Hearts on Fire 4: Kisses Sweeter Than Pie (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Dixie Lynn Dwyer

  “Are you touching yourself, Nina?”

  “Yes,” she hissed.

  “You’re a god damn fantasy, baby. I love that you’re so aroused and touching yourself.”

  “You do it to me Johnny,” she told him, and he felt wild and as if he were on a high.

  “You drive me wild. I want to get lost inside of you, Nina. Inside of you is heaven.” He kissed her neck and suckled along the skin as he pumped his hips faster. She spread her thighs wider, fingered herself and moaned as she stretched further over the arm of the couch. His cock felt so damn hard as he shoved deeper into her ass while she moaned and pushed back.

  “I’ve got you, baby. I’ve got you.” He began a rapid pace, gripped her hips, and pounded into her ass then held her hip with one hand as he maneuvered his other hand over her waist, down her belly, then over her fingers that were thrusting into her pussy. He moved his fingers over hers. She moaned when he massaged her clit and rubbed circles with her cream before shoving his fingers into her cunt. When he did, he thrust his cock into her ass and his fingers into her wet cunt. Nina screamed her release. It was all too much, too erotic to handle, and he pumped his hips then thrust hard and fast until he finally lost it holding her tight, his body flush against hers and released his seed.

  He moved his fingers, cupped her breasts, then glided his palms along her hips and ass massaging her muscles.

  “You’re perfect for me, Nina. Abso-fucking-lutely perfect.” She chuckled and he slowly pulled from her ass, turned her around, and hugged her to him. They didn’t bother with their clothing as they cuddled up on the couch until she fell asleep in his arms.

  * * * *

  Buddy and Trent along with Jake stood watching the blaze. The sirens blared as more units arrived to assist Ladder 19 put out the fire. Across town in the industrial park where many businesses had their storage facilities, one very large building was burning to the ground. The firefighters worked to control the blaze and to prevent the fire from spreading to the adjacent buildings surrounding them.

  “Who owns that building?” Buddy asked Jake.

  “I don’t know. Why?”

  “Well, we need to find out. Trent and I are coming up with some odd connections to the places that have been hit by this arsonist. Take into account Nina’s description of the guy, what he was wearing, and then the descriptions we received after interviewing some of the other witnesses, and there are some connections.”

  “Like what? You think you may know who this guy is?” Jake asked.

  “Not specifically who he is, but perhaps what his agenda might be. We can’t be certain. For example, the guy is always wearing a red jersey. Nina said she thought it had a weird word like Costa on it. We’re thinking Coastal Bay, a few towns over.”

  “Shit. Well maybe the guy’s from there?” Jake asked.

  “We’re running a few scenarios. Maybe you could see if there have been any people arrested for arson crimes in Coastal Bay over the last year or so. Nina as well as the other witnesses from the last fire thought that it was a teenager. It very well could be and that’s why the extent of damage has been minimal,” Buddy stated.

  “But he did assault one witness, who now is afraid to stay involved with the investigation,” Trent added.

  “You seriously think some teenager is responsible for all of this and even the assault?” Jake asked, appearing annoyed.

  “We’ve had our share of delinquent teens setting shit on fire for fun and attention,” Buddy added.

  “We’ve also got some serious competition between the schools along the shorelines. Baseball, especially,” Trent said.

  Buddy widened his eyes. “You think this about a sports rivalry?”

  “Shit, that could very well be. A few years back, well, more than that actually—I wasn’t even the sheriff yet—there was some major brawling going on between the high schools. The police had to respond to a lot of fights between the athletes.”

  “Anything more recently, Jake?” Buddy asked.

  “I don’t think so. Not since the boards got together and decided to contact the owner of the property bordering Treasure Town and Fairway and come up with developing one major sports facility. The reaction has been positive.”

  “Maybe this individual just wants to cause trouble and get things brewing,” Trent suggested.

  “He could have killed someone. Then add in the fact that he assaulted the woman who was a witness,” Buddy added.

