New Title 1

by Helen Hollick

  ‘I will enter Dinan in full armour on the morrow,’ William announced as he cleansed his fingers in the silver bowl held out to him by a servant.

  Could he hear the suffering? Harold wondered. Did it not stir his conscience?

  ‘You too, my friend, Earl Harold, must dress in splendour. We shall show this scum our superiority.’

  Poking a strand of meat from his teeth with his fingernail, Harold could not immediately answer. One woman’s frantic screams had risen above the other noises: ‘Ne touche pas l’enfant! Ne lui fait pas mal!’ Then they stopped abruptly. L’enfant est mort, Harold thought despairingly, wondered how old the child had been. His stomach was retching, yet he dare not show weakness to the Duke. He reached forward for his wine goblet, to rinse the foul taste from his mouth. He was also mildly embarrassed. He had no chain armour of the quality of William’s, nothing save for the iron-studded leather byrnie he wore. He flicked a glance at Will fitz Osbern, seated opposite, who, to give him his due, looked as green-sick as Harold himself must.

  ‘My Lord,’ fitz Osbern said quickly, ‘Earl Harold came to Normandy in peace and joined our venture merely as an observer. I believe he is unarmed.’

  ‘What? Has my bold companion not yet been suited with mail?’ William appeared genuinely taken aback that this had been overlooked. He thumped his fist on the table. ‘This will not do! My dear friend’ – he stalked around the table to Harold and offered him a modest bow of apology – ‘forgive this insult to your integrity and honour – and after your bravery at Mont Saint Michel too!’

  Further embarrassment overcame the Earl. While any man would covet the exquisitely made Norman armour, Harold possessed two full suits back home in England. Graciously he waved the Duke’s concern aside. ‘I have had no need of your fine workmanship, my Lord Duke,’ he answered with tact. ‘Besides, I am an Englishman, your guest, not a knight of your company.’

  William failed to catch the hint. ‘Well, sir, you ought to be!’ he responded, gesticulating for Harold to stand. Fists on hips, the Duke assessed Harold’s height, grunted approvingly.

  ‘Will, fetch me my own spare mail. We are not much different in build or height, you and I, Earl Harold. I will give you a suit of my own, as reward for your loyal service and your bravery. And as for the other . . .’ He drew his sword from the scabbard at his hip, commanded, ‘Kneel, sir, let me knight you!’

  Harold spread his hands, at a loss for what to say. ‘I thank you for your generosity, but —’

  The Duke thumped the table with his clenched fist. ‘Non! I have made up my mind to this!’

  Harold let his hands drop and peered in consternation at fitz Osbern who had conveniently already turned away to open the wooden coffer at the rear of the tent.

  Robert, comte de Mortain, Duke William’s second half-brother, William de Warenne and Walter Gifford, all sprang up from the table, cheering the sudden announcement: ‘Bravo!’

  Reluctantly, Harold accepted the Duke’s enthusiastic embrace and knelt before him to receive the investiture of arms. What choice had he but to accept the honour with grace? To refuse outright would be an insult, yet Harold had a shrewd suspicion that this seemingly impromptu performance had been well rehearsed. Why should William be so determined to knight a man of foreign birth who had no intention of fighting under the ducal banner? What advantage would it bring to Normandy?

  With foreboding, Harold placed his lips to the Duke’s ring, aware that to receive a knighthood was to pledge loyalty in return, to be bound as a liege man. And he was also aware, because his men had overheard the whispers, that William still nurtured the hope of laying claim to the English crown when Edward no longer needed it.

  In theory, as the Duke’s sworn man, Harold would be obliged to support William in that absurd intention. A theory with implications that Harold did not care to dwell upon.

  25

  Bayeux Promised a reunion with his kindred come the pre-Christmas gathering, Harold, who had begun to realise that Duke William’s promises were no more solid than waves running upon the seashore, was not in the least surprised to discover that only one of the boys appeared at Advent. His nephew Hakon came to the cathedral town of Bayeux, but not his brother Wulfnoth.

  ‘What of my brother and nephew?’ he had asked William during the ride home to Normandy after that ragged victory in Brittany.

  ‘Pardon?’ William had answered the Earl, his expression quizzical. ‘I know not what you mean?’

