipped statues of Jesus and Mary and some saints he didn’t recognize. It was empty. As soon as he walked in, his feet echoed on the polished floor, and Molly had blurted into his mind like a shout. He sat in the back row, looking up at the mural on the ceiling, pastel angels filmed with gold and white cottony clouds, and then, as soon as he was settled, he realized he didn’t know any prayers. Please was all he could think of to say. Oh, please. And he didn’t know if that was enough, if it carried any power or weight.

  Otis stirs now, his round, damp mouth moving, his hands as perfect as tiny stars you might wish upon. “Hey,” Gary says, and bends and kisses his son. He can’t kiss him enough. He gets drunk on the touch of him. He loves the baby’s clean scent and can’t help himself from sniffing Otis’s neck, his round belly, his head, his hands. Gary kisses Otis once more and then checks his watch. Time to feed him, his son who was breast-fed for three days, who was held against Molly’s heart, and he looks around for a waitress for another glass of hot water to warm Otis’s bottle.

  He knows the waitresses by now. He doesn’t have to look at their name tags, shaped like clocks, with names he suspects aren’t even theirs but are given to give the place a sense of atmosphere, the snap and sheen of style. Doreena. Darla. Donna. And his favorite name, his favorite waitress, a new one, Patsylu. Patsylu is tall and thin with green eye shadow and a bubble of bright bottle-blond hair tied back in a black velvet ribbon, and she has a soft spot for Otis. “Well, aren’t you just the piece of blueberry pie?” she says to the baby.

  Every time she glides by, she strokes back Otis’s hair, and though Gary knows you aren’t supposed to let anyone touch a newborn without making them wash their hands first, he hasn’t the heart to criticize someone so kind to his son and to him. She brings him refills without even asking. She always smiles and she never once asks him a question, Where are you from? Who do you know here? Why did you come here? What do you want? Everything, Gary thinks. What I had, which was everything.

  Tonight, Patsylu comes by with eggs. “Made them myself,” she says, her voice low, soft, and sweet as music. “I even cleaned the grill so there isn’t an ounce of bacon grease.” He smiles up at her and thinks she would be pretty if she scrubbed her face, if she let her hair go natural. Simplification is the theme of his life now that everything is so complicated. She taps him on his arm. “You eat,” she says, making it a command. “You eat that and you won’t have to worry about protein for the rest of the day.” She sets the plate down, a cheery bright red festooned with a flowered rim. The eggs are cooked hard into rubbery yellow buttons, the way she knows he likes them. They’re freckled with coarse black pepper, sprigged with parsley, and he’ll do his best to eat at least some of them, pushing the rest to the side of his plate to make it look like he did a good job, an old trick he learned way back in grade school.

  He hands Patsylu Otis’s bottle and lays one hand on Otis to calm him. He feels his son’s steady pulse, he feels the late hour, growing later still. Already he knows that G
erta, the live-in baby nurse he’s hired, will be good and pissed at him when he gets home. “You don’t take a newborn out at night,” she’ll scold. “What’s the matter with you?”

  Patsylu comes back with the bottle warming in a glass of water. She shakes her head at his plate. “You have to eat more than that. You’ve got to start thinking about nutrition. You’re a family now.” She sets the glass down; she moves to another table.

  A family. My God. An orphan, he doesn’t know anything about family except he is almost one. The only things he knows about his own parents are the stories that his aunt Pearl, who raised him, told him. Pearl was a lean, hard woman living on her husband’s Social Security and her teaching pension, and she loved Gary as much as he loved her. “I’m sharing my retirement with you,” she told him. “What could be better than an old lady and a little boy?” Pearl had snowy white hair she tied up with a rhinestone clip. She wore satiny suits in ocean colors and she let him wear whatever he wanted. She never cut his hair until he told her it was in his eyes. She loved him. They went to plays and movies and she baked him pies and cookies and told him tales at night, and some of them were about his parents.

  “Your folks were wildcats,” she said. “They didn’t have room in their hearts for anyone but each other—and you.”

