The Silver Box

by John Galsworthy

MAGISTRATE. But how did you get into the HOUSE?

  JONES. I was passin'. I was goin' 'ome from the "Goat and Bells."

  MAGISTRATE. The "Goat and Bells,"—what is that? A public-house?

  JONES. Yes, at the corner. It was Bank 'oliday, an' I'd 'ad a drop to drink. I see this young Mr. BARTHWICK tryin' to find the keyhole on the wrong side of the door.

  MAGISTRATE. Well?

  JONES. [Slowly and with many pauses.] Well—I 'elped 'im to find it—drunk as a lord 'e was. He goes on, an' comes back again, and says, I've got nothin' for you, 'e says, but come in an' 'ave a drink. So I went in just as you might 'ave done yourself. We 'ad a drink o' whisky just as you might have 'ad, 'nd young Mr. BARTHWICK says to me, "Take a drink 'nd a smoke. Take anything you like, 'e says." And then he went to sleep on the sofa. I 'ad some more whisky—an' I 'ad a smoke—and I 'ad some more whisky—an' I carn't tell yer what 'appened after that.

  MAGISTRATE. Do you mean to say that you were so drunk that you can remember nothing?

  JACK. [Softly to his father.] I say, that's exactly what—

  BARTHWICK. TSSh!

  JONES. That's what I do mean.

  MAGISTRATE. And yet you say you stole the box?

  JONES. I never stole the box. I took it.

  MAGISTRATE. [Hissing with protruded neck.] You did not steal it— you took it. Did it belong to you—what is that but stealing?

  JONES. I took it.

  MAGISTRATE. You took it—you took it away from their house and you took it to your house—

  JONES. [Sullenly breaking in.] I ain't got a house.

  MAGISTRATE. Very well, let us hear what this young man Mr.—Mr. BARTHWICK has to say to your story.

  [SNOW leaves the witness-box. The BALD CONSTABLE beckons JACK, who, clutching his hat, goes into the witness-box. ROPER moves to the table set apart for his profession.]

  SWEARING CLERK. The evidence you give to the court shall be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God. Kiss the book.

  [The book is kissed.]

  ROPER. [Examining.] What is your name?

  JACK. [In a low voice.] John Barthwick, Junior.

  [The CLERK writes it down.]

  ROPER. Where do you live?

  JACK. At 6, Rockingham Gate.

  [All his answers are recorded by the Clerk.]

  ROPER. You are the son of the owner?

  JACK. [In a very low voice.] Yes.

  ROPER. Speak up, please. Do you know the prisoners?

  JACK. [Looking at the JONESES, in a low voice.] I've seen Mrs. Jones. I [in a loud voice] don't know the man.

  JONES. Well, I know you!

  BALD CONSTABLE. HSSh!

  ROPER. Now, did you come in late on the night of Easter Monday?

  JACK. Yes.

  ROPER. And did you by mistake leave your latch key in the door?

  JACK. Yes.

  MAGISTRATE. Oh! You left your latch-key in the door?

  ROPER. And is that all you can remember about your coming in?

  JACK. [In a loud voice.] Yes, it is.

  MAGISTRATE. Now, you have heard the male prisoner's story, what do you say to that?

  JACK. [Turning to the MAGISTRATE, speaks suddenly in a confident, straight-forward voice.] The fact of the matter is, sir, that I'd been out to the theatre that night, and had supper afterwards, and I came in late.

  MAGISTRATE. Do you remember this man being outside when you came in?

  JACK. No, Sir. [He hesitates.] I don't think I do.

  MAGISTRATE. [Somewhat puzzled.] Well, did he help you to open the door, as he says? Did any one help you to open the door?

  JACK. No, sir—I don't think so, sir—I don't know.

  MAGISTRATE. You don't know? But you must know. It isn't a usual thing for you to have the door opened for you, is it?

  JACK. [With a shamefaced smile.] No.

  MAGISTRATE. Very well, then—

  JACK. [Desperately.] The fact of the matter is, sir, I'm afraid I'd had too much champagne that night.

  MAGISTRATE. [Smiling.] Oh! you'd had too much champagne?

