The Secret Life of Sarah Hollenbeck

by Bethany Turner

  © 2017 by Bethany Turner

  Published by Revell

  a division of Baker Publishing Group

  P.O. Box 6287, Grand Rapids, MI 49516-6287

  www.revellbooks.com

  Ebook edition created 2017

  All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means—for example, electronic, photocopy, recording—without the prior written permission of the publisher. The only exception is brief quotations in printed reviews.

  Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is on file at the Library of Congress, Washington, DC.

  ISBN 978-1-4934-1102-3

  This book is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents are the product of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously.

  Scripture quotations are from the Holy Bible, New International Version®. NIV®. Copyright © 1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.™ Used by permission of Zondervan. All rights reserved worldwide. www.zondervan.com

  Contents

  Cover

  Title Page

  Copyright Page

  Epigraph

  1. The Next Emily Dickinson

  2. The Speaker of Painful Truth

  3. Raine, with an E

  4. Now What?

  5. Benjamin Sarah Delaney

  6. Let’s Call Her Margaret

  7. What Nice Boys Do

  8. Meggie, Hester, and Mary Matalin

  9. Blame It on the Raine

  10. Really Crazy, Like, Certifiable

  11. Wasabi-Stained Restraint

  12. Feeling All the Feels

  13. Your Pot Holders Are No Good Here

  14. Seven Minutes at 350 Degrees

  15. Lurking in a Dark Corner Alley

  16. Number 7,483

  17. That Bellamy Girl

  18. Ethical and Professional Leprosy

  19. There Once Was a Girl

  20. Fade to Black

  Acknowledgments

  About the Author

  Back Ads

  Back Cover

  Now to him who is able to do immeasurably more than all we ask or imagine, according to his power that is at work within us, to him be glory in the church and in Christ Jesus throughout all generations, for ever and ever! Amen.

  Ephesians 3:20–21

  1.

  The Next Emily Dickinson

  If you’re willing to admit it, you probably know me as Raine de Bourgh. Yes, that Raine de Bourgh. Did you blush at the mere mention of my pen name? Yeah. So did I.

  Three and a half years ago, I certainly had no intention of ever becoming Raine de Bourgh. I was simply Sarah Hollenbeck. Or maybe I was still Sarah McDermott? No. Sarah Hollenbeck. Sarah McDermott was the product of an empty, loveless marriage, and I was doing all I possibly could to prove—at least to myself—that I wasn’t the shell my marriage had reduced me to. But did I even remember Sarah Hollenbeck? The girl I was before I met the guy? Could I become her once again?

  The answer had to be yes, so that Monday evening in June, three and a half years ago, I hoisted my Kate Spade messenger bag a bit higher on my shoulder, straightened my Stella McCartney blazer, wiggled my toes in my Christian Louboutin pumps, and took a deep breath. As I reached for the doorknob of the high school library, I noticed a slight tremble in my hand. I didn’t understand what was causing the reaction. I’d been faithfully entering that library each week for two months, and it was, after all, just a book club.

  Until a couple of months prior, my life had consisted of the duties of a trophy wife, proudly—though often resentfully—supporting my husband on his rise to the top of a Fortune 500 real estate conglomerate. His Fortune 500 real estate conglomerate. But suddenly, from the moment Patrick sent me a text message that said “Bringing Dan for dinner. He’s gluten-free” followed by a thumbs-up emoji, my life as I knew it was over. Well, I suppose that wasn’t the moment. The moment came later that evening when I caught Patrick making out with Dan’s wife, Bree, in the room I had dreamt would someday be a nursery.

  The dissolution of my marriage left me with a lot of free time. There were no gluten-free dinners to plan, no charity events to attend, no bigwigs to schmooze. We had been together since high school, and while the last few years certainly hadn’t been fulfilling or happy, I didn’t recognize my life without Patrick by my side. I didn’t recognize myself without Patrick by my side. All of our friends were actually Patrick’s friends, it turned out. I couldn’t blame them, really. They were social-ladder-climbers, and I was most definitely a woman whose social status was experiencing a free fall.

