Filthy Appeal

by Ramona Gray

  I didn’t reply. I couldn’t look either of them in the eye and fresh embarrassment washed over me when the dark-haired one said, “He really is an idiot. You shouldn’t listen to a word he says, Lily.”

  “Libby,” I whispered. “My name is Libby. He-he got it wrong.”

  “See? Complete idiot,” the dark-haired man said. “My name is Seth and this is my friend Theo.”

  “It’s a pleasure to meet you, Libby.” Theo held out his hand and after a moment I shook it. His hand had rough calluses as well that scraped across my palm. “Are you visiting our city for pleasure or business?”

  “I – I just moved here. I’m staying at the hotel tonight because my, uh, place isn’t ready until tomorrow.”

  “Welcome to Mansford,” Seth said. “I assure you that not all the men here are assholes like old Dwayne.”

  I shrugged and Seth leaned closer. I shivered when I felt his warm breath on the side of my face. “He’s wrong, Libby. You look - ”

  “I know what I look like,” I interrupted. “Thank you for the glass of wine but I’m dying of embarrassment and I want to forget this ever happened.”

  I grabbed my purse but before I slid off the stool, Seth said, “Libby, wait.”

  The command in his voice kept me frozen to the stool. I didn’t object when he tugged my purse from my hand and placed it back on the bar before taking my hand and rubbing his thumb over my palm.

  I was trembling and my skin felt hot and tight. I watched Seth’s thumb rub across my palm and shamefully made a soft moan when he leaned in and brushed his lips against my cheek.

  “You’re beautiful, Libby and much too good for a man like him.”

  “I’m not,” I whispered.

  “You are,” he insisted. “Look at me.”

  I dragged my gaze away from his thumb and stared into his eyes. They were the colour of dark chocolate and a shiver went down my spine when he dipped his head and pressed a feather-light kiss against my mouth.

  I whimpered quietly, my body arching toward him and a ghost of a smile crossed his lips. “Beautiful and responsive. Your turn, Theo.”

  I blinked at him but before I could ask him what he meant, Theo was cupping the back of my neck and tugging gently on it. I turned to face him and moaned when his mouth descended on mine. The tip of his tongue traced my lower lip and I parted my lips immediately. He pulled back and smiled at me, squeezing the back of my neck before dropping his hand from my neck and picking up his beer.

  He took a long drink as I said in a low and shaky voice, “What is happening?”

  “Why are you in this bar tonight, Libby?” Seth’s voice was right in my ear and I licked my lips as both men crowded close. The babbled conversation of the other patrons in the bar faded away and I had to work very hard not to lean against the warm bodies of either men. Their shoulders brushed mine and their heads were tilted toward me.

  “I came here because I,” my face flushed, “I couldn’t sleep and I thought a nightcap might help.”

  Seth’s eyebrow arched up and he glanced at Theo. “Do you believe her, Theo?”

  “No,” Theo said with a small grin. “Do you?”

  Seth shook his head and I gasped when his big hand rested on my thigh. His fingers pushed between them and he rubbed my inner thigh as Theo put his hand on my lower back and traced tiny circles.

  “I think you’re lying to us, sweetheart,” Seth said.

  “I’m not,” I whispered.

  “Lying gets you a spanking,” Theo said.

  All the muscles in my pussy clenched in a heart-stopping spasm of pleasure and my nipples beaded into hard points. I was nearly panting now and a flush was rising up my neck. Why did the thought of being spanked by them bring a shameful amount of liquid to my pussy? Spanking wasn’t my kink.

  How do you know? Old stick-in-the-mud Wayne liked two positions and wouldn’t know a kink if it smacked him in the face.

  “Tell us why you’re really here, Libby,” Seth said.

  His big hand squeezed my thigh and the words came tumbling out of me in a low rush. “I came home one day and my boyfriend was having sex with a much younger and thinner woman in our bed. When I asked him why he said, he-he said …”

  I trailed off and swallowed past the aching burn in my throat. I couldn’t say it. It was too humiliating. Seth rubbed my thigh and Theo pressed a gentle kiss against my cheek.

  “How are you guys doing? Need a fresh drink?”

  The bartender was back and I stared grimly at my hands in my lap as Seth said, “No thank you.”

