A Magnificent Obsession: The Death That Changed the Monarchy
Page 35
One other possibility remains: that the Prince had contracted abdominal tuberculosis, which can appear years after initial exposure to the TB bacillus and cause symptoms clinically indistinguishable from Crohn’s. In 1861 it would have been impossible for the royal doctors to have diagnosed TB with any accuracy. The cause (the bacillus Mycobacterium tuberculosis) and tissue diagnosis of it were only described by Robert Koch in 1882 (work for which he was awarded the Nobel Prize in 1905). Abdominal TB was at that time much more common than it is today; it can affect the lining of the abdomen (the peritoneum) and, when it does, fluid known as ascites accumulates in the abdominal cavity. It is possible, therefore, that Prince Albert was suffering from ascites due to abdominal TB, although the Victorian doctors should have been able to detect this clinically by percussing his abdomen, which would have been taut and uncomfortable.
The evidence, when carefully considered, would thus seem to favour a diagnosis of Crohn’s disease. But such a diagnosis is, of course, entirely retrospective and anachronistic, for it was not described for the first time until 1913 (by a Scotsman, T. Kennedy Dalziel) and then again in 1932 by the Jewish-American gastroenterologist Burrill Crohn and colleagues. Nevertheless, Crohn’s disease, which is gradually progressive and fluctuating in intensity, could explain the chronic, relapsing and remitting problems with his gut that Prince Albert had suffered from, undetected, over many years. It would have caused episodic partial obstruction in the bowel, which, if untreated, can be complicated by small perforations or abscess, leading to peritonitis, septicaemia and death. But only explorative abdominal surgery – at that time unavailable – would have revealed this. Crohn’s disease is characterised in some patients by other, extra-intestinal problems that are quite independent of the activity of Crohn’s itself, such as arthritis. It is conceivable that the Prince’s frequent complaints of ‘rheumatic’ pain in his joints for much of his adult life, and which became so prominent in his final month, could also have been a manifestation of Crohn’s disease. Such symptoms often persist even when the intestinal inflammation is inactive and are thus more compatible with this overall diagnosis. Like abdominal TB, Crohn’s can be exacerbated by overwork and anxiety. A recent study by Charles Bernstein in Winnipeg has shown that the risk of relapse in Crohn’s is almost doubled in those suffering high levels of perceived stress.21 If this were true in Albert’s case, then the ultimate irony is that Victoria’s assertions that Bertie killed his father may in a way be true. Albert’s extreme response to his son’s escapade at the Curragh, and the excessive levels of anxiety and insomnia that followed, combined with a chill and overwork, may well have provoked a severe flare-up of his condition.22
In many respects, therefore, the natural history of Crohn’s disease would fit the long-term pattern of Prince Albert’s documented physical complaints: periodic diarrhoea due to inflammation of the gut, with abdominal pain and vomiting from intestinal obstruction, fluctuating between acute episodes marked by swinging fevers and periods of remission. The bouts of depression and lassitude that he latterly suffered are also highly characteristic of an abscess or chronic sepsis. A pink rash of spots detected by the doctors on his abdomen in early December – which they seemed to fix on, almost with relief, as a sure sign of typhoid fever – could have been a consequence of cutaneous vasodilation brought on by septicaemia.23 One must bear in mind how desperate the royal doctors must have been in those final days: their most important patient (apart from the Queen) dying at a young age; the eyes of Her Majesty, their (envious) colleagues and the world upon them; and there they were, uncertain of their diagnosis.
