The Philo Vance Megapack

by S. S. Van Dine

  But the evening was not quite over as far as the Odell case was concerned. We had been back in the lounge room of the club but a short time when a man walked by the corner in which we sat, and bowed with formal courtesy to Markham. Markham, to my surprise, rose and greeted him, at the same time indicating a chair.

  “There’s something further I wanted to ask you, Mr. Spotswoode,” he said, “if you can spare a moment.”

  At the mention of the name I regarded the man closely, for, I confess, I was not a little curious about the anonymous escort who had taken the girl to dinner and the theater the night before. Spotswoode was a typical New England aristocrat, inflexible, slow in his movements, reserved, and quietly but modishly dressed. His hair and moustache were slightly gray—which, no doubt, enhanced the pinkness of his complexion. He was just under six feet tall and well proportioned, but a trifle angular.

  Markham introduced him to Vance and me, and briefly explained that we were working with him on the case and that he had thought it best to take us fully into his confidence.

  Spotswoode gave him a dubious look but immediately bowed his acceptance of the decision.

  “I’m in your hands, Mr. Markham,” he replied, in a well-bred but somewhat high-pitched voice, “and I concur, of course, with whatever you think advisable.” He turned to Vance with an apologetic smile. “I’m in a rather unpleasant position and naturally feel a little sensitive about it.”

  “I’m something of an antinomian,” Vance pleasantly informed him. “At any rate, I’m not a moralist; so my attitude in the matter is quite academic.”

  Spotswoode laughed softly. “I wish my family held a similar point of view; but I’m afraid they would not be so tolerant of my foibles.”

  “It’s only fair to tell you, Mr. Spotswoode,” interposed Markham, “that there is a bare possibility I may have to call you as a witness.”

  The man looked up quickly, his face clouding over, but he made no comment.

  “The fact is,” continued Markham, “we are about to make an arrest, and your testimony may be needed to establish the time of Miss Odell’s return to her apartment, and also to substantiate the fact that there was presumably someone in her room after you had left. Her screams and calls for help, which you heard, may prove vital evidence in obtaining a conviction.”

  Spotswoode seemed rather appalled at the thought of his relations with the girl becoming public, and for several minutes he sat with averted eyes.

  “I see your point,” he acknowledged at length. “But it would be a terrible thing for me if the fact of my delinquencies became known.”

  “That contingency may be entirely avoided,” Markham encouraged him. “I promise you that you will not be called upon unless it is absolutely necessary.… And now, what I especially wanted to ask you is this: do you happen to know a Doctor Lindquist, who, I understand, was Miss Odell’s personal physician?”

  Spotswoode was frankly puzzled. “I never heard the name,” he answered. “In fact, Miss Odell never mentioned any doctor to me.”

  “And did you ever hear her mention the name of Skeel…or refer to any one as Tony?”

  “Never.” His answer was emphatic.

  Markham lapsed into a disappointed silence. Spotswoode, too, was silent; he sat as if in a revery.

  “You know, Mr. Markham,” he said, after several minutes, “I ought to be ashamed to admit it, but the truth is I cared a good deal for the girl. I suppose you’ve kept her apartment intact.…” He hesitated, and a look almost of appeal came into his eyes. “I’d like to see it again if I could.”

  Markham regarded him sympathetically but finally shook his head.

  “It wouldn’t do. You’d be sure to be recognized by the operator—or there might be a reporter about—and then I’d be unable to keep you out of the case.”

  The man appeared disappointed but did not protest; and for several minutes no one spoke. Then Vance raised himself slightly in his chair.

  “I say, Mr. Spotswoode, do you happen to remember anything unusual occurring last night during the half hour you remained with Miss Odell after the theater?”

  “Unusual?” the man’s manner was eloquent of his astonishment. “To the contrary. We chatted awhile, and then, as she seemed tired, I said good night and came away, making a luncheon appointment with her for today.”

  “And yet, it now seems fairly certain that some other man was hiding in the apartment when you were there.”

