Persuading Eve [Passion Peak, Colorado 5] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Tara Rose

  “I’ll leave you alone to get dressed because if I don’t, Knox will walk in and we’ll already be fucking.”

  Phil winked at her. The gesture, coupled with his words, sent a rush of wetness to her pussy. Eve peeled off her smock and scrub pants, then did a quick wash-up in the bathroom before putting on the corset. He’d also bought sheer stockings, so she slipped those on and fastened the garters. She glanced around for mini shorts or panties, but saw none. Eve liked that. Her breasts, pussy and ass would be completely exposed, right from the start.

  The last thing she put on were the shoes, which weren’t new, but she loved the pumps he’d chosen. Phil always said how much he loved to watch her walk in high heels, and she usually ended up keeping them on during their scenes. She took one last look in the mirror, and then returned to the living room.

  “Fucking perfect.” Phil’s eyes blazed with lust and love. “The poor guy won’t know what hit him.”

  “Phil…I mean Sarge, thank you for this.”

  He crossed the room and cupped her face. “No, thank you. I want you to have fun tonight, Eve. Okay? I don’t want you to hold back. This is as much for you as it is for me. Promise me that, all right?”

  “I promise, Sarge.” When the doorbell rang, she moaned softly and dropped to her knees. Every nerve ending was on fire. Her pulse raced and her breathing became quick and shallow. Her pussy was soaked and her clit throbbed, and as she glanced down at her naked breasts, she bit back a smile at the sight of her nipples, engorged and taut.

  “Come on in.” Phil’s voice was filled with humor, and although Eve wanted desperately to glance up so that she could see the look on Knox’s face, she knew not to. She wouldn’t look at either man until Phil told her that she had permission to do so. She caught the whiff of Knox’s cologne, musky and warm, and took a deep breath to let it fill her senses.

  “Holy shit…” That was Knox’s voice, deep and rough, as though he had to clear his throat. At the sound of it, Eve stifled another moan.

  “You may look at us, Eve.”

  She raised her head and glanced first at Phil, who was grinning like he’d just been told the Broncos were going to the Super Bowl, and then she moved her gaze to Knox. He looked like he was ready to explode, and it was all she could do not to stand and walk over to him. He wore a plaid shirt and jeans, and unless Eve was mistaken, an impressive bulge tented the front of them. Fine beads of sweat stood out against his hair line. It was such a fucking turn-on knowing she’d had that much of an effect on him. This was going to be the most erotic night of her life.

  Chapter Eleven

  “Stand up, Eve.” She obeyed Phil’s voice without question. “Now I want to see you greet Knox as though he were your lover, and you haven’t fucked him in about a month.”

  She bit the inside of her cheek so she wouldn’t laugh at Phil’s instructions because they made her giddy with excitement. Recalling how he’d told her that he wanted to see her having fun tonight, she realized that she’d been worried earlier for nothing.

  Knox’s shoulders rose and fell rapidly, and as she advanced toward him, his gaze darted everywhere, from her face, to her boobs, down to her bare pussy, and back up again. He wanted her. Badly. And it didn’t surprise her now to realize how much she wanted him as well. She was delighted by it, and resolved to give in to the rush of hormones surging though her body so that she would enjoy both men tonight.

  Eve put her arms around Knox’s shoulders and kissed him. He groaned in the back of his throat as he pulled her close, pressing his bulge against her and tangling his fingers in her hair. Eve didn’t stop her moans this time as she parted her lips and his tongue raked the inside of her mouth in a kiss so hot she nearly came. Holy shit. Where had he been hiding this?

  When hands caressed her ass cheeks, she knew they were Phil’s, and the combined touch of both men forced more moans from her as Knox’s lips and tongue continued to ravish her mouth. Phil reached around and grabbed her breasts, teasing her nipples the way she loved, rolling them between his thumbs and forefingers. He alternated that with massaging her breasts, until she was so close to coming, she wasn’t sure she could hold it back.

  This was so fucking hot, and Eve wanted to beg Phil to make up his mind right now that they would definitely repeat this. When Knox finally broke the kiss, he cupped her face, his eyes full of desperation. “Thank you, Eve. Thank you for this.”

  “Thank you, Sir.”

