Prank Night

by Symone Craven

  “Speaking of excitement,” Kenny says. “Why don’t we play a game?”

  “What kind of game?” Heidi asks.

  “Truth or dare.”

  Alice breaks away from Mitch. “I’ll play,” she says. “I love that game!”

  Heidi and Kenny finish off their bottles of rum easily, while Mitch and Alice still work on their whiskey. They’ve so far covered the amateur basics of Truth or Dare, the highlight of which is when Heidi dares Alice to show off her pair of perfect breasts, at least according to Mitch. “Best titties in the world,” he says, letting the whiskey dull his censor. “Little nipples. Not too big. Just perfect.” He reaches over and begins to bite on her nipple.

  Alice laughs nervously, pushing him off. Out of the corner of her eyes, she can see Kenny’s ogling gaze boring through her. She pushes down her black-and-gray bustier, snatching the near-empty bottle of whiskey from Mitch’s grip. “Okay it’s Kenny’s turn,” she says.

  Mischievously, Kenny rubs his hands together. “Wonderful,” he says. Then, he faces Heidi. “Truth or dare?”

  Heidi hesitates, knowing that she’s chosen truth one too many times already. The rest of them will think she’s a loser if she keeps playing it safe. Finally, Heidi sighs. “Dare… I choose dare.”

  Kenny glances over at Mitch, who exchanges the same sneaky look. Heidi’s stomach begins to cramp, unable to fathom what embarrassing request Kenny may has up his sleeve. “Heidi,” he says. “I dare you to… eat dirt.”

  A look of repulsion washes over Heidi’s face. “Are you insane?” She says. “I’m totally not doing that.”

  “If you’ve been dared to do something, then you gotta do it,” Mitch replies. “Those are the rules.”

  “So there are rules to Truth or Dare now?” Alice asks. “No one showed me the instruction manual.”

  Mitch grins. “When you play Truth or Dare with the Reagan brothers, there are always rules. Rule número uno? If you’ve been dared to do something, then you gotta go through with it. No other way out.”

  Alice exchanges a concerned look to Heidi. Heidi, in turns, glances at Mitch and Kenny, hoping that one of them might snicker and tell her they’re playing around. But neither brother budges. Admittedly, the boys can’t help but get a small thrill from watching Heidi’s bottom lip tremble, listening to the faint whimper escaping from her frowned mouth. “You guys,” she says, her eyes desperate. “I’ll do anything else, I swear.”

  Kenny and Mitch exchange an all too familiar glance. Anyone who has been a victim of their pranks and plans know that look. “Okay,” Kenny finally replies. “You don’t have to eat dirt. But you can help us with something.”

  “Yeah,” Mitch chimes in. “Something very important.”

  Heidi shrugs. “Fine, what is it?”

  “Tonight, when those dumb-asses come to grab your panties, you need to find a way to distract them. Make sure they never finish the prank.”

  “How?” Heidi asks.

  “I don’t know,” Kenny says. “Use your feminine wiles or whatever.”

  Alice doubtfully shakes her head. “There’s no way Heidi’s handling those knuckleheads on her own,” she says. “If those boys are your problem, then you two should deal with it.”

  Kenny’s grin widens. “Did we mention that Lonnie James-Osmet will be escorting dumb and dumber on their panty raid?”

  In a blink of an eye, Heidi’s demeanor changes. Her face flushes red, and her green eyes sparkle at the sound of his name. “Lonnie?” She asks. “What’s he doing with those geeks?”

  “I see him around them all of the time,” Alice replies. “I think he does it out of pity.”

  “What a guy,” Heidi says. “If Lonnie’ll be there tonight, then hell yes! I’ll distract him plenty!”

  And, just like that, the plan for sabotage is set in motion.

  ****

  Heidi gives herself another look over in the mirror. She tries on a million different pairs of underwear before she finds something that she doesn’t hate as much as the others. It’s a hot pink two piece bikini set, with mesh cups that reveal some hint of her small perky breasts. The mesh on her panties shows off her plump pussy lips, freshly shaven and covered in a light layer of sweat. As she takes deep breaths. Heidi pats her armpits with a towel. She checks her phone. It’s 11pm already! Quickly, she grabs a piece of paper and scribbles in black marker, “Come inside for panties.” Heidi scurries to the front door and tapes it above the doorknob.