  JONES. May I ask the gentleman a question?

  MAGISTRATE. Yes—yes—you may ask him what questions you like.

  JONES. Don't you remember you said you was a Liberal, same as your father, and you asked me wot I was?

  JACK. [With his hand against his brow.] I seem to remember—

  JONES. And I said to you, "I'm a bloomin' Conservative," I said; an' you said to me, "You look more like one of these 'ere Socialists. Take wotever you like," you said.

  JACK. [With sudden resolution.] No, I don't. I don't remember anything of the sort.

  JONES. Well, I do, an' my word's as good as yours. I've never been had up in a police court before. Look 'ere, don't you remember you had a sky-blue bag in your 'and [BARTHWICK jumps.]

  ROPER. I submit to your worship that these questions are hardly to the point, the prisoner having admitted that he himself does not remember anything. [There is a smile on the face of Justice.] It is a case of the blind leading the blind.

  JONES. [Violently.] I've done no more than wot he 'as. I'm a poor man; I've got no money an' no friends—he's a toff—he can do wot I can't.

  MAGISTRATE: Now, now? All this won't help you—you must be quiet. You say you took this box? Now, what made you take it? Were you pressed for money?

  JONES. I'm always pressed for money.

  MAGISTRATE. Was that the reason you took it?

  JONES. No.

  MAGISTRATE. [To SNOW.] Was anything found on him?

  SNOW. Yes, your worship. There was six pounds twelve shillin's found on him, and this purse.

  [The red silk purse is handed to the MAGISTRATE. BARTHWICK rises his seat, but hastily sits down again.]

  MAGISTRATE. [Staring at the purse.] Yes, yes—let me see [There is a silence.] No, no, I've nothing before me as to the purse. How did you come by all that money?

  JONES. [After a long pause, suddenly.] I declines to say.

  MAGISTRATE. But if you had all that money, what made you take this box?

  JONES. I took it out of spite.

  MAGISTRATE. [Hissing, with protruded neck.] You took it out of spite? Well now, that's something! But do you imagine you can go about the town taking things out of spite?

  JONES. If you had my life, if you'd been out of work—

  MAGISTRATE. Yes, yes; I know—because you're out of work you think it's an excuse for everything.

  JONES. [Pointing at JACK.] You ask 'im wot made 'im take the—

  ROPER. [Quietly.] Does your Worship require this witness in the box any longer?

  MAGISTRATE. [Ironically.] I think not; he is hardly profitable.

  [JACK leaves the witness-box, and hanging his head, resumes his seat.]

  JONES. You ask 'im wot made 'im take the lady's—

  [But the BALD CONSTABLE catches him by the sleeve.]

  BALD CONSTABLE. SSSh!

  MAGISTRATE. [Emphatically.] Now listen to me.

  I've nothing to do with what he may or may not have taken. Why did you resist the police in the execution of their duty?

  JONES. It warn't their duty to take my wife, a respectable woman, that 'adn't done nothing.

  MAGISTRATE. But I say it was. What made you strike the officer a blow?

  JONES. Any man would a struck 'im a blow. I'd strike 'im again, I would.

  MAGISTRATE. You are not making your case any better by violence. How do you suppose we could get on if everybody behaved like you?

  JONES. [Leaning forward, earnestly.] Well, wot, about 'er; who's to make up to 'er for this? Who's to give 'er back 'er good name?

  MRS. JONES. Your Worship, it's the children that's preying on his mind, because of course I've lost my work. And I've had to find another room owing to the scandal.

  MAGISTRATE. Yes, yes, I know—but if he hadn't acted like this nobody would have suffered.

  JONES. [Glaring round at JACK.] I've done no worse than wot 'e 'as
. Wot I want to know is wot 's goin' to be done to 'im.

  [The BALD CONSTABLE again says "HSSh"]

  ROPER. Mr. BARTHWICK wishes it known, your Worship, that considering the poverty of the prisoners, he does not press the charge as to the box. Perhaps your Worship would deal with the case as one of disorder.

  JONES. I don't want it smothered up, I want it all dealt with fair —I want my rights—

  MAGISTRATE. [Rapping his desk.] Now you have said all you have to say, and you will be quiet.

