Star Trek: Enterprise - 017 - Rise of the Federation: Uncertain Logic

by Christopher L. Bennett

  Thank you for downloading this Pocket Books eBook.

  * * *

  Sign up for our newsletter and receive special offers, access to bonus content, and info on the latest new releases and other great eBooks from Pocket Books and Simon & Schuster.

  CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP

  or visit us online to sign up at

  eBookNews.SimonandSchuster.com

  To the memory of Mark Lenard

  Logic is a means for discovering truth, not for creating it.

  —Surak

  Kir’Shara

  2165

  Prologue

  January 6, 2165

  TesKahr Central Hospital, Confederacy of Vulcan

  T’RIN VALUED THE QUIET SOLITUDE that the data archives afforded during the nocturnal shift. It was an opportune environment for researching her dissertation, away from distractions such as the administrative requests she needed to process during daytime at the hospital or the enthusiasms of her Denobulan roommate at home. Thus, T’Rin allowed herself a moment’s twinge of annoyance when a panicked, armed man burst into the otherwise empty study area, brandished his phase pistol toward her, and cried, “Don’t move!”

  The seemingly Vulcan male then contradicted himself by grabbing her arm and pulling her roughly from her seat, spinning her around to clutch her from behind. He held the weapon against her temple as he dragged her into the archive stacks. “You’re coming with me.”

  She heard approaching footsteps outside the door. Her captor did not seem aware of them as yet, so she spoke to cover the sound. “Would you care to inform me of your reason for undertaking this—”

  “Shut up!”

  The main door opened, prompting her captor to pull her behind a tier of shelves. Through a slit in the shelving, T’Rin glimpsed the shoulders of a pair of individuals flanking the door, using the frame as cover as they peered inside. One wore the attire of Vulcan Security, while the other, who appeared human, wore a slate-gray tunic with a multicolored circular patch on the upper sleeve and at least one shoulder strap bearing two gold stripes. T’Rin was fairly sure it was a Starfleet uniform.

  “Stay out!” cried the gunman. “I have a hostage! I’ll kill her if you come any closer!”

  “Just take it easy, Temos,” the human called. “Look around you. There’s nowhere you can go from here. If you harm that woman, it will only make things worse for you.”

  “I won’t let you take me alive! Now, stay back!” It was strange to see such agitation in what looked like a Vulcan face.

  “Nobody has to be hurt here, okay? I’d just like a chance to speak to the woman you’re holding, if you don’t mind.”

  “I am perfectly capable of speaking for myself,” T’Rin informed the Starfleet officer.

  “That’s good, ma’am. My name’s Lieutenant Commander Takashi Kimura. I’m with the U.S.S. Endeavour. What’s your name?”

  “T’Rin of TesKahr,” she replied, recognizing the commander’s attempt to get her abductor to think of her as a person. “Employee at this hospital.”

  “Working late tonight?”

  “A private research project.” She glared at Temos—if that was his real name. “Whose interruption I do not appreciate.”

  “Enough of this,” the gunman barked. “Talk to me! You talk to me!”

  “I’m just trying to make sure everyone’s comfortable.”

  T’Rin raised her voice before Temos could respond. “Your concern is unnecessary, Commander. You have my leave to do what you must to resolve the situation.”

  “Shut up!” Temos fired through the door, forcing his pursuers to duck. He dragged her deeper into the stacks. “Do you want me to shoot you?”

  “No. But we are in a hospital, so my odds of survival if you do shoot me are better here than nearly anywhere else.” She looked him over. “Further, since your deportment belies your Vulcan appearance, I must conclude you are an impostor. Most likely a Malurian infiltrator. Therefore I surmise your familiarity with Vulcan anatomy is limited, further reducing the probability that you could deliver an instantly lethal injury.”

