Physics of the Impossible: A Scientific Exploration into the World of Phasers, Force Fields, Teleportation, and Time Travel

by Michio Kaku

  This classification is significant, I feel, because so many technologies in science fiction are dismissed by scientists as being totally impossible, when what they actually mean is that they are impossible for a primitive civilization like ours. Alien visitations, for example, are usually considered impossible because the distances between the stars are so vast. While interstellar travel for our civilization is clearly impossible, it may be possible for a civilization centuries to thousands or millions of years ahead of ours. So it is important to rank such “impossibilities.” Technologies that are impossible for our current civilization are not necessarily impossible for other types of civilizations. Statements about what is possible and impossible have to take into account technologies that are millennia to millions of years ahead of ours.

  Carl Sagan once wrote, “What does it mean for a civilization to be a million years old? We have had radio telescopes and spaceships for a few decades; our technical civilization is a few hundred years old…an advanced civilization millions of years old is as much beyond us as we are beyond a bush baby or a macaque.”

  In my own research I focus professionally on trying to complete Einstein’s dream of a “theory of everything.” Personally, I find it quite exhilarating to work on a “final theory” that may ultimately answer some of the most difficult “impossible” questions in science today, such as whether time travel is possible, what lies at the center of a black hole, or what happened before the big bang. I still daydream about my lifelong love affair with the impossible, and wonder when and if some of these impossibilities might enter the ranks of the everyday.

  ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

  The material in this book ranges over many fields and disciplines, as well as the work of many outstanding scientists. I would like to thank the following individuals, who have graciously given their time for lengthy interviews, consultations, and interesting, stimulating conversations:

  Leon Lederman, Nobel laureate, Illinois Institute of Technology

  Murray Gell-Mann, Nobel laureate, Santa Fe Institute and Cal Tech

  The late Henry Kendall, Nobel laureate, MIT

  Steven Weinberg, Nobel laureate, University of Texas at Austin

  David Gross, Nobel laureate, Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics

  Frank Wilczek, Nobel laureate, MIT

  Joseph Rotblat, Nobel laureate, St. Bartholomew’s Hospital

  Walter Gilbert, Nobel laureate, Harvard University

  Gerald Edelman, Nobel laureate, Scripps Research Institute

  Peter Doherty, Nobel laureate, St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital

  Jared Diamond, Pulitzer Prize winner, UCLA

  Stan Lee, creator of Marvel Comics and Spiderman

  Brian Greene, Columbia University, author of The Elegant Universe

  Lisa Randall, Harvard University, author of Warped Passages

  Lawrence Krauss, Case Western University, author of The Physics of Star Trek

  J. Richard Gott III, Princeton University, author of Time Travel in Einstein’s Universe

  Alan Guth, physicist, MIT, author of The Inflationary Universe

  John Barrow, physicist, Cambridge University, author of Impossibility

  Paul Davies, physicist, author of Superforce

  Leonard Susskind, physicist, Stanford University

  Joseph Lykken, physicist, Fermi National Laboratory

  Marvin Minsky, MIT, author of The Society of Minds

  Ray Kurzweil, inventor, author of The Age of Spiritual Machines

  Rodney Brooks, director of MIT Artificial Intelligence Laboratory

  Hans Moravec, author of Robot

  Ken Croswell, astronomer, author of Magnificent Universe

  Don Goldsmith, astronomer, author of Runaway Universe

  Neil de Grasse Tyson, director of Hayden Planetarium, New York City

  Robert Kirshner, astronomer, Harvard University

  Fulvia Melia, astronomer, University of Arizona

  Sir Martin Rees, Cambridge University, author of Before the Beginning

  Michael Brown, astronomer, Cal Tech

  Paul Gilster, author of Centauri Dreams

  Michael Lemonick, senior science editor of Time magazine

  Timothy Ferris, University of California, author of Coming of Age in the Milky Way

