Vietnam, An Epic Tragedy
Page 1
Copyright
William Collins
An imprint of HarperCollinsPublishers
1 London Bridge Street
London SE1 9GF
WilliamCollinsBooks.com
This eBook first published in Great Britain by William Collins in 2018
Copyright © Max Hastings 2018
The author asserts the moral right to be identified as the author of this work
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
Cover photograph © AP Photo/Art Greenspoon
All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. By payment of the required fees, you have been granted the non-exclusive, non-transferable right to access and read the text of this e-book on screen. No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, down-loaded, decompiled, reverse engineered, or stored in or introduced into any information storage and retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the express written permission of HarperCollins.
Source ISBN: 9780008132989
Ebook Edition © September 2018 ISBN: 9780008133009
Version: 2018-09-14
Dedication
For my dear friend Rick Atkinson, who chronicles the triumphs and tragedies of American armies with an elegance, penetration and human sympathy that his fellow-historians strive to match.
Contents
Cover
Title Page
Copyright
Dedication
List of Illustrations
List of Maps
Epigraph
Introduction
Note on Styles Adopted in the Text
Glossary
1 Beauty and Many Beasts
1 CLINGING TO AN EMPIRE
2 THE VIETMINH MARCH
2 The ‘Dirty War’
1 STEAMROLLER TYPES
2 WASHINGTON PICKS UP THE TAB
3 PEASANTS
3 The Fortress That Never Was
1 WAITING FOR GIAP
2 DISASTER BECKONS
4 Bloody Footprints
1 QUIT – OR BOMB?
2 ‘A TRIUMPH OF THE WILL’
3 GENEVA
5 The Twin Tyrannies
1 ‘A REGIME OF TERROR’
2 ‘THE ONLY BOY WE GOT’
3 BOOM TIME
4 A RECALL TO ARMS
6 Some of the Way With JFK
1 ‘THEY’RE GOING TO LOSE THEIR COUNTRY IF …’
2 McNAMARA’S MONARCHY
3 LE DUAN RAISES HIS STAKE
7 1963: Coffins for Two Presidents
1 SMALL BATTLE, BIG STORY: AP BAC
2 THE BUDDHISTS REVOLT
3 KILLING TIME
8 The Maze
1 ‘ENOUGH WAR FOR EVERYBODY’
2 DODGING DECISIONS
9 Into the Gulf
1 LIES
2 HAWKS ASCENDANT
10 ‘We Are Puzzled About How to Proceed’
1 DOWN THE TRAIL
2 COMMITTAL
11 The Escalator
1 ‘BOTTOM OF THE BARREL’
2 NEW PEOPLE, NEW WAR
12 ‘Trying to Grab Smoke’
1 WARRIORS AND WATER-SKIERS
2 UNFRIENDLY FIRE
3 TRAPS AND TRAIL DUST
13 Graft and Peppermint Oil
1 STEALING
2 RULING
3 GURUS
14 Rolling Thunder
1 STONE AGE, MISSILE AGE
2 ‘UP NORTH’
15 Taking the Pain
1 BEST OF TIMES, WORST OF TIMES
2 FRIENDS
16 Waist-Deep in the Big Muddy
1 PEACENIKS
2 WARNIKS
3 FIELDCRAFT
4 GUNS
17 Our Guys, Their Guys: the Vietnamese War
1 SONG QUA NGAY – ‘LET’S JUST GET THROUGH THE DAY’
2 FIGHTERS
3 SAIGON SOLDIERS
18 Tet
1 PRELUDE
2 FUGUE
3 A SYMBOLIC HUMILIATION
19 The Giant Reels
1 FIGHTING BACK
2 SURRENDER OF A PRESIDENT
20 Continuous Replay
1 DYING
2 TALKING
21 Nixon’s Inheritance
1 A CRUMBLING ARMY
2 AUSSIES AND KIWIS
3 GODS
4 VIETNAMISATION
22 Losing by Instalments
1 THE FISHHOOK AND THE PARROT’S BEAK
2 COUNTER-TERROR
3 LAM SON 719
23 Collateral Damage
1 MARY ANN
2 THE ‘GOAT’
3 ‘LET’S GO HOME’
24 The Biggest Battle
1 LE DUAN FORCES THE PACE
2 THE STORM BREAKS
3 AN EMPTY VICTORY
25 Big Ugly Fat Fellers
1 ‘IT WILL ABSOLUTELY, TOTALLY, WIPE OUT McGOVERN’
2 ‘WE’LL BOMB THE BEJEEZUS OUT OF THEM’
26 A Kiss Before Dying
1 THE PRISONER
2 ‘PEACE’
3 WAR OF THE FLAGS
27 The Last Act
1 INVASION
2 ‘AH, MY COUNTRY, MY POOR COUNTRY’
28 Afterwards
1 VENGEANCE
2 THE AUDIT OF WAR
Picture Section
Acknowledgements
Notes and References
Bibliography
Index
Also by Max Hastings
About the Publisher
Illustrations
Tonkin, 1896: entrance to the pagoda of the Great Buddha. (© BnF, département des Cartes et Plans, Société de géographie, Sg XCm 707)
Tonkin, 1908: French officers with the heads of Vietnamese suspected of poisoning French troops. (Apic/Getty Images)
1945: victims of the catastrophic famine that swept northern Vietnam. (Special Collections & University Archives Department, University of Central Florida Libraries, Orlando, Florida)
OSS officers with Vo Nguyen Giap and Ho Chi Minh.
