Tiffany Madison's MFM Collection

by Tiffany Madison

  “Hi,” I said, meekly. I was so nervous I could barely get the words out.

  They didn’t respond to me at all.

  “Tiffany, what is this?” I asked. “What’s going on?”

  Tiffany turned towards me and said, “These girls will decide if you are fit to be in the sorority. They are Pledge Mistresses and they won’t speak to you until you are officially a member.”

  As we stepped further into the room, I saw Nick and Jack sitting on the bed, wearing the same muscle shirts that they were wearing earlier. It was actually a huge relief to see some people that I knew.

  They were both looking me up and down and I could tell that they liked the outfit that I was wearing. I started to walk closer to them and I saw their eyes dilate as I approached.

  “Hi, guys,” I said, nervously. “So, is this the so-called party I was told about, for my initiation?”

  Jake responded, “Yes, something like that. So, you just be a good girl and do exactly what your asked. That’s all you have to do. Then, if the girls decide that you’re a good fit, you’ll be a member of the sorority.”

  His tone had changed significantly from when I had met him just hours before. He didn’t seem nearly as nice as he did initially. My heart started beating out of my chest and I felt a shot of adrenaline burning in my gut.

  What is he talking about? I asked myself.

  I wanted to seem like I could fit in with everyone, though, and prove that I would be good for the sorority. So, I responded, “Of course, Jake. I’ll do whatever you want. Do you want me to do some silly dances in front of the other girls or play a prank on one of my teachers?”

  Jake looked at me dead in the eyes and said, “Not exactly.”

  Then he stood up off of the bed and pulled off his muscle shirt, revealing his tanned skin and ripped body.

  “Wait, what are you doing?” I asked.

  He then walked towards me and closed the gap between us quickly, causing me to gasp. I looked towards Tiffany, hoping she would help, but she was already standing with the three girls on the other side of the room. I glanced at the door, but Tiffany had closed it and turned the lock.

  Jake pushed up against me and gripped my hips firmly. I could feel how strong he was and it didn’t seem like I was going to be able to make him budge. His hands clenched my skirt and caused it to pull up above my butt. I put my hands up to push him back and they landed on his ripped chest. As my fingers slid over his muscular body, I felt myself starting to get turned on.

  “Jake...” I said. He cut me off before I could say anything further.

  He squeezed my hips firmly and pushed me up against the wall. Then he pushed his lips into mine and I took a deep breath in. It felt so good and suddenly, I started feeling differently about the entire event. The kiss was giving me tingles down my entire body, from my lips to my toes. I closed my eyes and smiled softly.

  I felt as Jack slid his hands up from my hips and to my breasts.

  “Oh!” I said, in surprise.

  I grabbed his hand and pushed it away. Having a man touch my breasts for the first time felt amazing, but I didn’t want it to be like this. I wanted it to be sensual and meaningful. I also didn’t want there to be a room full of strangers watching when it happened.

  “Nicole,” Jake said, smiling. “You have to be a good girl now and do what you’re told.”

  His smile was pretty hard to resist and I couldn’t help but smile back.

  “What do you want me to do? I already let you kiss me,” I said.

  Then I saw as Nick got up from the bed. As soon as he got up, he pulled his shirt off over his head, revealing his toned body. He was just as muscular as Jake and it was clear he spent a lot of time in the gym.

  Wow, I said to myself. I couldn’t help but be impressed with how they looked.

  I noticed that he was holding a pink bandana in one hand.

  “Nick, what’s that for?” I asked, feeling my heart beat increase.

  Nick’s bright blue eyes shined through the dimly lit room and they seemed to get even brighter as he got close to me.

  My hands ran down Jake’s chest and over his washboard abs. I was getting more and more turned on. I was actually enjoying having both of these half-naked men in front of me.

  Jake pulled me towards him, away from the wall. This gave Nick enough space to get behind me.

  “Close your eyes, Nicole,” Nick said quietly in my ear.

  I lightly closed my eyes and then felt as Nick wrapped the bandana around them, enveloping me in darkness.

