Monroe, Marla - Their Broken Lady (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Marla Monroe

  “Fuck, aw, fuck, baby. You’re so freaking tight.” Bryan’s voice sounded even more strained than before. It was almost as if he were in pain.

  “Ride him, Amber. I want to see that pretty pussy swallow his dick.” Tanner stood behind her now. She couldn’t see him unless she looked over her shoulder.

  She pulled up then dropped down slow then fast, over and over. Soon, Bryan was shoving his cock up to meet her. His hands held her hips as he pistoned into her.

  “Bryan, hold her, man.” Tanner slowly pushed her down against Bryan’s chest.

  Bryan wrapped his arms around her. He kissed her forehead as she rested her cheek against his chest.

  Suddenly she felt something cold and wet at her asshole. She yelped and started to sit up. Bryan held her steady.

  “Easy, Amber. He won’t hurt you. He’s going to prepare you.”

  “I–I’ve never had anyone there before,” she said in a shaky voice.

  “I know, baby. That’s why he’s going to loosen you up. We don’t want to hurt you. Just push out when he uses his fingers on you. Okay, baby?”

  She squeaked out an okay and nodded her head against his chest. She wasn’t at all sure about this. She wanted to, wanted them both inside her, but she was scared at the same time.

  Tanner’s finger pressed the cool gel inside her ass. He dropped a little more there and pushed it as well. This time, his finger went with it. She didn’t even have to push out for it. She let out a relieved breath. Maybe this wouldn’t be so hard after all.

  He pushed his finger in and out of her several times, then added more of the lube, and added another finger. This time it pinched, and she pushed out until he made it inside with them. He pumped them in and out of her back hole over and over until they moved freely. Then he added yet more lube, and another finger joined the first two. This time it burned, and she suppressed a cry. She remembered what Bryan had said, and pushed out while trying to breath through the burn. When the third finger made it inside, he grew still, waiting on her to get used to it she guessed.

  Amber began to twitch. She needed them to move. It was too much. They needed to move inside of her. She tried to push back and pull off his fingers, but he followed her. Finally, he began pumping them in and out of her ass in a smooth rhythm that just wasn’t fast enough for her. She whimpered and tried to speed him up, but he kept the same pace.

  “More, Tanner. Faster. I need it faster.” She finally told him what she needed when it didn’t look like he was going to give it to her.

  Instead, he pulled his fingers out and added more lube. Then he fitted the head of his cock against her back opening and pushed. Fire burned as he pushed his way inside of her. She pushed out against the burn. Finally, he popped through the ring of resistance and tunneled deep into her ass. He stilled and they all panted, trying to catch their breath. Amber looked up at Bryan’s face. He was covered with sweat. His cock jumped inside of her occasionally as if chomping at the bit to be let go.

  Finally, she couldn’t stand it anymore and pulled back from them and shoved down, then shoved back. She heard Tanner curse then grab her hips while Bryan held her legs.

  “Be still, honey. Let us do the work. We don’t want to hurt you.” Tanner squeezed her hips.

  “Then move, damn you!” She couldn’t believe that was her voice demanding they fuck her.

  Tanner chuckled then began to move forward and pull back as Bryan pushed up and pulled out. They slowly gained a rhythm that was quickly driving her insane with pleasure. She held herself up some using her arms on the bed on either side of Bryan’s chest. She wanted to help, but they held her steady as they fucked in and out of her. She squeezed down on them using her cunt muscles and ass muscles in an effort to get them to speed up.

  “Aw, fuck, just like that.” Bryan said. “God! Do it again, baby.”

  “Hell, she’s going to make me come.” Tanner cursed again and slapped her ass.

  “God, yes!” she yelled out.

  He spanked her again on the other cheek and she shoved back on him, squeezing for all she was worth. Tanner growled at her, then shoved his dick deep in her ass as soon as Bryan pulled out of her pussy. They took her hint and sped up. Soon they were plunging in and out of her dual holes sending her higher and higher. Nerve endings in her ass came alive with the constant stimulation. She felt as if she were on the verge of something monumental. When it hit her, she wasn’t prepared for something so big.