  She sits on her bed, hands clasped together as she waits patiently for Lonnie. Excited, Heidi fights the urge to fidget or play with her hair. She tries to rehearse her reaction to him walking through her door, but she is having a hard time. She tries to remember how to smile with her eyes, just as Alice had taught her. But, she’s forgotten how.

  Suddenly, she hears footsteps approaching. Then, the doorknob turns. Heidi holds her breath. Her body shivers.

  Then, Bobby walks through the door, his pudgy body stuffed into a stealthy black suit and ski mask. “I’m here for the panties,” he says cheerfully. When he catches a sight of Heidi in her bra and panties, he freezes. “Did I… are you…?” Is she giving him more than just underwear? Bobby immediately grows hard at the thought.

  Heidi jumps underneath her blankets and covers herself up. “Where’s Lonnie?” She asks. “Did he chicken out again?”

  At first, Bobby is disappointed. He knows he’s no Lonnie James-Osmet. “He didn’t chicken out,” he replies. “He’s downstairs grabbing some underwear. I can tell him to come up - “ Then, suddenly, Bobby is struck with an idea. “But, just so you know… he’s a kinky fellow when it comes to the ladies.”

  Heidi gives him a doubtful look. “Is he?” She asks.

  “Most definitely,” he answers. “Y’see. That’s why he doesn’t go for girls here at Burrows. He doesn’t want everyone to know.”

  “Whatever,” she says as she crosses her arms. “You’re probably just talking a bunch of baloney anyway.”

  Bobby playfully shrugs, then he spots a pair of her panties on the floor near the hamper. “Maybe I am talking baloney,” he says. “Maybe I’m not.” He snatches her glittery purple briefs from the floor. “I’ll be taking these, if you don’t mind.” Bobby snickers. “I’ll let him know these are from you.” He twirls her undies around his finger as he strolls towards the door.

  “Wait!” Bobby freezes, he spins around to see Heidi with an expression of curiosity. “What’s he into?” She finally asks.

  Bingo, Bobby thinks to himself. “All the good stuff,” he says eagerly. “Nothing bad. Kinda like 50 Shades, you know what I mean?”

  Heidi rolls her eyes. “My mom reads that,” she replies with a sneer. “Is it… is it more like Rihanna?”

  “Ri-what-uh?”

  “You know,” she replies, smiling eagerly. “Like her BDSM song. Is he into really hardcore stuff?”

  “Sure,” he replies, ignoring Heidi’s question. “He’s into blindfolds and… bondage.” He studies Heidi as his answers sink in.

  “Blindfolds and bondage…” she says. “Okay… I don’t mind that, I guess.”

  “Good!” Bobby says, pumping his fist back. “Finally!”

  Heidi shoots him a dirty look. “You do realize you’ll be gone by the time he gets here, right?”

  Bobby coughs, pulling back his excitement. “Of course. I’m a gentleman, obviously. In fact, I’ll leave right now. But when I do, you should pretend like you’re sleeping. He’s into that.”

  Excited, Heidi gasps. “I have a sleeping mask,” she says. “I can put that on so when he gets here I’m all ready for him.”

  Bobby represses his excitement. “Whatever works,” he says, although he secretly prays that she has the mask on by the time he gets back.

  They sit together for an awkward moment. Heidi blankly stares at Bobby while he looks eagerly at her. Finally, Heidi gives him a wry smile. “You can go now,” she says.

  Bobby apologizes and happily
dashes out of her bedroom, making sure to shut the door behind him when he leaves. Once he’s gone, Heidi reaches for the satin mask on her bedside table. She slides it over her head, making sure to fix and fluff up her black frizzy curls. Then she relaxes into her bed and pretends to sleep. She can’t hold back the smile that’s glued to her face. The anticipation of waiting for him makes it hard for her to be anything but aroused. She tries her best, but when she hears the door open, she can’t help but squeal. Heidi sits up in her bed. “Lonnie?” She asks.

  It seems like hours have passed before she finally gets a response. “Aren’t you supposed to be asleep?” He asks.

  Heidi giggles. It’s not Bobby’s bellowing voice, thank God. Lonnie sounds much softer, but assertive. “I know, I was told to. But, I’m just so excited to finally be with you. I’ve fantasized about this for a while.” She blushes. “I’m sorry. I’m talking too much. I tend to talk too much when I — “

  “Enough,” she hears him say. Heidi mutters sorry before keeping her mouth shut. She can hear his footsteps approaching, sounding more crisp and less dull like Bobby’s heavy feet. “Hold on,” she says. She can hear Lonnie sigh. “Sorry, I just… do you want me to be on my knees? And… should I call you Master or Dom?”