  “God, that is so fucking sexy to hear you call me that.” He let go of her face and his gaze dropped to her breasts. Phil released them, and Eve shivered as Knox brushed his fingers lightly over first the sides, then the nipples, almost as though he were afraid to touch them. She wanted to beg him to just go for it. It’s not like she would break. But this was so erotic because she could see how overwhelmed and aroused he was, and of course that fed her ego.

  Was Phil enjoying this, too? If the rock-hard bulge he pressed up against her ass as Knox bent his head to lick her nipples was any indication, she had nothing to worry about. Both men were very into this. It was time to stop worrying and start enjoying them.

  Phil wrapped one arm around her waist, and the other hand caressed her pussy and her ass cheeks as Knox took one nipple into his mouth. He licked it gently at first, and then he began to suck it, sending shock waves of intense passion throughout her body. Eve closed her eyes and groaned loudly. This was more intense than anything she’d imagined. The emotion bubbling up surprised her, but she gave over to it, determined to make this an amazing experience for all of them.

  “Tell me what that feels like, Eve.” Phil’s voice was soft and sexy in her ear. “Does Knox know how to kiss? Can he suck titties?”

  Eve had to bite back another laugh. She loved it when Phil talked like that, but to hear him ask those questions of his cousin was so out of the norm that she became self-conscious for a few seconds. “He’s got a wonderful mouth, Sarge. It feels incredible.”

  Knox moved to the other nipple, and then he took her opposite breast in his hand and expertly massaged it. His soft moans made her soaking-wet pussy contract, and she swore again that she was going to come. The fact that Phil now rubbed her clit wasn’t helping any. How was she supposed to wait with both men doing this to her? And she knew she wouldn’t get away with it, even if she did let go and allow the climax to wash over her. Phil would know she’d come. Part of her wanted to chance it because it might earn her a good, hard spanking from both men.

  Knox released her nipple and gazed into her eyes, his expression full of so much lust that she nearly gasped. “I’m going to fucking explode here.”

  “Then tell her what you want,” said Phil. “As long as it’s not a limit, she’ll do it. Right, Eve?”

  “Yes, Sarge.” She met Knox’s gaze and smiled, hoping that would encourage him. It was such an exquisite thrill to submit to both men at the same time. There’s nothing she’d deny either one right now. All they had to do was ask.

  Knox didn’t speak, but a big grin that sent more shivers up and down her spine spread over his handsome face. His gaze darted around the room, finally landing on the coffee table. “Lie down on that,” he commanded, pointing. “On your back.”

  “Yes, Sir.” Eve walked slowly toward the table, wiggling her hips a bit as she did. She heard one of them chuckle, and then she glanced over her shoulder at Phil, ready to ask her question, but cut her gaze toward Knox instead. Phil had told her to treat him the same, after all, and he had been the one to give her this command. “Sir, may I have a cushion for my back?”

  Knox nodded like one of those bobble-head figurines that people place on their dashboard. “Yeah, whatever. Sure.”

  “Hold it together, dude. You’re doing great.”

  “Easy for you to say. I haven’t had sex in years.”

  Eve pulled a cushion from the sofa and placed it on the table, then lay down as Knox had asked her to do. She looked into his eyes, struck again by how similar they were to Phil�
��s. Why hadn’t this gorgeous, charming man had sex in so long? What the hell was wrong with the women in this town?

  “Spread your legs,” said Knox, his voice rough and low. He stared at her pussy like it was a work of art hanging in the Louvre. Eve couldn’t help but feel flattered by all this attention. It wasn’t that Phil never admired her body, but she was so aroused by the awe in Knox’s expression. “You’re soaked.” He brushed a finger along the inside of her right thigh, and she moaned. “Is that for me?”

  Eve nodded. “Yes, Sir.”

  Knox turned her so that her hips hung over the short end of the table, and then he knelt in front of her and licked her wet slit, her swollen clit, and then back again. Eve struggled to hold still while she whimpered and moaned. She was so close to coming, and she knew she’d better say something. “Sir? Sarge? Permission to come? Please?”

  “I don’t know.” Eve glanced up at Phil’s words. His eyes blazed with lust and humor. “What do you think, Knox? Should we let her come?”

  “Can’t talk. Eating.”