  Marvelling at his own patience, Harold had answered, ‘My brother and my nephew. Held hostage in Normandy this many a year. I wish to see them. It is, as I told you, the purpose of my visit.’

  Already he had tarried here in Normandy too long. The assault into Brittany, while interesting to observe, had achieved very little as far as Harold could see – and now this wearisome delay until the December Court.

  Conan had fled deeper into his Breton lands, where it was too dangerous for William to pursue. He had achieved the restoration of Dol and the submission of Dinan, bringing a few miles of Brittany under Norman control, but for how long? Harold saw a parallel to the English war with Gruffydd of Wales, the incessant border conflict, tit-for-tat raiding, exasperating skirmishes. Conan remained free to taunt the Duke if it suited him; had William sued for agreement before chasing his opponent into a burrow too deep to dig out of . . . ah well, that was William’s problem. Once Harold had secured the release of his two lads, he would head straight home for England, happily leaving the Duke to fend for his own future.

  On that mid-September ride home from Dinan the frown had deepened across the Duke’s brow as he had considered Harold’s question. ‘Have they not yet been brought to court?’ he had said with puzzlement to William fitz Osbern. ‘I surely issued orders soon after our guest arrived?’

  Harold suppressed a sigh. Norman procrastination. He was damned sick of it!

  Fitz Osbern had responded with his usual diplomacy: ‘You were about to, my Lord, but the matter of Conan suddenly arose. Many pressing matters were left untended, I believe.’

  ‘Ah, there you have it then, mon brave!’ William had answered with a smooth smile. ‘Let us return into Normandy and announce my victory. Later I shall send for your kindred. You have my word.’

  Later? Aye, if empty Norman promises permitted it.

  Bayeux was a rich, almost gold-gilded town dominated by the towering splendour of its elaborate cathedral – and equally elaborately attired bishop, Odo, Duke William’s eldest half-brother. Yet Harold was not impressed: the outward sheen of wealth belied the underlying stink of bad drainage and peasant poverty. Nor did he care for the portly bishop, a pompous, odious man.

  Odo was three years William’s junior, born to their mother Herleve soon after her marriage to Herluin, vicomte de Conteville. The two half-brothers shared the same arrogance but nothing else of likeness, except perhaps a similarity of hair colouring. Where William was tall and muscular, Odo stood a mere inch above five and one half feet, his lack of manly height emphasised by his stout bulk. Whereas William at least had the right to unquestioned respect, Odo’s haughty demand for deference stuck in Harold’s throat like a scratching fish bone. Where was the humility of a man who served God? The caring for the poor and sick, the devotion to the teachings of Christ? Ah, no, Bishop Odo cherished nothing more than the rich pickings of this worldly life.

  Without Harold being informed of his coming, Hakon arrived at Bayeux as another swirl of winter rain, heavier and more persistent, lashed across the courtyard. Duke William had not met Hakon before, for both hostages had been kept at various lodgings within the houses of lesser nobility. Harold had last seen him in England as a child of six years.

  Although the solar was more comfortable than the public Hall below, Harold felt tense and restless. He wanted to be surrounded by his own family, relaxing within his own manor. Edyth’s solar was so much more tastefully arranged than this rather carelessly furnished room. Harold could only conclude this was beca
use the Bishop had no wife to make the place into a home. Although he did have a woman, a black-haired mistress, or so Harold’s men had overheard. That was nothing unusual; only the most devout of clerics practised what they preached, and Odo, Harold reckoned, rarely even preached unless it were for his own gain.

  The afternoon stretched ahead with no promise of relief. Harold was bored. He knew few of the men present and apart from the Duchess Mathilda, Norman ladies rarely spoke to him. No doubt the rumours that Englishmen ate Frenchwomen for breakfast had affected what little manners these Norman noblewomen possessed.

  A tall, slim-built young man with a tumble of fair hair worn in the English style entered and was escorted before William. The newcomer bowed, though not with the reverence usually shown to the Duke. There was something about him that attracted Harold’s attention. His stance, his build . . . when William pointed in the Earl’s direction and the lad turned to face him, Harold smiled and began immediately to move through the clustered groups of men and women, his hand reaching forward to greet his nephew. Seventeen years of age and the image of his father! Harold would have known the lad anywhere, so like Swegn was he, even down to the hauteur in his narrowed dark eyes and the pointed refusal to clasp hands in greeting.

