A Tale of Two Hearts

by Michelle Griep

  PRAISE FOR A TALE OF TWO HEARTS

  A lovely tale of second chances, surprises, and love that will leave you with a sweet sigh of satisfaction. Perfect for Dickens fans at Christmas or any time of year.

  —Julie Klassen, bestselling author

  Michelle has an incredible knack of being able to twist mystery, romance, and historical detail into a giant ball of extraordinary fun! Not to be missed by fans of Dickens. Or anyone else for that matter!

  —MaryLu Tyndall, bestselling author of the Legacy of the King’s Pirates series

  A Tale of Two Hearts invites your heart to go on a wild roller-coaster ride. Trapped in a lie, can they find their way out before irreparable damage is done? Add to the plot sweet Uncle Barlow, adorable Miss Whymsy, and a pair of deplorable cousins, and you’ve got a story your heart won’t forget.

  —Ane Mulligan, award-winning author of the Chapel Springs series

  A Dickensian delight! Victorian London and the characters within come alive within these pages. I thoroughly enjoyed riding the characters coattails through bustling streets between the Golden Egg Inn, Purcell’s Tea Room, and more as they wove a tangled web of their own design—and then desperately tried to unravel it before falling through the strands. A refreshing tale perfectly paired with a cup of Christmas tea.

  —Jocelyn Green, award-winning author of A Refuge Assured

  When a seemingly harmless deception escalates to alarming proportions, the characters in A Tale of Two Hearts are forced to question their values and decide if sacrificing their integrity justifies the altruistic outcome. This delightful story combines a host of interesting characters, fresh writing, and a heartwarming ending that will leave the reader smiling.

  —Susan Anne Mason, award-winning author of Irish Meadows and A Most Noble Heir

  In A Tale of Two Hearts, Michelle Griep tells a skillfully woven tale both elegant and heartwarming. Charles Dickens would be delighted with the way she tucked into this story’s pockets truths and observations he penned long ago. Highly recommended reading, no matter the season.

  —Cynthia Ruchti, author of An Endless Christmas, Restoring Christmas, and more than twenty other novels and nonfiction

  Delightful Christmas fare perfect for fans of English historicals, brimful with Dickensian details and the beautiful Christian truth of second chances.

  —Carolyn Miller, author of Regency Brides: Legacy of Grace and Regency Brides: A Promise of Hope series

  I have found another favorite author and it’s Michelle Griep. With an incredible ability to spin a beautiful tale, Griep sucked me into the story from the very first paragraph. From the historical detail to the English setting to the unforgettable and enjoyable characters, I didn’t want to put this book down. William and Mina will stick with me for a long time. This will be a story to read again and again. And now I’m off to find every Michelle Griep book I can get my hands on.

  —Kimberley Woodhouse, bestselling author

  Just when you think you’re about to embark on a cheeky, fun Christmas lark, you realize what a multifaceted, complex story Griep has crafted. With characterizations Dickens would envy, and bright, fresh writing that pulls you in, A Tale of Two Hearts will have you cheering on Mina and William and appreciating the skill with which they have been wrought.

  —Erica Vetsch, author of A Perfect Christmas in The Victorian Christmas Brides Collection

  A heartwarming tale of second chances coming from the least expected places. I loved the many nods to Dickens and the inventive twists on a few other classics. In A Tale of Two Hearts, romance isn’t only for the young, and fresh starts aren’t only for the faultless. An uplifting and charming holiday story!

  —Jennifer Delamere, author of The Captain’s Daughter

  © 2018 by Michelle Griep

  Print ISBN 978-1-68322-259-0

  eBook Editions:

  Adobe Digital Edition (.epub) 978-1-68322-912-4

  Kindle and MobiPocket Edition (.prc) 978-1-68322-913-1

  All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted for commercial purposes, except for brief quotations in printed reviews, without written permission of the publisher.

  This book is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents are either products of the author’s imagination or used fictitiously.

  Any similarity to actual people, organizations, and/or events is purely coincidental.