French troops with a Vietminh suspect. (Photo by adoc-photos/Corbis via Getty Images)
French troops bring in a casualty. (©Daniel Camus/ECPAD/Défense)
Dienbienphu, November 1953. (Keystone/Staff)
Giap and Ho. (Collection Jean-Claude LABBE/Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images)
Cogny, de Castries and Navarre. (Ullstein bild Dtl./Getty Images)
French officers escort a Vietminh unit into their lines following the July 1954 ceasefire. (PhotoQuest/Getty Images)
Lodge and Diem. (Larry Burrows/The LIFE Picture Collection/Getty Images)
Nguyen Thuy Nga and Le Duan.
Mao Zedong and Le Duc Tho. (Bettmann/Getty Images)
Lou Conein.
Gen. Max Taylor and Gen. Paul Harkins. (Larry Burrows/Getty Images)
The Ho Chi Minh Trail. (© Le Minh Truong/Another Vietnam)
Hueys. (Bettmann/Getty Images)
Special forces camp at Plei Me under Vietcong assault in 1965. (Bettmann/Getty Images)
Walt Boomer. (Courtesy of Walter Boomer)
Tim O’Brien. (Courtesy of Tim O’Brien)
John Paul Vann and Doug Ramsey. (Courtesy of Doug Ramsey)
Bob Kerrey.
Leon Gouré. (State Archives of Florida)
Australian private Tom Blackhurst. (© Australian War Memorial C36943)
Mike Eiland. (Courtesy of Mike Eiland)
Classic combat image by Don McCullin. (© Don McCullin)
Doan Phuong Hai.
Bao Ninh. (© 1993 The Sorrow of War)
Nguyen Cong Luan.
/> Truong Nhu Tang.
1st Air Cav at An Thi. (AP/Shutterstock)
Maxwell Taylor and William Westmoreland. (Silverwell Films)
Duong Van Mai. (Courtesy of Duong Van Mai Elliott)
Nguyen Thi Chinh. (Courtesy of Kieu Chinh)
Vietcong doctor Dang Thuy Tram. (Courtesy of Dang Thuy Tram)
Body count. (Rolls Press/Popperfoto/Getty Images)
Dan Hickman. (Courtesy of Dan Hickman)
Jeff Anthony. (Courtesy of Jeff Anthony)
Bob Nelson. (Courtesy of Bob Nelson)
David Rogers. (Courtesy of David Rogers)
A US Marine carries an injured woman to safety. (Photo by © Hulton-Deutsch Collection/CORBIS/Corbis via Getty Images)
Hue 1968: Marine officer Myron Harrington with British photographer Don McCullin. (Nik Wheeler/Corbis via Getty Images)
Gen. Creighton Abrams. (Bettmann/Getty Images)
A bonze immolates himself on a Saigon street in 1965. (Malcolm Brown/AP/REX/Shutterstock)
South Vietnamese police chief Nguyen Ngoc Loan executes a Vietcong prisoner during Tet 1968. (Eddie Adams/AP/Shutterstock)
Children flee a 1972 napalm strike. (Nick Ut/AP/Shutterstock)
New York Times correspondent Harrison Salisbury with Pham Van Dong, 1966. (Black and White Photograph of Harrison Salisbury and Pham Van Dong, Hanoi, 1966–67. MS#1509, Box 210, Folder 23, Harrison E. Salisbury Papers, Rare Book & Manuscript Library, Columbia University in the City of New York)
North Vietnamese salvage wreckage from a downed US aircraft. (© Doan Cong Tinh/Another Vietnam)
Dean Rusk, John F. Kennedy and Robert McNamara. (Bill Allen/AP/REX/Shutterstock)
Lyndon Johnson harangues journalists, including the author, in the White House cabinet room, January 1968. (Author’s collection)
Henry Kissinger, Nguyen Cao Ky, Ellsworth Bunker, Nguyen Van Thieu and Richard Nixon, 1969. (VA004679, Douglas Pike Photograph Collection, The Vietnam Center and Archive, Texas Tech University)
Bill Weise after being wounded at Daido, May 1968. (Courtesy of William Weise)
Marines attack at Daido. (Courtesy of William Weise)
Jim Livingston. (Courtesy of James E. Livingston)
Staged shot of North Vietnamese troops. (© Hoang Mai/Another Vietnam)
Ho Chi Minh and Le Duan. (© Marc Riboud/Magnum Photos)
Frank Snepp. (Courtesy of Frank Snepp)
Catherine Anne Warnes.