  “Well, the other witnesses have been notified of the assault. They all go to the high school. Then of course there’s Nina. But we put her name into the system as Valez, just as precaution because of the other situation,” Jake informed them.

  “We appreciate that. Any news from Rye’s friend in the government?” Trent asked Jake.

  “Not yet. But I hear that Nina’s pie-baking business is really doing well. Michaela offered to help her set up shop in town.”

  “Really? Nina didn’t mention that,” Trent said.

  “Michaela did mention that Nina was a bit taken aback by the offer. But you know Michaela, she has a big heart, she knows a lot about business and advertising. She would be a huge help to Nina. Then add in all the people she knows, and she could just about help Nina with every aspect of the business. I think even Cindy is interested in helping Nina, too.”

  “That is amazing. I guess we’ll talk to Nina about it tonight. Maybe we can ease her mind about the offer. She’s so afraid to accept help from anyone. It’s like she feels she’ll owe them her soul.”

  “That’s understandable, considering what you said this ex of hers did to her,” Jake replied.

  “Hey, I was just thinking. Is there a common connection between the places this guy has set fire to and the witnesses at the school? Are they all connected to Treasure Town or Coastal Bay somehow?” Buddy asked, interrupting the current topic.

  “Well, the witnesses are all students at the high school here in Treasure Town. Um…the owner of the liquor store has a son that goes to school there,” Jake offered.

  “Any chance he plays baseball?” Buddy asked.

  Jake widened his eyes. “I think he does. But why would baseball be the target and not any other sports or even all of them?” Jake asked.

  “Nina said the arsonist was wearing a Yankees baseball cap. Just throwing some ideas around here. I think we need to find out who owns this particular storage facility and also the connection to the other small fires. Maybe question them and see if any threats had been made to them prior to the fires. Perhaps even minor things that were sort of suspicious.”

  “That’s a good idea, Buddy. Let’s see what we can come up with,” Trent said.

  “I’ll take care of things on my end. Oh, are you guys going to the Station Friday night? My dad and Jerome have the stage all set up and running now. There’ll be local bands playing there every Friday and Saturday night.”

  “Awesome. Yeah, we’ll be there,” Buddy told him. Then Jake headed over to the fire truck to talk to the fire chief.

  “Hey, that was really nice of Michaela to offer to help Nina. Do you think she’ll accept the help?”

  “No. I think she’ll fight it every step of the way.”

  “Maybe we can talk her into it. It’s not like it would be any easier if we offered to help.”

  “I wish she would let us. I mean, we’ve made major progress and all, but I can’t help but to worry about her. I know her scars run deep. Allowing us to make love to her was a huge step. I’m afraid if we push for more too soon she’ll panic.”

  “I get that feeling, too, Trent, but that doesn’t mean I’m going to hold back my feelings. The time we spent today was incredible. The only reason why I don’t feel nervous, worried, and sick to my stomach right now is because I know that Johnny is with her. She’s learning about all of us individually. That’s what we wanted.”

  “You’re right. But I have to say, taking her together was fucking incredible.”

  Buddy smiled. �
�She’s incredible. Let’s do what we can tonight and then head home. I can call Johnny and see if he made dinner or if we should pick something up.”

  “Sounds good. I’ll just check a few things out with the chief.”

  Buddy called Johnny’s cell, and when he didn’t answer he couldn’t help but to wonder if he was in bed with Nina after making love to her today, too.

  He smiled as he walked over toward Trent and the fire chief to get more information.

  * * * *

  Johnny stared at Nina’s back and ass as she continued sleeping. He had reached over to grab his phone and texted Buddy back and Nina didn’t even move. The poor woman was exhausted. She was working so hard, baking twenty pies every couple of days, and the orders were doubling. He had smiled when he heard Mercury and Jenks, two other paramedics, talk about these new homemade delicious pies being served at Sullivan’s. Those were Nina’s pies. His Nina.

