Deep in You

by Penny Wylder

  I gasp and tense, realizing he’s going to fuck me with the plug in my ass. No man has ever done that before. Not even when I asked—practically begged— my exes. They worried it would be too painful, too weird, too kinky. They didn’t understand.

  Caleb does. Caleb is as filthy as I am.

  “I’m going to fuck you, Carmine,” he murmurs, that accent of his making the words even sexier than they already are. “I’m going to fuck you with your ass already stuffed. I’m going to stretch your tight little pussy so fucking wide.”

  I moan with desire. “Fuck me, Caleb. Fuck me so fucking hard. Fuck me until I can’t walk straight.”

  He laughs, a low, throaty sound. “Oh, don’t you worry about that, Carmine.” He reaches up to caress my cheek with one hand. His finger leaves a sticky trail across my cheek, still wet from my pussy. “You’re going to have trouble sitting down tomorrow, let alone walking.”

  With that, he thrusts into me, deep, all in one shove. My pussy is so wet he glides all the way into me, and I scream out in sheer pleasure as his cock stretches my tight pussy. I can feel the plug deep in my ass still, and the thick girth of his cock straining at my pussy walls.

  As I cry out, he slides his finger into my mouth. “Suck it,” he commands, and I clamp my mouth around his finger instinctively, tasting myself, my juices mingled with the sharp salt flavor of his skin.

  He pulls back to thrust inside me again, keeping his finger in my mouth at the same time, his other hand clamped tight around my hip to hold me in place. I lick and suck at his finger, thirsty as fuck, while he builds up his pace, starts to fuck me in earnest.

  “Fuck, Carmine,” he growls. “You fucking like that? You like my cock inside you?”

  I moan into his hand, and he adds another finger to my mouth, then a third. As I lick and suck his fingers and thrust back against his cock, making the anal plug bounce inside me, I feel like I’m being fucked by three guys at once, every end satisfied, as full as I can be.

  He shifts his hips, angles his cock so the head drags along my inner front wall, and I cry out again, the sound muffled by his fingers deep in my mouth, as he thrusts against my G-spot. A few more thrusts and I’m already at the brink again, my clit still sensitive from my earlier orgasm, my pussy straining to accommodate his girth.

  He can tell. “That’s it, Carmine,” he murmurs. “Come for me again. Come for me, you filthy girl.”

  I scream with the force of the orgasm that hits me. He doesn’t slow down, doesn’t even pause in his thrusts. His cock keeps driving into me, sending me over the edge, and making the orgasm last, my knees shaking, my belly tight, hands quivering.

  Then he lets his fingers drop from my mouth, and I suck in a deep gulp of air, trying to catch my breath.

  But he’s grabbing my hips with both hands now, driving full-force into me, and I realize he’s about to come too.

  “Fuck yes, Caleb,” I cry over my shoulder. “Fill me up. Fill me up with your fucking cum, come inside me.”

  He growls and fucks me harder, so hard I can hear his balls slapping my pussy lips. I’m pretty sure my ass is going to bruise where his hips crash into mine, but I just push back against him, thrust as hard as I can against him. With a roar, he comes hard, still fucking me. I squeeze my pussy tight around him, milk every last drop as he thrusts away.

  Finally, he slows, then stops altogether, his dick still deep in me. I squeeze my pussy again, and he gasps, his cock twitching inside me. He lets go of my hips, slowly draws his cock out of me. There’s a rush of my own juices, spilling down my inner thigh as he slides out of me.

  I collapse forward onto the bed. I listen to the rubber snap of him rolling off the condom and tying it. Then he falls beside me a moment later, one hand resting on the plug in my ass.

  “Oh, I can…” I reach for it, but he catches my wrist and folds my hands in front of me.

  “Relax,” he commands yet again. And with a soft popping sound, he draws it straight out of my ass. Before I can make a move or offer to do anything, he’s already up off the bed, heading to the bathroom to take care of that and the condom. I’m not used to that. Not used to sharing my toys—or having help after everything is said and done. It’s nice to have someone else here. Someone else to come up with the ideas, someone else to take care of me at the end.