  Eve couldn’t stop the giggle as Knox bent his head and began to lick her again. She tangled her fingers in his thick, soft hair and glanced up at Phil again, silently begging.

  Phil shook his head and grinned. “All right. I think under the circumstances I’ll let you come. But it’s going to earn you extra swats later. A lot of extra swats. Agreed?”

  “Yes, Sarge. Thank you, Sarge.”

  Phil sat on the sofa and stroked her breasts, teasing the nipples with his fingers, while Knox went to town on her pussy. He slid two fingers into her wetness and sucked her clit. That was all it took. Eve cried out as the orgasm washed over her, sending powerful waves straight out to her fingers and toes. They just went on and on, and she didn’t care if they never stopped. Where had he learned to eat pussy so well?

  When he finally came up for air, Phil took his place, and Eve could only shake her head back and forth, whimpering as he tortured her sore clit with more sucking and gentle licks. There was no doubt she was going to come again. She glanced up to see Knox watching her, a big grin on his face. Her pussy juices still glistened on his face, and that sight forced more moans from her throat.

  “I want to fuck your mouth.”

  “Oh God…yes, Sir.” What an incredibly sexy thing to hear from him. This was so damn intense she was going to pass out. Felicity hadn’t been exaggerating. Knox undid the button and zipper on his jeans and Eve moaned again as fresh arousal coursed through her body. He was commando, and she was glad to see that. It told her that he’d had no doubts about what was going to happen tonight, and that kind of confidence was very sexy.

  “Scoot her closer to the edge.”

  Phil came up for air and helped Knox move her to the edge of the table, then resumed eating her out and finger fucking her, while Knox pulled a chair over so that he was sitting in front of her face when her head was turned to the side. Eve’s mouth watered at the sight of his dick. Thick, red, and dripping with pre-cum, she couldn’t wait to get it inside her mouth.

  “Open your mouth.” Knox’s voice was so commanding that Eve shivered again, and she didn’t hesitate to do as he asked. He slid his dick inside her mouth and she wrapped her lips around it. Knox’s loud groan told her how much he was enjoying it, but she wanted to tell him to just go for it. His thrusting was hesitant, and she was touched that he was worried about hurting her.

  Phil stopped licking and sucking her clit. “Don’t be afraid to fuck her mouth deep and hard. She likes it. And hold her head with both hands. She likes that, too.”

  Eve glanced into Phil’s eyes and he gave her a wink before returning to her pussy and clit. Eve cut her gaze toward Knox’s face, hoping he could read in her eyes that what Phil said was true. When Phil fucked her mouth, he did so roughly and while holding her head still, and Eve loved that.

  Knox grasped her head with both hands, and as his thrusting increased, so did his vocalization. His excitement increased hers. She moaned loudly in the back of her throat as another climax began to crest. As the waves started again, Knox’s cries filled the room. When he came in her mouth, she swallowed every drop of his hot, tasty cum as her own orgasm rocked her body with delicious pleasure once again.

  Phil helped her stand while Knox leaned back in the chair, eyes closed, and a look of pure bliss on his face. “On your knees, Eve.”

  She smiled and did as Phil asked. He undid his jeans, holding her gaze the entire time, his eyes filled with love. When he pushed his dick into her mouth, he held her head still and fucked her deep and rough. She loved this, and the realization that she’d just given both men blow jobs filled her with fresh excitement. It didn’t take Phil long to explode inside her mouth, and she swallowed every drop of his cum as well.

  He pulled her to her feet again and held her close, stroking her hair and back. “Thank you, Eve. That was fucking amazing.”

  “Thank you, Sarge.”

  Knox rose, and Phil released the embrace so that Knox could hug her, but he surprised her by kissing her, tongue and all. There was no way he wasn’t getting a mouthful of spunk, and that sent a fresh wave of desire straight to her throbbing clit. When Knox released the kiss, he gazed into her eyes with what could only be called adoration. “I can’t thank you enough for that. Not only the blow job, but letting me eat your pussy.”

  “I loved it, Sir. Thank you.”

  “It’s not over by a long shot, Knox.” Phil removed the rest of his clothing and tossed it on the floor. Eve watched as Knox did the same. She sighed at the sight of both men, muscled and dusted with dark hair. They were fucking gorgeous. She began to tremble again at the thought of both those dicks inside her pussy and ass. Would they do that? Would they take turns, or fuck her at the same time, one cock in each hole?