  The late Ted Taylor, designer of U.S. nuclear warheads

  Freeman Dyson, Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton

  John Horgan, Stevens Institute of Technology, author of The End of Science

  The late Carl Sagan, Cornell University, author of Cosmos

  Ann Druyan, widow of Carl Sagan, Cosmos Studios

  Peter Schwarz, futurist, founder of Global Business Network

  Alvin Toffler, futurist, author of The Third Wave

  David Goodstein, assistant provost of Cal Tech

  Seth Lloyd, MIT, author of Programming the Universe

  Fred Watson, astronomer, author of Star Gazer

  Simon Singh, author of The Big Bang

  Seth Shostak, SETI Institute

  George Johnson, New York Times science journalist

  Jeffrey Hoffman, MIT, NASA astronaut

  Tom Jones, NASA astronaut

  Alan Lightman, MIT, author of Einstein’s Dreams

  Robert Zubrin, founder of Mars Society

  Donna Shirley, NASA Mars program

  John Pike, GlobalSecurity.org

  Paul Saffo, futurist, Institute of the Future

  Louis Friedman, cofounder of the Planetary Society

  Daniel Werthheimer, SETI@home, University of California at Berkeley

  Robert Zimmerman, author of Leaving Earth

  Marcia Bartusiak, author of Einstein’s Unfinished Symphony

  Michael H. Salamon, NASA’s Beyond Einstein program

  Geoff Andersen, U.S. Air Force Academy, author of The Telescope

  I would also like to thank my agent, Stuart Krichevsky, who has been at my side all these years, shepherding all my books, and also my editor, Roger Scholl, whose firm hand, sound judgment, and editorial experience have guided so many of my books. I would also like to thank my collegues at the City College of New York and the Graduate Center of the City University of New York, especially V. P. Nair and Dan Greenberger, who generously donated their time for discussions.

  1: FORCE FIELDS

  I. When a distinguished but elderly scientist states that something is possible, he is almost certainly right. When he states that something is impossible, he is very probably wrong.

  II. The only way of discovering the limits of the possible is to venture a little way past them into the impossible.

  III. Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.

  —ARTHUR C. CLARKE’S THREE LAWS

  “Shields up!”

  In countless Star Trek episodes this is the first order that Captain Kirk barks out to the crew, raising the force fields to protect the starship Enterprise against enemy fire.

  So vital are force fields in Star Trek that the tide of the battle can be measured by how the force field is holding up. Whenever power is drained from the force fields, the Enterprise suffers more and more damaging blows to its hull, until finally surrender is inevitable.

  So what is a force field? In science fiction it’s deceptively simple: a thin, invisible yet impenetrable barrier able to deflect lasers and rockets alike. At first glance a force field looks so easy that its creation as a battlefield shield seems imminent. One expects that any day some enterprising inventor will announce the discovery of a defensive force field. But the truth is far more complicated.

  In the same way that Edison’s lightbulb revolutionized modern civilization, a force field could profoundly affect every aspect of our lives. The military could use force fields to become invulnerable, creating an impenetrable shield against enemy missiles and bullets. Bridges, superhighways, and roads could in theory be built by simply pressing a button. Entire cities could sprout instantly in the desert, with skyscrapers m
ade entirely of force fields. Force fields erected over cities could enable their inhabitants to modify the effects of their weather—high winds, blizzards, tornados—at will. Cities could be built under the oceans within the safe canopy of a force field. Glass, steel, and mortar could be entirely replaced.

  Yet oddly enough a force field is perhaps one of the most difficult devices to create in the laboratory. In fact, some physicists believe it might actually be impossible, without modifying its properties.

  MICHAEL FARADAY

  The concept of force fields originates from the work of the great nineteenth-century British scientist Michael Faraday.