  “Are you sure?” The bartender was persistent, I’d give her that. “I can bring you a menu if you’re hungry.”

  “No thank you,” Seth repeated. “We want privacy please.”

  “Oh, of course.” The bartender sounded both surprised and deflated and my inner voice cheered loudly. Score one for the big girl.

  When she was gone, Seth said, “Tell us, Libby.”

  I hesitated and then said, “If I don’t, will you spank me?”

  What the fuck?

  “Yes,” Theo said in a low voice. “We’ll bend you over the bed, pull down your jeans and your panties and spank your lovely ass until it’s covered in our handprints.”

  I moaned and Seth squeezed my thigh again before grinning at Theo. “I think we might have better luck if we threaten not to spank her.”

  “Oh God,” I whispered. “What is wrong with me?”

  “Nothing,” Theo said. “Tell us what we want to know, love.”

  “He cheated on me because I’d gained weight.”

  I didn’t have to tell them exactly what he said. I’d just make sure that if I did have sex with one of them, I wouldn’t be on top. Easy.

  I jerked when Seth made a low curse. Theo was studying me and I closed my eyes and said, “I came to the bar because I wanted to find someone to sleep with me. I wanted to convince myself that I was still attractive and desirable. I just wanted a fling, you know?”

  “Why did you choose Dwayne?” Seth asked.

  “Well, because he looked safe and,” I paused, “attainable for someone who looked like me.”

  “You saw us when we first came in, didn’t you?” Seth said.

  I nodded and he squeezed my leg again. “You saw the way I looked at you. You knew I wanted you.”

  “I didn’t,” I lied.

  “You did,” he insisted.

  “I – I didn’t think it was real,” I whispered.

  His hand moved off my thigh and he turned me on the stool to face him before kissing me again. This time there was no gentleness in the kiss. He took my mouth with a hard possessiveness that made me ache with need. His tongue pushed past my lips and flicked against mine. I forgot that we were in the bar and returned his kiss with an eagerness that surprised me. My heart was pounding in my ears and I was pressing myself against the stool in a vain attempt to ease the ache between my thighs. When Seth pulled away, I nearly fell off the stool. Only Theo’s hand on my hip kept me in my seat.

  “I want you, little Libby,” Seth said bluntly. “I want to take you back to your hotel room, spread your legs and fuck you into the best orgasm of your life. Does that clear things up for you?”

  I stared mutely at him before whispering, “You – you’re not safe.”

  He grinned. “Is safe what you really want, sweetheart?”

  “I don’t know.”

  Theo’s breath was warm on the back of my neck. “It isn’t, love.”

  I had forgotten completely about Theo and I shivered when he pressed up against my back and kissed my neck. “Play with us tonight, Libby. I promise it’ll be a night you won’t forget.”

  “Us?” I whispered. I gave Seth a shocked look and he nodded gravely.

  “We’re a package deal, sweetheart.”

  “I – I can’t take both of you to my room,” I said in a low voice.

  “Why not?” Seth asked.

  “Well, because it isn’t – I mean, what
would people say if they knew that I…”

  I trailed off and Seth grinned at me. “We won’t say anything if you won’t.”

  I didn’t reply and Theo kissed the side of my neck again. “Say yes, love. We want you very much. You want a one-night stand, let us give it to you.”

  “You can’t tell anyone I did this,” I whispered. I was being ridiculous. Seth and Theo’s rough hands and the way they were dressed suggested they were laborers. The thin layer of sawdust that clung to Seth’s jeans and the paint spatters on Theo’s shirt meant they most likely worked in a trade. This was a large city and since my circle of friends would probably be the people I worked with, we wouldn’t be in the same social circle. After tonight, I’d never see them again.

  Then take them to your room and fuck them! For God’s sake, you could have the time of your life tonight if you’d stop thinking about what others might say.

  Inner me was right. I came to the bar looking to find a man who found me attractive and wanted to fuck me. I had found not one, but two, and suddenly I was getting cold feet? Fuck that. No, not fuck that – fuck them, both of them… a lot.

  “We won’t say a word, love,” Theo said. “Cross our hearts, hope to die.”

  Seth made an X across his chest before winking at me.