  Phil crooked his finger at her. “Let’s go, beautiful. The toys are this way.” After she followed him into the bedroom, she dropped to her knees again and kept her gaze on the carpet, as she always did. Every nerve ending was on fire. The anticipation coursing through her was so delicious that Eve could barely stand it. Images of what they might do to her raced through her mind, making her dizzy with need.

  “What would you like to try first, Knox?”

  Eve didn’t need to raise her gaze to know that Phil was showing Knox the toys he’d brought out earlier. He’d come back into the bedroom after she’d changed clothes, and no doubt they were spread out on the bed right now. That’s usually where he put them so that she could see what he intended to use during the scene before he blindfolded her. Would he do that tonight, or would he let her watch their faces?

  “Wow.” She felt air movement next to her and watched Knox’s bare feet walk past her toward the bed. “I’ve never even seen some of these things. This would hurt.”

  Phil chuckled. “That’s the idea. And that’s why she has safewords. You can trust Eve to use them.”

  “This one then.”

  Eve desperately wanted to sneak a peek and see what Knox had chosen, but she didn’t. She didn’t want to give Phil any reason to be upset with her.

  “Where do you want her? Over your knee? On the bench? Tied to the cross? Somewhere else?”

  “Fuck. I don’t know.” Knox sounded overwhelmed. She wondered what he thought of all this, and hoped it was as exciting for him as it was for her and Phil.

  “Then let’s start with her over your knee. This is small enough that I think you can get in a good swat with it. We can always move her if you want to try something else.”

  “Okay. You’re the expert here.”

  “Eve, stand up and come over here. Also, you may look at us.”

  “Thank you, Sarge.” She glanced at the guys as she rose. Knox held the small black paddle with holes, and Eve gasped. He would pick the most painful fucking toy that Phil had. Phil chuckled, no doubt reacting to the look on her face, and grinned in a way that, despite the pain she knew was coming, made her pussy wet all over again.

 
“Sit down, Knox. Come on, babe. I’ll be right here with him, and you have your safewords.”

  “Yes, Sarge.” When she reached the men, Phil draped her over Knox’s left knee.

  “She won’t try to get away. Will you, Eve?”

  “No, Sarge.”

  “Are you sure about this?” Knox’s voice was full of trepidation, and she wasn’t sure if he’d addressed her or Phil, so she didn’t say anything right away.

  “Eve, he asked you that question. You may answer him.”

  “I’m sure, Sir.”

  “How hard should I hit her?”

  “Start soft and then you can work up. Her skin needs a bit of warming up, but she’s used to impact play so it usually doesn’t need too much.”

  “But how will I know whether she likes it?” Oh what a sweetheart. She wanted to kiss him again, just for being such a nice person. How was it that the only woman in this town who’d ever given him a second look was a bitch like Zoe Ewing? What was wrong with all of them?

  “Eve, what color are you when you’re enjoying something and want me to continue?”

  “Green, Sarge.”

  “It’s as simple as that,” said Phil. “You simply ask her what color she is. And, like I said, Eve will safeword with ‘yellow’ or ‘red’ if she needs to.”

  “This is like every fantasy I’ve ever had, all coming true at the same time.”

  Eve wanted to tell him that she felt the same way, and wondered if Phil would mind if she spoke up. “Sarge? May I tell Sir something?”

  “Yes.”

  “Thank you for saying that, Sir, I feel the same way. I’m so excited that you’re here and enjoying this.”

  A hand brushed her hair tenderly, and she sighed at Phil’s touch. “That was very heartwarming, Eve. And now I’m going to let Knox paddle you while I watch.”

  “Thank you, Sarge.”

  “I usually blindfold Eve for a scene, but I think for now we’ll leave that off. Begin whenever you’re ready, Knox.”

  She kept her gaze on the comforter below her as Knox started swatting her on both ass cheeks with the paddle at the same time. It hurt like holy hell and she sensed that he wasn’t even hitting her as hard as he could, but it was such a damn rush knowing that he was doing it, and not Phil, that Eve began to toss her head back and forth and moan within a few seconds. Her pussy was soaked once again, and felt so damn ready that she was certain both their dicks would fit inside there at the same time.