  In the background I could hear the girls giggling as they watched. I felt so vulnerable and embarrassed but at the same time, excited for what might happen.

  Jake pressed his lips against mine again as Nick wrapped his hands around me from behind. His strong arms pulled me in close and I felt his hands slide up my shirt and onto my breasts.

  “Mmmm,” I moaned softly.

  He squeezed them firmly and I could feel as my puffy nipples started to get hard.

  “Hey look, girls,” Nick said loudly. “She even decided not to wear a bra for us.”

  The girls giggled again in the corner. Then I heard Tiffany say, “I told you she wasn’t as innocent as she seemed.”

  I am innocent, though! I thought to myself.

  I was started to wonder how true that was, though, given how turned on was starting to get.

  My hands were all over Jake’s chest and abs as he kissed me, and it was turning me on so much that I could start to feel my panties dampen.

  Wait! What are you doing, Nicole? You don’t even know these boys! I thought to myself.

  I pulled away from Jake’s kiss and said, “I can’t do this.”

  “Okay,” Jake said, pulling away from me. “Your choice. I guess we’ll see you later then.”

  Nick let go of me and I could hear him step away from me. As soon as they pulled away, I started to miss their touch.

  “I guess you didn’t want to be in this sorority as much as you thought you did,” Nick said.

  I pulled the bandana up onto my forehead, gaining sight once again. Nick and Jake were standing in front of me. They had slipped out of their jeans and into their boxers while I was blindfolded. Underneath their boxers, I noticed a large bulge and it was clear that they were already turned on.

  Oh wow, I thought.

  I could tell how big their members were from the bulge. This definitely was not how I intended to lose my virginity, but I was so turned on that I started to have second thoughts on how much I cared about that.

  Tiffany and the girls were still in the corner, watching.

  I came to this school so I could be part of this sorority. Fuck it. I want to be part of it and I’ll do whatever it takes, I thought to myself, affirmatively.

  “Actually...” I said to the boys, pausing momentarily. “I want this. Being in this sorority is very important to me. So do whatever you want...I’m all yours.”

  I pulled the bandana back over my eyes, causing the darkness to once again cover my vision.

  I then felt as one of the boys grabbed my hand and led me to the bed.

  “Lay on your back,” said Jake. He wasn’t asking.

  I laid on my back and felt as one of them straddled over me. He grabbed both of my wrists and held them over my head, bringing my hands together. Then he slowly slid my shirt up over my naked tits, releasing them to the air. Within a second, he started licking and sucking on them. It wasn’t long before each of them had one of my breasts in their mouths, making both of my nipples rock hard.

  “Oh my gosh,” I said quietly.

  I heard Tiffany and the girls whispering softly in the background. There was something about them watching that was actually turning me on even more. My entire life I had been shy and I felt like I was finally being liberated.

  Let them watch, I thought. They’re probably jealous anyway.

  Then I felt one of them stop licking my nipple and get off the bed. As I laid my he
ad back, I realized I could see just below the bandana, giving me a peek into what was going on.

  Nick was licking and sucking on one of my tits and fondling the other one with his hand. Jake was standing at the foot of the bed, looking me over.

  I watched as Jack slid off his boxers, letting them fall to the floor. His cock was already so hard that it was practically throbbing. He stroked it a couple of times and stepped closer to me. I felt my pussy dampen even more in anticipation of what was about to happen.

  He grabbed the underside of my knees and lifted them up, causing my legs to spread and my skirt to slide up to my waist.

  “I like your panties, Nicole,” Jake said. “But you won’t be needing those.”

  Then before I could say a word, Jake grabbed my cotton panties at the waist and literally ripped them off of me. The tearing sound was startling.

  My skirt was bunched up around my waist and my little wet pussy was exposed to the entire room. I brought my hands down from above my head and tried to cover myself. I was feeling a little embarrassed.

  Nick grabbed my hands and put them back up above me.