  Cover Design: Kirk DouPonce, DogEared Design

  Published by Shiloh Run Press, an imprint of Barbour Publishing, Inc., 1810 Barbour Drive, Uhrichsville, Ohio 44683, www.shilohrunpress.com

  Our mission is to inspire the world with the life-changing message of the Bible.

  Printed in Canada.

  CONTENTS

  Chapter 1

  Chapter 2

  Chapter 3

  Chapter 4

  Chapter 5

  Chapter 6

  Chapter 7

  Chapter 8

  Chapter 9

  Chapter 10

  Chapter 11

  Chapter 12

  Chapter 13

  Chapter 14

  Chapter 15

  Chapter 16

  Chapter 17

  Chapter 18

  Chapter 19

  Chapter 20

  Chapter 21

  Chapter 22

  Chapter 23

  Chapter 24

  Chapter 25

  Chapter 26

  Chapter 27

  Chapter 28

  Chapter 29

  Chapter 30

  On a stormy night

  two thousand years ago,

  a babe was born

  and in a land far from that rugged stable

  a coin was forged -

  both the bearers of a second chance.

  The God-man returned to heaven,

  but the coin yet roams the earth,

  passing from hand to hand,

  hope to hope…

  DEDICATION

  To Jan Miller—my Effie kind of friend. And as always,

  to the One who not only gives me second

  chances but oh so much more—Jesus.

  CHAPTER ONE

  London, 1853

  Whether I shall turn out to be the hero of my own life, or whether that station will be held by anybody else, these pages must show.

  David Copperfield

  In the tiny back courtyard of the Golden Egg Inn, Mina Scott lowered her copy of David Copperfield to her lap and lifted her face to the October sun. Closing her eyes, she savored the warmth and the first line to a new adventure, as was her wont whenever Miss Whymsy stopped by and lent her a book. Though she no longer stared at the page, the shapes of the words lingered, blazed in stark contrast to the brilliance against her lids. What a curious thought, to be one’s own hero—for the only hero she wanted was William Barlow.

  Ahh, William. Just thinking his name lit a fire in her belly.

  “Mina!”

  She shot to her feet, and the book plummeted to the ground. Her stomach dropped along with it—both for being caught idle and for the dirt smudges sure to mar the cover. With her toe, she slid the novel beneath her skirt hem, then patted her pocket to make sure the note Miss Whymsy had left behind hadn’t fallen out as well. The small, folded paper crinkled beneath her touch, hidden and snug. Satisfied, she faced her father.

  Jasper Scott, master of the inn and commander of her life, fisted hands the size of kidney pies at his hips. “What are ye doin’ out in the yard, girl, when ye ought to be serving?”

  She dipped her chin. “It’s hardly teatime, Father. I thought to take a break before customers arrived.” From the peak of the inn’s rooftop, a swallow not yet flown to war
mer climates chided the frail excuse. Not that she blamed the bird. It was a pitiful defense.

  Her father fumbled his big fingers inside a small pocket on his waistcoat and pulled out a worn brass pocket watch. He flipped open the lid—and the whole thing fell to the ground. “Oh, bother!”

  As he bent to pick it up, she stifled a smile. How large Father’s grin would be on Christmas Eve when he opened the new watch fob she’d been saving all her pennies for.

  Swiping up the dropped watch, Father first frowned at the time, then at her. “It’s past tea.” He snapped the timepiece shut and tucked it away. “I wager ye were reading again. Am I right?”

  How did he know? How did he always know?

  Slowly, she retrieved the book and held it out. “Maybe you ought to keep this until we close tonight.”

  “I thought as much when Miss Whymsy stopped by. Keep your head in the world, girl, not in the clouds. Ye’ll never get a husband that way.” He snatched the novel from her hand. “And besides that, this being the last day o’ October, ye must turn yer sights away from make-believe tales and toward Christmas. Only a little over seven weeks remain to make this the best celebration the Golden Egg has ever seen, so ye must focus, girl. Now off with ye. There are patrons already clamoring for a whistle wetting.”