  “There’s little doubt on that point,” agreed Spotswoode, with the suggestion of a shudder. “And her screams would seem to indicate that he came forth from hiding a few minutes after I went.”

  “And you had no suspicion of the fact when you heard her call for help?”

  “I did at first—naturally. But when she assured me that nothing was the matter, and told me to go home, I attributed her screams to a nightmare. I knew she had been tired, and I had left her in the wicker chair near the door, from where her screams seemed to come; so I naturally concluded she had dozed off and called out in her sleep.… If only I hadn’t taken so much for granted!”

  “It’s a harrowin’ situation.” Vance was silent for a while; then he asked: “Did you, by any chance, notice the door of the living room closet? Was it open or closed?”

  Spotswoode frowned, as if attempting to visualize the picture; but the result was a failure.

  “I suppose it was closed. I probably would have noticed it if it had been open.”

  “Then, you couldn’t say if the key was in the lock or not?”

  “Good Lord, no! I don’t even know if it ever had a key.”

  The case was discussed for another half hour; then Spotswoode excused himself and left us.

  “Funny thing,” ruminated Markham, “how a man of his upbringing could be so attracted by the empty-headed, butterfly type.”

  “I’d say it was quite natural,” returned Vance.… “You’re such an incorrigible moralist, Markham.”

  CHAPTER 12

  CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE

  (Wednesday, September 12; 9 A.M.)

  The following day, which was Wednesday, not only brought forth an important and, as it appeared, conclusive development in the Odell case but marked the beginning of Vance’s active cooperation in the proceedings. The psychological elements in the case had appealed to him irresistibly, and he felt, even at this stage of the investigation, that a final answer could never be obtained along the usual police lines. At his request Markham had called for him at a little before nine o’clock, and we had driven direct to the district attorney’s office.

  Heath was waiting impatiently when we arrived. His eager and covertly triumphant expression plainly indicated good news.

  “Things are breaking fine and dandy,” he announced, when we had sat down. He himself was too elated to relax, and stood between Markham’s desk rolling a large black cigar between his fingers. “We got the Dude—six o’clock yesterday evening—and we got him right. One of the C. O. boys, named Riley, who was patroling Sixth Avenue in the Thirties, saw him swing off a surface car and head for McAnerny’s Pawn Shop. Right away Riley wigwags the traffic officer on the corner and follows the Dude into McAnerny’s. Pretty soon the traffic officer comes in with a patrolman, who he’s picked up; and the three of ’em nab our stylish friend in the act of pawning this ring.”

  He tossed a square solitaire diamond in a filigreed platinum setting on the district attorney’s desk.

  “I was at the office when they brought him in, and I sent Snitkin with the ring up to Harlem to see what the maid had to say about it, and she identified it as belonging to Odell.”

  “But, I say, it wasn’t a part of the bijouterie the lady was wearing that night, was it, Sergeant?” Vance put the question casually.

  Heath jerked about and eyed him with sullen calculation.

  “What if it wasn’t? It came out of that jimmied jewel case—or I’m Ben Hur.”

  “Of course it did,” murmured Vance, lapsing into
lethargy.

  “And that’s where we’re in luck,” declared Heath, turning back to Markham. “It connects Skeel directly with the murder and the robbery.”

  “What has Skeel to say about it?” Markham was leaning forward intently. “I suppose you questioned him.”

  “I’ll say we did,” replied the sergeant; but his tone was troubled. “We had him up all night giving him the works. And the story he tells is this: he says the girl gave him the ring a week ago, and that he didn’t see her again until the afternoon of the day before yesterday. He came to her apartment between four and five—you remember the maid said she was out then—and entered and left the house by the side door, which was unlocked at that time. He admits he called again at half past nine that night, but he says that when he found she was out, he went straight home and stayed there. His alibi is that he sat up with his landlady till after midnight playing Khun Khan and drinking beer. I hopped up to his place this morning, and the old girl verified it. But that don’t mean anything. The house he lives in is a pretty tough hangout, and this landlady, besides being a heavy boozer, has been up the river a coupla times for shoplifting.”