  Every job search came up empty. Apparently no one in the tough Chicago job market was interested in hiring someone who hadn’t worked since college, where she’d earned a degree she’d never once put to use. I’d had one career and one career only, and I’d been forced into early retirement—and I never was able to figure out how to list my job experience as “Mrs. Patrick McDermott” on my résumé.

  I was a social pariah desperately in need of something to do, but for a depressed, newly divorced woman with more money and time than talent or skills, finding the right hobby is a surprisingly tricky thing.

  Traveling meant traveling alone, and that wasn’t something I knew how to do.

  Quilting took too much patience.

  Community theatre took too much confidence.

  Painting took too much effort.

  Book clubs? Book clubs could work.

  I joined seven book clubs in the Greater Chicago area simultaneously. Seven. And that meant I was reading seven novels simultaneously. I thought that was the perfect solution—after all, doing that much reading, when would I have time to think about the shambles of my life? Yeah . . . that sounds good in theory, but every book reminded me of what I’d lost—or worse, what I’d never had. A fulfilling marriage. A life with someone who considered me his best friend. Children.

  Every book, from The Picture of Dorian Gray to Eat, Pray, Love, from Lord of the Rings to The Hunger Games, somehow reminded me of my misery. When my Dark American Romanticism book club started reading The Scarlet Letter, I knew I’d had all I could take. I quit all of the book clubs except for the one on Monday night, because that was the one that met closest to my house. I decided that Monday night book club would be my primary hobby and exclusive social circle.

  And I approached that social circle the only way I knew how—with all of the rules and safeguards that had been so necessary for self-preservation in the highfalutin world of the snobs and blue bloods, into which I had made every effort to feel as if I belonged. I would dress for success and speak only when I had something monumental and memorable to contribute. I would hide my scars and shortcomings, and only put forth the most impressive version of myself. I would keep everyone at arm’s length so that if I eventually fell out of favor with them, I would not be impacted.

  It would be just like any other social gathering I had ever attended, apart from one striking difference: my last name was no longer McDermott, so I wouldn’t be viewed as nothing more than an accessory from the moment I was introduced.

  And with all of the extra time, once I had whittled the book club list down to one, I would write a book of my own. Then I could be in control of the content. Then my emotions wouldn’t be putty in the hands of authors who had probably written to escape their own misery, with nary a care given to the feelings of the miserable divorcée who would one day read their work while attempting to bury her pain beneath enough cheesecake to bestow diabetes upon a small village. I’d never written anything before, but I’d certainly done more than my fair share of reading.r />
  How hard could it be?

  My first attempt was a book of poetry, and while I waited for the call from the president asking me to accept the post of Poet Laureate of the United States, I decided it was time to share my gift with the world. Or at least the Monday night book club. Though I couldn’t ever remember their names, the ladies in that circle were, after all, my closest friends. No, I hadn’t known them very long, and yes, our conversations had never plunged any deeper than whether we’d preferred Jim Caviezel as the Count of Monte Cristo or Jesus, but they were the constants in my life of upheaval, and I knew that our bond was true and indestructible.

  I’d been walking into that high school library every Monday evening for two months, but that first Monday evening in June was the beginning. That Monday evening represented a fresh start.

  That Monday evening was the first book club meeting of the rest of my life.

  “Excuse me.” I raised my hand and smiled as the ladies began gathering their things to go, having exhausted all possible thoughts, feelings, and debates over Northanger Abbey. “If you could all spare just a few more moments of your time, if it’s not too much to ask.” I blinked sweetly, conveying humility so well in that tried and true manner I had watched Patrick employ for so many years.

  I rarely spoke in book club, so I wasn’t surprised that everyone stopped in their tracks.