  “Yes, Father.” She scurried past him. Since she’d been a little girl, the annual Christmas Eve celebration at the Golden Egg meant everything to Father. ’Twas a poor replacement for her departed mother, but a replacement, she supposed, nonetheless. She darted through the back door and nearly crashed into Martha, the inn’s cook.

  “Peas and porridge!” Martha stepped aside, the water in her pot sloshing over the rim and dampening the flagstones. “Watch yer step, missy.”

  “Sorry, Martha.” Giving the woman a wider berth, she grabbed her apron from a peg and a cloth for wiping tables, then scooted out to the taproom.

  Once she entered the public area, she slowed her steps and drew a deep breath. No one liked to be waited upon by a ruddy-cheeked snippet of a skirt. Scanning the room, she frowned. Only two tables were filled. Surely Father could’ve managed to wait upon these few—

  Her gaze landed on her brown-haired hero, and her heartbeat increased to a wild pace. William Barlow leaned forward in a chair, deep in conversation with the fellow seated adjacent to him—his friend, Mr. Fitzroy. Will’s presence lit the dull taproom into a brilliant summer landscape simply by merit of his presence—especially when he threw his head back and laughed. And oh, what a laugh. Carefree and merry, as if he’d reached out his hand and pulled her into a jig with the lightness of it.

  Mina grabbed a pitcher and filled it with ale, the draw of William too strong to deny. Bypassing the other customers, she headed straight for his table.

  “He’s invited me to a tea, of all things.” His voice, smooth as fresh flowing honey, grew louder the closer she drew to his table. “Can you imagine that, Fitz? A tea. How awful.”

  A smile curved her mouth as she imagined taking tea with William. Just the two of them. Him in his finest frock coat with a snowy cravat. Her in a new gown. She’d pour a steaming cup for him, and he’d lift a choice little cake to her lips while speaking of his deepest affections. She sighed, warm and contented. “I should think a tea would be very pleasant,” she murmured.

  Both men turned toward her. Mr. Fitzroy spoke first. “Well, if it isn’t the lovely Miss Scott, come to save me from this boorish fellow.” He elbowed William.

  Will arched a brow at her, a rogue grin deepening the dimples at the sides of his mouth. “I was wondering when you’d grace us with your appearance, sweet Mina.”

  Sweet Mina. Heat flooded her cheeks. She’d be remembering that endearment in her dreams tonight.

  But for now, she scowled. “Mr. Barlow, if my father hears of your familiarity, I fear—”

  “Never fear.” He winked—and her knees weakened. “I’m a champion with ruffled fathers.”

  Ignoring his wordplay, she held up the pitcher. “Refills?” William slapped his hand to his heart. “You know me too well.”

  Not as well as I’d like to. She bit her tongue. Where had that come from? Maybe Father was right. Maybe she had been reading too many books.

  “I’m as intrigued as Miss Scott.” Mr. Fitzroy held his cup out to her, for she’d filled William’s mug first. “Why would you not want to attend your uncle’s tea? As I recall, he’s a jolly enough fellow.” Will slugged back a long draw of his ale and lowered his cup to the table. “Nothing against Uncle Barlow, mind you. And in truth, I was pleased he’d made contact. It’s just that, well…I am to bring my wife along.”

  Wife!

  The pitcher clattered to the floor. Mina stared at it, horrified. Ale seeped into the cracks of the floorboards, the very image of her draining hopes and dreams. William Barlow had a wife?

  Will shot to his feet. “Mina, you look as if you’ve seen the Cock Lane ghost. Are you ill?”

  “I’m f–fine. The pitcher—it slipped, that’s all.” She crouched, righted the pitcher to preserve the remaining ale, then yanked the rag from her waistband and mopped up the mess with more force than necessary. The scoundrel! All this time he’d had a hearth and home already tended by a wife? Did he have children as well? She scrubbed harder, grazing her knuckles against the rough wood. Good. She relished the pain and for a wicked moment thought about swishing the spilled ale over William’s shoes.

  “Wife?” Surprise deepened Mr. Fitzroy’s voice also. So…Will’s best friend had not known either? That was a small satisfaction, at least.

  “This is news,” Mr. Fitzroy continued. “When did that happen?”

