Playing to Win

by Becca Van

  Jake scrutinized her face just to be sure she wasn’t downplaying with words and was thankful she didn’t seem to be in any pain. While he hated seeing the waterproof patches on her chin and side and the cast on her arm, he was grateful she hadn’t been injured worse. He also realized that Cindy must have a very high pain threshold. He was sure if any other woman had sustained the injuries she had, they would have been resting up in bed.

  He felt a little guilty for wanting to make love with her and make her his woman, after both of his older brothers had already done so, but he wasn’t sure he was selfless enough to wait for another day. That was unless Cindy decided she needed to rest. He’d do anything to keep her happy. Her health and well-being, her wants and needs, came first always.

  “Let me wash you, darlin’,” Curt said as he reached for the sponge and body wash.

  After squirting some liquid soap onto the loofah, he ran it over Cindy’s neck and shoulders. When Curt got lower, washing her breasts, she gasped. Jake stared at her breasts, swallowing back a groan when he saw how hard her nipples were. They were a darker-hued pink than they had been and he hoped they weren’t too tender.

  Curt must have thought the same. “Are your nipples tender, Cindy?”

  She shook her head. “Sensitive.”

  Curt reached under the water with sponge and washed between Cindy’s legs. When his brother had finished bathing her front, Jake clasped her hips, lifted, and turned her before lowering her back onto his lap. Her small hand splayed on his chest as she stared into his eyes while sitting astride his hips. He closed his eyes and tried to control his escalating breathing when he felt her pussy pressed up against his cock. His dick had started going down while he covered her cast with the plastic bag but had quickly come back to life when he’d watched Curt wash her.

  “Do you want me, Jake?” Cindy whispered her question as she pressed kisses to his chest.

  A shudder ripped up his spine when she licked over one of his nipples. Only one woman had ever done that before, and he’d felt absolutely nothing. Having the love of his life do it was a totally different story. His cock twitched when she laved her tongue over the small hard nub again, and when she nipped it between her teeth, he swore he almost came.

  “So fucking much I ache,” he managed to answer raspingly.

  “Good.”

  Cindy raised up higher onto her knees, grasped his dick, and aligned the head with her pussy. He barely had time to draw a breath before she was sinking down over his shaft. He groaned as her wet heat enveloped his throbbing cock. She took a few inches of his shaft into her body, lifted up, and then dropped down onto his dick hard and fast, taking him all the way inside of her.

  “Fuck!” Jake blew out a breath, trying to curb the ravaging need heating his blood.

  “Our woman is the sexiest woman alive,” Curt said hoarsely.

  “On that…we’re in total agreement.”

  “Curt?” Cindy said.

  “Yeah, darlin’?”

  “I need you, too.”

  Cindy’s words almost sent him over the edge again. She was staring at Curt with so much hunger he was sure he could see flames flickering in her brown eyes.

  “Are you sure, Cindy?” Curt rasped out.

  “Yes.” She nodded emphatically. “I’m more than sure.”

  “So you liked it when Grant fucked your ass with his thumb?” Jake asked.

  “No,” Cindy answered. “I didn’t like it. I loved it!”

  “You are so fucking perfect, darlin’.” Curt kissed her on the shoulder, caressed a hand down her back, and massaged her ass. He stood, stepped out onto the bathmat, wiped his feet, and then rushed over to the vanity. When he turned back to the tub, he had a condom in one hand and lube in the other. Curt stepped into the tub, placed the rubber and lube on the edge of the bath, and then knelt behind her. “You are the sexiest fucking woman.” He caressed his hands up and down her back and then squeezed her ass cheeks. “I love this ass, darlin’. So toned, cute, and peach-shaped. Every time I look at it, I crave a taste, a bite.”

  “Oh,” Cindy moaned.

  Jake groaned when she clenched her pussy around his dick. He swallowed, met Curt’s gaze, and nodded at his brother to hurry the fuck up. He was so fucking hard, hot, and horny, he wasn’t sure he was going to last the distance, but there was no fucking way he was shooting off first.

  He wrapped an arm around Cindy’s waist, making sure he didn’t go anywhere near her stitches, threaded his fingers into her hair, raising her face up to his, and kissed her.

