Sun in a Bottle_The Strange History of Fusion and the Science of Wishful Thinking

by Charles Seife

  Bazell, Robert. “Hype-Energy Physics.” New Republic, 24 April 1989, 7-8.

  Begley, Sharon. “Cold Fusion Isn’t Dead, It’s Just Withering from Scientific Neglect.” Wall Street Journal, 5 September 2003.

  Bernstein, Jeremy. Oppenheimer: Portrait of an Enigma. Chicago: Ivan R. Dee, 2004.

  Bethe, Hans. “Comments on the History of the H-Bomb.” Los Alamos Science, Fall 1982, 42-53.

  ———. “Energy Production in Stars.” Nobel Prize Lecture, 11 December 1967. From Nobel Lectures, Physics 1963-1970. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1972. nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/physics/laureates/1967/bethe-lecture.pdf.

  Bethe, Hans, K. Fuchs, J. O. Hirschfelder, J. L. Magee, R. E. Peieris, J. von Neumann. Blast Wave. LA-2000. Los Alamos, NM: Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, 1947.

  Bickerton, R. “Thermonuclear Processes.” Nature 184 (25 July 1959): 240-41.

  Bird, Kai, and Martin J. Sherwin. American Prometheus: The Triumph and Tragedy of J. Robert Oppenheimer. New York: Knopf, 2005.

  Bishop, Amasa S. Project Sherwood: The U. S. Program in Controlled Fusion. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 1958.

  Bishop, Jerry E. “Heat Source in Fusion Find May Be Mystery Reaction.” Wall Street Journal, 3 April 1989.

  ———. “Physicists Outline Possible Errors That Led to Claims of Cold Fusion.” Wall Street Journal, 3 May 1989.

  ———. “Scientist Sticks to Test-Tube Fusion Claim.” Wall Street Journal, 27 March 1989.

  Bishop, Jerry E., and Ken Wells. “Taming H-Bombs?” Wall Street Journal, 24 March 1989.

  Blackmore, John. “Ernst Mach Leaves ‘The Church of Physics.’” British Journal of the Philosophy of Science 40 (1989): 519-40.

  Blakeslee, Alton. “Sea Atoms May Solve Mankind’s Power Problems.” Associated Press. Benton Harbor (Michigan) News-Palladium, 28 August 1958.

  Blumberg, Stanley A., and Gwinn Owens. Energy and Conflict: The Life and Times of Edward Teller. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1976.

  Braams, C. M., and P. E. Stott. Nuclear Fusion: Half a Century of Magnetic Confinement Fusion Research. Bristol: Institute of Physics Publishing, 2002.

  Broad, William. “Cold Fusion Claim Is Faulted on Ethics as Well as Science.” New York Times, 17 March 1991.

  Bromberg, Joan Lisa. Fusion: Science, Politics, and the Invention of a New Energy Source. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1982.

  Brown, P. S., and L. J. Ferderber. The Stockpile Stewardship Program. UCRL-JC-131080. Livermore, CA: Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, 1993.

  Browne, Malcolm W. “Fusion Power: Is There Still an El Dorado for Energy?” New York Times, 15 April 1979.

  ———. “Physicists Debunk Claim of a New Kind of Fusion.” New York Times, 3 May 1989.

  Brumfiel, Geoff. “Bubble Fusion Dispute Reaches Boiling Point.” Nature 416 (7 March 2002): 7.

  ———. “Lack of Funding Puts ‘Bubble Fusion’ Replication on Hold.” Nature 417 (27 June 2002): 887.

  ———. “Misconduct? It’s All Academic . . .” Nature 445 (18 January 2007): 240-41.

  Buch, Esteban. Richter: Ópera Documental de Cámara. Libretto (Unpublished copy supplied by librettist; translated by Meridith Seife and Charles Seife).

  Burchfield, Joe D. “Darwin and the Dilemma of Geological Time.” Isis 65 (September 1974): 300-321.

  Burkhardt, L. C., and R. H. Lovberg. “New Confinement Phenomena and Neutron Production in a Linear Stabilized Pinch.” Nature 181 (25 January 1958): 228-30.

  Burkhardt, L. C., R. H. Lovberg, and J. A Phillips. “Magnetic Measurement of Plasma Confinement in a Partially Stabilized Linear Pinch.” Nature 181 (25 January 1958): 224-25.