  Her orgasm exploded over her until she couldn’t see anything but white light or hear anything but her racing heartbeat. Then she became aware of Tanner roaring as he shot his cum into the condom deep in her ass. A few seconds later, Bryan shouted her name as he filled the condom. Slowly things began to drift back to normal with her continued twitching as nerves fired off randomly, sending little shock waves through her clit and cunt. Every time one hit, the guys groaned.

  Amber lay half alive and half unconscious across Bryan’s chest. She didn’t have the energy to open her eyes, much less move off of the top of him. She knew he had to be having trouble catching his breath with her on him, but she couldn’t move.

  Finally, Tanner pulled out of her ass with a soft pop and padded to the bathroom. When he returned, he began to clean her up. She whimpered at being disturbed. She was as comfortable as she could possibly be trying to catch her breath.

  “Tanner. You need to get her off of me before this condom leaks. I’ve never come so much in my life.” Bryan held the condom as Tanner lifted Amber off of his mostly flaccid dick. He rolled off the bed and hurried to the bathroom. Tanner laid her back on the bed and continued cleaning her up. Then he pulled the covers up over her and returned the cloth to the bathroom.

  “Tanner, hold her while I check on the men and the horses. I’ll be back as soon as I can.” He bent over her and kissed her. “I’ve never felt anything like you, Amber. You drove me wild.”

  He kissed her again and walked out of the bedroom presumably to get dressed. Tanner climbed into the bed with her and pulled her into his arms. He wrapped a leg over hers and pulled her hair back so he could nuzzle her neck.

  “You are the most amazing woman I’ve ever met, Amber. I just came so hard my eyes burned, and already I want you again. He pushed his hardening cock against her ass. She moaned.

  “I’ve never come like that before. It was unbelievable.” She wanted to do it again, but she needed to rest first.

  If someone had told her she would enjoy having sex with two men at the same time, she would have told them they were crazy. Not so now. She loved every minute of it. She sighed. Hell, she might even love them. Maybe it was just the emotional reaction to all the endorphins. Amber couldn’t believe she could possibly fall in love with two men, and fall so quickly.

  Tanner mouthed her shoulder, then nipped at it. She leaned her head forward, giving him more room to explore. She liked the feel of his mouth on her body.

  “How are you feeling?” he asked between nibbles.

  “Hmm, good.” She drew in a deep breath and let it out slowly. “Real good.”

  “I’m going to go run you a bath. I don’t want you to be real sore. The warm water will help that.” He kissed her neck then rolled off her and the bed.

  Amber watched him disappear into the bathroom. A few seconds later, she heard the water turn on. She closed her eyes and was almost asleep when he came back and pulled the covers off of her. She yelped and tried to grab them, but he just laughed and picked her up.

  “Warm water, Amber. Just a second.” He carried her into the bathroom and climbed into the tub with her.

  Tanner slowly let her slide out of his arms until she was standing up on her own. He kept a hand against her back until she knelt in the tub and sat down. He did the same thing and pulled her back into his arms before pushing the button for the jets to start. She moaned as the water began to froth around her.

  “This feels so good.” She would love one of these at her house.

  “Told
you it would feel good.” He rubbed up and down her arms. She felt his cock jerk against her ass as she lay back against him. It brought a grin to her face.

  “Tanner?”

  “Hmm?”

  “Do you believe the police that someone might be after me?”

  “Honey, don’t think about it right now. You’re safe with us.”

  “But I can’t stay here forever, Tanner. I have to go home.”

  He stiffened. “No you don’t. You can live with us.”

  “You’re asking me to move in with you? What would Bryan say?”

  “That he would have already asked you, except he was scared you would say no.”

  Amber turned her head in time to see Bryan peel off his jeans and walk toward them. He stepped over into the tub and sat across from them.

  “Guys, I can’t move in with you. I have my own life.”