  “Yes,” I said abruptly.

  Chapter Two

  Neither of them waited for me to say anything else. Theo urged me off the stool and Seth took my hand in a firm grip. We left the bar and although I was certain that everyone was staring at us, in reality no one gave us a second look. We rode up the elevator in complete silence. The men flanked me, Seth still holding my hand and Theo resting his on the small of my back.

  At the door to my room, Seth took the card key from me and opened the door before handing it back. I tucked it into my purse as they followed me into my room.

  “Nice room,” Seth said as Theo crossed the room and drew the curtains shut.

  “Thank you,” I said. My voice was an anxious squeak and my entire body was shaking as Seth drew me into his arms.

  “Don’t be nervous, little Libby.”

  “I’ve never slept with two men before,” I said. “So, how does this work? Are you two, um, fond of each other as well?”

  Seth shook his head. “No, Theo and I are only into women.”

  “Okay,” I whispered. “Now what?”

  “Now?” Theo had come up behind me and I twitched when he put his arms around me above Seth’s arms and cupped both my breasts. “Now we get you naked and make you come repeatedly.”

  “I can’t do multiple orgasms,” I said.

  “Seth and I love a good challenge,” Theo said before licking the skin on my throat. I moaned and arched into his hands as Seth pulled on the hem of my shirt.

  “Move for a minute, Theo.”

  Theo stepped away and Seth quickly pulled my shirt over my head and tossed it on the other bed.

  “Fuck,” he muttered as he stared at my tits. “Theo, get that fucking bra off.”

  The hooks on my bra were released with a quick flick of Theo’s fingers and before I could think of protesting, it had joined my shirt. I reached to cover my breasts and Theo’s fingers slid around my upper arms. He pulled my arms back, forcing my back to arch, and held me in a firm grip as Seth studied my breasts.

  I wiggled and squirmed against Theo. His hot breath tickled my ear when he leaned down and said, “Hold still so Seth can see your tits or I’ll spank your ass.”

  I twisted my head to stare at him and he kissed my mouth before sucking on my bottom lip. I moaned as he lifted his head. “Give us a safe word, Libby.”

  “Wh-what are you going to do to me?”

  Seth laughed. “Nothing you won’t enjoy, sweetheart, I promise. But Theo and I are dominant and we never play with a submissive unless she gives us a safe word.”

  “I’m not a submissive,” I said.

  “You still need a safe word, love,” Theo said.

  I hesitated as the sensible part of my brain started throwing out large neon caution signals.

  “Libby,” Seth said, “we promise we won’t do anything you’re not comfortable with. And if you are uncomfortable, say your safe word and we’ll stop immediately.”

  “Do-do you promise?” I whispered.

  “Yes,” Theo said solemnly. “We promise.”

  “Okay, I guess, uh, red will be my safe word,” I said. “Is that too cliché?”

  Seth laughed and shook his head. “No, sweetheart, it’s perfect.”

  Theo’s hands tightened on my arms and I arched my back a little more.

  “Good girl,” Theo said.

  Warmth flooded through me but before I could try and analyze why Theo’s approval should make me feel so good, Seth was cupping both my breasts. He tugged on my nipples and I moaned and rubbed my ass against Theo’s crotch. He pressed his erection against me as Seth said, “Her left tit is slightly bigger than her right one.” He pulled on my nipples again and smiled when I gasped. “Her nipples seem to be very sensitive.”

  He cupped my breasts and lifted them. “Nice and heavy, just how we like them.”

  “Very nice,” Theo said. He was looking over my shoulder and I shivered when he nipped at my collarbone. “Show me her cunt.”

  Seth quickly unbuttoned and unzipped my jeans and yanked them down my legs. They dragged my panties with them and I squirmed a little when the cool air washed over my pussy. Theo dropped my arms but before I could move, he’d grabbed my wrists with one hand and held them in the small of my back.

  He stepped back as Seth encouraged me to lift first one foot and than the other. He removed my shoes, my jeans, and my panties, and left them on the floor before straightening. I squirmed again. I was completely naked and neither Seth or Theo had even taken off their shoes.

  “Fuck, her ass is amazing,” Theo groaned.