  “What does Skeel say about the fingerprints?”

  “He says, of course, he made ’em when he was there in the afternoon.”

  “And the one on the closet doorknob?”

  Heath gave a derisive grunt.

  “He’s got an answer for that, too—says he thought he heard someone coming in, and locked himself in the clothes closet. Didn’t want to be seen and spoil any game Odell mighta been playing.”

  “Most considerate of him to keep out of the way of the belles poires,” drawled Vance. “Touchin’ loyalty, what?”

  “You don’t believe the rat, do you, Mr. Vance?” asked Heath, with indignant surprise.

  “Can’t say that I do. But our Antonio at least spins a consistent yarn.”

  “Too damn consistent to suit me,” growled the sergeant.

  “That’s all you could get out of him?” It was plain that Markham was not pleased with the results of Heath’s third degree of Skeel.

  “That’s about all, sir. He stuck to his story like a leech.”

  “You found no chisel in his room?”

  Heath admitted that he hadn’t. “But you couldn’t expect him to keep it around,” he added.

  Markham pondered the facts for several minutes. “I can’t see that we’ve got a very good case, however much we may be convinced of Skeel’s guilt. His alibi may be thin, but taken in connection with the phone operator’s testimony, I’m inclined to think it would hold tight in court.”

  “What about the ring, sir?” Heath was desperately disappointed. “And what about his threats, and his fingerprints, and his record of similar burglaries?”

  “Contributory factors only,” Markham explained. “What we need for a murder is more than a prima facie case. A good criminal lawyer could have him discharged in twenty minutes, even if I could secure an indictment. It’s not impossible, you know, that the woman gave him the ring a week ago—you recall that the maid said he was demanding money from her about that time. And there’s nothing to show that the fingerprints were not actually made late Monday afternoon. Moreover, we can’t connect him in any way with the chisel, for we don’t know who did the Park Avenue job last summer. His whole story fits the facts perfectly; and we haven’t anything contradictory to offer.”

  Heath shrugged helplessly; all the wind had been taken out of his sails.

  “What do you want done with him?” he asked desolately.

  Markham considered—he, too, was discomfited.

  “Before I answer, I think I’ll have a go at him myself.”

  He pressed a buzzer and ordered a clerk to fill out the necessary requisition. When it had been signed in duplicate, he sent Swacker with it to Ben Hanlon.

  “Do ask him about those silk shirts,” suggested Vance. “And find out, if you can, if he considers a white waistcoat de rigueur with a dinner jacket.”

  “This office isn’t a male millinery shop,” snapped Markham.

  “But, Markham dear, you won’t learn anything else from this Petronius.”

  Ten minutes later a deputy sheriff from the Tombs entered with his handcuffed prisoner.

  Skeel’s appearance that morning belied his sobriquet of “Dude.” He was haggard and pale; his ordeal of the previous night had left its imprint upon him. He was unshaven; his hair was uncombed; the ends of his moustache drooped; and his cravat was awry. But despite his bedraggled condition, his manner was jaunty and contemptuous. He gave Heath a defiant leer and faced the district attorney with swaggering indifference.

  To Markham’s questions he doggedly repeated the same story he had told Heath. He clung tenaciously to every detail of it with the ready accuracy of a man who had painstakingly memorized a lesson and was thoroughly familiar with it. Markham coaxed, threatened, bullied. All hint of his usual affability was gone; he was like an inexorable dynamic machine. But Skeel, whose nerves seemed to be made of iron, withstood the vicious fire of his cross-questioning without wincing; and, I confess, his resistance somewhat aroused my admiration despite my revulsion toward him and all he stood for.

  After half an hour Markham gave up, completely baffled in his efforts to elicit any damaging admissions from the man. He was about to dismiss him when Vance rose languidly and strolled to the district attorney’s desk. Seating himself on the edge of it, he regarded Skeel with impersonal curiosity.

  “So you’re a devotee of Khun Khan, eh?” he remarked indifferently. “Silly game, what? More interestin’ than Conquain or Rum, though. Used to be played in the London clubs. Of East Indian origin, I believe.… You still play it with two decks, I suppose, and permit round-the-corner mating?”