  “That includes us now. You can still do all the things you normally do. You’ll just live out here instead of that house.” Bryan seemed to censor his words concerning her house.

  She knew it wasn’t much, but it had been all hers. She loved that house. Well, she had loved it until a man had attacked her in it. Now she wasn’t sure if she could actually stay there anymore. But that didn’t mean she had to stay with them, either.

  “What are you thinking in that amazing head of yours?” Tanner asked.

  “That even if I can’t live in the house anymore, it doesn’t mean I can stay with you either. What will people say?”

  “Why does it matter what people say, Amber?” Bryan asked.

  “I work at a bank. They are pretty straightlaced there. It could cost me my job.”

  “Bryan.” Tanner seemed to be trying to tell him something.

  “Then quit the bank. You don’t have to work. We’ll take care of you.”

  Amber stiffened. He obviously hadn’t listened to Tanner. She started to get out of the tub, but Tanner held her still.

  “Let me go, Tanner.”

  “Not until you hear us out. Bryan didn’t explain it right.”

  “I think he did a pretty damn good job of explaining it as far as I’m concerned.”

  “If you want to work, you can work, but if you don’t want to, you don’t have to. We can take care of you, but it doesn’t mean you can’t take care of yourself.”

  “So I can work if I want to. You’ll let me work. Somehow that didn’t convince me at all, Tanner.”

  “You’re reading too much into it, baby.” Bryan said with a desperate sound in his voice.

  “I don’t think I am. You’ve been taking over my life ever since you came into it. Yes, you’ve saved it twice, but that doesn’t give you the right to tell me what I can and can’t do.”

  “We’re not trying to tell you what to do, Amber. We’re just asking you to move in with us. We like you, a lot. We enjoy being around you, and the sex is fucking unbelievable. It’s the next step most couples take,” Bryan reasoned.

  “First of all, usually couples date before they move in together. We’ve never been on one date, much less enough to warrant moving in together. Two, couple being the operative word here. You’re talking about a ménage, not a couple. And three, you can’t keep me here against my will.”

  Chapter Ten

  There was absolute silence in the room. No one moved. She could hear her own rapid breathing and equally rapid heartbeat.

  “I’m sorry, baby.” Bryan stood up. “I didn’t mean to screw this up. I just want you to be happy and safe.” He got out of the tub and, grabbing a towel, walked out of the bathroom trailing water behind him.

  Tanner released her and sighed. “You never gave us a chance to date you, Amber. We wanted to. Would have Friday night except you were attacked. It kind of put a damper on our plans. You’re right, though. We’re jumping the gun. Would you consider dating us for a while to see if you want to live with us?”

  Amber could still feel her heart in her throat. She wrapped her arms around herself and stood up.

  “I don’t know, Tanner. We’ve done this all backward. I don’t know if I can handle two men all the time. It’s not a normal type of relationship.”

  “But you’ll think about it?” he asked.

  “Yeah, I’ll think about it.” She climbed out of the tub and started drying off, then padded into the bedroom to find something to put on.

  She heard the tub shut off and then the sounds of it draining. A few seconds later, Tanner walked out with a towel around his waist. He looked at her for a second, then drew in a deep breath and let it out. He didn’t say anything, just walked out of the room, shutting the door quietly behind him.

  Tears formed in Amber’s eyes and she brushed them away angrily. Why did she feel like the bad guy? She was the one that had been maneuvered into doing what they wanted. Only she wasn’t going to do it. She was her own person and could make her own decisions. She didn’t need them to run her life.

  She quickly mopped up the mess Bryan had made walking out the door wet. Then she pulled on her clothes and straightened up the bed before walking out of the bedroom and down the stairs. She found Tanner dressed standing in the kitchen drinking coffee.

  “Would you like a cup? I have cinnamon rolls in the oven.”

  “Some coffee, yes. Thanks. I’m not really hungry, though.” She waited while he poured a cup for her.