  Not to mention someone else whose backside I can ogle while he does it. I smirk as I drink in Caleb’s sexy ass, and the sharp muscles of his back, almost as sexy as that V-cut on his front.

  Then I roll onto my back and stretch. Before I even finish, he’s already back, lying beside me to wrap his arms around my waist.

  “Shit,” I murmur, curling into his side. “That was…”

  “Fucking hot as hell,” he murmurs, leaning down to kiss my temple.

  “Yeah,” I manage. I’m not sure how else to sum it up. I’d fantasized about this for so long—finding someone as kinky as me, someone who was into my same fantasies. Someone who’d be willing to get down and dirty with me. Not to mention have some fun with my toy collection.

  But I never imagined it would feel like this. So comfortable, so easy. My other boyfriends or hookups would all act horrified when I told them about my kinks. If they let me talk them into trying anything, I still felt like a freak, a dirty weirdo who was corrupting them, or totally insane for wanting any of this.

  Caleb, on the other hand, is just as filthy as I am. Maybe more so. And he doesn’t care. He doesn’t judge me for who I am. On the contrary, he seems to fucking love it.

  “Is it always like that?” I ask softly, curious. Is this how clients and escorts always feel?

  If so, I can’t say I blame people for hiring escorts. This is so… comfortable. So relaxed. He liked everything we did. Was into everything I was. Didn’t judge me, in a way no one ever has. He just tried it all, no questions asked. Hell, he was enthusiastic about it.

  “Fuck no,” he murmurs, his voice low and sleepy.

  I swallow hard. What does that mean? Is it usually better? Did he enjoy himself as much as I did? It certainly sounded like it. But maybe I was wrong.

  Before I can work out a way to ask what he means, though—to ask how this time was different—the tone of his breathing shifts. It goes deep, even, and his chest rises and falls against my ear in a soothing, relaxing rhythm. It lulls my eyelids into going heavy, my own breathing into slowing.

  Without even realizing it, I nestle closer to Caleb, his warm arms still wrapped around me. I fall asleep with the sound of his breathing in my ear, his scent wrapped around me, and the faint, pleasant tingling sensation in my body of being totally, completely satisfied.

  5

  I wake up feeling like a million bucks. Even the usual shrieking tone of my alarm clock doesn’t unsettle me. It sounds better today, more manageable given how fucking great I feel.

  My body is sore as hell, yes, but it’s the best kind of ache. A bone-deep feeling that tells me I’ve finally found someone who can really, truly satisfy me. Give me everything I want—everything I ever imagined and then some.

  I stretch, luxuriating in this feeling, the warm, pleasant glow that suffuses my whole body.

  That’s when I realize, stretching feels way too easy.

  I roll over and find the bed beside me still warm, Caleb’s scent still on my sheets. I crack one eyelid and squint at the room. Nobody.

  I roll the other direction and sit up to peer at the bathroom. Lights off, door wide open. Not there either.

  I reach out to turn off the alarm clock. Then I stifle a yawn and sit up. But there are just my toys neatly stacked beside the bed, all of them squeaky clean. None of Caleb’s clothes are here anymore—not the boxers or shirt he left strewn around the place.

  “Caleb?” I call, hesitant, knowing it’s a long shot.

  The dead silence of my house answers the question. He’s gone.

  I collapse back onto the pillows with a deep sigh. It’s fine, I tell myself. This is what I’m paying for,
after all. I hired him to have a little fun. To get the release I was craving—the one I needed after two years without a partner in my bed. That’s all.

  So why do I feel emptier now than I did before I was filled?

  I get to the bakery on time today. Lara comes in later on Saturdays, so I open the storefront myself and set up the front of house while I wait on Jen to come in. She and Carl trade off on Saturdays. Normally it should be a lighter load today, but after the delays yesterday, we’ll still need to work our asses off to catch up.

  I’m not looking forward to it.

  Lara keeps insisting we should hire a third assistant, or that I should let her help out in the kitchen. Or at least let Jen or Carl take over lead chef position once a week, as practice.