  Bush, George W. Speech Announcing New Vision for Space Exploration Program. NASA Headquarters, Washington, DC, 14 January 2002. http://whitehouse. gov/news/releases/2004/01/20040114-3.html.

  Bussard, Robert. “Should Google Go Nuclear?” Google Tech Talk, 9 November 2006. video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1996321846673788606 (accessed 2 July 2007).

  Bylinsky, Gene. “Shiva: The Next Step to Fusion Power.” Fortune, 30 January 1978, 85-88.

  Cantelon, Philip L., Richard G. Hewlett, and Robert C. Williams, eds. The American Atom. 2nd ed. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1991.

  Carey, Frank. “Argentina Claims New Atom Secret.” Associated Press. Council Bluffs (Iowa) Nonpareil, 26 March 1951.

  Carruthers, R. “The Beginning of Fusion at Harwell.” Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion 30, no. 14 (1998): 1993-2001.

  Cartlidge, Edwin. “Europe Plans Laser-Fusion Facility.” PhysicsWeb, 2 September 2005. physicsweb.org/articles/news/9/9/2/1 (accessed 25 July 2007).

  Cartwright, David C. Inertial Confinement Fusion at Los Alamos. Vol. 1, Progress in Inertial Confinement Since 1985. LA-UR-89-2675. Los Alamos, NM: Los Alamos National Laboratory, 1989.

  Chadwick, J. “The Existence of a Neutron.” Originally in Proceedings of the Royal Society A 136 (1932): 692-708. Available at dbhs.wvusd.k12.ca.us/webdocs/Chem-History/Chadwick-1932/Chadwick-neutron.html.

  Chang, Gordon. “To the Nuclear Brink: Eisenhower, Dulles, and the Quemoy-Matsu Crisis.” International Security 12 (Spring 1998): 96-123.

  Chang, Kenneth. “Experts Say New Desktop Fusion Claims Seem More Credible.” New York Times, 3 March 2004.

  Chirac, Jacques. Speech by Mr Jacques Chirac, President of the French Republic, On the occasion of the signing ceremony for the International ITER Agreement on controlled Nuclear Fusion, Paris, Elysée Palace, 21 November 2006. www.iter.org/pdfs/speech_Chirac.pdf.

  Clery, Daniel. “ITER Pact Signed.” ScienceNOW, 21 November 2006. sciencenow.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/2006/1121/1 (accessed 22 November 2006).

  Close, Frank. Too Hot to Handle: The Race for Cold Fusion. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1991.

  Cockcroft, J. D. “Peaceful Uses of Atomic Energy: United Nations Conference at Geneva.” Nature 182 (4 October 1958): 903-5.

  Cohen, James S, and John D. Davies. “The Cold Fusion Family.” Nature 338 (27 April 1989): 705-7.

  Coleman, L. Status of Inertial Fusion in the United States. UCRL-JC-108463. Livermore, CA: Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, 1991.

  Connor, Steve. “Fusion ‘Breakthrough’ Heralds Cleaner Energy.” Guardian, 6 March 2002.

  Cowan, George A. Nuclear Explosions as Neutron Sources. LAMS-2391. Los Alamos, NM: Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, 1959.

  Crawford, Mark. “Cold Fusion: Is It Hot Enough to Make Power?” Science 244 (28 April 1989): 423.

  ———. “Utah Looks to Congress for Cold Fusion Cash.” Science 244 (5 May 1989) 522-23.

  Cronkite, E. P., V. P. Bond, L. E. Browning, et al. Study of Response of Human Beings Accidentally Exposed to Significant Fallout Radiation. Operation Castle—Final Report Project 4.1. Naval Medical Research Institute, Bethesda, MD, and U. S. Naval Radiological Defense Laboratory, San Francisco, CA, October 1954.

  Crum, Lawrence A. “Sonofusion: Star in a Jar?” PowerPoint Presentation. www.washington.edu/research/graphics/sf/pdfs/Crum.pdf (accessed 26 July 2007).

  Cumings, Bruce. The Origins of the Korean War. Vol. 2, The Roaring of the Cataract, 1947-1950. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1990.

  Curie, (Marie) Sklowdowska. “Radium and Radioactivity.” Originally in Century Magazine, January 1904, 461-66. www.aip.org/history/curie/article_text.htm (accessed 25 July 2007).