  ‘Voilà! Your nephew, my Earl Harold, as promised.’ The Duke looked smug as he indicated that the lad might go with the Earl, but added in a deliberately loud voice, ‘Though the lad seems none too pleased to be here!’

  Hakon’s disgruntled expression was evident to all who were watching. ‘So you have remembered my existence at last,’ he drawled, not caring for the interest he was stirring, looking Harold up and down as if he were judging whether an ox be suited for the plough or the cooking pit. ‘Why? What has brought you here to seek me out? Do you come to gloat at my predicament? Placate me with apologies and regrets for not coming ere now?’ He stood two feet from Harold, arms folded, head raised high. Angry.

  Aware of the intrigued audience, Harold nodded briefly in acknowledgement of the Duke’s dismissal and forcibly steered the lad away into the relative privacy of a window recess. ‘Hush, man,’ he chided, matching Hakon’s anger. ‘Do you want this court to hear every word? You do not want the Duke to misinterpret your behaviour.’

  ‘You tell me that?’ Hakon retorted, his mouth twisting, fists clenched. ‘There is very little that I have not learnt of William these past years. Not least that once in his clutch the snare will never be sprung.’

  ‘It is not my fault you have been kept here for so long,’ Harold hissed. Through eleven years had he been pleading for Hakon’s plight and now, when they were here, face to face, they were arguing. Christ’s blood, how William must be enjoying the spectacle! At that, Harold glanced quickly over his shoulder at the Duke, saw that aye, he was watching with an amused smile. He took a breath and calmed his misplaced surge of anger. ‘We have repeatedly attempted to negotiate your return.’ He indicated Hakon’s clothing, the fine leather of his boots and the gold brooch fastening his woollen cloak. ‘You do not appear too badly treated. You have not been left to rot in a dungeon as others less fortunate have.’

  ‘There are many forms of imprisonment; a dungeon is not obligatory. Being unable to ride where you will, write or receive letters without first having them read by the censoring eyes of others. Being shepherded day and night, aye, even to the privy or the flea-hopping bed of a tavern whore. That, my Lord Earl, is imprisonment.’

  Harold laid a placating hand on Hakon’s arm and said, with sorrow, ‘It was not of my doing that you came to be a hostage Hakon. The events of 1053 were beyond our control. Everything was chaos, we were tossed hither and thither like autumn leaves torn from their branch by a gale, swirled high then abandoned once the storm was over.’

  ‘Aye,’ Hakon snorted, shrugging off Harold’s touch, ‘and no one came to sweep the remains into a tidy pile. The household left the detritus to rot in the courtyard.’

  Fighting his inclination to walk away from the youth, Harold smothered his ire. The lad was hurting, confused and, aye, even though he had been well treated, angry at being abandoned to the mercy of Normandy. What else could Harold expect? It occurred to him that in this, too, Hakon was much like his father, who had been so given to unreasonable outbursts. But then, unlike his father, Hakon had just cause.

  ‘You undervalue yourself, lad,’ Harold commented, calling on all his reserves of patience. ‘My mother, your grandmother, has one of the finest gardens that I have had the privilege to wander in. Her roses smell sweet in summer, the bees swarm to the herbs and flowers. To create such beauty she enriches the soil with compost made from fallen leaves. It is a fact, my lad, that what may be discarded by one is highly prized by another.’ Harold met Hakon’s eyes. Had the lad understood his metaphor?

  To his delight, Hakon relented; his shoulders sagged, his head with its jutting chin and blazing eyes lowered, the defiance gone.

  Harold held out his hand as an offering of peace and friendship. ‘It was not my fault, Hakon, that you were sent here, but it is my fault that you have been left mouldering for so long. I am here to rectify that. For you, and for my brother.’ He glanced again at William, attracting Hakon’s attention to the interest the Duke was taking in their contretemps. ‘I would not wish the Bastard to achieve his intention of alienating kindred from kindred.’