  “Uh, uh,” he said, softly. He then went back to licking circles around my nipples.

  I decided to just relax into it and enjoy the ride.

  I felt as Jake touched my clit and immediately it brought a pleasure to me that I had never felt before. It didn’t feel anything like when I would touch myself in the shower. His strong hands and grip brought a firm pressure to my pussy that so intense, it made me lightheaded.

  “Oh!” I yelled out in pleasure.

  His fingers were shooting in and out of me and I could feel how wet I was.

  Then Jake did something that I wasn’t expecting. He brought his head down to my pussy and starting licking and sucking on my pussy lips. The tingles that were originally shooting through my body had turned into huge waves of ecstasy.

  I brought my hands down out of reflex and started rubbing my clit while Jake licked around my pussy. This time Nick didn’t stop me.

  Jake stood up and grabbed his cock in one had and started bringing it towards my awaiting opening.

  “Wait!” I shouted.

  I pulled the bandana up to my forehead again.

  “You’re going to use a condom, right?” I asked, seeming concerned.

  Jake laughed and said, “Who’s making the rules again?”

  Nick looked at me and pulled the bandana back over my eyes.

  I wasn’t on birth control and I was afraid of getting pregnant if Jake came in me.

  I felt Jake push the tip of his penis up against my wet opening. It felt big and hard as it pushed into the entrance.

  A part of me wanted to push him back and demand that he wear a condom. But there was also a part of me that didn’t care. I wanted him inside of me badly and I was ready for him.

  Fuck it, I thought.

  I reached my hands down and grabbed his ass, pulling him into me firmly.

  The first half of his dick slid inside of me. It was so big that I could feel my pussy stretch to accommodate it. Then he pulled out and pushed in again, coming up to some resistance.

  The pleasure was so intense that my eyes had rolled back into my head and a huge smile had come across my face.

  Jack pulled out one more time and pushed in hard. There was a huge pressure inside of me and then there was release. His dick slid all the way inside of me. It was painful at first, but as soon as the pain came, it was gone and replaced with one of the best feelings I had ever had in my life.

  Did he pop my cherry? I asked myself.

  The waves of ecstasy were almost too much to handle. I was screaming out in pleasure and I didn’t even care what Tiffany and her friends were thinking.

  I reached a hand over to see what Nick was doing. I didn’t feel him around my chest, so I took the opportunity to remove the bandana from my head. I ripped it off and looked over to see Nick with his hard cock in hand, staring me straight in the face.

  “Put it in your mouth,” he demanded. “I want to watch you be a bad girl.”

  With Jake inside of me, I reached next to me and put my hand around Nick’s throbbing member. It was easily as big as Jake’s, and I hardly knew what to do with it.

  I started licking the tip of it and Nick moaned out softly.

  “Yes, like that,” Nick said, in between breaths.

  Nick put both of his hands behind my head and pushed his dick into my mouth. It went in deep and hard and it caused me to gag. It was probably pretty clear that I had never done it before and it made me blush with embarrassment. However, Nick didn’t seem to care. He kept thrusting his dick deep into my throat. He grabbed my ponytail and pulled up so hard that it lifted my head off of the bed.

  “Look up at me,” Nick demanded.

  I looked up at him and attempted a smile, but it was difficult with my mouth full.

  “Good girl,” he said, smiling down at me.

  Jake was still pounding me hard, causing my entire body to quiver with pleasure. Every once in a while, Jake would reach up and squeeze my breasts, causing the sensations in my body to increase even further.

  Just when I thought I was about to have my first orgasm, I heard Jake say, “Okay, Nick. I think it’s your turn.”

  What? They’re both going to fuck me? I don’t know how much more I can take, I thought.

  I didn’t want to say anything, though. They were going to do whatever they wanted and if I wished to be part of the sorority, then I had to obey.

  Jake pulled his dick out of me. I couldn’t believe how wet it was. I could see my lubrication covering his member, practically dripping off of it.

  Nick let go of my ponytail, letting my head fall back to the pillow.