  Damron, Gina. “Oakland Twp. Teen Creates Fusion.” freep.com, 19 November 2006. www.freep.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2006611190602 (accessed 21 November 2006; currently defunct).

  Darwin, Charles Robert. The Origin of Species. The Harvard Classics. New York: P. F. Collier & Son, 1909.

  Davies, N. Anne. Letter to John A. Woods, 2 October 1998 (copy supplied to author).

  The Day After Trinity. Directed by John Else. KTEH, 1981.

  de Hoffmann, Frederic. Minutes of an Informal Meeting on Nuclear Rockets. LAMS- 836. Los Alamos, NM: Los Alamos Scientific Laboratory, 1949.

/>   Dean, Steven O. “Fifty Years of U.S. Fusion Research—An Overview of Programs.” Nuclear News, July 2002, 34-40.

  ———. “Status and Objectives of Tokamak Systems for Fusion Research.” Journal of Fusion Energy 17, no. 4 (1998): 289-337.

  ———. “The Decision L Is Yes.” 6 February 1950.

  Dibble, Timothy, Saibal Bandyopadhyay, Jamal Ghoroghchian, et al. “Electrochemistry at Very High Potentials: Oxidation of the Rare Gases and Other Gases in Nonaqueous Solvents at Ultramicroelectrodes.” Journal of Physical Chemistry 90 (9 October 1986): 5275-77.

  Dickman, Steven. “1920s Discovery, Retraction.” Nature 338 (27 April 1989) 692.

  Ditmire, T., J. Zweiback, V. P. Yanovsky, T. E. Cowan, G. Hays, and K. B. Wharton. “Nuclear Fusion from Explosions of Femtosecond Laser-Heated Deuterium Clusters.” Nature 398 (8 April 1999) 489-92.

  Divine, Robert A. Blowing on the Wind: The Nuclear Test Ban Debate. New York: Oxford University Press, 1978.

  ———. Eisenhower and the Bomb. New York: Oxford University Press, 1981.

  Duncan, Mark. “Should Google Go Nuclear?” 7 May 2007. www.askmar.com/ConferenceNotes/Should%20Google%20Go%20Nuclear.pdf (accessed 24 July 2007).

  Dunn, Peter H. “RE: Inquiry Committee Proceedings Under Executive Memorandum No. C-22.” Letter to Rusi Taleyarkhan and Leah H. Jamieson, Dec. 15, 2006.

  Economist. “Here We Go Again; Table-Top Fusion.” 9 March 2002, 95.

  Eder, G., and H. Motz. “Contribution of High-Energy Particles to Thermonuclear Reaction Rates.” Nature 182 (28 October 1958): 1140-42.

  Einstein, Albert. Letter to F. D. Roosevelt, 2 August 1939. Available at www.anl.gov/Science_and_Technology/History/Anniversary_Frontiers/aetofdr.html.

  Emmett, John L., et al. “NIF Technology Review.” Report of the Technology Resource Group of the NIF Council, 4 November 1999.

  Energy & Technology Review. “The National Ignition Facility: An Overview.” December 1994, 1-6.

  Erlandson, A. C., R. London, K. Manes, et al. Accelerated Thermal Recovery for Flashlamp-Pumped Solid-State Laser Amplifiers. UCRL-ID-135668. Livermore, CA: Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, 1999.

  Farber, W. R., J. C. Fraser, D. J. Grove, et al. A Conceptual Design of the Model C Stellarator. NYO-7309, AEC Research and Development Report. Princeton, NJ: Project Matterhorn at Princeton University, 1956.

  Farnsworth, P. T. Electric Discharge Device for Producing Interactions Between Nuclei. U.S. Patent 3258402, filed 11 January 1962 and issued 28 June 1966.

  ———. Method and Apparatus for Producing Nuclear-Fusion Reactions. U.S. Patent 3386883, filed 13 May 1966 and issued 4 June 1968.

  Feder, Toni. “DOE Warms to Cold Fusion.” Physics Today, April 2004, 27.

  Ferrell, Robert H., ed. The Eisenhower Diaries. New York: W. W. Norton, 1981. Finney, John W. “A.E.C. Spurs Work on H-Bomb Power.” New York Times, 11 February 1958.