  “Keep it up and we’ll test that!” His burst of anger at her deduction merely confirmed it. The criminal class of the Malurians, known for their skills in disguise and infiltration, had been prominent in the news since they, along with other criminal organizations allied with the Orion Syndicate, had been implicated in efforts to manipulate last year’s election for President of the United Federation of Planets, in favor of those factions supporting the weakening and, at the greatest extreme, the dissolution of the federal state in favor of planetary autonomy. Following that discovery, most of the Planetarist factions had voluntarily cooperated in weeding out infiltrators within their own ranks—save for Vulcan’s own Anti-revisionist movement, led by Professor T’Nol, who had fervently denied even the possibility that her group had been compromised. Which, in T’Rin’s view, had made it the most likely candidate for continued infiltration—a view that the current situation strongly reinforced.

  “We have all the exits covered, Temos!” Kimura called. “You’re not gaining anything this way.”

  Giving up the search for an exit, the disguised infiltrator pushed her to the floor in a short dead-end space between two tiers of shelving, then stood nervous vigil at its open end. “I’ll take you all with me if I have to! I’m not afraid to die!”

  The Starfleet man’s response was careful, calming. “Honestly, Temos, it seems to me that what you’re doing now is about trying to stay alive. Now, I’d like to help you figure out a way to do that.”

  “That would be agreeable for all concerned,” T’Rin opined.

  Temos glared back at her. “Do you never stop talking?” She merely studied him from where she sat on the floor, arms folded. “I just need time to think. Got to sort this out.”

  Though he seemed to be muttering to himself, his agitation made him loud enough that Kimura heard him. “That’s good. Let’s think this through.”

  “Don’t tell me what to do!”

  “I just want to help you figure this out for yourself, Temos. There are a couple of things you might want to consider.”

  He hesitated. “Like what?”

  “Let me ask you something first. What reason would an agent like yourself have for sacrificing his life? It’s to keep anyone from finding proof of Malurian involvement, isn’t it?”

  “You don’t know what you’re talking about!”

  “I’ve seen how far the Raldul alignment will go to keep that secret. I once saw a Malurian leader kill dozens of his own people to try to keep us from discovering who they really were. It was ruthless. He didn’t give a moment’s thought to his people, didn’t give them a chance to survive.”

  “You’re lying! Garos cares about his men. He wouldn’t sacrifice us unless he had to. All those men understood that.” He froze, realizing he’d said too much.

  But the human didn’t acknowledge the slip. His goal was clearly to put Temos at ease, not make him feel more trapped. “I can understand being willing to sacrifice yourself for your cause. But what cause would be served by your death, Temos? We already know you’re Malurian. We have the evidence to prove it. You see, we knew what materials went into making Malurian masks. My ship’s doctor, Phlox, figured that out. So we notified the manufacturers and vendors of those materials to be alert to certain types of orders. And when you ordered the materials for that new mask you’re wearing, the one
you had to make to infiltrate the hospital staff, they notified Vulcan Security. That’s what led us here to you.

  “And we know you’re linked to the Anti-revisionists, Temos. We found the correspondence on your apartment’s computer. So you see, you’ve got no secrets to preserve anymore. And no mission either,” Kimura went on, sounding almost apologetic. “Now that we know you were trying to plant false records, there’s no point in trying to hide it anymore. You’d be killing yourself, and an innocent woman, for no reason. Is that really what your alignment would want? Would that be good for Maluria?”

  Temos shook his head, almost laughing. “Oh, this is insane.” He sagged against the shelves to T’Rin’s right. “I shouldn’t even be here,” he said quietly, addressing her almost as a confidant. “I should’ve left months ago. Garos wanted to pull me out, but the damned professor wouldn’t let him.”

  “Professor T’Nol?” T’Rin interpreted. “The Anti-revisionist leader?”

  “Oh, she assured Garos that she’d just keep me in reserve, let me lay low until the heat faded. But she couldn’t wait.” He made a sharp exhalation that sounded paradoxically humorous. “She made it all sound so logical, even though I knew it was a mistake to risk exposure this soon. And now look where I am!”

