Craig Creates A Harem: The Beginning

by Mason, K. C.

  “It seems like we should have put more thought into this. I don't want to hurt anyone or make them feel used.”

  They both paused in thought before Lisa began again, “I would suggest that if we want to fuck someone, like Melissa in this case, then if we're willing and she is there's no reason it needs to be a onetime screw. The first rule is our everlasting love for each other so that's never in question, which would mean there's no harm in it.”

  “And if she falls in love with one of us? I know it's assuming a lot of things but I think we need to figure out how we want to handle that.” Craig reasoned.

  “I'd say as long as it isn't a possessive love and we're still together I'm fine with that. I don't think we should punish anyone for their feelings that we've helped to nurture.”

  “I think that's a wise plan.” Craig said without emotion.

  “Before we had our talk earlier I think the idea of someone loving you would have really bothered me but I can understand someone loving you and I know it won't cost us our love, right?”

  “Right!”

  They smiled, then hugged, and headed out for the short walk to the bar a few blocks away.

  CHAPTER 4

  “Did you find the place okay?” Craig asked Melissa over the thumping music.

  “That's pretty funny considering I love upstairs.”

  “I didn't realize. You live up there with your uncle?” Craig asked.

  “Oh no, he's got a house outside of town. This used to be a rental apartment so it made sense that he'd let me stay here for now.”

  “How did you manage to get the night off? Isn't Saturday one of your busiest nights?” Lisa joined in the conversation.

  “I work three days and two nights a week. The only weekend night I get is Friday night. We only need one bar tender at a time and Tracy had seniority and got to pick her nights first. She took Saturday night then I took Friday night and she ended up with Sunday night.”

  Tracy was the other full-time bar tender of Chump Change, the local bar that Craig and Lisa frequented, where Melissa recently began working upon returning to the area.

  “It's good that neither of you have to work all weekend. Then you both get a chance to cut lose.” There was an awkward pause as Lisa and Melissa both nodded then Craig asked Melissa, “Do you want to dance?”

  Melissa smiled then stopped smiling and looked over to Lisa.

  “Go!” Lisa encouraged.

  Looking back at Craig, Melissa said, “Sure, lets go.”

  She grabbed Craig's hand and led him to the dance floor. The small dance floor was packed but even still Melissa moved them through the middle to the other side of the dance floor, away from where Lisa could see. Lisa watched but didn't react. There was mild reaction from some of the other locals, who were used to seeing Craig and Lisa dance the night away. Particularly jealous glances came from a blonde dirty blonde and brunette dancing together on the edges of the dance floor.

  They began to dance in the acceptable fashion of hands going high and low but away to give their body’s ample opportunity to get close and possibly touch if they desired.

  Melissa had raven dark hair and dark eyes that glistened in the strobe lights. Now that she was up close Craig realized how beautiful she really was. She had on makeup, but not as much as you may think, having perfect skin all on her own. Her hair was straight and came down over her shoulders but was a good six inches shorter than Lisa's. The proportion was perfect though, Craig thought, because she was two inches shorter than Lisa, making her a full foot shorter than Craig's six-foot tall frame. Her breasts were a B-Cup, which fit her petite, slender frame well. She didn't wear the low rider jeans most in the bar had on but her jeans were not much higher and were quite flattering. She wore a dark colored tight t-shirt that was tucked into her jeans.

  Halfway through the first song Melissa turned around and backed into Craig, giving him a full view of her cute little ass. It was not the apple bottom round fullness of Lisa's ass. Rather it was small but proportionate to her narrower hips and still had curves that drew Craig's gaze. In some ways Craig couldn't help but think Lisa and Melissa were similar yet opposites. They could not be confused with each other but he loved the same feature on each, which seemed to be everything, despite those features being complete opposites.

  Their second song had barely started when Lisa seemed to pop out of nowhere and slide in behind Melissa so that Melissa was between the two with Melissa facing Craig.