  [There is a silence; the MAGISTRATE bends over and parleys with his CLERK.]

  Yes, I think I may discharge the woman. [In a kindly voice he addresses MRS. JONES, who stands unmoving with her hands crossed on the rail.] It is very unfortunate for you that this man has behaved as he has. It is not the consequences to him but the consequences to you. You have been brought here twice, you have lost your work— [He glares at JONES]—and this is what always happens. Now you may go away, and I am very sorry it was necessary to bring you here at all.

  MRS. JONES. [Softly.] Thank you very much, your Worship.

  [She leaves the dock, and looking back at JONES, twists her fingers and is still.]

  MAGISTRATE. Yes, yes, but I can't pass it over. Go away, there's a good woman.

  [MRS. JONES stands back. The MAGISTRATE leans his head on his hand; then raising it he speaks to JONES.]

  Now, listen to me. Do you wish the case to be settled here, or do you wish it to go before a jury?

  JONES. [Muttering.] I don't want no jury.

  MAGISTRATE. Very well then, I will deal with it here. [After a pause.] You have pleaded guilty to stealing this box—

  JONES. Not to stealin'—

  BALD CONSTABLE. HSSShh!

  MAGISTRATE. And to assaulting the police—

  JONES. Any man as was a man—

  MAGISTRATE. Your conduct here has been most improper. You give the excuse that you were drunk when you stole the box. I tell you that is no excuse. If you choose to get drunk and break the law afterwards you must take the consequences. And let me tell you that men like you, who get drunk and give way to your spite or whatever it is that's in you, are—are—a nuisance to the community.

  JACK. [Leaning from his seat.] Dad! that's what you said to me!

  BARTHWICK. TSSt!

  [There is a silence, while the MAGISTRATE consults his CLERK; JONES leans forward waiting.]

  MAGISTRATE. This is your first offence, and I am going to give you a light sentence. [Speaking sharply, but without expression.] One month with hard labour.

  [He bends, and parleys with his CLERK. The BALD CONSTABLE and another help JONES from the dock.]

  JONES. [Stopping and twisting round.] Call this justice? What about 'im? 'E got drunk! 'E took the purse—'e took the purse but [in a muffled shout] it's 'is money got 'im off—JUSTICE!

  [The prisoner's door is shut on JONES, and from the seedy-looking men and women comes a hoarse and whispering groan.]

  MAGISTRATE. We will now adjourn for lunch! [He rises from his seat.]

  [The Court is in a stir. ROPER gets up and speaks to the reporter. JACK, throwing up his head, walks with a swagger to the corridor; BARTHWICK follows.]

  MRS. JONES. [Turning to him zenith a humble gesture.] Oh! sir!

  [BARTHWICK hesitates, then yielding to his nerves, he makes a shame-faced gesture of refusal, and hurries out of court. MRS. JONES stands looking after him.]

  The curtain falls.

  John Galsworthy – His Life And Times

  John Galsworthy, eldest son of John Galsworthy (1817-1904), a solicitor and company director of Old Jewry, London, and Blanche Bailey (1835-1915), daughter of Charles Bartleet, a needlemaker in Redditch. His father’s ancestors originated in Wembury, near Plymouth in England, and Galsworthy, for whom family origins were of significant importance, maintained a close connection with Devon. His more immediate family were considerably wealthy and well established in the shipping industry, and owned a fine estate in Kingston-upon-Thames called Parkfield, where Galsworthy was born on the 14th August 1867. At the age of nine he began education at Saugeen, a Bournemouth preparatory school, before starting at Harrow school in 1881 where he remained until 1886, distinguishing himself as an athlete.