  He smiled then trailed his finger along the curve of her hips and ass. She had a fantastic ass. He’d never felt so possessive before. He looked back down at the light-red lines along her lower back and ass. They were faint but noticeable when she was like this, naked and spread out on the couch next to him. His cock instantly hardened and he would love to make love to her again. Maybe with Buddy and Trent coming home and meeting them here at her apartment, it would mean the three of them taking her together again. That had been life altering.

  She was truly a part of each of them now, and he would never let her go. He wanted to make her happy, make her smile and feel the love she deserved to feel.

  In the distance he heard the truck pull up in the driveway then the doors close. Johnny was glad he’d texted Buddy telling him to use his key. Nina stirred slightly and he watched her lift her ass and then get comfortable again, pressing her ass toward his hip. His cock twitched, hitting her thigh. He smiled and then ran the palm of his hand along her back.

  “What time is it?” she asked, sounding all groggy and sexy.

  “Dinnertime.” He trailed a finger down the crack of her ass. He pressed lower and she moaned but also parted her thighs. His woman loved to be touched by him.

  He pressed lower until his fingers made contact with her pussy, swollen, wet, ready for exploration. He thrust a finger up into her then heard her moan. The door to the apartment opened and Nina jerked her head up. Johnny held her in place.

  He smiled as he locked gazes with Trent and Buddy, who immediately took in the sight of Nina, naked and aroused on the couch. He wondered if they could see his finger between her thighs.

  “What do we have here?” Trent asked as he passed the pizza boxes to Buddy, who smiled and took them.

  “Just waking Sleeping Beauty for dinner. She’s very wet, though.”

  Trent rubbed his hands together as he approached and then squatted down next to the couch. Johnny continued to thrust his fingers up into her as Trent cupped her face and held her gaze.

  “You look well loved and well rested.”

  He leaned forward and kissed her. Nina began to turn her hip, and Johnny maneuvered in front of her, lifting her thigh and spreading her wide as she rolled to her back.

  “I think desert is in order first,” Buddy said from behind Trent as he started undressing.

  * * * *

  Trent absorbed the feel of Nina’s body and the way she responded to Johnny arousing her. His own cock hardened and he wanted nothing more than to sink balls-deep into her cunt and love her.

  “Are you hungry?” Trent asked her.

  She reached up and cupped his chin then caressed his whiskers. “For you.”

  He felt the instant need and hunger for her as he cupped her breast and leaned down to lick and suckle her nipple. “I’m hungry for you, too. Every inch of you, baby.”

  “I want you now. All three of you.” Her cheeks turned a nice shade of red. She was so sweet. His heart soared.

  Trent stood up, tossing off his shirt. Johnny climbed over the couch, and Buddy sat down, taking Nina into his arms to straddle his waist.

  He kissed her deeply as Trent moved in behind her, caressing her ass.

  “I missed you,” Buddy told her.

  “I missed you, too.” She cupped his cheeks and kissed him as Buddy aligned his cock with her pussy and she slid down, taking him in. The sight aroused Trent even more as he held his cock in his hand and stroked the long, thick muscle. With a hand on her hip he bent down and began to lick and nibble Nina’s ass. She moaned and Johnny was there moving something behind the couch.

  “What are you doing?” she asked, sounding breathless as she thrust up and down on Buddy. Trent looked up and saw Johnny lifting a small stool. He stood on it behind the couch and now his cock was up higher. Nina chuckled.

  “Hey, I want to feel that hot, sexy mouth while my brothers fuck you, but I didn’t think Buddy would appreciate my cock next to his cheek.”

  “Fuck no,” Buddy said then pulled Nina’s breast into his mouth and suckled it.

  Trent laughed, blowing warm breath against Nina’s puckered hole. He spread her ass cheeks and licked along the bud. “Are you ready for me, Nina?” Trent asked then licked up and down the crack over her anus. He pressed a finger to it and pushed in.

  “Oh God, yes. Yes.”

  “Come here,” Johnny whispered.

  Trent looked over Nina’s shoulder and watched her take Johnny’s cock into her mouth. He thrust his finger into her ass as Buddy’s hands squeezed onto her hip bones and lifted her up and down. Trent could hear Buddy suckling Nina’s breast, holding on to it and tugging. He could only picture it since his view was obstructed by Nina’s back and glorious ass.