  Melissa at first appeared to panic slightly until she realized it wasn't another guy trying to grind against her. Melissa eased a bit, but still was not as free as she had been before Lisa arrived.

  Craig gave Lisa a knowing grin and Melissa could have swore he'd moved a little closer to her. Lisa was getting incredibly turned on at how close she was to Melissa in a spooning dance position. She took in her slight height advantage and slight hip advantage over Melissa and her mind couldn't help but think about Melissa face down on her bed while Lisa dry humped her from behind.

  Melissa took the opportunity to make more contact with Craig, rationalizing in her mind that it would have to seem that it was because Lisa was pushing into her.

  Craig gave a twirl of his finger in the air and Melissa looked at him in quizzically.

  “Turn around,” Craig said with a grin.

  Very smoothly Melissa turned and faced Lisa. Melissa did the same hand motion saying to Lisa, “Turn around,” and Lisa complied and backed into Melissa slightly, continuing to dance. Craig was getting a great view again without having to be careful of staring since Melissa was facing the other direction.

  Melissa was less satisfied by the current positions because she found it more difficult to back into Craig. And Lisa found it less satisfying because she also found it difficult to back into Melissa as she rationalized that Melissa must be trying to back into Craig.

  After a very short time, Lisa turned around facing Melissa again but before Melissa could try and turn around like, Lisa feared she might, Lisa stepped into Melissa and straddled her left thigh so that Melissa was also straddling Lisa's left though. This move generated an “Oh” from Melissa at the surprised pleasure of Lisa's thigh rubbing against her pussy through her jeans. Then Melissa realized her thigh was also rubbing against Lisa's pussy and she took that as a sign to let loose.

  Lisa was amazed at how sexy she found it that with her and Melissa interlocked that she seemed to be a bit taller than Melissa as their breasts touched periodically and their faces and hair came close together, near cheek to cheek. She wondered if this is how Craig felt with her, him being so much taller. She'd always felt the opposite side and this feeling was new but exciting her as well.

  Craig couldn't believe what he was seeing but acted casually and decided to move in closer to Melissa. And despite Lisa's knee darting out through between Melissa's legs Craig was able to lower himself enough to comfortably grind with Melissa with the front of his jeans against the back of her lower back and belt line. Craig was tall enough that he wasn't able to get much lower on such shorter women when dancing but the effect was still the same and more.

  While an erection grew in Craig's pants Melissa was getting turned on not only by Lisa but by feeling a growing bulge from Craig's pants against her back and top of her ass. She wished it were lower and hitting a preferred sweet spot but just knowing he was getting hard dancing with her was plenty for now.

  Oddly, the rest of the dance floor lessened their glances and the surprise erased entirely when Lisa joined Craig and Melissa. Seeing multiple people dance was not as uncommon as dancing with someone else's spouse apparently.

  They carried on this way, changing positions while keeping Melissa in the middle the entire time, until Craig couldn't take any more.

  “I need to get a drink.” Craig said into Melissa's ear from behind.

  Melissa stopped dancing and said, “Oh, okay,” looking disappointed but nodding in approval.

  “You two go ahead. I'll be r
ight back.” Craig motioned for them to keep going.

  Melissa stood there but Lisa got the point and moved in behind Melissa, placing her hands on her hips and started to grind on her from behind. Melissa was back to dancing before Craig cleared the first crowd of people next to them.

  Craig was back at the bar drinking a tall beer to try and cool down. Tracy tossed him a clean towel from behind the bar.

  “Thanks.” Craig nodded, “It's quite a workout out there.”

  “Where's Lisa?” Tracy asked.

  “She's still dancing.” Craig paused and Tracy had a questioning look. “She's dancing with Melissa.”

  Tracy nodded in understanding.

  Lisa and walked up behind Craig, leading Melissa by the hand.

  “Let’s get out of here,” Lisa told Craig, winking.

  Craig took another big drink of his beer and tossed the towel back to Tracy.

  “I guess we're throwing in the towel.”