  ———. “Atomic Freedom Hailed at Geneva.” New York Times, 3 September 1958. 9.

  ———. “Gains in Harnessing Power of H-Bomb Reported Jointly by U.S. and Britain.” New York Times, 25 January 1958.

  ———. “Navy Breakthrough in Control of Hydrogen Bomb Power Seen.” New York Times, 18 August 1959.

  ———. “U.S. Experts Hint H-Bomb Control. New York Times, 5 September 1958.

  ———. “U.S. Will Show H-Power Control Devices.” New York Times, 17 August 1958.

  The Fire Place. 12 July 2007. fire.pppl.gov/ (accessed 20 August 2007).

  Fitzpatrick, Tim. “Japan Yanks Funding for Cold-Fusion Effort.” Salt Lake Tribune, 27 August 1997.

  Fleischmann, Martin, and Stanley Pons. “Electrochemically Induced Nuclear Fusion of Deuterium.” Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry 261 (1989): 301-8.

  ———. “Some Comments on the Paper Analysis of Experiments on Calorimetry of LiOD/D2O Electrochemical Cells, R. H. Wilson et al., J. Electroanal. Chem. 332 (1992) 1.” Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry 332 (1992): 33-53.

  Fleischmann, Martin, Stanley Pons, Marvin W. Anderson, Lian Jun Li, and Marvin Hawkins. “Calorimetry of the Palladium-Deuterium-Heavy Water System.” Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry 287 (1990): 293-348.

  Fleischmann, Martin, Stanley Pons, Marvin Hawkins, and R. J. Hoffman. “Measurement of -rays from Cold Fusion.” Nature 339 (29 June 1989): 667.

  Fleischmann, Martin, Stanley Pons, and others. Press conference of 23 March 1989. Audio recording. Available at newenergytimes.com/Audio/1989UtahPC1.mp3, newenergytimes.com/Audio/1989UtahPC2.mp3, and newenergytimes.com/Audio/1989UtahPC3.mp3.

  Foot, Rosemary. “Nuclear Coercion and the End of the Korean Conflict.” International Security 13 (Winter 1998/99): 92-112.

  Footlick, Jerrold K. Truth and Consequences: How Colleges and Universities Meet Public Crises. Phoenix: The American Council on Education and Oryx Press, 1997.

  Forslund, David W., and Philip D. Goldstone. “Photon Impact: High-Energy Plasma Physics with CO2 Lasers.” Los Alamos Science, Spring-Summer 1985, 2-27.

  Forty, C. B. A., and N. P. Taylor. “Low Activation Material Candidates for Fusion Power Plants.” Paper presented at the Euromat96 Conference, Bournemouth, UK, 21-23 October 1996.

  Fowler, T. Kenneth. The Fusion Quest. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1997.

  Fox, Hal. “Cold Fusion Isn’t as Cold as You Think.” Deseret (Utah) Morning News, 4 September 1997.

  Frankel, Max. “Soviet Scientist Sees Candor Curb.” New York Times, 1 March 1958.

  Friedman, Edward. “Nuclear Blackmail and the End of the Korean War.” Modern China, January 1975, 75-91.

  Friendly, Alfred. “New A-Bomb Has 6 Times Power of 1st.” Washington Post, 18 November 1949.

  Fusion Power Associates. “U.S. Fails to Sign ITER Extension Agreement; JET Demonstrates Fusion Remote Maintenance.” Executive Newsletter, August 1998.

  ———. “US Fusion Budgets for OFES and ICF.” Available at aries.ucsd.edu/FPA/OFESbudget.shtml (accessed 26 July 2007).

  Gallagher, Paul. “‘Hit Men’ vs. LaRouche’s Fusion Energy Foundation.” Executive Intelligence Review, December 3, 2004. Available at www.larouchepub.com/other/2004/3147_hit_men_vs_fef.html (accessed 12 July 2007).

  Gamow, G., and E. Teller. “The Rate of Selective Thermonuclear Reactions.” Physical Review 53 (April 1938): 608-9.

  Garwin, Richard L. “Consensus on Cold Fusion Still Elusive.” Nature 338 (20 April 1989): 616-17.

  Gehmlich, Dietrich K. A History of the College of Engineering, University of Utah. 2003. www.coe.utah.edu/about/history.pdf (accessed 24 July 2007).

