Hardy 04 - 13th Juror, The

by John Lescroart

  "My husband beat me up."

  The courtroom was rapt, silent.

  "Your husband, Phil DiStephano, the natural father of the defendant?"

  "Yes."

  "And was this the first time he'd beaten you?"

  Talking about it, Nancy was starting to withdraw, to hunch her shoulders, the way her daughter did. Or was it more the other way around? She shook her head and Villars leaned over, speaking quietly. "You'll have to answer with words, please."

  "No," Nancy said, "it wasn't the first time."

  To give her a moment, Hardy stepped toward the jury box, turned to look at his client — Jennifer was frowning, not liking this. Hardy came back to Nancy. "Did your husband beat you often?"

  The witness shook her head, then, remembering, said, "yes."

  "How long has it been since your daughter, the defendant, moved out of the house?"

  "About ten years."

  "And before she moved out, did you suffer these beatings at the hands of her father?"

  "Yes… it's always been there. Phil would drink too much and get mad about something and hit me."

  "And did this ever happen in Jennifer's sight?"

  "Yes."

  "Did he ever hit your daughter?"

  She shook her head. "No. He threatened a couple of times but I wouldn't let him. I got between them. He loved her." Tears had begun to show on her cheeks. "He just lost control."

  "He just lost control," Hardy repeated. Taking a few steps again toward the jury, he continued: "In your opinion, Nancy, did this pattern of your husband beating you have any obvious effect on Jennifer's behavior?"

  Nancy was toughing it out, letting the tears come. But, as Jennifer did, she spoke clearly through them. "We didn't talk about it afterward."

  This wasn't the answer to the question, but it moved toward it. "You didn't talk about what?"

  "They just happened and then they went away and everything went back to being the same."

  "You denied that this was happening? The family denied it?"

  "Yes. We just pretended."

  "And Jennifer?"

  "She got more and more quiet. And then she moved out."

  "You'd say she became withdrawn, moody, mistrustful?" This was leading her all over the meadow, but he was allowed to do it in this phase and it would, he hoped, go a long way to explain to the jury Jennifer's apparent callousness in the face of the authority of the court.

  "Yes." Nancy looked over at her daughter. "She was such a sweet little girl. She was my baby girl…"

  Although she was maintaining her composure, Nancy's emotion lay over her like a blanket — her face was blotching with tears. Villars leaned over again. "Mrs. DiStephano? Would you like to take break?"

  * * * * *

  They were moving on.

  "Nancy, did your daughter ever talk about how she felt about Matt?"

  "Matt was her life."

  "Matt was her life." He took in the jury, then went back to the witness. "She loved her son?"

  "Completely. Oh, God, yes."

  "Did you ever see any sign at all that she ever mistreated him, abused him, anything like that?"

  "No, nothing. If anything, I thought she was a little overprotective. Maybe she spoiled him more than I would have. But I understand where that came from."

  "And where was that?"

  "Well, what she'd seen. Her father and me. Larry was the same way, overprotective. They just didn't want anything bad to happen to Matt."

  This was good. It put Larry and Jennifer on the same side. Back at the defense table, Jennifer was staring straight ahead, crying without a sound.

  "Nancy," Hardy said abruptly, "could your daughter have killed Matt, her son, even by mistake?" He held his breath, waiting.

  She shook her head. "No. If she did, even by accident like you say, she would have killed herself."

  Powell got up slowly. He knew this was emotional testimony and he didn't want to appear callous himself, but he felt he had to object to the speculation. Villars sustained him.

  But Hardy at least had what he wanted. He went on to his last prepared questions, and to the answer he expected but that he believed was genuine. "What are your feelings for your daughter now?"

  "I love her," she said. "She's all I have left."

  * * * * *

  Powell knew he had his work cut out for him, especially since Villars had denied a recess before his cross. Here was an emotionally charged, physically abused woman, and his job was to discredit her, take her apart. If he was going to be effective, it had to be a slow dance.

  He smiled, breaking the ice. He had no doubt that she remembered him from the previous night in the homicide detail, but he had no choice — he couldn't come out swinging. He was going to be her friend, just clarifying a few little things. Her shoulders were forward, hunched, defensive, but she gave him a tentative smile. It was a start.

  Mrs. DiStephano, you and your late husband also have a son, don't you?"

  This, from out of left field, put her off balance. "Yes. Tom."

  "And was Tom ever the victim of your husband's abuse?"

  "Phil hit Tom a few times when he was younger, but it was more like just spankings. He never hurt him."

  "And how are the two men now? Are they close?"

  Hardy stood up. "Your Honor, if it please the court, Mr. Powell knows full well that Mr. DiStephano is deceased."

  It was casual, and Hardy's phrasing of the objection side-stepped the overt admission tha Nancy had killed him, if anyone didn't already know. Powell gestured apologetically. "Did Tom ever witness your husband beating you?"

  "Yes."

  "Just like Jennifer did?"

  "Yes. I mean until later."

  "What happened later?"

  "Well, later, when Tom got older, he'd, like, he tried to protect me. So Phil would make sure Tom wasn't around."

  "But that wasn't the case with Jennifer?"

  "I'm sorry. What wasn't?"

  "Your late husband, Phil, would hit you even if Jennifer was around?"

  "Sometimes."

  "And she didn't try to stop it?"

  "She couldn't stop my husband. I couldn't…" She stopped, realizing that finally she had done just that. "He was too strong. Jennifer just hid, I think."

  "So Jennifer hid and watched her father beat you up without trying to help you in any way. But your son Tom tried to step in. How do you feel about your son now?"

  "Tom? He's a good boy."

  "You love him?"

  "Of course. He's my son."

  "And of course mothers love their sons."

  "Yes."

  Powell let that sink in. "And yet you testified that Jennifer was all you had left?"

  Nancy glanced in panic around the room, then looked at Hardy. He nodded. It was okay. She was doing fine.

  "That was just a figure of speech," she said. "She's the only daughter I have left."

  "And are you very close to her?"

  "Yes. Very close."

  "You're very close. I see. Can you tell the jury roughly how many times, in the past year before your daughter was arrested, that you visited her at her house?"

  Hardy put a hand to his forehead. The trap was going to spring here. Jennifer had her hand on his arm.

  Nancy hesitated, sitting back now for the first time. Seconds crept by.

  "Mrs. DiStephano," Villars prodded, "please answer the question."

  Powell waited some more. He wasn't pressing — it was an obvious and simple question, hanging in the room. No one, least of all Nancy, was apt to have forgotten it. "Not last year," she said at last.

  "You didn't visit your daughter's home during the last year?"

  "No."

  "Not at all?"

  "No."

  Powell did a three-sixty, his expressive face showing every nuance of his deep surprise. "Well, how about the year before that?"

  Nancy started to sound a little snappish. "No, we didn't see them very much. Larr
y was… Larry didn't want us to."

  "Larry didn't want you to." Powell, sparing Nancy's feelings, a good guy, tried to find a way out for her. "Then, with your very close relationship, you and Jennifer must have spoken on the phone quite a lot?"

  She looked down. "She was very busy."

  "Your daughter was busy. Did she have a job?"

  "I had a job, I have a job."

  "Which left nights and weekends, is that right?"

  Hardy stood up. "Your Honor, this is badgering."

  "Overruled."

  Powell asked again. "Just approximately, Mrs. DiStephano, how often did you and your daughter speak?"

  Nancy kept her eyes down.

  "Every week? Once a month?"

  "She always called on my birthday. I always called on hers."

  Powell let the words speak for themselves. He nodded, then walked back to the prosecution table. "I'd like to explore one last point — you've told us, Mrs. DiStephano, that Matt was Jennifer's life, that she even spoiled him. I wonder if you could be more specific."

  Again, the eyes came to Hardy, pleading for help. "What do you mean?"

  "I mean, if you didn't see much of Jennifer and Matt, which you've just told us, how do you know how she felt about him or how she treated him?"

  "Well, when he was younger, when he was a baby—"

  "Matt was Jennifer's life then?"

  "Yes."

  "And now?"

  "Yes."

  Powell was still trying to seem gentle, generous. He came close to the witness box, speaking softly. "Mrs. DiStephano, I just don't see how you can know. Please help me here."

  Nancy sat quietly for an hour's worth of fifteen seconds. Finally Hardy stood and asked if a question had been asked. Powell gave it some more time, then sighed, saying he supposed not. Mrs. DiStephano could sit down.

  49

  Finally, after lunch, the defendant took the stand.

  She wore a taupe-colored suit with a bright multi-colored scarf. Hardy wasn't sure how he felt about the outfit — it gave out conflicting messages. On the one hand, it cut Jennifer away even further from the common thread shared by the rest of the people on the jury, which was not good. She needed their empathy, not their envy. But he had to admit, and statistics supported it, that there was a subtle dynamic at work in death-penalty cases. A natural reaction, he guessed, although not a particularly noble one. A jury would only be likely to vote for the death penalty if it had become convinced that the defendant was, in some tangible way, a kind of monster, a deformity cut off from the bonds of humanity. To avoid this impression — shallow as it might be — Jennifer's clothes would help. Looking as she did, dressed as she was, she was very much a human presence, not a non-person, certainly not a monster. More than that, there was something in her physical beauty and carriage that was generally highly valued in America. Hardy hoped the jury — especially the men — would not be inclined to vote to turn this suffering beauty into a corpse.

  Of course, his fear in calling her to the stand was that by opening her mouth she would break the spell cast by her appearance. And Hardy well knew that from behind that appearance might erupt someone to turn off even the most predisposed in her favor.

  They had discussed the format for this testimony, and had decided that Jennifer should say what she had to in her most modulated voice. She would be her best self. The risk would come with Powell's cross-examination. Meanwhile, Hardy tread lightly.

  "Jennifer, you're up here today to argue for your very life. Is there anything you would like the jury, and the judge, to know?"

  She turned to them. "I know that you have found the evidence was enough to convict me." Swallowing, nervous, she looked at Hardy, who nodded. "I'm really not here to make an argument for my life, as Mr. Hardy says. I'm here to tell you that I did not do any of this. I did not kill my husband. I certainly did not kill my son." She swallowed again. "I admit I may not have been the greatest mom in the world, but I loved Matt…" Again, she stopped, bit down on her lower lip. Gathering herself, she forced a weak smile. "I guess that's all."

  Powell was scribbling furiously — about what?

  Hardy had intended to question her some about Larry, but this statement was so clean that he was tempted to stop right there. The jury now had heard her deny the killings with her own voice — it just might be all he needed, or at least the best he was going to get.

  But on the other side, the jury might feel it was too easy to fake something so short. He felt he had to bring her out a little more — as Freeman had said, life was a risk.

  "Do you want to tell us about the morning of December 28?"

  Powell stood up. "Your Honor, this testimony belonged in the guilt phase of this trial."

  Hardy had to get in a word before Villars ruled. "This is Jennifer Witt's story and the jury deserves to hear it, Your Honor."

  The judge frowned as she always did when counsel went at each other, then she agreed with Hardy. Turning to Jennifer, she said, "Tell us about that morning, Mrs. Witt."

  Jennifer nodded. "I got up early because we'd had dinner late and I hadn't done the dishes from the night before. And Larry was going to be home all day, all week really, so I wanted to be sure the house was perfect. I wanted to go jogging later, which I usually did, so I just put on my running clothes and went downstairs.

  "It got pretty late, maybe eight-thirty, but it was Larry's vacation and I thought he should be able to sleep in if he wanted. Then finally he came down. Matt was still sleeping, he was a good sleeper."

  Nice touch, Hardy thought shamelessly.

  "Anyway, Larry reads the paper in the morning with his breakfast. It's just something he always does…" She paused, collecting herself. "I mean he always did. But this morning he came down angry."

  "Over what?" Hardy said.

  She swallowed hard. "I wasn't dressed right."

  "Didn't you say you were in your running clothes?"

  She nodded. "But that wasn't going to be for an hour or so, you see? I guess I still looked like I just rolled out of bed. I mean my hair and no make-up."

  "But hadn't you just been up for a while cleaning house, doing the dishes?"

  Jennifer might not wasn’t to talk about Larry beating her, but this was good stuff for her. Saint Larry was taking a few hits and Hardy was trying to keep Jennifer swinging. "Well, yes, but… he just didn't like it."

  "Did he yell at you?"

  "No. I could just tell he was upset. You know?"

  "I think so, Jennifer." Hardy included the jury. "And then what happened?"

  "Well, I got his coffee and then I tried to rub his shoulders, which he liked when he was tense about something, but he shrugged me off."

  "He shrugged you off? You mean he physically moved you away?" Powell seemed to be willing to let him lead the witness and Hardy would use a leash if he had to.

  But Jennifer wouldn't go along. "No. You know, he just didn't want me to look this way. So I told him I'd go upstairs to change if he wanted me to…"

  "Even though you were still going running in an hour?"

  She nodded. "If he wanted. It wasn't a big deal to me. But then he told me not to bother, he said he'd been awake for an hour upstairs, going over our bills. He was worried about money. Christmas, you know, that sort of thing?"

  "And what happened then?"

  "It got to be a family budget argument." Jennifer was facing the jury. "You know, everybody has them."

  "All right, and then what?"

  "Then Matt came down, rubbing his eyes, like he did when he woke up… I didn't like to have Matt hear us arguing and yelling so I stopped and went into the kitchen and made him some French toast, which was his favorite. Then I went upstairs to make the beds. I thought maybe it would all blow over."

  "And did it blow over?"

  "No… When I came down Larry started in again on how I looked. He thought I'd gone upstairs to change into something decent. I told him I was going running now, but he was still mad a
bout the other… about everything. So we had more words and Matt was crying. I thought I could make it stop if I left, so I did."

  "You went out running?"

  "Yes."

  "And what time did you leave the house?"

  "I don't know. I walked down a couple of blocks, which is what I always do to warm up, then I started running."

  She told it well… the stop at the bank, her return to the house, the inventory where she didn't list the gun as missing because she hadn't gone back into the bedroom. Hardy was coming to the opinion that in his fear over Jennifer's abrasive personality, Freeman had badly erred in not putting her on the stand. She had a consistent story to tell and she told it well, her voice gaining in confidence as she went on until her direct testimony came to an end just before they broke for lunch.

  If only she could stand up as well to Powell's cross-examination.

  * * * * *

  "I'd like to start by asking you to clarify something for me. Is that all right?"

  During lunch in the "suite," Hardy had let her savor her partial victory for a few moments, and then thought he'd best begin to prepare her for Powell's expected onslaught. Perhaps it would work — she was facing Powell calmly now, her eyes clear as she nodded.

  "You've said, and I quote: 'I didn't kill my husband. I certainly did not kill my son.' Do you mean that you're not as certain that you didn't kill Larry?"

  This was a get-your-goat question and as such, Hardy thought, it was good strategy. But he wasn't about to let Powell get away with it. "Argumentative, Your Honor. What's the substance of that question?"

  Villars agreed. Jennifer did not have to answer, but Hardy could see that the question had rattled her, already chipped at her reserve. He caught her eye and half-lifted a palm — keep cool, Jennifer, don't let it get to you.

  Powell smiled at the defendant and started again. "If you don't mind, Mrs. Witt, I'd like to clear up one part of your story I still don't understand. You've testified that when you came back downstairs after making the beds and so on, that you and your husband started fighting again."

  "Larry started yelling again, yes."

  "And Matt started crying?"