Hearts on Fire 7: Claiming Catalina (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Dixie Lynn Dwyer

  Cooper moaned and thrust along with him.

  “I’m coming, bud. I’m fucking coming,” Cooper exclaimed and then thrust upward, wrapping his arms around Catalina to pull her close before he covered her mouth and kissed her deeply.

  Don thrust faster and faster.

  “Don, oh God, you’re so hard. This is so wild. I’m coming again. Oh!” She cried out, and so did Don as they came simultaneously.

  * * * *

  Catalina collapsed against Cooper’s chest as Don eased out of her. Jeremy was there to help his brother lie back down on the bed. There were a lot of grunts and mumbled “fucks” as everyone calmed their breathing. Catalina felt sedated. She’d done it. She’d allowed four men to make love to her together, and looking at each of them, she figured she was a very lucky woman indeed.

  Cooper rolled her to the side, sliding his cock out from her pussy. She moaned softly, and then Cody was there with a warm washcloth and began to wash her up. She grabbed for the cloth.

  “I can do that.”

  Cooper tightened his hold and rolled her to her back, placing one of his legs over her left thigh as Cody cleaned her up, then kissed her pussy.

  “It’s our job to take care of our woman,” Cooper said firmly.

  Her cheeks blushed, and her belly did a series of flips and flops from his possessive words.

  “That was amazing, Catalina. Thank you for trusting us and letting us in.”

  “I can’t believe we just did that,” Catalina said. She couldn’t resist running her fingers through Cooper’s hair and feeling the slight bit of stubble on his cheeks.

  He lowered his mouth to hers and kissed her. “You’re so damn special, baby. Damn special.”

  “And so are the four of you,” she said, and then closed her eyes and absorbed every moment of contentedness she felt right now.

  * * * *

  “Do you have to go?” Cooper whispered to Catalina as she tiptoed out of Don’s room after checking on him and the bandage. He’d watched her kiss Don’s forehead and then smile at him before she met Cooper at the doorway.

  “He needs to rest, and I have plans this morning,” she told him, and he took her hand, brought it to his lips, and kissed her fingertips.

  Cooper pressed her against the wall, maneuvered his thigh between her legs, and absorbed the feel of her in his arms. He didn’t want her to leave. He wanted everything instantly, a house, her living with them, a family, all of it. Cooper started to kiss along her neck and suckle her skin. He felt her grip his arms as he ran his hand under her dress to her hip.

  “Stay, baby. Don’t leave.”

  “Cooper, I stayed last night. I have these plans with my friends.”

  “Ditch them and stay with us,” Cody added, and Cooper chuckled against her neck. He felt her shiver.

  When Cooper pulled back, she cupped his cheeks then ran her hands through his hair. “I would love to stay, but I just can’t. Besides, Jeremy and Cody came to see you guys and spend some time together. I’ll call you tonight.”

  “Where are you going?” Cody asked with his arms crossed in front of his chest.

  Cooper pulled back, and she straightened out her dress.

  “To register for the 10K race next Saturday morning, then to lunch with friends, and I think the Station later tonight, but I’m not sure yet. Shayla, MaryAnn, and Destiny want to go to this new club in Fairway.”

  “New club? Which one?” Cooper asked her.

  “The Water Crest Yacht Club. Destiny’s cousin works at the place, and she said the tiki bar and live band are supposed to be phenomenal.”

  “So you’re going there with them and Serefina, too?” Cooper asked her.

  “No, just Shayla, MaryAnn, and Destiny. Serefina and the girls are meeting for lunch.” She ran her palms up his chest and then looked at Cody.

  “Why are you looking at me like that?” she asked, and Cooper released her, but he was feeling like Cody probably was, unsure and a bit jealous, as he looked at her long blonde hair and gorgeous blue eyes.

  “Come here,” Cody said with his arms still crossed until Catalina slowly walked toward him. Cody caressed her cheek. When she reached up and held his wrist and arm, then closed her eyes as if relishing the feel of Cody’s touch, Cooper felt even more protective.