  She took it to the bar and got up on a barstool. He didn’t look at her, just stared into his coffee.

  “Where is Bryan?” she asked.

  “He went to let the locksmith in to work on your windows.”

  “What locksmith? I haven’t called anyone yet.” She set the cup on the bar.

  “We called one. We trust him to do a good job. I know you could have done it, but you were upset, and then we hoped maybe you would move in with us.” He set his cup down and checked the rolls. “Anyway, don’t get upset about it. Just live with it, Amber. If nothing else, I’m going to make damn certain you’re safe.”

  She opened her mouth to fuss anyway, but closed it. They had been nothing but good to her. She shouldn’t bitch at them over every single thing.

  “Okay. Thanks. You can send me the bill and I’ll pay it.”

  Tanner didn’t say anything. He pulled out the cinnamon rolls and set them on top of the stove. He pulled down a plate and transferred them to the plate before spreading the glaze across them.

  They looked good, but Amber really didn’t have an appetite. In fact, she was a little bit nauseous. Too much had happened in a short time. She’d known them all of two weeks now. Watching Tanner, she realized she knew nothing about him other than he was a doctor of some kind, and that he and Bryan had this ranch with the amazing house.

  “You’re welcome to stay here as long as you want to, Amber. We’ll take you home whenever you get ready once the house is secure.”

  “I think it’s best if I go today once they finish the locks. I’m just causing trouble by being here.”

  “No you’re not, Amber.” He stood up straight from where he’d been lounging against the counter again.

  “I’ve either made Bryan mad or hurt his feelings. You’re not happy now, either. I’m disrupting everything. I need to go.”

  Tanner pressed his lips together and nodded. “Fine. When Bryan gets back, we’ll take you home as long as the locks are all done.”

  He refilled his coffee cup but didn’t touch the cinnamon rolls. Now she’d taken his appetite as well. She climbed off the barstool and took her coffee into the living room and sat on the hearth of the fireplace, wishing it were cold enough for a fire. Right now, she felt cold enough inside. A fire might have reached the recesses of her heart. Maybe.

  A few minutes later, Tanner walked into the room. He stood in the doorway for a few minutes, then crossed the room to where she sat on the hearth. He bent down and took the cup form her and set it on the coffee table. Then he pulled her to her feet and walked her across to the couch. He sat down and pulled her down into his
lap. She wasn’t sure why she let him other than the look on his face. He looked sad and that bothered her.

  “Just let me hold you for a while, Amber. Nothing sexual, just hold you.”

  Amber let him hold her. She wasn’t sure how long they sat there, but sometime later, Bryan walked in the front door. He looked haggard and worn out. He took one look at them and sighed. He turned and headed upstairs.

  After a while, he returned downstairs freshly showered dressed in clean clothes. He sat on the other side of the couch and stared at them.

  “The windows are secure now, Amber. The locksmith guarantees them, short of breaking the glass. I started to get bars, but I figured you wouldn’t like them. They would have been safer.”

  “Thanks, Bryan, for taking care of it for me. I told Tanner to send me the bill.”

  Bryan started to say something, but Tanner stopped him.

  “Leave it, Bryan.”

  “Anyway, I cleaned everything up so your room didn’t have fingerprint dust all over it. You’ll probably want to dust again, but most of it’s gone.”

  “Thank you. You didn’t have to go to all that trouble.”

  “Had to do something while the locksmith was working. He didn’t like me hanging around him.

  “I told Amber we’d take her back once you were back and the windows were finished.”

  Tanner stood up and let Amber slide down his body. It did things to her insides. She shook it off and stood up straight.

  “Yeah, sure. Where is your stuff?” he asked.

  “I don’t have anything, remember?” Amber frowned.

  “Yeah you do. All the things we bought you. They’re yours,” Bryan insisted.

  “I’ll have my own things when I get back home. You can take those back, can’t you, and get your money back? You bought too much anyway.” She turned to look at Tanner.

  “Take the clothes, Amber. We bought them for you.” Tanner sounded defeated.