  Faraday was born to working-class parents (his father was a blacksmith) and eked out a meager existence as an apprentice bookbinder in the early 1800s. The young Faraday was fascinated by the enormous breakthroughs in uncovering the mysterious properties of two new forces: electricity and magnetism. Faraday devoured all he could concerning these topics and attended lectures by Professor Humphrey Davy of the Royal Institution in London.

  One day Professor Davy severely damaged his eyes in a chemical accident and hired Faraday to be his secretary. Faraday slowly began to win the confidence of the scientists at the Royal Institution and was allowed to conduct important experiments of his own, although he was often slighted. Over the years Professor Davy grew increasingly jealous of the brilliance shown by his young assistant, who was a rising star in experimental circles, eventually eclipsing Davy’s own fame. After Davy died in 1829 Faraday was free to make a series of stunning breakthroughs that led to the creation of generators that would energize entire cities and change the course of world civilization.

  The key to Faraday’s greatest discoveries was his “force fields.” If one places iron filings over a magnet, one finds that the iron filings create a spiderweb-like pattern that fills up all of space. These are Faraday’s lines of force, which graphically describe how the force fields of electricity and magnetism permeate space. If one graphs the magnetic fields of the Earth, for example, one finds that the lines emanate from the north polar region and then fall back to the Earth in the south polar region. Similarly, if one were to graph the electric field lines of a lightning rod in a thunderstorm, one would find that the lines of force concentrate at the tip of the lightning rod. Empty space, to Faraday, was not empty at all, but was filled with lines of force that could make distant objects move. (Because of Faraday’s poverty-stricken youth, he was illiterate in mathematics, and as a consequence his notebooks are full not of equations but of hand-drawn diagrams of these lines of force. Ironically, his lack of mathematical training led him to create the beautiful diagrams of lines of force that now can be found in any physics textbook. In science a physical picture is often more important than the mathematics used to describe it.)

  Historians have speculated on how Faraday was led to his discovery of force fields, one of the most important concepts in all of science. In fact, the sum total of all modern physics is written in the language of Faraday’s fields. In 1831, he made the key breakthrough regarding force fields that changed civilization forever. One day, he was moving a child’s magnet over a coil of wire and he noticed that he was able to generate an electric current in the wire, without ever touching it. This meant that a magnet’s invisible field could push electrons in a wire across empty space, creating a current.

  Faraday’s “force fields,” which were previously thought to be useless, idle doodlings, were real, material forces that could move objects and generate power. Today the light that you are using to read this page is probably energized by Faraday’s discovery about electromagnetism. A spinning magnet creates a force field that pushes the electrons in a wire, causing them to move in an electrical current. This electricity in the wire can then be used to light up a lightbulb. This same principle is used to generate electricity to power the cities of the world. Water flowing across a dam, for example, causes a huge magnet in a turbine to spin, which then pushes the electrons in a wire, forming an electric current that is sent across high-voltage wires into our homes.

  In other words, the force fields of Michael Faraday are the forces that drive modern civilization, from electric bulldozers to today’s computers, Internet, and iPods.

  Faraday’s force fields have been an inspiration for physicists for a century and a half. Einstein was so inspired by them that he wrote his theory of gravity in terms of force fields. I, too, was inspired by Faraday’s work. Years ago I successfully wrote the theory of strings in terms of the force fields of Faraday, thereby founding string field theory. In physics when someone says, “He thinks like a line of force,” it is meant as a great compliment.

  THE FOUR FORCES

  Over the last two thousand years one of the crowning achievements of physics has been the isolation and identification of the four forces that rule the universe. All of them can be described in the language of fields introduced by Faraday. Unfortunately, however, none of them has quite the properties of the force fields described in most science fiction. These forces are

  1. Gravity, the silent force that keeps our feet on the ground, prevents the Earth and the stars from disintegrating, and holds the solar system and galaxy together. Without gravity, we would be flung off the Earth into space at the rate of 1,000 miles per hour by the spinning planet. The problem is that gravity has precisely the opposite properties of a force field found in science fiction. Gravity is attractive, not repulsive; is extremely weak, relatively speaking; and works over enormous, astronomical distances. In other words, it is almost the opposite of the flat, thin, impenetrable barrier that one reads about in science fiction or one sees in science fiction movies. For example, it takes the entire planet Earth to attract a feather to the floor, but we can counteract Earth’s gravity by lifting the feather with a finger. The action of our finger can counteract the gravity of an entire planet that weighs over six trillion trillion kilograms.