  “I thought we would take this time to spend together?” Cody whispered. She stepped closer and placed her hand on his chest as she looked way up at him. She was so petite compared to each of them. They towered over her.

  “I made these plans a week ago. Besides, you and Jeremy came here to see Don and Cooper. It’s a good time to catch up and talk things over. I’ll see you soon.”

  “Tomorrow? You’ll spend the entire day and night with us tomorrow?” he asked.

  Cooper waited for her response, and just then, Jeremy walked into the hallway after showering.

  “I think we can do that.”

  Cody pulled her close. He had one arm wrapped around her waist with his palm half over her ass, and the other cupped her hair and cheek. “Definitely we’re doing that. What time should we pick you up tomorrow?”

  “All depends on how late I get in tonight,” she replied.

  “Late? Where are you going?” Jeremy asked.

  “She has plans with friends to go to some fancy yacht club,” Cooper told his brother.

  “We’re not going to see you tonight? What about Don? He might need you,” Jeremy added, and Cooper was surprised. It seemed to him that Cody and Jeremy really liked Catalina. In fact, they were acting even more possessive and protective than he was.

  “Jeremy, he’ll be fine. He has all the information and care instructions the doctor gave him, plus his experience and Cooper’s with first aid. I’ll miss all of you if that makes you feel better.”

  Cooper nuzzled against her neck and began kissing her skin. “Stay longer.” He ran his hands up her dress and over her ass. He pressed her hard against him before he moved his mouth from her neck to her jaw and then her mouth.

  When he lifted her up and pressed her against the wall with her straddling his hips, Cooper got all excited and felt needy all over again.

  “Cody.” She gasped, pulling her mouth from his, as Cody appeared to be fingering her cunt. The material of the dress covered her, but one look at her head tilted back, her blotchy chest, and Cody’s arm moving back and forth and Cooper knew he was fingering their woman.

  “Cody. Oh God, Cody, please.”

  “Come for me, sugar. Come all over my fingers. Let me take you right here against the wall. I need you.”

  * * * *

  Catalina gasped as Cody fingered her pussy and pressed her against the wall. She felt so aroused and needy. The truth was she didn’t want to go out today or tonight. She wanted to be here with her men, but she also felt as though they needed time to talk and she needed a little space to comprehend what had taken place between them last night and this morning.

  She felt Cody remove his fingers and then unzip his pants.

  “Cody,” she whispered as he set her down, pushed down her panties, and picked her back up again.

  “Condom, bro,” Jeremy said, joining them with Cooper by the wall.

  “Catalina?” Cody held her gaze.

  “You don’t need them. I’m on birth control,” she told Cody.

  “What?” Cooper and Jeremy asked at the same time.

  Cody’s expression changed. He looked so carnal and wild.

  “Fuck yeah. No barriers. I get to feel you completely.” He stroked up into her cunt. She gripped his shoulders, tilted her head back, and moaned at the instant fullness she felt.

  Cody thrust into her, and she counter-thrust against him as she ran her fingers through his hair and held on for the ride. He was relentless with his strokes, and the feel of his large, hard hands squeezing her ass and her thighs, widening them so he could get deeper, made her lose her breath.

  “Cody!” She screamed out his name as she came so hard she shook in h
is arms.

  Cody continued to thrust and grunt her name. “Catalina, Catalina. Oh God, baby. Fuck.” He roared and came inside of her, filling her with his seed.

  In her mind, she imagined being pregnant, bearing their children and being a family. The thoughts struck a sore spot in her heart. Her own flesh and blood, her sister, had betrayed her, hurt her over a man. Could Cody, Jeremy, Don, and Cooper be trusted to belong to only her, or could another woman come along and take them away from her just like her sister had taken away Paul?

  She hugged Cody tight as the tears reached her eyes.

  “Catalina?” he whispered and pulled back. He cupped her face. “Did I hurt you, baby?”

  She shook her head. “No. No, Cody, that was beautiful,” she whispered.

  He slowly set her down and kissed her again.

  Jeremy moved closer and took her hand. He looked at Cooper then back at her. “Coop and I need you, too, before you go.”