  I twitched when Theo’s hand smoothed over the curve of my right ass cheek and then squeezed. “How does her cunt look?” He asked in a hoarse voice.

  “Spread your legs, Libby,” Seth said.

  I kept my legs closed. Seth and Theo were examining my body almost like it was a piece of meat. I should have been insulted, I should have been safe wording and then telling them to get the hell out. Instead I was so turned on by the way they were treating me, I was afraid to open my legs because I was certain I’d drip all over the carpet. What was wrong with me?

  I squealed when Theo slapped my ass. It hurt like hell and I turned my head and glared at him.

  “Do what Seth says, love,” Theo said calmly.

  When I didn’t spread my legs, Theo spanked my ass again. This one hurt even more and I cried out and spread my legs wide.

  “That’s our good girl,” Theo said. His big hand rubbed my stinging ass but I barely noticed. Seth had cupped my pussy the moment I spread my legs and his rough fingers were rubbing my clit.

  “She’s soaking wet already and her little clit is swollen and hard,” he said in a low voice.

  “Oh God, please,” I moaned as he brushed the tips of his fingers over my clit.

  Theo’s hand stroked down my ass and slid between my legs. Seth spread my pussy lips apart and Theo rubbed at my clit before making a noise of approval.

  I moaned and twisted against their hands and when Theo released my wrists, I grabbed Seth’s shoulders in a desperate grip.

  “Please, Seth,” I pleaded. “I need – oh my God!”

  I rose up on my tiptoes as two of Theo’s thick fingers invaded my pussy. I clenched around him in surprise at the invasion and he groaned against my back. “Fuck, her cunt is tight.”

  He removed his fingers and I whimpered at the loss. He kissed the back of my shoulder as Seth cupped one heavy breast and pinched my nipple. My back arched and I squealed in surprise when I felt Theo’s wet finger push against my anus.

  “Hey!” I squeaked out.

  Theo stopped and pressed another kiss against my shoulder. “Have you been f
ucked in the ass before, Libby?”

  “No,” I said.

  A look of disappointment crossed Seth’s face and I pressed my lips together. “I’m sorry.” For some reason, I hated that I was disappointing him even though he was pretty much a stranger. “I’m willing to give it a try though.”

  Libby! You’re going to let them fuck you in the ass? Sleeping with two men is one thing but do you really want to just have a go at the old DP? You haven’t even seen their dicks yet – they’re probably huge!

  Seth smiled at me. “No, sweetheart, we can’t.”

  “I – what? Why not?” I stuttered.

  “Because you’ll be too tight. You need to be stretched first before you take a cock, and that takes more than one night,” Seth said.

  I scowled at him. “It’s my body and I’m willing to give it a try so – owch! Goddammit! Why are you spanking me?”

  Theo stopped with his hand hovering over my ass and said, “Seth told you no and you argued with him. You’ll do what you’re told or be punished.”

  “But it’s my body! I can decide if I…shit!”

  Theo had pulled me over to the bed. He sat on the side of it and I was sprawled face down over his lap before I knew what was happening. One hard hand splayed across my lower back, holding me down easily despite the way I was starting to wiggle. My face burned with humiliation and I squealed when Theo spanked me hard. I squirmed wildly but I was no match for his strength. As his hand painted my ass with bright red prints, I squealed again and said, “That hurts! Stop it!”

  He ignored me completely, slapping each ass cheek in a hard, unforgiving rhythm as Seth quickly undressed. Even with the burning pain and humiliation of being spanked, lust tinged with a little fear coursed through me when I saw the size of his dick.

  I was distracted by another hard slap across my burning ass. Tears were beginning to slide down my face and I moaned at Theo to stop and tried to squirm away again. Why wasn’t he stopping? I was practically begging him.

  Safe word, idiot. If you want him to stop you have to use your safe word.

  Fuck, I was an idiot. I opened my mouth to snap ‘red’ at Theo, but before I could say a word, he stopped spanking me and slipped his hand between my thighs. He rubbed my clit with a firm touch and all thoughts of safe wording disappeared in an instant. I had no idea if the pain had made me extra sensitive or if Theo was amazing at touching clits but pleasure exploded in my belly. I cried out, my ass arching up and my hands clenching into the bedcovers as Seth grinned at Theo.