  An involuntary frown gathered on Skeel’s forehead. He was used to violent district attorneys and familiar with the bludgeoning methods of the police, but here was a type of inquisitor entirely new to him; and it was plain that he was both puzzled and apprehensive. He decided to meet this novel antagonist with a smirk of arrogant amusement.

  “By the bye,” continued Vance, with no change in tone, “can anyone hidden in the clothes press of the Odell living room see the davenport through the keyhole?”

  Suddenly all trace of a smile was erased from the man’s features.

  “And I say,” Vance hurried on, his eyes fixed steadily on the other, “why didn’t you give the alarm?”

  I was watching Skeel closely, and though his set expression did not alter, I saw the pupils of his eyes dilate. Markham, also, I think, noted this phenomenon.

  “Don’t bother to answer,” pursued Vance, as the man opened his lips to speak. “But tell me: didn’t the sight shake you up a bit?”

  “I don’t know what you’re talking about,” Skeel retorted with sullen impertinence. But, for all his sangfroid, one sensed an uneasiness in his manner. There was an overtone of effort in his desire to appear indifferent, which robbed his words of complete conviction.

  “Not a pleasant situation, that.” Vance ignored his retort. “How did you feel, crouching there in the dark, when the closet doorknob was turned and someone tried to get in?” His eyes were boring into the man, though his voice retained its casual intonation.

  The muscles of Skeel’s face tightened, but he did not speak.

  “Lucky thing you took the precaution of locking yourself in—eh, what?” Vance went on. “Suppose he’d got the door open—my word! Then what?…”

  He paused and smiled with a kind of silky sweetness which was more impressive than any glowering aggression.

  “I say, did you have your steel chisel ready for him? Maybe he’d have been too quick and strong for you—maybe there would have been thumbs pressing against your larnyx, too, before you could have struck him—eh?… Did you think of that, there in the dark?… No, not precisely a pleasant situation. A bit gruesome, in fact.”

  “What are you raving about?” Skeel spat out insolentl
y. “You’re balmy.” But his swagger had been forgotten, and a look akin to horror had passed across his face. This slackening of pose was momentary, however; almost at once his smirk returned, and his head swayed in contempt.

  Vance sauntered back to his chair and stretched himself in it listlessly, as if all his interest in the case had again evaporated.

  Markham had watched the little drama attentively, but Heath had sat smoking with ill-concealed annoyance. The silence that followed was broken by Skeel.

  “Well, I suppose I’m to be railroaded. Got it all planned, have you?… Try and railroad me!” He laughed harshly. “My lawyer’s Abe Rubin, and you might phone him that I’d like to see him.”34

  Markham, with a gesture of annoyance, waved to the deputy sheriff to take Skeel back to the Tombs.

  “What were you trying to get at?” he asked Vance when the man was gone.

  “Just an elusive notion in the depths of my being struggling for the light.” Vance smoked placidly a moment. “I thought Mr. Skeel might be persuaded to pour out his heart to us. So I wooed him with words.”

  “That’s just bully,” gibed Heath. “I was expecting you any minute to ask him if he played mumbly-peg or if his grandmother was a hootowl.”

  “Sergeant, dear Sergeant,” pleaded Vance, “don’t be unkind. I simply couldn’t endure it.… And really, now, didn’t my chat with Mr. Skeel suggest a possibility to you?”

  “Sure,” said Heath, “that he was hiding in the closet when Odell was killed. But where does that get us? It lets Skeel out, although the job was a professional one, and he was caught red-handed with some of the swag.”

  He turned disgustedly to the district attorney.

  “And now what, sir?”

  “I don’t like the look of things,” Markham complained. “If Skeel has Abe Rubin to defend him, we won’t stand a chance with the case we’ve got. I feel convinced he was mixed up in it; but no judge will accept my personal feelings as evidence.”

  “We could turn the Dude loose and have him tailed,” suggested Heath grudgingly. “We might catch him doing something that’ll give the game away.”