  “Jeremy, it’s getting late,” she said, but he cut her off and kissed her deeply. A moment later, he was picking her up and carrying her to another bedroom.

  In a flash, they had her naked.

  Jeremy lay on the bed, stroking his cock and curling his finger toward her. She smiled at him and that sexy, hard body, the determined look on his face, and a superiority that oozed from him. He was just so fine that she would follow his orders, his control any day of the week.

  She crawled up on top of him, and he gripped her hips.

  “We’re going to give you something to remember us by tonight when you’re out with your friends,” Jeremy told her as he cupped her head and brought her down for a deep, sensual kiss. He ran his hand along her hip and over her ass, squeezing it hard and possessively.

  Then she felt the hands on her ass, Cooper move in behind her, and then the cool liquid against her anus.

  She pulled from Jeremy’s mouth and gasped when Cooper pressed a finger into her ass.

  “When guys come flirting with you, remember who you belong to, baby,” Cooper said as he eased a finger in and out of her ass while he pressed over her and suckled her neck.

  Jeremy lifted her hips and aligned his cock with her pussy. She felt so aroused, turned-on by their words and touch, that she lowered over Jeremy’s large, thick cock and sank down, taking him deep.

  “Fuck yeah, you feel so good. God, I love being inside of you without a condom. Holy fuck.” Jeremy gripped her hips and pumped up into her slowly.

  Behind her, Cooper removed his finger and placed the tip of his cock against her anus. He slowly began to breach her ass.

  “No barriers. No walls or uncertainty that this is real, that we’re meant to be. All of us together.” He sank into her slowly as she gasped for air and moaned aloud. When she felt the “plop,” all three of them moaned a sigh of contentedness, and she shivered as her pussy quaked.

  In and out, they began to move in sync, one cock in her pussy and one in her ass. She held on to Jeremy’s shoulders, locked gazes with his brown eyes, the control, the manliness, and authority in him so apparent even now in bed. He was a leader, a sexy, bossy federal agent, and she would be lying if she said it didn’t make her wild. She pressed her ass back, and Cooper thrust into her harder.

  Smack.

  “Cooper!” she squealed.

  Smack, smack, smack.

  “This is our ass, our body. You belong to the four of us. Remember that, baby. You hear me?” he asked, his tone so hard, loud, and so wild that she felt her pussy explode.

  “Yes. Yes, Cooper.” She rocked back and forth, and Jeremy cupped her breasts. Cody joined them.

  “Setting down the rules, brothers, so our woman knows she’s all ours always?” he asked.

  “Hell yeah,” Cooper stated.

  Catalina moaned and wiggled as both men continued to thrust into her body, and then Cody leaned over and suckled her breast that Jeremy held in offering. It was so sexy, naughty, the way they did that. Everything about them excited her. Their large hands, their take-charge attitudes, and the way they fed off one another’s desires and need to possess her.

  Cody tugged on her nipple, and she moaned.

  “I’m there, baby. I’m so fucking there,” Cooper said.

  Smack.

  He spanked her again, and she was shocked at how turned-on she was. She moaned and fell forward, and both men increased their pace.

  “God, you’re so beautiful. I love watching my brothers fuck you,” Cody told her, and he cupped her cheeks and then plunged his tongue into her mouth.

  Jeremy pinched her nipples and thrust upward hard while Cooper smacked her ass and thrust three more times before calling out her name.

  Her body exploded again, and then Jeremy gripped her hips tightly and thrust upward hard.

  “Ours. All fucking ours,” Jeremy said.

  Cody moved back, and she fell against Jeremy’s chest. Cooper caressed her ass and kissed her shoulders and down her spine as he eased out of her ass.

  Jeremy ran his hands along her back and then to her ass, squeezing it. She gasped. It felt tender, and Jeremy chuckled.

  Cody reached over, and she felt his hands and then his mouth.

  “A nice, pink ass. I love it. So fucking sexy, the way you came when he spanked you. You’re made for us, that’s for sure,” Cody said, and she moaned.