  * * * *

  Although Cindy was nervous, she wanted this more than anything. She was so needy for Jake and Curt, she was trembling. When Jake opened his mouth over hers, she clung to his shoulder and kissed him back hungrily. Their tongues dancing and tangling with an eroticism so carnal, she was sure she was going up on flames.

  She shivered when the hair on Curt’s chest brushed up against her back and gasped when he pulled her butt cheeks apart. While she didn’t mean to, she held her breath when she felt a slick finger caress over her star. Even though she’d been dreaming about an exclusive loving ménage relationship for years, she’d always been worried that she wouldn’t like or enjoy anal play. Luckily for her and her men, that wasn’t the case.

  “Breathe, honey,” Jake ordered as he cupped her cheek.

  She exhaled and inhaled then did so again and again. The tension she hadn’t been aware of in her muscles waned, and she moaned when he pressed his finger into her ass. She loved the tingly burning sensation of having the sensitive tissues of her star stretching and couldn’t wait to be filled to the brim with cock.

  She closed her eyes, savoring each stroke of Curt’s finger into her ass and how good it felt. When he pulled his finger out, she opened her eyes and locked gazes with Jake again.

  “Jake, sit up on the edge of the tub,” Curt said hoarsely. “I don’t want the bathwater washing away the lube.”

  Jake tightened his arm around her waist, smoothed a hand down her back, and gripped her ass. She wrapped her good arm around his neck, resting her cast on his shoulder, and hooked her legs around his waist, just before he surged up to his feet, taking her with him. He hissed out a breath when he sat on the rim of the tub, and even though she tried to stifle her giggle over his discomfit, it escaped.

  “Think that’s funny, do you?” Jake winked at her.

  Cindy nodded.

  “I’ll remember that, honey. Next time I put you on the counter, I’m not getting a towel for you to sit on.”

  Cindy grinned and shrugged. Goose bumps raced over her flesh when Curt kissed her shoulder. “Keep your eyes on Jake, darlin’. Okay?”

  “Okay.”

  Curt tickled two lube-coated fingers against her ass, and she sucked in a noisy breath. Though her eyelids grew heavy, she kept them open and her gaze locked with Jake’s. She loved looking into her men’s eyes. Someone—she had no idea who—had once said that the eyes were the window to the soul, and while she wasn’t sure that was exactly right, it was close. All the Kenny men looked at her with such hunger and emotion. Even though she couldn’t discern their feelings, she had a feeling that they at least cared for her a little. If they didn’t, surely they wouldn’t have pursued her and made love with her.

  “Oh!” she moaned when Curt pressed his fingers into her ass. The burning sensation was a little stronger as her flesh parted to admit his erotic intrusion, but it wasn’t really painful. Her inner muscles spasmed, causing her pussy to ripple around and clamp down on Jake’s hard dick.

  “Fuck, honey. I love how you keep squeezing my cock. I can’t wait until you’re coming all over me.”

  “Shut the fuck up, Jake,” Curt growled. “I’m on the edge already, and I’m not even inside of her yet.”

  “How the fuck do you think I feel?” Jake snarled.

  “Hey, maybe we should just forget it,” Cindy said, tensing as she prepared to pull of Jake’s erection. She didn’t like to h
ear them angry at each other. This was one of her biggest worries over being in a ménage. She didn’t want, hated to think that she’d come between brothers, family members, and cause a cataclysmic rift.

  “We aren’t angry, darlin’.” Curt leaned around toward her.

  Cindy stared into his eyes. He held her gaze steadily.

  “We’re not. I promise. We’re just eager and famished for you.”

  “Curt’s right, honey.” Jake swept his thumb back and forth over her skin.

  “Then let’s get this show on the road,” Cindy said. She was relieved that the brothers weren’t fighting over her, and she was just as excited and needy as they were, which was a shock considering she’d already had sex with their two eldest brothers.

  Jake cupped her breasts, caressing and kneading them as he peppered kissed down her neck and lower.

  Curt slowly worked his two fingers in and out of her ass until they were in as far as they could go. He pumped them a few times and spread his fingers to stretch out her tight muscles. Withdrawing them, she heard him pop open the tube of lube, and then he was back with three fingers. This time the burning pain was more intense, but it ratcheted her arousal up higher.