  “Fuck, baby, you got me,” Trent whispered. He pulled out his finger and replaced it with his cock, pressing into her anus.

  Nina moaned and Johnny grunted as he rocked against the couch. Buddy stilled for a moment while Trent worked his cock into her ass. He pulled slightly out then pushed deeper and deeper until he was fully seated in her ass.

  “Grrr.” He growled and leaned over her, his thighs pressed against the back of her thighs.

  It was so amazing, the feeling of completion, a connection like he’d never felt. Making love to Nina with his brothers strengthened their bond, their brotherhood, like never before. He felt so hard, so aroused that he knew he wouldn’t last long. It was such an out-of-control feeling that he knew was a losing battle. They worked in sync, stroking, thrusting, sucking. The sounds and grunts that echoed in the room were so wild and erotic that he grew thicker.

  “Oh, baby, I’m coming, Nina. This mouth is too much. This fucking body is too much,” Johnny said. Trent thrust harder, faster, and held on to Nina’s shoulders, pulling her slightly back. It gave him a view of her mouth sucking Johnny’s cock in and out and Buddy’s mouth sucking her nipple as Johnny held it out to his brother like an offering of a feast.

  “Fuck that’s hot. Holy shit, I love it,” Trent told them, and Johnny grunted, released her breast, grabbed Nina’s hair, and moaned as he shot his seed down her throat. She was slurping, licking, and suckling his cum until Johnny cursed and jumped back.

  It was Buddy and Trent now, and Trent knew he wouldn’t last much longer.

  “I’m there, baby. I’m right fucking there.”

  The sounds of his thighs slapping against her thighs was so wild he lost control. Trent grunted and held himself deep in her ass, making her scream her release as he shot his seed. He thrust two more times then felt Buddy lifting Nina up and down on his shaft. Trent pulled from her ass, making her moan and then fall forward against Buddy’s chest. He was pumping his hips upward at record speed. Nina was moaning and then sat up and counterthrust on top of him.

  It was a sight to see, Nina’s tits bouncing, Buddy’s face bright red, the veins by his temples pulsating, and then they both moaned and came together. Buddy wrapped his arms around her so tight she was lost in his embrace.

  “I love you, Nina. I fucking love you,” Buddy told her and Trent
felt his heart tighten. This was serious. An intense moment. Nina pulled back and stared at Buddy, breathing rapidly and holding his gaze.

  Buddy cupped her breasts and ran his thumbs along the nipples.

  “You don’t have to say anything. When the time is right, when you feel it and know it’s true and you mean it, say it then.”

  She wrapped her arms around his neck and squeezed him tight as tears fell from her eyes. Trent smiled at Buddy and Johnny.

  They were all in love with her already. Nina was going to be theirs forever.

  Chapter 9

  Rico stood by the bar on the top floor of the club. It was a private area he used for business meetings and entertaining important clients. As the music blared and people drank, danced, and enjoyed the nightlife, he stood there anticipating the meeting with trepidation and anger.

  Miguel and Martino had expressed their upset over Nina’s disappearance. Martino found out what actually happened to get Nina to leave, and now he was taking over and minimizing Rico’s role in the club business. It didn’t help matters to find out that the feds were investigating Rico on over a dozen accusations of murder, attempted murder, grand larceny, illegal gambling, and a list of other shit that would put him behind bars for life.

  Rico lifted the shot glass to his lips and drank the contents. He would need more than a buzz to get through this meeting with Martino and Miguel. He would need a goddamn miracle and for Nina to be found. He was paying those investigators good money to track her. Where the fuck did she go? How was she making money? The thought of her prostituting flashed through his mind.

  Not my Nina.

  Part of her appeal to Miguel and Martino was her virginity. They knew he’d had her first and took that, but even when they eventually would take her together, he had insisted that he be her first. She had become a bonus to the deal they were going into together that included a new line of clubs in Puerto Rico.