  “If you find the professor’s objective so irrational, why endanger yourself? Why not merely surrender to the authorities?”

  “I can’t turn myself in! Can’t risk being interrogated about my alignment.”

  “Temos, are you still there?” Kimura called.

  “Quiet! I’m trying to think!”

  “Okay, but I want to keep this conversation going, all right?”

  “Commander,” T’Rin spoke up, “I believe Mister Temos and I are having a productive conversation of our own. But I would like to consult you on a certain point that may be relevant.”

  The human paused. “Anything I can do to help.”

  “In your opinion as a security expert, what do you think Mister Temos’s employers would do if they were concerned with the possibility of his capture? Would they rely solely on the expectation that he would self-immolate?” She held Temos’s eyes as she asked this.

  “No, ma’am, I don’t think so. If I were in their place, I’d have long since nullified any intelligence he had. Changed access codes and procedures, relocated outposts, and so on.”

  “I see. Then in that case, Temos would not be protecting his alignment by committing suicide?”

  “I don’t think so. In fact—Temos, are you still listening?”

  The gunman held T’Rin’s eyes, but responded to Kimura. “I’m here.”

  “You said Garos cares about his men,” the human said. “That he wouldn’t sacrifice you for no reason. If that’s true, then he wouldn’t want you to do this. Now, what you need to ask yourself is: Can you say the same about Professor T’Nol? Is it worth doing this for her?”

  After a long, thoughtful silence, Temos informed the security contingent that he was coming out. He placed his weapon on the floor and allowed himself to be taken into custody. Kimura personally saw to T’Rin, thanking her for what he called her brave assistance. Unfortunately, he also insisted on taking her in for questioning and a medical examination, rather than simply letting her get back to her studies as she desired. As Kimura led her out of the archives, she contemplated that she might need to find a better refuge from all these distractions.

  January 7, 2165

  Administration Tower, Central ShiKahr, Vulcan

  Admiral Jonathan Archer watched the news feed on First Minister Kuvak’s office monitor with considerable satisfaction. On the screen, Professor T’Nol, the gaunt and severe-featured leader of the Anti-revisionist faction, was making an unconvincing attempt to explain away the testimony of the captured Malurian infiltrator. The polling figures displayed at the bottom of the screen (helpfully in both Vulcan and Terran notation, though Archer was getting better at reading the former) made it clear that support for the Anti-revisionists was crumbling with her every sentence.

  “I still find it astonishing that T’Nol believed she could succeed in this plan,” Kuvak said from behind his desk, clasping his hands within the shroud of his loose, flowing sleeves. The first minister of the Confederacy of Vulcan was an older man with white-gray hair framing a sour, rounded face. In the eleven years since the rediscovery of the Kir’Shara—the long-lost, firsthand writings of Surak, the father of Vulcan philosophy—had triggered a planetwide reformation, Kuvak had grown in serenity and self-control compared to the easily agitated High Command minister he had been when Archer had first met him. But now, Archer could hear a definite edge of irritation and contempt in Kuvak’s curt, nasal voice. “Even if her operative had succeeded in planting the falsified data in my birth records, the premise that I was actually a human agent in disguise would never have been credible to the Vulcan people.”

  “To most of the Vulcan people, perhaps,” Captain T’Pol replied from her seat alongside Archer. “But there are many who would welcome any opportunity to accuse and discredit you, First Minister, and by extension the Syrannite movement as a whole.”

  “On Earth,” Archer said, “we used to call it ‘firing up the base.’ ”

  “It is not logical,” Kuvak said, shaking his head. “If one must deliberately falsify evidence to support one’s case, that should be sufficient proof that one’s case is erroneous and in need of modification.”

  “But we have seen such behavior from Vulcans before,” T’Pol reminded him.