  CHAPTER 5

  The three walked briskly but silently the two blocks back to Craig's house, all three holding hands the entire time.

  Once Craig unlocked the door and they moved inside and turned the lights on Craig took a step toward Melissa, put a hand around her right shoulder and pulled her toward him. He craned his neck and began to deeply kiss her and she was ready for it, returning the passion in the kiss.

  Instinctively, Lisa pushed Melissa's hair aside with her left hand, placed her right hand on Melissa's hip, and started to kiss Melissa's neck.

  They stood that way for what felt like an arousing eternity but was only a matter of seconds when Lisa reached down and began pulling up Melissa's t-shirt from within her jeans. Melissa had moved her right hand around to find Craig's ass but broke the kiss and lifted her hands when Lisa lifted the shirt over her head, exposing her black lace bra.

  Melissa stood silently as she and Craig looked into each other's eyes. Craig reached up and placed his hand inside of Melissa's bra, cupping one of her breasts. She let out a slight moan and closed her eyes.

  Lisa tossed the shirt aside and reached around Melissa to attach her belt buckle, which she expertly undid from the same angle she'd undo her own belt. Melissa stood still with her eyes closed while Lisa pushed Melissa's jeans over her hips. Lisa began kissing from ass on down to knee as she lowered Melissa's jeans to her feat.

  Craig withdrew his hand and took off his shirt. He looked down admiring the black hip huggers panties Melissa was wearing. The rest of her body was smooth as silk, just like Lisa's. Craig undid his belt and slid his jeans down to the ground and stepped out of them and his shoes just as Melissa did the same. Melissa was mesmerized as Craig's erection almost touched her. It made her even more excited to know there hadn’t been anything between him and her jeans except his jeans before. She was glad she didn't know that sooner, she mischievously thought, though now she was glad she did in case the moment took her to do something about it in the future.

  Craig was going to step toward Melissa but this time she took the initiative and stepped toward him, reaching up behind his neck and pulling his head down so his lips met hers. As a result, his erection was firmly pressed against her belly, which she enjoyed enough to reach behind him with her other hand and pull his ass toward her.

  Being the only one left fully clothed and enamored with the erotic sight in front of her, Lisa quickly removed everything but her panties. Lisa stood behind Melissa as they'd done on the dance floor, this time without the dancing, and slowly crouched down so kissing Melissa's hair and back and her face approached her panties. Using Craig's trick from earlier, she used her left hand to slide the panties to one side, getting full view of a pink, wet pussy. This one was fronted by a raven dark colored hairy patch that was groomed but was still intact. Lisa began to see what Craig liked about this look now that she'd seen one up close for herself.

  Melissa moaned with surprise but didn't stop kissing Craig. The kiss did stop and instead she grabbed Craig around the neck and spread her legs slightly when she felt Lisa's tongue first hit the outside of her snatch. Craig wrapped his arms around her now and looking down behind Melissa at what Lisa was doing he put his hands on Melissa's ass and spread slightly to give Lisa a better angle.

  Melissa didn't realize how horny she'd gotten throughout the dancing and what led up to this moment because there was never a time to stop and think. When Lisa inserted two fingers into her cunt she felt a warmth start to come over her from within. She held onto Craig tighter and tighter until she let out a squeal. Lisa was shocked, but not unpleasantly, to fee Melissa convulsing in orgasm on her tongue and fingers. Craig felt Melissa tighten but he enjoyed every moment of the gentle caress it was providing his cock against Melissa's belly.

  Melissa's body went somewhat limp and Lisa released her panties, causing them again to close over her wet pussy. Melissa was in a bit of a daze of ecstasy still when Craig whispered into her ear, “My turn.”

  Craig lurched down and grabbed the back of Melissa's thighs since he wasn't sure she would move on quivering legs. He pulled her up and she reacted by wrapping her legs around him. He pulled her up high enough that his cock now was free and Melissa's pussy was resting on it, separated only by the fabric of her panties.