  General Atomics. “The Promise of Fusion Energy.” PowerPoint presentation, ca. 2004. fusioned.gat.com/images/pdf/promise_of_fusion.pdf (accessed 26 July 2007).

  George, K. A. “Neutron Production and Temperature in ZETA.” Nature 182 (13 September 1958): 745-46.

  Gibson, A. “Possibility of Ion Runaway in ZETA.” Nature 183 (10 January 1959): 101-2.

  Gladwell, Malcolm. “The Televisionary.” New Yorker, 27 May 2002, 112-16.

  Glanz, James. “Behind the Official Optimism, Flawed Projections.” Science 274 (6 December 1996): 1601.

  ———. “A Harsh Light Falls on NIF.” Science 277 (18 July 1997): 304-7.

  ———. “Requiem for a Heavyweight at Meeting on Fusion Reactors.” Science 280 (8 May 1998): 818-19.

  ———. “Turbulence Might Sink Titanic Reactor.” Science 274 (6 December 1996): 1600.

  Glanz, James, and Andrew Lawler. “Planning a Future Without ITER.” Science 279 (2 January 1998): 20-21.

  Goncharov, G. A. “American and Soviet H-Bomb Development Programmes: Historical Background.” Physics-Uspekhi 39 (1996): 1033-44.

  Goodchild, Peter. Edward Teller: The Real Dr. Strangelove. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2004.

  Gorman, J. G., I. G. Brown, G. Lisitano, and J. Orens. “New Model for Plasma Confinement Times at Stellarators.” Physical Review Letters 22 (6 January 1969): 16-20.
/>
  Groves, Leslie R. Now It Can Be Told. New York: Da Capo, 1983.

  Hagerman, D. C., and J. W. Mather. “Neutron Production in a High-Power Pinch Apparatus.” Nature 181 (25 January 1958): 226-28.

  Harte, J. A., W. E. Alley, D. S. Bailey, J. L. Eddlemay, and G. B. Zimmerman. “LASNEX—A 2-D Physics Code for Modeling ICF.” ICF Quarterly Report. UCRL-LR- 105821-96-4 (1996): 150-64.

  Hattiangandi, J. N. “Alternatives and Incommensurables: The Case of Darwin and Kelvin.” Philosophy of Science 38 (December 1971): 502-7.

  Heller, Arnie. “Collaboration Ignites Laser Advances.” Science & Technology Review, June 1999, 19-21.

  ———. “On Target: Designing for Ignition.” Science & Technology Review, July 1999, 4-11.

  ———. “Orchestrating the World’s Most Powerful Laser.” Science & Technology Review, July-August 2005, 4-12.

  Herken, Gregg. Brotherhood of the Bomb. New York: Henry Holt, 2002.

  Herman, Robin. Fusion: The Search for Endless Energy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990.

  Herrmann, Mark C. “ICF Basics, NIF and IFE.” PowerPoint presentation, UCRL-PRES-207384, ca. 2005. fire.pppl.gov/icf_hermmann_2005. pdf (accessed 26 July 2007).

  Hershey, Robert D., Jr. “Nuclear Fusion Growth Aim of New Law.” New York Times, 9 October 1980.

  Hewlett, Richard G., and Jack M. Holl. Atoms for Peace and War. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989.

  Hillaby, John. “British Changing Fusion Machines.” New York Times, 23 July 1959.

  ———. “British Chide U.S. on Nuclear Pace.” New York Times, 17 January 1958.

  ———. “H-Power System to Take 20 Years.” New York Times, 25 January 1958.

  Hijiya, James A. “The Gita of J. Robert Oppenheimer.” Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 144 (June 2000): 123-67.

  Hoffman, Ian. “Edward Teller Legacy Goes beyond H-Bomb.” Oakland Tribune, 15 September 2003.

  Hoffmann, M. David. Readings for the Atomic Age. New York: Globe, 1950.

  Holloway, Rachel L. In the Matter of J. Robert Oppenheimer: Politics, Rhetoric, and Self-Defense . Westport, CT: Praeger, 1993.

  Holtkamp, Norbert. “Status of the ITER Project.” PowerPoint presentation, October 2006. fire.pppl.gov/aps06_holtkamp.ppt.