  His education at Harrow being successful enough to gain him entrance to Oxford, he began at New College to read law and gained a second-class degree with honours in 1889. Following Lincoln’s Inn he was called to the bar in 1890. Despite this recognition he realised that he was not keen to actually begin practising law and so he resolved instead to look after the family’s shipping business while specialising himself in Marine Law. This decision saw him take to the seas to destinations such as Vancouver, Island and South AFrica, though it was at the age of twenty-five on one particular journey to Australia, motivated by an (unfulfilled) intention to meet Robert Louis Stevenson on Samoa that he would being to realise fully his literary interests: though he was not considering becoming a writer at this time, his enjoyment of literature was enough to encourage an attempt at meeting a great writer and eventually enabled one of the most significant encounters of his life. He made the journey with his friend Edward Sanderson and, though he missed Stevenson, he met Joseph Conrad, a fellow future author famed for his novels which were often nautically themed. At the time Conrad was the first mate of the sailing-ship Torrens moored in the harbour of Adelaide, Australia; still very much focused on his ship-borne career, he was yet to begin his writing in earnest.

  Indeed, though neither knew at the time, both Conrad and Galsworthy were at similar junctures in their lives, their time spent as sea acting as a transitional period during which each found their literary calling. It is perhaps owning to this unknown common ground that they became close friends. During his time on the Torrens Galsworthy recorded several details, offering a frank and valuable characterisation of Conrad while also illuminating his own experiences as a student of Marine Law.

  ”I supposed to be studying navigation for the Admiralty Bar, would every day work out the position of the ship with the captain. On one side of the saloon table we would sit and check our observations with those of Conrad, who from the other side of the table would look at us a little quizzically.”

  On his return to England and the cessation of his nautical voyaging, Galsworthy began an affair with the wife of his first cousin, Major Arthur John Galsworthy. Ada Nemesis Pearson Cooper (1864-1956), the daughter of Emanuel Copper, an obstetrician from Norwich, remained married to the Major for ten years and the affair remained secret for its duration. In order to conceal the affair they took considerable pains to avoid suspicion. One such tactic was to stay in a secluded farmhouse called Wingstone in the village on Manaton on Dartmoor, in Devon. In Galsworthy’s decision to choose Devon as the location for their clandestine rendezvous we see evidence of Galsworthy’s affection for the place of his father’s origin. It was only when, in 1905, she divorced the Major that their affair became known following their marriage on 23rd September of that year.

  Galsworthy now took to writing sometime after having met Conrad and his career began in earnest when, in 1897, his first work, From the Four Winds, a volume of short stories, was published under the pseudonym John Sinjohn. He succeeded this in 1898 with Jocelyn, his first novel, and then his second in 1900, Villa Rubein. In 1901 he published a second volume of short stories, A Man of Devon, which was the last of his work to be published under pseudonym. The first of his work to be published under his own name was The Island Pharisees in 1904, a novel of social observation, seasoned with flashes of satire and propaganda. His decision to write under his own name is arguably owing to the recent death of his father, either as a mark of respect to his name or because now he was able to publish freely without incurring the possibility of paternal disappointment at his choice of career. It also marked a shift in his professionalism; he had hitherto published with small, independent publishers, but The Island Pharisees was published by Heinemann, a far more established Hous
e and one with whom he remained for the duration of his writing career.

  He arguably cemented his position and maturity as a writer when, in 1906, he saw the publication of both his first major play, The Silver Box, and the novel The Man of Property. Each was published to considerable critical acclaim, and to achieve both in such a short space of time was impressive. The Silver Box concerns the imbalance in the justice system with regards to criminals of differing class by contrasting the treatment of a poor thief and a rich thief, both of whom stole silver cigarette cases but for very different reasons. The complexity of individual experience when not dealt with in public is highlighted and questioned in a bravely critical manner; despite the clear issues it raises with class and privilege, the final night was attended by the Price and Princess of Wales. The Man of Property was the first novel in the famous The Forsyte Saga, a trilogy of novels with an ‘interlude’ between each one, written between 1906 and 1921. Dealing with the questions of status, class and materialism, The Man of Property introduces us to the Forsyte family, particularly Soames Forsyte, who is acutely aware of his status as ‘new money’ and equally keen to assert himself as a wealthy man. Jealous of his wife and desperate to own things in order to confirm his wealth to those observing him, he engineers a plan to keep his wife from her friends which backfires spectacularly when, instead of cutting her off, all Soames achieves is enabling her to have an affair. This drives Soames to terrible actions with terrible consequences, which Galsworthy depicts with confidence.