  Craig stepped back a few steps to the couch and sat down, still holding Melissa. Without even thinking Lisa followed and when Craig sat down she reached down and again slid Melissa's panties to the side, this time also guiding Craig's erection into the now exposed cunt. Craig released the pressure of his hold, but still kept Melissa close, and as he did she slid down on to the full length of his cock.

  Melissa reacted with a high pitched slow moan. She pulled her head from beside Craig and loosened her grip on his neck. She went in for a kiss but before she did whispered “Fuck me.” Then Craig kissed Melissa and she began to move up and down on his shaft, slowly at first and never fast, but gaining some speed after the first few gallops.

  Lisa was still kneeling behind Melissa as they sat on the couch fucking and at first wasn't sure what to do. If they were on a bed she was sure she'd put her pussy in Craig's mouth and start feeling away at Melissa's small, perky breasts. From behind the action she didn't have access to much but was so horny she needed to do something so she took access with what she had.

  Lisa first decided it would help Craig if Melissa weren't wearing her bra so she removed it, giving Craig access to taste those breasts if desired. Next, she slowly slid away, resting on her left hand, until her face was at insertion length. She wasn't sure exactly what she wanted to do yet but she somehow knew that's where she wanted her tongue. With her right hand she reached into her panties and began to masturbate. She was glad she'd decided to leave her panties on because it was easier and more effective to use the tension of her panties to hold her hand in place and bounce it off while massaging and tapping her cunt.

  After a few minutes of liking Craig's shaft and balls and occasionally the rim of Melissa's pussy she realized she'd been rimming Melissa without realizing it when Melissa came again. Feeling this second orgasm put Lisa over the top and she also came, wetting her panties as her panting slowed.

  Melissa appeared exhausted and had stopped moving up and down on Craig's shaft. Craig was happy but unsatisfied and after a few brief moments while Lisa and Melissa collected themselves Melissa moved herself off Craig's cock and said to Lisa, “I guess he's the only one who hasn't cum yet.”

  Melissa began stroking Craig's cock from beside him on the couch and Lisa moved forward taking his member into her mouth. Now that Melissa had a good close-up look at Craig's cock she realized it was a good size but not so large that it gave her fear to do what came next.

  Taking turns with Lisa, Melissa began a furious blow job, every once in a while taking as much of him into her mouth as she could. This didn't last too long, as Craig was close to cumming several times while fucking Melissa. When Lisa was on her turn Craig let her know, “I'm going to cum”. Lisa reflexively lifted her head of
f his shaft and continued to pump. Instinctively thinking it was her turn Melissa put her mouth back around Craig's cock. He and Lisa each had a worried look. It was all Craig could do as he felt the pressure build to say, “I'm cumming.”

  Instantaneously Craig unloaded wad after wad of cum into Melissa's mouth and some directly down her throat. She had her head just on the tip now but was completely covering the end so no cum would escape as Lisa continued to pump, not knowing what else to do.

  After a few short moments that felt like an eternity she released what was left of Craig's erection, swallowed one last time and sat up.

  “I'm sorry,” Craig said. “I tried to warn you.”

  “Oh, I thought Lisa was just being polite and offering it to me.”

  “Oh no! He doesn't cum in my mouth. I've never let him do that,” Lisa said, looking concerned.

  “You should sometime.”

  Seeing that they still weren't totally at ease with it Melissa removed their concern by saying, “I don't mind it. And honestly, it's easier than trying to clean it up afterward.”

  “That sounds like something he'd say,” Lisa said with a grin, more at ease now.

  “I suppose it's a matter of experiences. I've had guys that wanted to cum on my face and hair and that's such a pain if it gets in your hair. Along with the turn on I get from the taboo of it, I've always preferred that a guy come inside me or at least in my mouth.”

  “I wish I'd have known that,” Craig said. “I almost came a few times there but I wasn't sure how you'd feel if I suddenly filled you up.”