  “Stay right where you are. Don’t say anything. Don’t call me anything.” He waits but hears naught. “Good,” he says.

  Suddenly, Heidi feels her blankets being ripped away from her body. Then, his hands glide up her skinny, but subtle curves. They slow down to admire every inch of her behind before flying up to her hands. He takes a scarf hanging around her bedpost and wraps it tight around her wrists. After making an impenetrable knot, he ties the rest of the loose ends around the slits in her headboard.

  “Now you can’t move a muscle,” he says. He reaches around her neck and unties her bikini. The strings fly through the darkness. He pulls her bra down to gaze at her small breasts, a pair of firm mounds of flesh rising and falling as she breathes. “Nervous?” he asks.

  She laughs nervously. “I’ve never done this before,” Heidi replies.

  “Just relax,” he says.

  Heidi obeys, until she feels her bed suddenly become lighter. The box springs moan as he stands up. Then, she hears his footsteps. “Lonnie?” She tries to sit up, forgetting that she’s tied to her bed. And blindfolded. “Lonnie, where are you?” She asks.

  Only… it’s not Lonnie.

  Nick opens the door slowly so she’s unable to hear him. Before he can even open the door, Bobby tries to push his way through.

  “Dammit,” Nick whispers. “Will you slow your fat ass down?”

  Inside they can hear Heidi frantically calling Lonnie’s name. Quickly the two shuffle back into the room. Bobby stays by the door while Nick approaches her. He hurries to take off his pants. When he does he tosses them to the side and sits down beside Heidi on the bed. “Just getting ready for you, sweetheart,” he says. Nick leans forward and playfully flicks his tongue against her lips. She squeals and does the same, sticking her tongue out to taste his. Nick opens his mouth wide enough to let her slip through, and together they lock in a kiss that makes her toes curl. Nick stealthily climbs over Heidi’s squirming body and lays beside her, his hands crawling underneath her lacy bottoms. His fingers slide against her pussy lips, her flesh becoming more and more wet as he dives down towards her bubbly clit.

  Bobby tiptoes toward the pair. He remains within the shadows, creeping around the room until he finds a spot where he has a perfect view of Heidi and Nick. He nervously unzips his fly and pulls out his chubby cock. He watches Nick’s hands move fast through her pussy, and the sound of his fingers swimming through her wet skin makes Bobby feel like he’s high. He rubs himself slowly at first, admiring Heidi’s tiny physique, aching for a taste of her while she’s still trussed up and oblivious. He’s seen her before in her cheerleading outfit, performing splits and tumbles as if her bones are made of rubber. Before he has a chance to realize it, Bobby edges closer and closer to the bed. Nick has already crawled over Heidi’s face, lowering his long cock into her mouth and whispering for her to suck. She obeys, and stuffed with his flesh, her lips have no choice but to cling to his smooth shaft and swallow him as far as she could. Meanwhile, his fingers are still deep inside of her cunt. He can feel her pussy muscles as they squeeze around him, trembling as she comes, her orgasmic cries muffled by his cock.

  By now, Bobby’s been able to get so close that he can reach out and touch her. He doesn’t waste another minute. As not to raise any suspicion, he fondles her breast in a way that makes Heidi believe Nick is touching her. She moans, thrusting her chest into the air to spur his touch. Bobby tries not to get too excited. He squeezes, making sure to pinch his nipples with her fingers. Nick’s eyes are squeezed shut, trying hard to reign in his desire. He impulsively pulls out of her gaping mouth. She gasps for air. Then, out of nowhere, Nick feels Heidi’s tongue paint his puckering asshole. Biting his bottom lip, he relaxes into her mouth, even grinding a bit as she stimulates his anus. No girl has ever done that to him before. And, surprisingly, he can’t get enough. “That’s it baby,” he says to Heidi. “Keep it up.”

  She responds with a breathless sigh. “I want to feel your cock inside me, Lonnie.”

  Both Nick and Bobby’s ears perk up. They glance at one another, carefully avoiding direct contact. Then, they’re off! Bobby dashes for the end of the bed, while Nick crawls towards Heidi’s cunt. Surprisingly, Bobby’s nimble enough to climb over the footboard, spread Heidi’s legs, and inch his fat cock towards her pussy. The entire time, she giggles, imagining how eager he must be, and how excited he is to be with her. “I need you now, Lonnie,” she cries.

