Cavanaugh on Duty

by Marie Ferrarella

  Kari shrugged in response to his question.

  “Same thing that everyone else does,” she answered. “That the cartel is evil and should be eradicated before all those vulnerable kids wind up either dead or getting hooked—or both.”

  She’d almost blown it, Kari upbraided herself. She hadn’t made up her mind yet whether to tell him that she knew about his family and offer her condolences, or to just continue playing it by ear for the time being.

  For now, she went with the latter.

  “Why do you ask?” Kari said innocently.

  His eyes held hers for a long, penetrating moment before he looked away. “No reason. Just thought maybe you’d heard something.”

  She decided to push it a little further, since that was what she would have done under normal circumstances. “Like what?”

  “Like me getting back undercover.”

  He really wanted that, didn’t he? She felt bad for him. But she also knew that saying so was the fastest way of getting her head handed to her.

  So instead, she cracked, “And give up this glamorous life where you can shower, shave and put on clean clothes in the morning? Surely you’re kidding.”

  “Yeah,” he muttered, his voice a monotone. “Dunno what I must have been thinking. So why did you stay here?” he asked. She hadn’t given him an answer yet.

  “I don’t know,” she admitted. “I thought that maybe if I stared at that board hard enough, and it was quiet enough, something I’d missed before might just come to me.”

  He looked at her, mildly interested as he sampled his coffee from the vending machine. It was particularly bitter—but not particularly hot. It was hard not making a face.

  “And did it?”

  “Yeah—that I still have no idea what the connection is between these two victims.” There was frustration evident in her voice. “What we need,” she told him, “is more data to work with.”

  “Maybe there doesn’t have to be a connection,” he suggested, setting the offending container of coffee down on his desk. “Maybe the killer just doesn’t like nice, retired people who try to make a difference. Maybe seeing them go about their lives makes him feel worse about himself.”

  Kari looked at him, impressed. But then, she recalled, he’d struck her as being smart back in high school. A jock who not only actually studied for exams—but who did well on them.

  “That sounds very philosophical,” she told him with a smile.

  Esteban tossed off her compliment with an indifferent shrug. “Psych 101.”

  “Hey, Hyphen, Fernandez...get in here.” Lieutenant Morrow stepped out of his office and called out to them.

  Kari pulled herself up to her feet, waiting for the drained feeling to leave her. She handed Esteban back his coffee container. It was still half-full.

  “Thanks,” she told him, nodding at the container. And then she indicated the lieutenant, who’d already gone back into his office and was waiting for them to follow. “I don’t think I like the sound of that.”

  Esteban said nothing. Taking the container back, he left it on his desk standing next to its smaller, rejected brethren, and followed behind Kari to the lieutenant’s office.

  Morrow didn’t bother closing the door, giving them the impression that they weren’t going to be in there all that long.

  The impression was right.

  “You got another one,” he announced the second Esteban was in the office.

  She didn’t have to ask what he meant by “another one,” because she knew. Still, she could hope that he was wrong. “You sure it’s our guy?” Kari asked.

  The look he gave her said he hadn’t gotten to where he was by making mistakes. “It’s him, all right. Throat slashed from behind.”

  Kari asked the next logical question, since she was trying to establish just what the killer’s M.O. was. “Retired?”

  Morrow looked at her, a puzzled furrow stretched across his brow. “What?”

  “The victim,” Kari underscored. “Was she—?”

  “He,” Morrow corrected.

  Esteban surprised her by picking up the thread and asking the lieutenant, “Was he retired?”

  The lieutenant shook his head. “Some of his coworkers found him at work when they came in this morning. That’ll give them nightmares for a long time,” he speculated. “He was an accountant,” Morrow added, then produced the all-important slip of paper and held it out to Kari. “Here’s the address.”

  Kari looked it over before sliding the paper into her pocket. She really should have gone home last night and gotten a decent night’s sleep. That would have helped her more than finding out about Steve’s— Esteban’s—past, she told herself.

  With a sigh, she looked in her partner’s direction. “Okay, let’s go.”

  “Why the long face?” he asked as they walked out of the lieutenant’s office. “You said you wanted more data,” he reminded her. They stopped at her desk so she could pick up her purse.

  She did and they were on their way. Only then did she answer his question.

  “I meant more data about the other two victims. I didn’t want a third body to turn up.” That was the last thing she had wanted.

  “Maybe you should have been more specific,” he told her.

  Aghast, she shot him a look as they waited for the elevator to arrive. “What are you suggesting...that there’s a serial killer fairy or a homicide genie out there, granting me three wishes?”

  The elevator arrived and they got on. Since there was no one else in it, they continued talking. “No, just something more along the lines of ‘careful what you wish for,’” he answered.

  She was just punchy enough to see the merit in his argument. That alone convinced her that she needed more sleep.

  “Well, if I did have three wishes...” she began.

  “Yeah?” God help him, he was actually curious. Was this woman getting to him after all? He was going to have to watch that, not let himself risk opening up to her. You never knew who was listening, he thought.

  “I’d wish my partner talked more to me.”