  Kuvak nodded, recalling the events that had initially brought the three of them together. “T’Nol did serve as an adviser to Administrator V’Las during his tenure,” he affirmed. “It is reasonable to expect her to be similarly capable of . . . dissembling.” V’Las, as Archer recalled well, had lied without hesitation or remorse in order to destroy his political enemies and agitate for an unnecessary war against Andoria—almost causing the deaths of Archer and T’Pol in the former effort and the entire crew of Enterprise in the latter. It had been the last gasp of the old, militaristic Vulcan before the Kir’Shara reforms had ushered in a new, more enlightened regime.

  “Luckily, she was more inept at it than V’Las was,” Archer told him in a tone of amused satisfaction. “She really overplayed her hand this time, and it’s cost her the whole game.”

  “Quite so, if I follow your metaphor correctly.” The first minister turned to T’Pol, who cut a crisp figure as always in her avocado-green command tunic (adorned with the Endeavour mission patch on the right sleeve and the golden arrowhead of Earth’s space service on the breast) and close-fitting black trousers. “I particularly wish to commend your Lieutenant Commander Kimura,” Kuvak told her, “for persuading the Malurian agent to surrender peacefully. Temos’s testimony should discredit the Anti-revisionist movement once and for all—and without T’Nol’s leadership, the remaining anti-reform factions are too small and divided to create significant difficulties.”

  “I shall convey your gratitude to Mister Kimura,” T’Pol told him. “Although he was trained as a combat officer, I have found him to be capable of considerable wisdom and restraint.” Archer chose to ignore the implied for a human.

  “I’d say this is a good day for everyone,” Archer said—then nodded toward the screen, where T’Nol had just ended her statement and was retreating from the reporters’ questions. “Well, except her. From what Temos says, the Malurians, the Orions, and their allies have pulled out all their operatives in the Planetarist movement. That means we can have a proper debate about Federation law and policy without outside forces trying to sabotage the process. We can disagree honestly now—and that’s what makes a democracy work.”

  Residential district, ShiKahr

  Professor T’Nol suppressed a surge of irritation as she reflected on the disastrous press conference just concluded. Irritation would be an admission of vulnerability
. It was not her position that was at fault, but the mentality of the masses—so blinded by the propaganda of the Syrannites and their human allies, so distracted and confused by the ambiguities of the experiential world, that they could not see the truth revealed by pure logic alone. It was unfortunate—she reflected for what was not the first time—that Surak had phrased the text of the Kir’Shara in a way that could be so easily misrepresented by those favoring fashionable delusions such as pacifism and the equality of non-Vulcan races. In their folly, they ignored the clarification provided by the Analects—the writings of Surak’s disciples, who had refined and expanded upon his words and thus brought forth their true meaning.

  Thus reassured of the purity of her own logic, T’Nol was able to calm herself. Of course it was not she who was at fault, for she reasoned by absolute logic, untainted by the complications of the everyday world. The cause was just as valid despite the attempt of the Malurians to subvert it to their ends. That was why she had welcomed Temos into the movement’s ranks once she had become aware of him, recognizing that she could use his skills and resources to assist her in reconstructing the appearance of reality to bring out its deeper truths. That Kuvak was not, in fact, biologically human was beside the point; the purer truth was that he and the Syrannites advanced a human agenda to undermine Vulcan’s strength and autonomy.

  Granted, the failure and exposure of Temos was a setback. T’Nol should have known better than to place such faith in a non-Vulcan. And his superior in the Raldul alignment, Dular Garos, showed no inclination to assist T’Nol in controlling the damage Temos had caused the movement. “I anticipated the consequences of this mistake as soon as you made it, Professor,” the Malurian crime lord told her during the brief communication he had allowed. “I have already done all I could to insulate Raldul from any consequences. But the consequences to you and your party are richly deserved.” The brown eyes in his scaled gray face examined her disapprovingly before he finished: “You are useless to Maluria now, so from this point on—if anyone asks—I do not know you.” The screen went dark.