Gen. Van Tien Dung. (AP Photo/Vietnam News Agency/REX/Shutterstock)
Doug Ramsey at his 1973 release after seven years in Vietcong hands. (Courtesy of Doug Ramsey)
Fugitives during the April 1975 collapse of the South Vietnamese army. (Anonymous/AP/REX/Shutterstock)
ARVN defenders of Saigon, 1975. (Bettmann/Getty Images)
North Vietnamese troops approach Saigon. (Hervé GLOAGUEN/Getty Images)
ARVN captives attend a reindoctrination session. (© Marc Riboud/Magnum Photos)
Boat people. (Courtesy National Archives, photo no. 428-N-1175389)
Every effort has been made to trace copyright holders and to obtain their permission for the use of copyright material. The publisher apologises for any errors or omissions in the above list and would be grateful if notified of any corrections that should be incorporated in future editions of this book.
Maps
French Indochina
Dienbienphu, 1954
Partitioned Vietnam
South Vietnam’s provinces and main towns
The Ho Chi Minh Trail
The Tet offensive, 1968
Hue
Daido, 30 April–2 May 1968
Operation Linebacker, 1972
January 1973: rival areas of control
The 1975 North Vietnamese offensive: main thrusts
Epigraph
‘Asia will have a long-deferred revenge on her arrogant younger sister’
Dean Inge, 1928
‘Every military fact is also a social and political fact’
Antonio Gramsci
‘Contains mature content strong language and graphic violence: Viewer discretion is advised’
Screen warning introducing the 2017 PBS Burns-Novick series The Vietnam War
Introduction
The struggle for Vietnam, a poor South-East Asian country the size of California, comprising mountains, jungles and paddies which enchant twenty-first-century tourists but were uncongenial to twentieth-century Western warriors, lasted three decades and cost between two and three million lives. In the eyes of the world, and even those of the communists’ Chinese and Soviet armourers, for the first twenty years it was a marginal affair. During its last phase, however, the war seized the imagination, roused the dismay and indeed revulsion of hundreds of millions of Western people, while destroying one US president and contributing to the downfall of a second. In the wave of youthful protest against authority which swept many countries in the 1960s, rejection of old sexual morality and an enthusiasm for the joys of marijuana and LSD became conflated with lunges against capitalism and imperialism, of which Vietnam appeared an exceptionally ugly manifestation. Moreover, many older Americans who lacked sympathy for any of those causes came to oppose the war because it was revealed as the fount of systematic deceits by their own government, and also seemed doomed to fail.
The 1975 fall of Saigon represented a humiliation for the planet’s most powerful nation: peasant revolutionaries had prevailed over American will, wealth and hardware. The silhouetted stairway up which on the evening of 29 April fugitives ascended to a helicopter, as if towards Calvary, secured a place among the symbolic images of that era. Vietnam exercised greater cultural influence upon its times than has any other conflict since 1945.
The merits of rival causes are never absolute. Even in the Second World War, the Western allied struggle against fascism was compromised by its reliance upon the tyranny of Stalin to pay most of the blood price for destroying the tyranny of Hitler. Only simpletons of the political right and left dare to suggest that in Vietnam either side possessed a monopoly of virtue. The authors of all the authoritative works about the conflict are American or French. More than a few of the former write as if it was their own nation’s story. Yet this was predominantly an Asian tragedy, upon which a US nightmare was overlaid: around forty Vietnamese perished for every American.