  That made him laugh. “Again, careful what you wish for,” he warned.

  “Why? Because you’re going to turn into a chatterbox and talk my ear off?” Now that was funny, she thought. “There’s more of a chance of me sprouting wings and flying—or our serial killer turning himself in and making a full confession,” she tossed in, “than you suddenly running off at the mouth.”

  She had that pegged right, Esteban thought. “Hey, I’ve got an idea—why don’t you just enjoy the peace and quiet?” he suggested.

  She pretended it was an honest question and gave him an honest answer. “Because peace and quiet make me nervous,” she admitted.

  He laughed dryly, thinking she was joking. But one look at her face and he could see that she wasn’t. “That’s a new one.”

  She could see by Esteban’s expression that he didn’t believe her. Having nothing to lose, she decided to set him straight.

  “No, really,” she insisted. “When my surroundings are peaceful and quiet, I know that it’s just a matter of time before something happens to shatter that...and at least half the time, what shatters peace and quiet is really not a good thing.”

  They got out on the ground floor and began walking to the exit and the parking lot beyond.

  “So you catch yourself waiting and holding your breath until whatever you know is going to happen—” she paused, then said “—happens.”

  In a way, they weren’t all that different, always expecting some sort of chaos, Esteban thought. That was the way he lived his life, as well.

  “Easy to peg you for a Cavanaugh,” he commented. “Your family’s always in the thick of it, all that constant action,” he added in case she wasn’
t following his reasoning.

  “We like keeping busy and keeping the peace,” she told him.

  “Or being in the middle of all the noise,” he countered, giving the general situation another interpretation.

  She inclined her head, not seeing the need to challenge the point he’d just made.

  “There’s that, too.”

  * * *

  Unlike the other two victims, the third victim—a Ronald Hays—was in his early forties and, according to the coworker that they interviewed, Hays was far too busy with his social life to volunteer for any sort of activity. “Don’t get me wrong—when they passed the hat around for Vera, Ron gave just like everyone else. Maybe even a little more,” he added after thinking it over.

  “Vera?” Kari asked, waiting for some kind of an explanation from the man who claimed to be the deceased’s closest friend at the accounting firm.

  The interviewee nodded. “Vera Wells,” he clarified, but the name still didn’t mean anything to her. “Vera’s husband was in a car accident, and the bills just went through the roof in record time. We took up a collection in the office to help her cover a little of what the insurance didn’t. Ron didn’t even stop to count what he was putting in,” he told them proudly, “just grabbed a handful of bills out of his wallet and slipped them all into the collection envelope.

  “But he didn’t have time for stuff like coaching some Little League team or mentoring a kid having trouble in his math class.” The man laughed to himself as he recalled a specific incident.

  “Remember something funny?” Esteban asked him.

  The question, coming from someone like Esteban, instantly sobered the man being interviewed.

  “Hell, when Ron got that jury summons in the mail, it put him in a bad mood for a week—especially when the boss told him his pay wasn’t getting docked, that the company looked favorably on that sort of thing.”

  “Wait.” Kari held up her hand, trying to understand. “You’re saying he became angry because his pay wasn’t getting docked?”

  “Yeah. He was going to use that not-getting-paid thing as an excuse for getting out of jury duty. But since the boss said it was his patriotic duty to go down for jury duty, he had to go. And he wound up getting put on a case, too.” The man paused to laugh, shaking his head as he began relaying more things about the incident. “I can tell you that really got him mad.

  “Turns out, the case didn’t last all that long. It started to, but Ron told me he pushed through the deadlock, convincing everyone else that the guy was guilty. They voted to convict the guy and Ron hightailed it back to work.

  “But you see, he just didn’t have time for volunteering and selfless stuff like that.” As if suddenly aware of the picture he’d just painted of the victim, the man’s friend quickly added, “But that really didn’t make him a bad guy.”

  “No,” Kari agreed. “It didn’t.”

  But what did? she couldn’t help wondering. What made Ronald Hays, Mae Daniels and William Reynolds “bad guys,” at least in the killer’s eyes?

  That, she thought, was the question that needed answering.

  Chapter 11

  The more she and Esteban delved into Ron Hays’s life, the less he appeared to have in common with the first two victims. He was younger than they were, still employed and obviously had little interest in volunteering any of his free time to help those less fortunate than himself.

  Kari paced back and forth in front of the bulletin board. Hays’s photograph had been added to the board, taking its position next to William Reynolds and Mae Daniels.

  Even the photograph looked out of place, Kari thought, slanting a glance toward it as she paced. Hays looked young enough to be their son.

  Why was he victim number three?

  Was he victim number three? she suddenly wondered, stopping dead in front of the board and staring at the man’s photograph.

  Leaning back in his chair, Esteban noted the way she was looking at the board—as if her eyes could shoot laser beams out. “Got something?” he asked.

  Maybe yes, maybe no, she thought.

  “Maybe someone killed Hays after reading about the other two murders,” she theorized. She turned to look at her partner, her eyes bright.