  2. Electromagnetism (EM), the force that lights up our cities. Lasers, radio, TV, modern electronics, computers, the Internet, electricity, magnetism—all are consequences of the electromagnetic force. It is perhaps the most useful force ever harnessed by humans. Unlike gravity, it can be both attractive and repulsive. However, there are several reasons that it is unsuitable as a force field. First, it can be easily neutralized. Plastics and other insulators, for example, can easily penetrate a powerful electric or magnetic field. A piece of plastic thrown in a magnetic field would pass right through. Second, electromagnetism acts over large distances and cannot easily be focused onto a plane. The laws of the EM force are described by James Clerk Maxwell’s equations, and these equations do not seem to admit force fields as solutions.

  3 & 4. The weak and strong nuclear forces. The weak force is the force of radioactive decay. It is the force that heats up the center of the Earth, which is radioactive. It is the force behind volcanoes, earthquakes, and continental drift. The strong force holds the nucleus of the atom together. The energy of the sun and the stars originates from the nuclear force, which is responsible for lighting up the universe. The problem is that the nuclear force is a short-range force, acting mainly over the distance of a nucleus. Because it is so bound to the properties of nuclei, it is extremely hard to manipulate. At present the only ways we have of manipulating this force are to blow subatomic particles apart in atom smashers or to detonate atomic bombs.

  Although the force fields used in science fiction may not conform to the known laws of physics, there are still loopholes that might make the creation of such a force field possible. First, there may be a fifth force, still unseen in the laboratory. Such a force might, for example, work over a distance of only a few inches to feet, rather than over astronomical distances. (Initial attempts to measure the presence of such a fifth force, however, have yielded negative results.)

  Second, it may be possible to use a plasma to mimic some of the properties of a force field. A plasma is the “fourth state of matter.” Solids, liquids, and gases make up the
three familiar states of matter, but the most common form of matter in the universe is plasma, a gas of ionized atoms. Because the atoms of a plasma are ripped apart, with electrons torn off the atom, the atoms are electrically charged and can be easily manipulated by electric and magnetic fields.

  Plasmas are the most plentiful form of visible matter in the universe, making up the sun, the stars, and interstellar gas. Plasmas are not familiar to us because they are only rarely found on the Earth, but we can see them in the form of lightning bolts, the sun, and the interior of your plasma TV.

  PLASMA WINDOWS

  As noted above, if a gas is heated to a high enough temperature, thereby creating a plasma, it can be molded and shaped by magnetic and electrical fields. It can, for example, be shaped in the form of a sheet or window. Moreover, this “plasma window” can be used to separate a vacuum from ordinary air. In principle, one might be able to prevent the air within a spaceship from leaking out into space, thereby creating a convenient, transparent interface between outer space and the spaceship.

  In the Star Trek TV series, such a force field is used to separate the shuttle bay, containing small shuttle craft, from the vacuum of outer space. Not only is it a clever way to save money on props, but it is a device that is possible.

  The plasma window was invented by physicist Ady Herschcovitch in 1995 at the Brookhaven National Laboratory in Long Island, New York. He developed it to solve the problem of how to weld metals using electron beams. A welder’s acetylene torch uses a blast of hot gas to melt and then weld metal pieces together. But a beam of electrons can weld metals faster, cleaner, and more cheaply than ordinary methods. The problem with electron beam welding, however, is that it needs to be done in a vacuum. This requirement is quite inconvenient, because it means creating a vacuum box that may be as big as an entire room.