  “They’re good kids,” Lara keeps saying. “If you give them enough instruction, they can handle taking care of things for a day or two a week. To give you some time to recharge.”

  I know, deep down, that she’s right—I’ll have to let them take on more responsibility sooner or later. Lara can supervise them when I’m gone—and hell, at this point, Jen and Carl have been with us for so long that they could probably handle running the whole store on their own for a while if need be.

  But it’s so hard to trust anyone else with my baby. I built this company from scratch. It’s doing so well right now. But I’m all too aware of how fast successes like this can collapse in the food world. One wrong step, one terrible review, one vengeful customer with too much influence, and your whole empire can come crashing down around you.

  I refuse to let that happen to my baby. Which means I refuse to leave my baby in anyone else’s hands, even for a single day.

  Today, however, I’m distracted from said baby for once. It takes me three tries to count the register right, and I give up on balancing the account book entirely this morning. I’ll handle it in the afternoon, hopefully once my dose of caffeine kicks in, or once Lara shows up to smack my forehead and snap me back to reality.

  In the meantime, I can’t stop daydreaming.

  Reminiscing, really.

  Did last night really happen? It feels like a dream now, a distant fantasy that couldn’t possibly have been real. No way did I find a guy that hot, a guy who was into the same kinks as me, and willing to get so down and dirty with me in the bedroom. No, more than willing—excited to.

  That’s why they call them escorts, I remind myself. He’s paid to do that. To make me feel totally relaxed and at ease with myself. To make it seem like he’s feeling just as much as I am about our hot, wild night together.

  My belly tenses. I bet he’s off planning another wild night like that with some other client. I’m probably just one in a million women with freakish kinks who he’s banged.

  But something about it felt different. Felt like more than just a monetary exchange, a paid hookup.

  Unbidden, I find myself opening my phone and flipping through to the website. To ogling the photos on his profile again.

  Fucking hell, he looks even hotter in person than he does on this site.

  Still, he doesn’t look too shabby on here.

  I’m ogling one of his shirtless photos when Jen arrives and startles me into pocketing my phone.

  “You okay?” she asks, eying me strangely.

  “Of course!” I answer, my voice too high-pitched, my smile too wide. Really subtle.

  Luckily Jen has never been the curious type. We work side-by-side in the back for most of the morning. Then, at lunch break, I’m back to the same site, scrolling through the pictures again.

  My pussy tightens at the memory of the way his thick cock felt inside me. And his filthy mouth, goddamn. Or the way his cock tasted when he deep-throated me, my back pinned against the wall by that dildo…

  My clit throbs with need. Fuck. At this rate I’m going to have to sneak into the bathroom to rub one out.

  I duck out front, phone in hand, to avoid Jen stumbling across me again. And of course, I run smack into Lara coming in from the street, just arriving for her afternoon shift.

  “Hey, careful there,” she scolds as she catches my phone.

  I reach for it, flushing bright red.

  Too late.

  Lara squints at the screen. Her eyes go wide. Then her smirk does too. “Is this him, then?”

  “No,” I spit, grabbing the screen and turning it off. My cheeks are still telltale neon red. “Maybe,” I amend with a sigh.

  She laughs. “Well he’s definitely ripped. So how did telling him you weren’t interested anymore go?”

  I am in danger of setting this store on fire with my blush.

  Lara’s eyes widen all over again. Her mouth drops. “You didn’t.”

  “I…”

  “Oh my god. Look at your face.” She bursts into laughter. “Of course you did. Shit, girl, you are glowing.”

  “Shut up,” I mumble, waving a hand.

  “How was it?” She grabs my hand and, with a quick check over my shoulder at the back of the store where Jen is still busy working away, tugs me outside, to the safety of the parking lot out front. “Tell me everything,” she gushes.

  “It was… fucking amazing,” I admit.

  “Details,” she presses in a low whisper.

  My cheeks burn even brighter. “Hell no! TMI is a real thing, Lara.”

  “Oh god, you’re the worst. But fine, was he into the same stuff as you at least?”

  I swallow hard, and manage to nod.