  “Of course, Sarah. What can we do for you?” asked the leader of the book club, whose name had slipped my mind. And by “slipped my mind,” I mean I hadn’t bothered to learn it.

  “I value each and every opinion in this circle. You each present such witty and insightful views, and that, I believe, is what I as a budding poet need in order to develop my craft.” I saw them take in my rehearsed speech, and they responded with enthusiastic support. Once I was fully convinced that they were the eager demographic I was seeking, I meekly proceeded. “You are all just the best. If no one would mind . . . may I?”

  I opened the leather-bound binder in my hands and pulled out the crisp linen stationery on which I had lovingly transcribed each poem by hand over the course of the past several days and began to read.

  Lights flicker. Kerosene?

  Perhaps.

  The man in suede wishes me well,

  But I doubt his sincerity.

  Never you mind.

  Suede and kerosene. The two don’t mix.

  Boom.

  I read poem after poem after poem and, as expected, I was rewarded with stunned silence. They were clearly overcome with emotion and overwhelmed by the power of the lyric. I smiled at them all and gave them a moment to collect themselves. I cast my eyes downward, not wanting to impose upon their deeply intimate moment.

  “Thank you, Sarah,” Book Club Leader Lady said after clearing her throat. “That was truly . . . something.”

  “Yeah . . . wow . . .” random women in the circle said in unison.

  I was so very full of myself that I took it as true, sincere praise.

  “Thank you all so much.” I beamed condescendingly. “It was an honor sharing my work with you.”

  “I’m sorry,” a woman I had never noticed before said softly. “Can I be honest?”

  You want me to take over the book club? You think I’m the next Emily Dickinson? You’re a Hollywood producer who wants to adapt “Lavatory Purgatory” for the screen?

  “Of course.” I smiled and gestured to indicate I would allow her to proceed. “Please.”

  “Well, I don’t want to be rude, but this group is about honest analysis of the quality of what people write, and it’s also about the way what we read makes us feel. So, I just have to say, I have some issues with your poetry that I would be happy to elaborate on if you would allow me to do so.”

  Convinced that she couldn’t possibly be referencing anything more than a rhyme she didn’t like or, more likely, a long-buried emotion within herself that my words had unwittingly brought to the surface, I nodded that she had the floor.

  “Okay,” she began, sitting up a little straighter. “I think there is a pretty decent chance that you’ve actually got some writing talent, but let’s face it—poetry isn’t where you need to be. And what’s with the subjects? It’s like you just flipped through the yellow pages until something jumped out at you. What’s next? Exterminators?”

  I looked down at the papers in my hands and sheepishly shuffled “Insecticide Nuclear Winter” to the bottom of the stack.

  The critic pressed on. “Look, I didn’t feel any emotional connection to any of it, and that’s fine. I don’t feel any connection to Jane Austen, either.” Every other woman in the room gasped, which made her smile, I noticed. “But the problem is, I don’t think you felt any emotional connection to any of it. That is what it is, I suppose, and if you’re running from something or trying to avoid feeling, well, that’s your decision. But please don’t subject the rest of us to it.”

  The others in the circle seemed not to breathe, anxious for, and yet dreading, my reply. I knew she was right. Of course I knew she was right.

  And that was the moment. The depression and the hole in my heart and the suffocating sadness couldn’t be pushed to the background any longer. I started crying like in an old Looney Tunes cartoon—you know, where the tears shoot out horizontally with the force of a garden hose. Actually, I think it was kind of a combination of Looney Tunes and I Love Lucy, because I think I actually made that “Waaaaa!” sound.

  All of the women in the group—the nameless women for whom I hadn’t taken the time or made the effort to develop true respect or affection—gathered around me and hugged me and said generic things like “There, there” and “It’s going to be okay.” I was so touched by that moment. So much so that I told myself I was going to make brownies for them all and bring them to next week’s meeting. They may be the only thing I know how to bake, but my brownies really are amazing, so that was a big gesture for a social pariah allowing herself to feel again.