  She gasped and moaned as Curt began to pump his fingers until finally he had all three inside her ass. Cindy felt so stuffed full, but it was a pleasurable feeling. She couldn’t wait until Curt had his cock deep in her rear entrance. Couldn’t wait until he and Jake made love to her for the first time.

  Cindy wanted it all, and she wanted it now.

  She couldn’t help but close her eyes when Jake pulled a nipple into her mouth, suckling strongly on the hard nub. Each time he drew on the sensitive peak, arcs of stimuli shot from her breast to her pussy, causing her to clench. She was so wet she was dripping.

  Curt withdrew his fingers from her ass, and a few moments later, she felt the head of his condom-and-lubed-covered cock against her star. Jake released her nipple with a pop, grasped one hip, and cupped the back of her neck with the other. She nodded to let him know she knew what he wanted and kept her eyes on his.

  “Take a deep breath for me, Cindy,” Curt ordered.

  After exhaling, she inhaled deeply, filling her lungs, and gasped out when Curt pressed firmly against her asshole. “Keep breathing, honey,” Jake said. “If you can, keep your muscles loose. It might help if you push back against him.”

  Cindy licked her dry lips, nodded, drew in another breath, relaxed, and bore down.

  “Fuck!” Curt groaned as his dick sank inches into her ass.

  Cindy felt spread to the limit, but it felt so good. Nerves she hadn’t realized existed came to life. She wanted to shove back toward Curt and take his cock all the way into her ass, but she didn’t want to hurt herself. This was another first for her, and she wanted to be able to look back on this moment with a smile. She wanted to remember the pleasure and joy her men bestowed on her and she bestowed on them.

  Cindy prayed that this relationship worked out and was the one and only she’d ever have, but she couldn’t see the future, didn’t know what was around the corner. She wanted to be with them for the rest of her life, but she didn’t know if they felt the same.

  If this didn’t work out, if they broke her heart, she’d never want to be in another relationship or have another man or men touch and kiss her. The thought made her feel sick to her stomach.

  Even though it shocked her to feel so much so quickly, Cindy knew she was in love with Shane, Grant, Jake, and Curt. They were it for her no matter what happened.

  All her thoughts fled when Curt stroked his cock into her deeper and deeper until finally he was in her ass balls-deep.

  “You okay, darlin’?” Curt gasped out.

  “Yeah,” she moaned. “You’re both so hot and hard. I can’t believe how good you both feel.”

  “It’s about to get better, honey.” Jake kneaded a breast and then pinched and plucked at her nipple.

  Curt gripped one of her ass cheeks firmly. Then he slowly withdrew his dick from her ass to the tip. As he pushed back in, Jake retreated from her pussy and then stroked back in.

  Cindy groaned as pleasure assailed both her channels. It felt so amazing, so carnally mystical, she couldn’t wait until they were moving faster, harder, and deeper. She wanted them to lose all that self-control and let go. She wanted Jake and Curt to fuck her so good that she and them, came screaming.

  Each time the men pumped their hips, they incrementally increased the pace until their bodies were slapping against hers. The friction of their cocks sliding in and out of her pussy and ass was so beautiful, so erotic, and so intimate. She’d never felt so close to a person until she’d made love with first Shane, then Grant, and now Jake and Curt. Her heart was so full of emotion, and she felt as if her soul was reaching out to theirs. The intimacy of making love, the powerful, emotional connection was something she couldn’t have imagined let alone explain.

  With each glide of their dicks into and out of her pussy and ass, the pressure inside grew higher. The embers that had flared into flames leapt higher and higher. Tension invaded her muscles, her body, as she moved up the steep slope toward the summit.

  Jake tugged at her hair, tilting her face up to his, and kissed her ravenously. He swept his tongue into and around her mouth, then tangled with hers.

  Curt cupped a breast from behind, gripped her nipple between his finger and thumb, and squeezed. Shots of pleasure sparked down to her womb, pussy, and clit.

  She gasped in a breath when Jake released her lips. Then he lowered his head and latched onto her other nipple with his mouth, laving his tongue over the sensitive nub before flicking it back and forth it with the tip.