  Holding her breath, she ceased her scrubbing, though why she cared indicted her for being naught but a dunderheaded hero seeker. Silly girl. Silly, stupid girl.

  William sank back to his seat. “Well, I don’t actually have one yet. And that’s the problem.”

  “Thank God.” The words flew out before she could stop them, and she pressed her lips tight.

  William’s face appeared below the table. “Are you quite all right?”

  “Yes. Just finishing up.” She forced a smile, reached for the runaway pitcher, and stood. This afternoon was turning into a novel in its own right. For the first time since she’d met William, she couldn’t decide if he were truly a hero or a villain.

  Will straightened as well, his gaze trained on her. The sun slanted through the front window, angling over his strong jaw and narrow nose. But it was his eyes that drew her. So brilliant, so magnificently blue, a sob welled in her throat. She swallowed. She truly was a silly girl.

  “Say, Mina,” he drawled. “You wouldn’t be willing to be my bride, would you?”

  “I—I—” The words caught in her throat like a fish bone, and she coughed, then coughed some more. Heat blazed through her from head to toe. Surely, she hadn’t heard right.

  William’s grin grew, his dimples deepening to a rakish angle. “Oh, don’t panic. It would only be for one afternoon. Surely you could beg off serving for an hour a week from next Thursday?”

  Her mouth dropped, but no words came out. What was she to say to that? Everything in her screamed to shout yes, but how could she possibly slip out from beneath Father’s notice? And a week from next Thursday? Not that her social calendar was packed full, but something niggled her about the date.

  “Oy, miss! Another round over here.” Across the taproom, a stout fellow, buttons about to pop off his waistcoat, held a mug over his head.

  “I—I don’t know,” she blurted out to Will and turned.

  But William grasped her sleeve. “Please, Mina. Allow me to explain. It won’t take but a moment.”

  She stared at his touch, a frown tugging her lips. Father wouldn’t like her dawdling with William, but how could she refuse the man she’d cast as the champion in every story she’d read? With a quick nod and a brilliant smile to stave off the other customer, she turned back to Will. “Make haste. I have work to
attend.”

  “Right, here’s the thing.” He leaned forward, the excitement in his tone pulling both her and Mr. Fitzroy closer to him so that they huddled ’round the table.

  “Uncle Barlow is ready to choose his heir. It’s between me and my cousin Percy—”

  “Egad!” Mr. Fitzroy rocked back on his chair. “That pompous donkey? I should think there’d be no competition.”

  “I agree, but my uncle favors a married man. And since I am not…” Will tugged at his collar, loosening his cravat. “Well, I gave Uncle Barlow the impression I’d recently wed, or I’d not even be considered.”

  Mr. Fitzroy let out a long, low whistle.

  Mina’s eyes widened. “You lied to your uncle?”

  William shook his head, the tips of his hair brushing against his shoulders. “No, not outright. I merely led him on a merry word chase, and he arrived at a particular conclusion.”

  Mr. Fitzroy chuckled. “One day, my friend, your deceptions will catch up to you.”

  “Perhaps. But not today. Not if you, my sweet Mina”—William captured her free hand and squeezed—“will agree to be my wife for the tea. I could pick you up at two o’clock. What do you say?”

  Say? How could she even think with the warmth of his fingers wrapped around hers and his blue gaze entreating her to yield? It would be lovely to live a fairy-tale life if only for part of an afternoon. Take tea in a grand house, finally be a real lady, just like those she so often read about—

  “Miss!” the man across the room bellowed again.

  —And escape the drudgery of serving corpulent patrons who more often than not smelled of goats and sausages.

  Pulling her hand away, she smiled at William. “I say yes.”

  God bless her! For surely her father wouldn’t. Before Will could say anything more, she scurried off to fill the other patrons’ mugs and drain her pitcher dry. On her way back to the tap, she swerved around a table, and her gown brushed against her hand. Paper crinkled at the contact.

  Then she knew.

  Setting the pitcher down on the counter, she glanced over her shoulder to make sure no one was looking before she retrieved the note from her pocket. A moan caught in her throat as she reread the instructions: