Leaf, Erin M. - The First Time is the Sweetest (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour)

by The First Time is the Sweetest

  “Please—” he groaned, but Sabrina didn’t know what he wanted. She was out of her depth, completely.

  She cleared her throat. “What do you want?” Sabrina ran her finger over the crown again. Gabriel shook under her hands but didn’t speak, thrashing his head back and forth. Jimmy moved his right hand onto her waist, rubbing against her ribs right under her breasts. His left hand cradled Gabriel’s neck and Sabrina felt him grip Gabriel’s hair in his fist.

  “He wants you to pull down his boxers and touch him, Sabrina,” Jimmy murmured in her ear. Sabrina’s breath caught as Gabriel nodded distractedly. His hips twitched, making little bucking movements under her palm.

  “Are you sure?” she asked Gabriel. “I don’t know what I’m doing.”

  “Yes, yes. You couldn’t do anything wrong right now if you tried,” he muttered, moaning again as her fingers stroked him. Sabrina smiled to herself, enjoying the look on his face. She still felt bashful, but with Jimmy’s hand in his hair and her fingers on his cock, she could see that he couldn’t control himself any longer. He pushed himself into her hand again, then opened his eyes and stared hotly at her. “Do whatever the hell you want, Sabrina.”

  A zing of excitement flashed through her. Given his firm encouragement, Sabrina found the courage to grasp the elastic of his boxers and gently pull them down. It was more difficult than she expected because his erection bobbed out toward her as she tugged the cotton away. Gabriel lifted his hips, and she pulled his pants and underwear down to his thighs until he sat there, fully exposed. She stared.

  His cock arched up above his groin, thick and beautiful. He was uncut, the head flushed a deep rose color. A small, glistening drop of pre-cum decorated the tip. Sabrina licked her lips again, fighting the urge to bend over and lick him. Instead she stroked her hand up his length experimentally, and Gabriel groaned, shoving into her palm.

  “God!” Sabrina looked up, afraid she’d hurt him. “I am so fucking hot right now.” Gabriel gasped and bucked again. The soft skin of him slid against her palm as Jimmy panted hotly down her neck. She paused, not sure what to do.

  “No, Sabrina, don’t stop!” Gabriel groaned, gripping the sofa cushions with his left hand. His right hand flexed on her leg, and she realized he was holding back, trying not to frighten her. She watched as the skin of his cock moved under her fingers and then she let go, running her fingers through his pubic hair. His balls nestled tightly underneath and she fondled them gently, exploring their heft and wondering what it felt like when she touched them. When Gabriel moaned, she stopped again, not sure what to do. She hadn’t realized they were so sensitive. And she thought they’d be larger. Gabriel had his eyes closed, and he was definitely flushed now. Sabrina fondled him some more and watched a bead of sweat run down his face.

  “Can I still ask questions?” she whispered, running her hand back up his length. Another drop of moisture seeped from his cockhead, and she ran her thumb over it, rubbing it gently into his skin as he bucked up into her grip. He gasped.

  “What do you want to know?” Jimmy murmured in her ear when Gabriel didn’t respond. Sabrina felt herself breathing heavier, but even in her arousal she felt shy about voicing aloud what she wanted to know. “Don’t be afraid, sweetheart.” Jimmy stroked his hand along her ribs as she stroked Gabriel. When Gabriel opened his eyes and looked up at them, the blue was almost swallowed by the black of his pupils. Jimmy sucked in a breath, and Sabrina felt his hips move against her as though he needed to press against something.

  Gabriel moaned again, and Sabrina abruptly realized she loved when he did that. It was hotter than her fantasies, hotter than anything she’d imagined. She hesitated, another question on the tip of her tongue, and Jimmy smiled reassuringly.

  “You can ask us anything, okay?” Gabriel nodded agreement with his eyes closed.

  “I always thought a man’s, um, balls would be bigger.” Sabrina grimaced, completely mortified that she’d said that aloud. Gabriel smiled, but didn’t open his eyes. She couldn’t believe she was doing this. She couldn’t believe she was holding Gabriel’s sex in her hand, feeling his warmth, the slightly moist skin. He was letting her touch him, letting her do whatever she wanted to him. And she especially couldn’t believe she was doing all this with Jimmy right next to her, breathing in her ear. Sabrina felt both powerful and shy, caught between the two emotions like she was caught between the two men.

  “He’s really aroused right now,” Jimmy whispered. He’d moved his hand down from her waist and was inching over to Gabriel. He leaned over her and cupped Gabriel’s sac just as she slid her hand over Gabriel’s cock again. She wondered if she should lick her hand to make it easier to slide over him, but as soon as Jimmy touched the other man, Gabriel bucked in their grasp and she lost her train of thought.

  “God!” Gabriel rolled his head back and forth on the couch now. Sabrina almost pulled away but Jimmy stopped her, holding her hand steady as Gabriel’s cock flexed beneath both of their fingers.

  “When a man is this close to coming, his balls tighten up and draw close to his body. Sometimes, you can keep him from it if you grasp them and pull them gently down and away, like this.” As he spoke, he gripped Gabriel again, gently but firmly, and pulled down the sac as Gabriel groaned. His cock pulsed under her palm. Then Jimmy let go and moved his hand up to cover Sabrina’s.

  “Shit! Stop fucking teasing me!” Gabriel gasped weakly. Sabrina’s eyes flew up to Gabriel and then Jimmy, who laughed and then looked at the other man.

  “All right, Gabriel, hang in there,” he said, his voice low and sexy, and Sabrina watched Gabriel shiver at the sound. Wow, Sabrina thought. He’s as attracted to Jimmy as I am! Then Jimmy pulled her hand away from Gabriel and she had a moment to be confused before he spoke again.

  “Sabrina, here, lick your palm, okay?” Jimmy brought her right hand to her mouth. Just as she went to lick her palm, Gabriel’s eyes shot open and he looked right at her, his pupils blown with arousal. She licked her skin slowly, not looking away. She even sucked briefly on one of the fingers Jimmy had curled around hers. Gabriel swallowed hard and Jimmy choked. Arousing two men at the same time has to be some sort of accomplishment for someone as inexperienced as I am, Sabrina thought, feeling a thrill. She was really here, touching them even though she was still a little scared, but the way Gabriel looked, gripping the sofa’s cushions and shaking, was enough to convince her that she wanted more. A lot more. Jimmy brought their hands back down to Gabriel’s cock and slicked her palm down over the crown. When Gabriel thrust up, she curled her fingers around him, savoring the silky heat.

  “This part is the most sensitive,” Jimmy instructed, moving her thumb carefully, rubbing it into the spot just beneath the top while the other man thrashed his head. “Most men really like it when you stroke them there.”

  Sabrina did as he instructed, delighted when Gabriel moaned again. His balls drew up even closer to his body as he opened his legs further. His cock flushed a darker red and she’d never seen anything so beautiful in her life. She wanted to lean down and kiss him, right on the top, but wasn’t sure if she should. She let Jimmy move her hand some more.

  After a few more strokes, paying careful attention to that one spot, Jimmy shifted and murmured in her ear, “He’s really close now.”

  Sabrina flushed, thinking about what that meant. She felt hot and sweaty and excited. Jimmy pressed against her. Is he really uncomfortable? Sabrina wondered, then felt him turn more, pressing his erection against her hip, hard. She moaned, unable to keep quiet, sandwiched as she was between two of the most gorgeous men she’d ever seen, one of them on the verge of climax, the other one pressing his sex into her.

  Gabriel was sweating and Sabrina could feel him throbbing in her hand. He was so close, he didn’t seem able to think, or form words. He opened his eyes and Sabrina licked her lips as Jimmy thrust against her, both of them watching Gabriel’s cock. His head fell back when Jimmy scraped his thumb over the rim of his cock y
et again, making his hips buck. Sabrina watched as Gabriel clenched his teeth, trying to hold back his climax, knowing even in her inexperience that he’d be unsuccessful.

  She let Jimmy move her hand quicker, grateful that at least he knew what he was doing. Then Gabriel’s sex thickened, growing impossibly harder, and she found herself wondering, How the hell could this fit inside me? She didn’t have long to dwell on the problem though, because when Jimmy tightened his hand, Gabriel suddenly gasped and thrust his hips up, cock pulsing as he came. Jimmy moaned as he worked his fingers around hers, stroking Gabriel through his orgasm. He gripped Gabriel more loosely now, rubbing along the slowly softening length. Jimmy shoved his erection even harder into her hip as Gabriel bucked again, and then once more before dropping bonelessly onto the couch. Sabrina felt him soften beneath their fingers, but Jimmy didn’t let her pull away. They held Gabriel’s cock gently as the other man shuddered, then fell still.

  “Oh my God,” Sabrina croaked, aroused beyond belief. She hadn’t really thought about what they were doing, but now that Gabriel had come all over her hand, she realized that she wasn’t just playing with some guy from school. Gabriel was a man, an incredible, desirable man. She desperately wanted to kiss him. She wanted him to make love to her just as much as she wanted Jimmy. She suddenly realized that he’d given this to her, let her touch him, knowing what would happen, knowing he’d be totally vulnerable. It was at that moment that Sabrina realized she was falling in love with him just as much as she already loved Jimmy.

  Then Gabriel opened his eyes and looked up from where he’d slouched, flushed and limp against the sofa. The sweet-bitter smell of his come drifted up, and as they gently released him, he smiled at them, looking completely boneless.

  “Thanks,” he said.

  Sabrina stared at him in disbelief. Jimmy chuckled, once again pressing his erection into her hip.

  “It was our pleasure,” Jimmy said. Sabrina nodded dumbly. Gabriel reached over to the footrest and snagged a few tissues from the box she’d left there a few days ago. He handed them to her, still smiling as he hitched up his underwear and jeans, not bothering to zip up.

  “So, any more questions, Sabrina?” Gabriel asked, smiling. Sabrina squirmed, pressing her thighs together, as Jimmy discarded the tissues they’d used to clean up. She brought her hand up to her face and sniffed while Gabriel watched. She could smell him all over her fingers, and Jimmy groaned and ground his cock against her again.

  “Jesus, Sabrina, don’t do that.” Jimmy laughed into her ear. “I’m going to come in my pants, I swear to God, what you do to me.” Gabriel smirked and leaned in to kiss her. Sabrina opened her mouth eagerly as his tongue slipped over her bottom lip, sucking on it gently, nipping at the sensitive skin with his teeth. Jimmy’s breath heated her neck as he watched them kiss. She moaned, wanting things she couldn’t describe.

  “Questions, Sabrina?” Gabriel asked again, a smile in his voice as he released her lip with a soft pop. She shook her head and tried to gather her thoughts. She still wanted to taste him, and as Jimmy pressed against her again, she realized that she wanted to watch Jimmy come apart the same way Gabriel already had. She turned to Jimmy.

  “Can I taste you?” Sabrina asked. Jimmy’s eyes widened as Gabriel chuckled behind her.

  “She knows what she wants,” Gabriel said, voice light. Jimmy fell silent for a moment and she began to think that maybe she’d overstepped, or maybe he’d misunderstood her, when he spoke.

  “Usually, it’s not a good idea to swap body fluids, Sabrina,” he began and she felt her heart sink in realization that she’d been stupid. Shit! She knew about the whole safe sex thing! How could she forget? “No, no, don’t look so worried,” Jimmy continued, bringing up his hand to stroke Sabrina’s face. She caught a whiff of Gabriel on his fingers as he cradled her cheek. “I’ve just been tested and I’m clean, and I haven’t had sex in over a year.”

  “Over a year?” Sabrina exclaimed, surprised. She felt even worse now thinking of how many times they’d kissed, how often he’d been aroused and unfulfilled before Gabriel came. Unless he’s taken care of it himself, he probably hasn’t had any relief in weeks, she thought, then blushed at the idea of Jimmy taking himself in hand. She saw him looking at her kindly and realized that he wasn’t trying to make her uncomfortable. He was just trying to make sure she understood the implications of what she wanted before acting on her desires.

  “Yeah. I never really liked the one-night-stand thing and I got tested after I came back from Afghanistan, for STDs and other diseases.”

  Sabrina nodded. “Does that mean you’ll let me—”

  “Yes, definitely yes.” Sabrina smiled at the heated look on Jimmy’s face.

  Behind her, Gabriel shifted his weight. “I’m clean, too. I have to get tested for everything every three months, and aside from just the past few minutes, I haven’t had sex in over two years.”

  Sabrina turned to him, even more surprised. “You’re kidding!” How was it possible? He was beautiful!

  “I was undercover, remember? I didn’t particularly want to fool around in that situation, and like Jimmy, I don’t enjoy having sex with someone I don’t know.” Gabriel shook his head, then smiled sweetly at her.

  Sabrina didn’t know what to say. That meant he let her touch him, knowing full well that it implied some sort of commitment on his side of things. She was stunned. She hadn’t realized he cared for her that much, though she knew how she felt about him. After a moment, the practical meaning of his words sunk in and she realized she could do the one thing she’d been yearning to since she watched him come. She brought her right hand up to her mouth and deliberately slid her fingers in, tonguing his taste off her skin.