  She beams. “That’s great! Hey, a guy just as insanely kinky as you, right? What is your thing, is it butt stuff?”

  I groan and wave a hand in her face. “Stop it, Lara.”

  “Foot fetish! I bet it’s a foot fetish.”

  I burst into laughter. “Stop guessing.”

  “Food? Maybe you like whipped cream smeared all over? I mean, you love baked goods…”

  “You are the absolute worst,” I mutter as I push past her and storm back into the bakery.

  “Well, at least you got your money’s worth, right?” she calls after me.

  That’s when I stumble over my own feet, halfway back into the front of the store. Because I realize… I never paid.

  At least, I don’t think I did? I never put my credit card on that website—I selected the cash payment option when it asked.

  “What’s wrong?” Lara comes up beside me to peer at my expression. “What, was it that pricey?”

  I shake my head. “It was fine,” I bluff. Then I sidestep her and pull up the site on my phone again, scrolling to payments. But nope, no card info. And I definitely chose cash. Damn. Maybe he charges me later, like an invoice or something? I refresh my email. But I don’t have any new messages from him. And I don’t have anything in my inbox about payments, either.

  Weird.

  Lara, for her part, has finally given up on asking questions, it seems. She turns to head back inside. “Well, at least you’ll be a little less of a stressball now,” she mumbles.

  I stick my tongue out at her backside. Then I head back into work, still refreshing my inbox. Still confused.

  That confusion only increases when an hour later, Lara ducks into the back room. “Carmine? Customer to see you.”

  I dust flour off my hands, run them under the tap quickly, and duck out of my apron to head to the front. Halfway out the door, though, I freeze.

  Lara leans in close, that mischievous grin on her face again. “Honestly, Carmine, way to pick ‘em. I didn’t even know guys like this existed in real life, but…”

  Across the shop, Caleb leans in the doorway. He’s dressed in even better clothes than he wore last night—a really nice shirt along with dress slacks. The shirt sets off his jawline, and makes his gray eyes seem even more piercing than usual as he grins at me. The lopsided grin isn’t helping my knees function properly either.

  “Is he as well-hung below the belt as above?” she whispers.

  I manage to stomp on her foot without giving too much away, I think.

/>   “Good morning,” I say when I’ve recovered enough to cross the store toward him.

  He takes a moment to let his gaze drift over my body in that way he has, drinking in every inch of me before he responds, the grin still on his sexy fucking mouth. “You look good today, Carmine.”

  “Back at you,” I respond, unable to help myself. “Tell me, do you always stalk your clients after encounters, or did you make a special visit just for me?”

  His eyes dart past me when I say the word client, probably looking for Lara. But she’s too good at reading situations to have stuck around for this—I know she ducked into the back room to give us privacy.

  Caleb relaxes a little. “It’s not normal practice, no. But then again, you aren’t normal, are you, dirty girl?”

  “Only as filthy as you,” I remind him, voice lowered so Lara won’t hear me from the back room.

  His grin widens. “Actually, I came to ask a favor.”

  “You never charged me,” I say, already reaching for my wallet. “Did you forget, or…?”

  But he’s shaking his head and wrapping a hand around mine, closing the wallet again between us. “I don’t want your money.”

  My heart leaps into my throat. “Why not?”

  “First round is free.” He winks.

  “Sounds like bad business practice to me,” I point out with a raised eyebrow. Mostly to disguise how hot that makes me feel. My pussy is already getting wet just at his proximity.

  He laughs and steps closer. His scent wraps around me, warm and familiar already, even after just one night together. “I’m kidding,” he says, and my heart sinks again.

  Damn.

  But he’s still holding my wallet shut.

  “I didn’t charge you because I need a favor,” he says.

  My brows contract, and I tilt my head with a frown.

  “My sister needs a cake for her daughter,” he explains. “It’s her birthday on Monday. She actually…” He glances past me at the calendar on the wall. “She actually already booked one with you guys, but you got in touch and said you needed to cancel it next week. You offered a huge discount on another cake at a later time, which, don’t get me wrong, we totally appreciate, but it’s my niece’s birthday, and she had her heart set on this cake…”