  2.

  The Speaker of Painful Truth

  The next week in book club, it wasn’t until after I had soaked in all of the praise—this time undoubtedly genuine—for my brownie-making skills that I noticed something. Each week, I sat in a circle of fifteen women—all ages, body types, hair colors—and saw nothing of any of them apart from their ages, body types, and hair colors. Skinny Redhead with Freckles sat just to the left of me each week, and on the other side of her was Boob Job Bonnie, as I had mentally named her. Across from me sat Coke Bottle Glasses, Dorothy Hamill Hairdo, and Granny. Each of them stood out to me as a caricature, apart from Book Club Leader Lady, who I was so grateful was the leader of the group, since she seemed to possess no other defining visual characteristics whatsoever. There were visitors to the circle once in a while, but I didn’t even bother to glance at them until I knew they would be around awhile. But on brownie day, for the first time I noticed someone was missing.

  “Hey, where’s . . . umm . . .” I began before quickly realizing I had no way of describing her apart from Plain Girl I’d Never Noticed Before She Dashed My Poetic Delusions, and that didn’t seem like a nickname that should ever be allowed outside of the confines of my mind. I pointed my eyes and chin toward the one empty chair in the circle and hoped that she, like the rest of us, sat in the same spot each week.

  “Hey, guys, sorry I’m late,” a voice called out from the door as the speaker of painful truth herself walked into the room and took off her coat.

  “Hi, Piper!” Barbra Streisand Nose said in greeting. “Sarah was just asking about you.”

  Piper. Okay, so I knew a name, but I couldn’t help but wonder how other people knew it. I really didn’t remember ever seeing Piper before the previous week. Does it tell you how self-centered I was back then that I never for a moment wondered how they all knew my name? Of course I was Sarah, and not Perfectly-Coiffed Camille, or Princess Prada, or any of the other names I probably would have come up with if I saw myself on the other side of the circle.
<
br />   “Hi, Sarah. Are these the famous brownies?” Piper smiled at me as she took one from the pan and carried it with her to the empty chair between Botox and Way Too Old for Pigtails.

  For a brief moment I wondered which friend Piper and I had in common, and I was obviously flattered—though not terribly surprised—to discover my brownie-baking reputation preceded me. I smiled in response to the flattery and was just about to say something like, “Famous? I doubt that. Though they are quite legendary in the wives’ lounge of the Beverly Country Club,” but all of a sudden I had what felt like an out-of-body experience. I could see clearly, as if I were floating above the scene in the moment of my mental breakdown from the week prior. I had thought the promise of brownies had been only a silent, mental one. A note to self, if you will. But, no. In the moment that had been half Porky Pig, half Lucille Ball, and just a little bit Marlon Brando in A Streetcar Named Desire, I had wailed, “I’ll bring you my secret recipe brownies, because I love you all!”

  I felt as if I could see what they had all seen, and I was mortified. Absolutely mortified. I looked around the room and examined the eyes, all of which were planted on me, and realized for the first time that, while my brownies were indeed delicious, the emotion being conveyed by all of those sets of eyes, and Pirate Patch Patty, wasn’t appreciation or awe. It was pity.

  “Excuse me,” I mumbled as I bolted out of my seat and ran into the hallway.

  I stood there with my tear-ridden face buried in my arm, which was propped up against a row of lockers. I have never been so humiliated in my entire life, I thought for one brief moment before the onset of the sad realization that there was no truth in that at all. As bad as that moment was, it had been a year of moments that were far worse.

  “Are you okay?” Piper asked as she approached quietly and carefully, no doubt fearing that the wild animal might attack.

  I turned around, humiliation not mattering much at that moment. “Is it possible that upon the dissolution of my marriage to my high school sweetheart, the only emotion I am truly feeling is embarrassment? Can that really be what my life’s reduced to?”