  “Jesus!” Gabriel breathed. Sabrina smiled around her fingers at his shock. She noticed his cock twitch, despite the orgasm he’d just had. She sucked on her fingers until all traces of Gabriel’s come were gone, ignoring the way Jimmy’s breath hiccupped. She saw Gabriel watching Jimmy watching her, and inside she felt more grown-up than ever before. She pulled her fingers out and smiled.

  “Mmm,” she said, just for kicks, making Gabriel laugh. “So, does this mean you’ll let me touch you, too, Jimmy?” Sabrina absently rubbed her hand dry on Gabriel’s thigh.

  “Sure, yeah,” Jimmy said, voice husky.

  She noticed him pressing his hand against his groin. “Why do you do that?” she asked, gesturing to his hand.

  Jimmy shrugged. “It helps me keep control when I’m really aroused, and it feels good.” Then he moved his hand up and flicked open the top button of his jeans, then the next and the next. Sabrina laughed at his not-too-subtle encouragement. She didn’t look away. He wasn’t wearing any underwear, and the first thing she saw was the rosy hue of his cock peeking at her and Gabriel from the V of his opened jeans. It sat curved against his dark hair, the tip already leaking. She gulped and Jimmy laughed.

  “Would you take off your shirt?” Gabriel asked Jimmy, watching raptly as Jimmy’s hips bucked when he pressed his hand against his erection.

  Sabrina nodded. “Yeah, very good idea.”

  “Your wish is my command.” Jimmy stripped off his white T-shirt. His silver nipple ring gleamed brightly against the tanned skin of his chest, and Sabrina let her eyes wander over his taut abdomen down to his groin. She felt more than heard Gabriel breathe heavier.

  “Damn,” Gabriel whispered in admiration. Sabrina wondered if Gabriel was aroused again already. She turned to look at him.

  “Do you still want to taste him?” she asked. Gabriel dragged his eyes away from Jimmy where he lay sprawled on the sofa and looked at her.

  “Yeah, I do.” They smiled at each other.

  “Maybe we can do this together.”

  “Oh, God,” moaned Jimmy from the sofa. Gabriel and Sabrina laughed.

  “Hey, remember I’m a complete novice here. I’m not making any promises.” Sabrina smiled at Jimmy.

  He just shook his head.
“Yeah, well, Gabriel knows what he likes, so I bet between the two of you, I’ll be a wreck in no time.” Gabriel smirked at this and shifted off the couch to kneel between Jimmy’s legs.

  “Come down here, Sabrina.” Gabriel tugged on her hand. She cocked her head at him. “It’ll be easier to reach the goods from here.” Jimmy groaned again, and Sabrina chuckled and slid off the couch, but not before kissing Jimmy full on the mouth, enjoying the softness of his lips against hers. Then she settled next to Gabriel, who pulled Jimmy’s jeans off the rest of the way, baring the other man completely. Jimmy pulled his right leg up onto the sofa, and Sabrina’s eyes widened at the sight. Jimmy lay there, relaxed, letting his left thigh rest against Gabriel’s shoulder. Sabrina leaned in and rubbed her face on the soft skin of his right leg and watched his erection leap as she breathed on him. She pulled his leg down, thinking he couldn’t be comfortable like that, and he rested his knee against her. She licked the sensitive skin at his hipbone.

  “Oh,” Jimmy breathed. He sounded wrecked. She saw him look down at them and felt a spark of pride as he tried to catch his breath. She helped do this to him and she smiled, savoring the look on his face, enjoying the way his hands smoothed through her hair. He rubbed the strands between his fingers before sliding them into the thick mass to rub her scalp. She arched up, sensing Gabriel’s rapt attention. She closed her eyes for a moment, then jerked when Gabriel moved his hands up and over Jimmy’s legs onto his chest, brushing against her breasts to tug at Jimmy’s nipple ring. Jimmy bowed nearly completely off the couch, desperate for it.

  Sabrina didn’t know what to do. She wanted to taste Jimmy, but figured it would be better to start off with what she already knew. She slid her hands up his thigh and brushed her fingers gently against his balls before curling her fingers around his cock.

  “Mmmm,” Jimmy moaned, bucking as Gabriel placed his hands flat on Jimmy’s chest, holding him down. Sabrina cupped Jimmy’s balls and he thrust his hips again. Sabrina smiled at Gabriel and he leaned in to kiss her, both of them keeping their hands on Jimmy. Gabriel slipped his tongue into her mouth, and she squeezed Jimmy’s cock unthinkingly.