  “Oh you’ll get it,” Nick mutters. Defeated and erect, he crawls quietly closer to Heidi. He admires her upper body. When she inhales, the details in her ab muscles are refined. Her breasts barely move as her body is jerked back and forth.

  “Yes, Lonnie,” she shouts. “God, you’re so big!”

  Bobby doesn’t make a sound. His grin is wide and his stride is hard and slow. He can’t help it; he loves watching his cock slide in and out of her pussy, the juices and flesh clinging to his swollen shaft. He braces her hips and pumps through her until he quickens his speed. Bobby quietly grunts, trying hard not to cry out as he climaxes. Suddenly, he pulls his cock out and sprays pearls of come all over her toned stomach. As he softens, Bobby pulls himself out and slinks off of the bed.

  “Lonnie,” she whispers. “Are you still there?”

  “Hell yeah, baby,” Nick says eagerly. He grabs her panties and cleans Bobby’s come off of her stomach. “I just caught my second wind!” He zips down towards her and climbs in between his legs. When he slides into her warm pussy, Heidi’s struck by how noticeably different his penis feels inside of her. He doesn’t feel as thick as he used to. Instead he’s longer, and when he fucks her, his thrusts are faster. He lowers himself closer to her. Nick sucks on her breast while his finger reaches down to rub her clit. As soon as he touches her, Heidi’s body thrashes from side to side. She’s able to loosen herself from the ties. Nick doesn’t notice right away. It’s not until he feels her fingers running through her hair that he nearly shits himself.

  Heidi gasps. “Lonnie,” she says. “You cut off all of your hair!” Nick pins her arms down to either side of her body as continues to fuck her. She giggles. “Let me touch you, Lonnie! I promise I won’t take off my blindfold.”

  Nick is reluctant at first. But he eventually lets go of her. “Fine,” he says. “But, if you want to come, then be a good girl.” He presses his finger against her clit, rasping its meaty bulb.

  She screams. “Yes sir!” Heidi replies, so excited that she begins to grunt and howl like an animal.

  Nick wants to laugh, but instead his rubs his sensitive clit harder. “That’s it,” he tells her. “Be as loud as you want to. Let everyone know!”

  “I want you to come inside me this time,” she begs him. But Heidi can
barely finish her sentence. As she screams, Nick can feel her pussy throb, then tighten again around his cock before relaxing altogether. He feels her wetness pouring through her. Ripples flow through Heidi’s body. As he watches the euphoric glow wash across her face, Nick moans. He drives himself deeper into her pussy. Then, he unloads, gushing come through her wet hole. He breathes heavily in her ear for a moment, kisses her, then collapses next to her on the bed.

  “Dammit, Lonnie,” she says as she takes off the blindfold. “You really are something… “ Heidi glances over at him. Then, she does a double take and screams.

  Nick bolts out of her bed, nearly falling over her as he hits the floor. “So sorry,” he says. “I thought you were someone else.”

  Bewildered Heidi glares at him as he hops around the room, trying to put his pants back on. “I thought you were someone else,” she shouts.

  “Those mistakes can happen,” Nick says, hoping that she might just laugh it off as a case of mistaken identity. She doesn’t.

  “Get out of my room!” Anything within reach is thrown at Nick’s head. A coffee mug. A paperweight shaped like a starfish. Heidi’s cell phone.

  He cowers to the other side of the room. “If you stop throwing things at me, then I could leave!” She ignores him. She reaches for shoes, her purse, then her behemoth history textbook.

  Suddenly, Nick hears a commotion outside. He glances out the window to the far right of the room. “It can’t be,” he says to himself. He pulls back the curtain and continues to watch the scene unfold outside. He begins to chuckle, and his chuckle soon turns into a hysterical laugh.

  Annoyed, Heidi jumps out of bed. “Didn’t you hear me the first time?” She asks as she storms over her to him. “I told you to get out!” She doesn’t know what she’s going to do with him. Nick’s cute enough for a nerdy-looking fellow, but he’s a nerd nonetheless. Everyone in Burrows wouldn’t let her live it down if they knew she’s had sex with a social pariah. But then, as Heidi glances out the other window to see what has his attention, her mind goes completely blank. Heidi nearly rips the curtain off its rod when she realizes what’s going on outside.