  “I don’t even feel like moving,” she whispered.

  Jeremy caressed her hair from her cheek and kissed her temple. “Good. You can stay right here, and we can make love all day and all night.”

  She thought about that and would have loved to, but then her friends would be mad, and she would also be giving these guys way too much control over her too soon.

  She rose up, and he raised one of his eyebrows at her.

  She smiled. “It’s better if I go. This is all so new, and I don’t want to make the wrong choice. I promised my friends I would hang out with them today and tonight. I need to go.” She kissed his lips and slowly sat up, but as she began to climb off of him, Jeremy gripped her hips and held her in place.

  “This is special. It’s real. We’ll work things out, Catalina.”

  She gave him a smile and caressed his chest.

  “Take the time to talk things over, and I’ll call you tomorrow.”

  She got up, and Cooper was there, pulling her into his arms.

  “You’ll text us and let us know where you are and that you’re okay, then again when you get home.”

  She ran her fingers through his hair and pressed her breasts against his chest.

  “And if I’m really late getting home?”

  Smack.

  She gasped and pulled back and covered her ass with her hand. “Cody,” she reprimanded.

  “Watch it, you, or you’ll get a spanking again tomorrow for naughty behavior.”

  Jeremy and Cooper laughed.

  “Very funny, Cody.” She grabbed her dress and headed toward the bathroom, but Cody came up behind her, lifted her up over his shoulder, and ran his hand along her ass.

  “You’re not leaving yet. I’ve got shower plans for us.”

  As he closed the door with his foot and turned on the shower, all while holding her over his shoulder as if she were light as a feather, she knew she was going to be late. In fact, it was going to take some serious discipline to get her to stick to her guns and not give in to their immediate demands and control, even though she loved every second of it.

  Cody set her down and then brought her into the shower. He kissed her deeply and then began to slowly soap up her body. She leaned back with his instructions, closed her eyes, and exhaled, thinking maybe she could stay a little longer. Maybe their control and desire to be with her was exactly what she needed after all.

  Chapter 3

  The bar was noisy, but that background static somehow made it easier for them to discuss what was going on in their lives and get on board together.

  “There are things we can look into doing. It’s just going to ta
ke some time to work things out with the job,” Cody said, and then he took a sip of beer while he and his brothers sat around a pub table at the Station. They had been talking about Catalina since she left this morning. Well, closer to noon. They would have preferred being with her tonight, but she did have a point about how fast things were moving.

  “It’s a lot to think about,” Jeremy said, “but in a way, meeting Catalina and having such strong feelings equally makes the decision to make the changes in our life a little easier. I mean, I know I’ll miss what I did, but it was dangerous. I dealt with a lot of heavy shit, and the fact that a few of those bad guys are still at large, even if they are out of the country, doesn’t sit right with me, but I have to face the facts that the agency isn’t going to spend money and time searching for those men when there are other, stronger threats. I guess it’s time to move on, retire, and maybe settle down.” Jeremy looked at each of his brothers before taking a slug of beer.

  “I feel the same way,” Cody said. “Yet, I don’t want to give up this fight against terrorists and their threats. As I mentioned earlier, one of the main headquarters affiliated with my current office is a commute away from Treasure Town by thirty-five, forty minutes. I could look into openings there.”

  “This is great. It can work out, but we want the two of you to be one-hundred-percent certain. Even if it’s a strain on this relationship, we can give the long-distance thing a shot. Cooper and I will be here, and you can drive out on weekends until you decide,” Don told them.

  “That’s not fair. Not to you guys, to us, and especially not to Catalina. She’s our woman now, and she must come first in everything we do. That’s how our dads did it with Mom,” Cooper told them.

  “He’s right, but we pretty much are agreeing and facing the fact that Catalina is the one for us, that she’s special and we’re willing to change our lives for her,” Jeremy stated.

  “For us. We deserve this. You guys deserve to be happy and for all of us to be together like we talked about. It’s right,” Cooper said to them.

  “Now if only I can get rid of this sick feeling in the pit of my stomach, not having her here,” Don said to them.