Although my narrative is chronological, I have not attempted to chronicle or even mention every action, but instead to capture the nature of Vietnam’s experience through three decades. As in all my books, while relating the political and strategic tale I also try to answer the question: ‘What was the war like?’ – for Northern sappers, Mekong delta peasants, Huey pilots from Peoria, grunts from Sioux Falls, air defence advisers from Leningrad, Chinese railway workers, bar girls in Saigon.
I was born in 1945. As a youthful correspondent, I lived for almost two years in America, and later repeatedly visited Indochina. My understanding was so meagre, my perceptions so callow, that in the text that follows I shall not allude to personal experiences, instead summarising them here. In 1967–68 I travelled widely in the US, first on a journalistic study fellowship and latterly as a reporter during the presidential election campaign. I had brief encounters with many of the major players, including Robert Kennedy, Richard Nixon, Eugene McCarthy, Barry Goldwater, Hubert Humphrey, Ronald Reagan … and Harrison Salisbury, Norman Mailer, Allen Ginsberg, Joan Baez.
In January 1968, I was among a group of foreign journalists who visited the White House. Seated in the cabinet room, we were harangued for forty minutes by President Lyndon Johnson about his commitment to Vietnam, weeks before he stunned the American people by announcing that he would not run for re-election. That morning his personality seemed no less formidable for being close to the caricature. ‘Some of you like blondes, some of you like redheads, and some of you maybe don’t like women at all,’ he declared in that deadweight drawl, gesticulating constantly to emphasise his points and making bro
ad pencil strokes on a notepad before him. ‘I’m here to tell you what kind I like. I’m prepared to meet Ho Chi Minh any time in a nice hotel with nice food and we can sit down and talk to settle this thing.’
After making his pitch this big man left the room abruptly, without taking questions, merely loosing a Parthian shaft at anti-war columnist Walter Lippmann. We had risen and were gathering our notes, when suddenly the president put his head around the door again. ‘Now, before y’all go,’ he said almost coyly, ‘I want to ask: do any of you feel any different from anything you had read or heard about me before you came?’ We were stunned into inarticulacy by this glimpse of Johnson’s awesome vulnerability.
In 1970, I presented a series of reports for BBC TV’s 24 Hours programme from Cambodia and Vietnam, then returned in the following year to do more of the same, interviewing President Nguyen Van Thieu and also visiting Laos. Among other themes of those films, I accompanied men of the US 23rd Division on a sweep in the Hiep Duc valley, flew in a Vietnamese Skyraider on a strafing mission, and reported on the battle for Firebase 6 in the Central Highlands. Later that year, in Beijing’s Great Hall of the People I shook the hand of Zhou Enlai. In 1973 and 1974 I travelled again in Vietnam, and in 1975 reported the final campaigns, including the shambles of Danang just before its fall, later from around Saigon.
I intended to remain among the handful of correspondents covering the North Vietnamese takeover. On the afternoon of the final day, however, I lost my nerve, forced a path through the mob of terrified Vietnamese around the US embassy, and scrambled over its wall with some assistance from the Marine defenders. A few hours later I was evacuated in a Jolly Green Giant to the USS Midway.
The above episodes* yielded immature journalism, but today lend personal colouring to my descriptions below of the sweat-soaked, dust-clinging, bomb-happy ‘boondocks’, as Vietnamese, French and American fighters knew them. In later years I met Robert McNamara, Henry Kissinger and other giants of the Vietnam era. Arthur Schlesinger became a friend.
All wars are different, and yet the same. A myth has grown up, in the US at least, that Vietnam inflicted unique horrors on its participants, attested in countless veterans’ anguished gropings into poetry. Yet anyone who lived through Rome’s Carthaginian struggles, the Thirty Years War in Europe, Napoleon’s campaign in Russia or the 1916 Somme battles would mock the notion that Indochina offered qualitatively worse experiences. The violence that men inflicted with spears and swords, or unleashed on innocents in the path of armies, was as ghastly in the second century AD as in the twentieth. An attacker set afire by burning oil poured from the walls of a medieval city suffered as terribly as one who fell victim to napalm. Looting, rape, black markets, casual violence towards civilians and prisoners, are inseparable from all conflicts. The 1939–45 cities of Europe hosted as many girls for sale as later did Saigon – recall London’s ‘Piccadilly commandos’. In times gone by, however, little was said to folks back home about such sordid manifestations. Film footage authorised for public screening excluded images that were deemed demoralising, because explicit.