  He has photos of them, his mother pale and luminous, her hair spun sugary blond, pinned up with a flower, or skating down to her shoulders. In one photo, his favorite, she’s lifting one hand against the sun, but it looks to Gary like she’s beckoning to him, like she’s calling, Come here, come here, come here to me. His father is tall and thin with a slick of dark hair and a toothy grin. He always wears suits and ties and a fedora at a snappy angle. His shoes are shiny and his fingers look like they are snapping to the beat of music. Pearl said Gary’s parents took him everywhere, to restaurants and movies and department stores, to ball games and roller rinks and walks on the beach at night. “You were good as gold,” Pearl said. “Portable as a box of popcorn.” They took him with him the day they were killed.

  They were grocery shopping, carrying brown bundles of food, maybe something special for dinner, maybe something romantic like chocolate cake or oysters or a half-decent bottle of red wine. They were wheeling Gary in his blue stroller and it had started to rain. Lightning sparked the sky. Thunder boomed. His parents were struggling with the stroller and the groceries. The brown bags were tearing, spilling food across the damp ground. They were trying to get the stroller and Gary up the steep front stairs to their apartment and finally they must have decided to take him out, just until they could get their bearings. The car was parked in front, a turquoise Plymouth with cream trim, and they sheltered Gary in it, laying him across the front car seat, shutting the door. Just for a moment. Just to protect him. And then they both put their hands on his stroller, to get the groceries packed underneath, to collapse the carriage, and the only thing wrong was that they touched the shiny silver metal handlebars the same exact moment the lightning did. “Freak accident,” Pearl told Gary, rocking him in her arms, soothing his hair as he tried to imagine it. The spark and fire of life. The brilliant sudden sizzle. Did they think about Gary or did they turn and see only each other or did they think nothing at all but the quick shock of it all? They died instantly, but he, Gary, had slept in the car for two hours, lulled by the rhythmic pounding fizz of rain. It took a neighborhood kid, running home without his red rubber boots and duck-printed umbrella, to find Gary’s parents, and then to find Gary, small and compact, and perfectly asleep.

  He has photographs, but no memories. Pearl died four years ago, and now Molly and Otis are all the family he has. Has, he says. Present tense. Has. He feels himself rustling like leaves.

  “How about some ice cream to top that all off?” Patsylu says. “We’ve got peach, fresh as a June day.”

  Gary starts to say, Oh, I’m dying for some, and then stops. A phrase as simple as that, and he can’t say it. It feels as if a layer has been pulled off his life. He’s scared all the time. And he keeps thinking: What happens now?

  But the thing is, no one knows what is wrong with Molly. She went in to have a routine delivery of Otis, and three weeks, five operations, and two near deaths later, still no one knows. They keep her anesthetized so she won’t feel what is happening to her. Sometimes when he comes to see her, he wonders if she is imagining that he’s left her, if he’s dead, because she hasn’t seen him, not for days, not for what seems like months, when the truth is, he is always there. “Honey,” he says. Her eyes flutter open and then shut again, and she doesn’t hear him, she doesn’t see. It is as if there were a wall separating them, a wall he would smash with his own hands if he could just find it.

  “I’ll wrap some pie up for later,” Patsylu suddenly says. “So you can have something sweet later.”

  Gary pays Patsylu, overtipping her as usual, and bundles Otis up in his arms. “Bye, bye, sweetie pie,” Patsylu says, and for one moment, he can’t tell if she is talking to him or to the baby. He opens the front door, careful of Otis, and steps out into a nudging unseasonable chill.

  chapter one

  Gary Breyer had first fallen in love with Molly at the Tastee diner. He was not a man who fell in love easily, but he had always hoped he might. People had always told him that he was smart and funny, and although he didn’t consider himself very good-looking, women, to his great astonishment, found him handsome. They touched his heavy lashes, his thick mop of black hair curling into the collars of his jackets. They found his sloppy way of dressing in flannel shirts and tees, in faded jeans and high-top sneakers, endearing and boyish.