  “Turn around and bend over for me, Nicole,” Nick said.

  Without any hesitation, I got up onto my knees and bent over, exposing my ass and pussy to the girls in the corner. I was getting so into the sex that I didn’t even care at that point.

  Nick got behind me and grabbed my hips firmly. Immediately, Nick’s cock slipped inside of me. I was so wet that it had no trouble plunging in completely, and I instantly felt his balls slap up against my clit.

  “Oh fuck, Nick,” I shouted.

  I reached back and pulled him into me. I couldn’t get enough of it.

  Jake crawled on the bed and was on his knees in front of me with his cock in my face. I opened my lips and let him slide it into my mouth. I could taste my pussy juices that were covering it. I looked up and smiled at him, knowing that he would like that. He briefly smiled back and then grabbed my ponytail, forcing his cock firmly into my throat.

  The pleasure of having two men inside of me was enough to make me explode. Nick was pounding me so hard that I was slowly being pushed up the bed with every thrust. The waves of ecstasy were almost too much to handle and my hands were shaking from the pleasure.

  The sensation started to intensify with every plunge and I knew I was going to cum. I started getting lightheaded as I reached orgasm and my pussy wrapped tight around Nick’s cock.

  “Oh, hell yeah,” Nick said.

  I knew he could feel me orgasm because he started pumping me harder and faster.

  “I’m going to cum!” he shouted out.

  He grabbed my hips firmly, pulling me into him. He pulled me so hard that it lifted me slightly off of the bed. The thrusts got harder and faster until finally he pushed in firmly and stopped. I felt his dick pulsate inside of me and then I felt a hot splash. I knew he had just cum in me, but I didn’t mind. I actually wanted it. I squeezed my pussy tight around his cock, letting it draw up every single drop of cum. Nick pushed his dick in and out of my pussy slowly, still recovering from his orgasm. Then he pulled out and I felt as his cum dripped out of my wet flower and onto the bed.

  Jake’s cock was still deep in my throat and it was only a few seconds later that Jake sent his load into my mouth.

  “Ohh, fuck!” Jake said, as he exploded into my t
hroat.

  He grabbed my ponytail and pushed my mouth onto his dick firmly. I felt a hot liquid pour out of his cock and onto my tongue. He took his dick out of my mouth and smiled at me. I smiled back and a little bit of his cum came out of my mouth and ran down my chin.

  “Good girl,” Jake said, releasing my ponytail.

  I heaved a sigh of exhaustion and laid onto the bed. I turned to look at the Tiffany and the girls.

  Their jaws were dropped and they all seemed really surprised.

  Jake and Nick immediately got up and started putting their clothes back on. I got up also and picked up my ripped panties that were thrown carelessly across the room.

  Tiffany walked up to me and said, “What the hell was that all about?”

  I looked at her in completely bewilderment, “What do you mean? Isn’t that what you wanted?”

  She laughed and said, “Well, we were just going to make you kiss both of the boys. They thought they would push it a little bit further as a joke and to see what you would do. We didn’t think you would actually go along with it.”

  I felt as my face turned pale and my stomach sank.

  Tiffany giggled and said, “Well, don’t worry silly. You’re definitely in the sorority after that!”

  I smiled with relief. It wasn’t exactly how I thought my first day of college would be, but I guess it could have been worse.

  “I just hope you’re on birth control!” Tiffany said, jokingly.

  I turned even more pale. In the heat of the moment I had completely forgotten about that. I hadn’t ever been on birth control because I was planning on getting married before I had sex.

  Whatever. It was worth it. That was incredible, I thought to myself.

  Tiffany took my hand and pulled me out of the door.

  I glanced behind me to see Nick and Jake still getting dressed. The girls in the corner were waving and smiling at me for the first time.

  “Bye, Nicole!” they said in unison. “We can’t wait to get to know you!”

  I turned back and followed Tiffany out the door. A smile came on my face as I realized I had just become a full fledged member of one of the most prestigious sororities in the country. My parents were going to be so proud.