  Damn, but they were hypnotic, he thought. Like the rest of her. He forced himself to focus on her train of thought. “You mean, using the so-called serial killer—”

  “Almost serial killer,” Kari interjected. “Technically, it takes three like murders before we can call the perp a serial killer, and we haven’t quite put Hays in the same category as Reynolds and Daniels,” she reminded Esteban.

  “Okay.” He had no problem with adjusting his statement to suit her. He was accustomed to rolling with the punches—most of the time. “Using the so-called ‘almost serial killer’ for cover, whoever killed Ron Hays might have just been focused on getting rid of him and was hoping the murder wouldn’t wind up on his doorstep.” As he spoke, another idea occurred to him. “Or the other two murders he committed could have been done to provide his cover and his real intended victim was Ron Hays all along,” he suggested.

  He watched her face to see her reaction, not quite sure just what to expect. What he saw was an amused, nonjudgmental smile. A smile that caught him a little off guard. “What?” he demanded.

  She would have never believed it. “You were a fan of Agatha Christie mysteries when you were a kid, weren’t you?”

  Defensiveness had always been second nature to him. Now was no different. “What makes you say that?” he wanted to know.

  “Because you just described the setup behind one of her classic stories. I think it was called The ABC Murders. A killer murders three people in order to ‘hide in plain sight’ his intended victim.”

  Esteban frowned. “I take it you don’t agree with the last theory.”

  “I didn’t say that,” she pointed out. “I don’t have enough information on the third victim to rule that ‘hide in plain sight’ theory in or out right now.” She took a breath. “What I am saying is that the only thing that we know for certain that victim number three has in common with numbers one and two is that slashed throat.”

  “Not the only thing.”

  Kari and Esteban turned around in unison and looked toward the doorway at the woman who’d just spoken. Sean’s senior assistant, Destiny, was standing in the room.

  “Okay,” Esteban said gamely, recognizing the woman from the last crime scene. She’d been one of the investigators there. “What else is there?”

  Kari looked at her hopefully. “You found something,” she added, mentally crossing her fingers.

  Destiny didn’t answer either one of them. “The boss wants to see the two of you in his lab.”

  Kari knew better than to try to badger an answer out of Destiny. The woman could give lessons to clams when it came to being closemouthed.

  “Lead the way,” Kari told the other woman, gesturing toward the door.

  Destiny wordlessly turned on her heel and did just that.

  * * *

  “You know, I don’t recall you ever being this dramatic,” Kari told her father as she and Esteban filed into the main lab directly behind Destiny.

  Her father was there, along with his array of the latest state-of-the-art equipment, all of which was lined up along the dark blue granite counter within easy reach. When she spoke, Sean Cavanaugh looked up from the microscope he’d been using.

  “Must have something to do with my renewed lease on life,” her father speculated. He was all but beaming.

  She noted that he’d been that way for weeks, ever since Deirdre Callaghan had accepted his marriage proposal.

  “Remind me to thank your fiancée the next time I see her,” Kari told him, doing her best to look serious. About to say someth
ing else, she abruptly stopped as she remembered. “That’ll be a week from Saturday, won’t it? Boy, that came fast. I’m still trying to get used to the idea.”

  Because she could see from the slightly puzzled frown on Esteban’s face that he wasn’t following any of this, she told him, “My father’s getting married next Saturday. To Detective Matt Callaghan’s mother.”

  He was only vaguely aware of who Matt Callaghan was. He was still trying to become familiar with the names of various police detectives.

  “Congratulations,” Esteban said.

  “Thanks.” For a moment, Sean stepped outside his position as head of the lab and smiled at Esteban. “Why don’t you come to the ceremony? Everyone’s invited.”

  “I doubt if everyone’s invited,” Esteban responded, then saw by the expression on Kari’s face that, just possibly, his assumption was inaccurate.

  That seemed impossible...and yet, from what he’d picked up around town, the Cavanaughs were an extremely outgoing family—

  Kari laughed at her partner. “Obviously, you haven’t heard about the famous Andrew Cavanaugh get-togethers. I’m beginning to think the man is a direct descendent of one of those characters out of Aesop’s fables, the one who had a jug that was never empty, no matter how much you poured out of it, and a basket that never ran out of bread, no matter how many loaves you removed from it.”

  Totally confused now, he looked at Sean for some sort of an explanation. “Is she going to start making sense soon?”

  “Actually, she is making sense in her own way,” Sean replied with a laugh. “It seems that for some reason, my brother knows how to whip up food for the masses without breaking a sweat. I’ve seen it for myself. No matter how many people turn up for an occasion, no one ever goes away from his door hungry, or thirsty—or disappointed, for that matter,” he added with a smile.

  “And he just lives for birthdays, weddings and christenings,” Destiny chimed in.

  “And whatever you do,” Kari told him with a great deal of enthusiasm, “you really don’t want to miss out on one of his Christmas celebrations.”

  The day held no special allure for him, or any special significance anymore. To Esteban, Christmas had become just another day, like all the other days that came before it and all the days that came after. But he instinctively knew that his opinion would not exactly go over well with these people, so he kept it to himself and merely asked, “Why?”