  He almost always had dates, photographers he worked with, a cellist he had met at a concert, a pharmacist who had filled his antibiotic prescription, and once even a hand model who had put a skin of cold cream on her hands before slipping them into her white cotton gloves every night. Sometimes the women fell in love with him and sometimes he fell in love back, but in the end, nothing ever took, his relationships slowly drifted apart, and he never quite understood why. His girlfriends told him he was too intense, or sometimes not intense enough. “The fit isn’t right, that’s all it is,” Emily, his last girlfriend, had said two days before she left him to go back with her ex-boyfriend, a ski bum living in Utah who seemed to fit her just fine. Sometimes, though, he was the one who broke off the relationships. He fell out of love with a nurse because she hated to talk about her feelings. He stopped seeing a book editor after she came home from a two-week business trip and he suddenly realized he hadn’t missed her.

  Gary began to feel a great, deep sadness, a restless longing as if love were a season that had somehow never arrived for him. He tried to keep busy. He had a job he loved, designing book jackets at Treasures Press in Brooklyn, and he didn’t mind working long hours or late at night. He lived in bookstores and at the movies, and he had a network of friends who opened their homes to him Thanksgivings and Christmases and New Years. But gradually, as he and his friends all started getting older, their twenties nudging into their thirties, his friends began marrying and having kids. He rented tuxes for their weddings, he gave fluid, funny toasts and flirted gallantly with all the bridesmaids, and gradually, he even began to attend the christenings and birthday parties, the pint-sized celebrations filled with small, buttery voices calling him Uncle Gary. Uncle. Family. He was and yet he wasn’t. And as his friends moved farther and farther away from him, out of his Chelsea neighborhood and deeper into the suburbs or out of New York entirely, he saw them less and less, and when he did, his friends’ conversations were peppered with names and places he didn’t recognize; their kids sometimes couldn’t remember who he was.

  He couldn’t help but envy his friends’ lives. He stood in his married friend Bob’s kitchen in Massachusetts, leaning along the adobe tile wall, watching Bob and his wife, Rayanna, cooking, the two of them teasing, every passed spoon so intimate an act, Gary felt like a voyeur. He walked to films in Ithaca with Allan, a copywriter he ha
d worked with and befriended, and Allan’s girlfriend, Peggy, but Gary walked alone with his hands deep in his pockets, while theirs were twined together. His friends saw how silent he sometimes got; they tried to keep including him in their lives, they handed him phone numbers of women they thought he might like, they tried to generate romance. “Maybe you want too much,” Allan finally suggested. “Maybe you should be more realistic. Stop expecting miracles.”

  Gary began to feel weary. He began to tell himself that peace and solitude were not such bad things, that a person could be happy in his own company. He began taking drives, exploring, and he began to eat more and more of his meals at a tiny New Jersey diner he discovered, a black-and-chrome shoe box called the Tastee.

  The Tastee had chrome tables and soft leatherette booths. There was a rotating neon clock that took up a quarter of the far wall. The diner was fairly crowded, and there were four waitresses bustling around, white aprons snapped about their waists, name tags pinned to their breasts. One of them, a middle-aged blonde with a name tag that said Donna, nodded toward the back. “Spicy fries are good today,” she urged.

  “Okay. And coffee, too,” Gary said. Glen Campbell was crooning on the jukebox about being a lineman for the county. It was one of those corny songs Gary was embarrassed to admit he liked. Gary made his way to the back and sat down in a booth and looked around. There were lots of families here, mothers daubing napkins at their kids’ faces, fathers in business suits, leaning forward, talking earnestly to their teenaged daughters who were rolling their eyes or staring blankly off into space. There were some couples, a few groups of elderly women, and there in the back, sitting alone, eating soup, was the most beautiful woman Gary had ever seen.

  Her hair was a fiery tangle of curls spiraling down her back. She had a constellation of freckles dotted across her nose, a small pointed chin, and eyes as clear and gray as slate. Her white overalls looked a size too big for her, her white sweater underneath was unraveling at the elbow, and her left high-top sneaker had a blue paint scribble on the toe. She was curved over, one hand cupping her chin, the other on her book, reading so avidly, she seemed to be eating her soup blindly, raising the spoon slowly to her mouth, not taking her eyes from her page. He liked it that she liked to read, that she seemed so at home by herself. He liked it, too, that she didn’t act like it was a failing that she didn’t have a guy with her or another girlfriend, but rather that she was enjoying herself completely. He watched her for a moment, waiting, seeing if there might be an opening for him, but when she didn’t look up, when his fries arrived, he turned his attention to them.