  “So fucking hot and tight,” Curt stated raspingly. “You feel so fucking good, darlin’.”

  Cindy could feel herself getting closer and closer to ecstasy, but she wasn’t sure if her men were too since she wasn’t experienced. However, she was determined to take them with her when she flew.

  Gripping Jake’s shoulder, she waited until she had their rhythm down and then she started moving with them. Forward and back, up and down, she moved, taking first Curt’s cock deep into her ass, then Jake’s into her pussy.

  The invisible corkscrew wound tighter and tighter until the spring was so tight, she was sure it was about to break.

  Jake released the nipple he’d been sucking on and then pressed his lips to hers again. Curt surged harder and faster into her ass. Jake drove his dick into her pussy, and just as she was hovering on the edge of rapture, both men stopped, holding still.

  Cindy drew in a breath, just about to yell at them to move, but before she could speak, they rocked their hips rapidly, pistoning their dicks into and out of her ass and pussy, harder, faster and deeper, at the same time.

  Cindy was either nearly almost empty or filled to the brim.

  She moaned and groaned, digging her nails into Jake’s shoulder as she began to tremble harder. Jake caressed his hand down from her breast, skimming his palm over her nipple and down lower. A shiver wracked her frame when his fingers brushed against her trimmed pubes, and then he pressed the pad of his finger over her clit.

  She gulped in air and just before she exhaled Jake squeezed her clit between his finger and thumb.

  “Jake! Curt!” Cindy screamed as she tumbled over into rapture.

  Her whole body quivered and quaked with nirvana. Her inner muscles spasmed, clenched, and released around the two cocks still plunging in and out of her ass and pussy.

  “Fuck yeah,” Jake groaned. “You got me there, honey. Cindy!”

  “I’m gonna…Cindy!” Curt shouted as he too climaxed.

  She felt each twitch and pulse of their cocks as their cum spumed up their shafts and into her pussy and ass. Even with Curt wearing a rubber, she felt the heat of his semen as it jetted into the end of the condom.

  Aftershocks shook her body each time their dicks jolted inside of her.

  As the pleasure faded, leaving p
leasurable tingles in its wake, she panted and tried to catch her breath. Tears of joy stung her eyes, but she pushed them away. She didn’t want her men to see her crying, even if they were happy tears, since they were likely to misconstrue them and think they’d hurt her. That was the last thing she wanted.

  Cindy hadn’t even noticed she’d all but collapsed onto Jake, her cheek resting on his chest until he caressed a hand over her head and down her back.

  “That was amazing, darlin’.” Curt kissed her shoulder, and then they both moaned as he eased his softening cock from her ass. “Thank you for trusting me.”

  Cindy lifted her head from Jake’s chest, turned, and met Curt’s gaze over her shoulder. He smiled and gave her a playful wink. She smiled back.

  “Let’s get you cleaned up, honey.” Jake held her against him as he slipped back into the bath. Her flesh pebbled as the warmth of the water seeped into her cooler skin. “Are you cold, Cindy?”

  “No.” Cindy had never been so warm in her life, and it had nothing to do with the ambient or water temperature, but everything to do with what was in her heart.

  She was in love and hoped, prayed, that the Kenny brothers would end up loving her in return.

  If they didn’t, she’d be devastated.

  Cindy was sure she’d die if they didn’t love her as much as she loved them.

  A knot of dread formed in her stomach, and though she tried to shove it away, it wouldn’t budge.

  Was she feeling scared because she wasn’t sure they loved her back, or for another reason entirely?

  Chapter Fifteen

  Shane wasn’t sure it was a good idea for Cindy to be going to work so soon after being injured, but she was determined.

  “I’m fine, Shane.” She held his gaze with hers. “My arm isn’t even hurting.”

  “What if one of the kids needs help with something?” he asked. “You only have the use of one hand. I don’t want you hurting yourself.”

  “I can ask one or both of the kids’ moms to help out. I’m sure they won’t mind.”

  Shane sighed as he ran his fingers through his hair. While he and his brothers would be close by, they wouldn’t be able to see her and help her if she needed it. He hated that she was so determined to work, even if he understood it.