  Hakon immediately understood, regretted his churlishness. Slowly he took his uncle’s hand. Found suddenly a burst of pleasure at having contact with someone on his own side, someone, alone in this entire duchy, on whom he could count. At last a friend for the sake of friendship alone. The lad attempted a tentative smile. He would never oblige William the Bastard. ‘Nor I, Uncle, most certainly, nor I.’ Was rewarded by Harold’s wider grin and a sudden fond embrace.

  Releasing Hakon, but keeping hold of his arms, Harold said solemnly, ‘You will be returning with me into England, that I promise.’

  ‘Returning? What, tired of us already?’ the conceited voice boomed loud behind them, a plump hand descending on to Harold’s shoulder, remaining clamped there, unwelcome but immovable. Odo, Bishop of Bayeux. Harold gritted his teeth.

  With a guffaw that held more malice than jest, Odo announced scathingly, ‘You will not be returning anywhere these next few days I fancy, my dear Earl, not with this wind and rain. We’re in for a storm, I reckon. Besides – the Duke expects you to make merry with us. I expect it.’ His small eyes – pig-like eyes, Harold thought – bored into Hakon’s a moment, then flickered to Harold. His head nodded once to emphasise his point, then he walked away.

  ‘As I said,’ Hakon remarked drily, ‘not all prisons have metal grilles and bolted doors.’

  ‘Ah, but I am no prisoner!’ Harold objected.

  Hakon shrugged. ‘Are you not? Try leaving.’

  During the next few days Harold forced his nephew’s warning from his mind, but the doubt had been planted. On how many occasions had Harold implied he was considering leaving Normandy? How many times, in return, had William – or Duchess Mathilda with her smiling eyes and fluttering lashes – persuaded him to stay a while longer? Unease lay heavy in Harold’s stomach. On reflection, he realised the suspicion had been there from the very first, but had been lulled by the flattery and friendship of the Duke and his lady.

  Why had William been so intent on rescuing him, so urgently, from Guy de Ponthieu? Because, as he had indicated, he would tolerate no form of disobedience from his sworn vassals? Harold had believed the claim then, believed it, in part, still, for the Duke had, most assuredly, been angry at the humiliation Harold had suffered. It would not do for one country at will to imprison visiting dignitaries for ransom. No trade, no alliance – no outward semblance of trust – would coexist between one realm and another.

  Yet, had William realised the potential of holding such a prestigious hostage for himself? If Guy de Ponthieu could exact ransom, then so, too, could the Duke of Normandy. Perhaps not a monetary one, but something more valuable to an amb
itious man. If holding a nephew and youngest brother had, for all these years, served a purpose for William, how much more useful would a king’s most trusted earl be?

  This visit of Harold’s had no diplomatic motive, no treaty with England or Edward to discuss, yet William had welcomed Harold to court as if he were a long-lost brother. Why? Once roused, suspicion was difficult to eradicate, especially when the evidence began to emerge with sudden and startling clarity.

  Friday, a day of obligatory fasting, was nearly completed. Once the final prayers of the Evening Mass had been intoned in the distinctly damp and cold cavern of Bayeux Cathedral, the deprivations of the day could be relaxed. Before making his way to the cathedral, Harold had tried something that he had hoped would send this gnawing fear scuttling back into the shadows. He had ordered a horse saddled and, riding alone save for one servant, had gone out beneath the gate of the Bishop’s palace. No one had stopped him, no guard had barred his way. Through the narrow streets of Bayeux he had ridden at a sedate walk, the flare of the servant’s torch flickering in the buffeting wind and with each hiss of rain that scorched the burning resin. The town’s gates were, of course, barred once night had come. Harold had demanded they be opened for him. The watch had stamped to attention, but made no move to lift the heavy wooden bars.

  ‘I need to leave immediately,’ Harold had said. ‘I demand you allow me exit.’

  The guard had looked uneasily from one man to another; relief appeared on their faces when an officer stepped from the guardroom.

  ‘My Lord forgive me, but I cannot open these doors at this hour of the night without express command from my duke or his brother the Bishop.’

  ‘But I am Earl Harold of Wessex, England.’

  ‘I cannot, sir. Fetch word from the Duke, then I shall be glad to oblige.’

  Furious, Harold had returned to the cathedral, all the while telling himself that the watch were indeed being reasonable. Once the gates to a town were secured, rarely were they opened.