The final three-week cycle of illness would thus fit the time-frame for Crohn’s, complicated by an abdominal abscess, developing into a terminal event with the opportunistic onset of pneumonia (‘pulmonary congestion’) in the last two or three days.24 Although it was not widely reported at the time, this latter view concurs with that of other medical practitioners: what in fact carried the Prince off was that age-old nemesis of the sick and vulnerable – pneumonia.25 In the absence of solid clinical evidence, or detailed autopsy notes, we can only ever make informed guesses. Whatever it was that killed Prince Albert – and we must now lay the ghost of typhoid fever to rest – no antibiotics, steroids or abdominal surgery were then available to help him. To Prince Albert himself must go the final word; if his condition had not killed him in 1861, it is likely, as he told his stepmother, that the ‘weak stomach with which I came into the world…I shall take with me to my grave’.26
Bibliography
Archives
Arkhiv der Hessischen Hausstiftung, Schloss Fasanerie, Eichenzell:
Briefe Kronprinz Wilhelm von Preussen an Kronprinzessin Victoria, 1861, 7.1/1-BA 3
Balliol College, Oxford:
Morier Family Papers, K1/4/4, 1866–72, Queen Victoria’s letters to General Peel
Bodleian Library Special Collections:
Diaries of Lady Katherine Clarendon, Clarendon Papers, MSS Eng. e. 2122–5
Diary of Charles Pugh, MS.Eng.misc.d472
Journal of John Rashdall, MS.Eng.misc.e 359
British Library:
Gladstone Papers, vol. CCXL, Add. MSS 44325 and 44326, letters from the Duchess of Sutherland; vol. CXCV Add. MS 44289
Queen Victoria’s ‘Album Consolativum’, Add. MSS 62089, 62090
Cheshire Archives:
Correspondence and Papers of Dean Stanley, DSA 85
Public Record Office, Kew:
Lord Chamberlain’s papers, PRO LC 1-90-005
Royal Archives, Windsor:
Letters and journals of Queen Victoria, Prince Albert and members of the royal household; memoranda from the Lord Chamberlain and Comptroller of the royal household [itemised in detail in the Notes]
Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain Collections:
Peter Squire, pharmacist: Queen Victoria’s Account book, 1861–1869
Ian Shapiro collection:
Diaries of Sir John Cowell, 1861–2; letter of Ra Haniraka, 3 March 1862
Staatsarchiv Darmstadt:
Briefe von Prinzessin Alice, 1861, D24 Nr. 25/3–4 and 26/1
The Times Newspapers Limited Archive, News International Archive:
TT/ED/JTD/A/022, Lord Torrington letters to Delane
TT/ED/JTD/10–13, Delane Correspondence
Newspapers and Journals
British national and regional newspapers digitised in the online resource, 19th Century British Library Newspapers, available at the British Library, London, and other libraries and repositories. Major papers consulted:
Belfast News-letter
Daily News
Daily Telegraph
Leeds Mercury
Lloyds Weekly Newspaper
London Gazette
Morning Chronicle
Morning Post
Pall Mall Gazette
Reynolds’s Newspaper
The Times Digital Archive 1785–1985
New York Times Article Archive 1851–1980
Magazines and journals digitised in 19th Century UK Periodicals, British Library, London (availability as per the newspaper archive):
Illustrated London News
The Lancet
Medical Times and Gazette
Punch
Tomahawk
Primary Published Sources
Alice, Princess of Great Britain, Grand Duchess of Hesse: Letters to Her Majesty the Queen, New and Popular Edition with a Memoir by HRH Princess Christian, London: John Murray, 1897.
Anon., ‘The Last Hours of Prince Albert’, in Wesleyan-Methodist Magazine, vol. 47, 1864, p. 906; published in pamphlet form as ‘The Last Hours of HRH Prince Albert of Blessed Memory’, London: John Snow, 1864.
Arengo-Jones, Peter, Queen Victoria in Switzerland, London: Hale, 1995.
Bailey, John, ed., Diary of Lady Frederick Cavendish, 2 vols, London: John Murray, 1927.
Bennett, Daphne, King without a Crown, London: Heinemann, 1977.
Bolitho, Hector, Albert, the Good, London: Cobden-Sanderson, 1932 [revised in 1970 as Albert, Prince Consort].
—— The Prince Consort and his Brother: Two Hundred New Letters, London: Cobden-Sanderson, 1933.
—— Victoria and Albert, London: Cobden-Sanderson, 1938.
—— Further Letters of Queen Victoria from the Archives of the House of Brandenburg-Prussia, London: Thornton Butterworth, 1938.
Buckle, George Earl, ed., Letters of Queen Victoria 1862–85, 2nd series, 3 vols, London: John Murray, 1926–8.
Connell, Brian, Regina v. Palmerston: The Correspondence between Queen Victoria and her Foreign and Prime Minister, London: Evans Brothers, 1962.
Corti, Egon, The English Empress, London: Cassell & Co., 1957.
Downer, Martin, The Queen’s Knight, London: Bantam Press, 2007.
Erskine, Mrs Stewart, ed., Twenty Years at Court: From the Correspondence of the Hon. Eleanor Stanley, London: Nisbet & Co., 1916.
Fulford, Roger, Dearest Child: Letters Between Queen Victoria and the Princess Royal, 1858–61, London: Evans Brothers, 1964.
—— Dearest Mama: Letters between Queen Victoria and the Crown Princes of Prussia, 1861–64, London: Evans Brothers, 1968.
—— Your Dear Letter: Private Correspondence of Queen Victoria and the Crown Princess of Prussia, 1863–71, London: Evans Brothers, 1971.
—— Darling Child: Private Correspondence of Queen Victoria and the German Crown Princess, 1871–78, London: Evans Brothers, 1976.
—— Beloved Mama: Private Correspondence of Queen Victoria and the German Crown Princess, 1878–85, London: Evans Brothers, 1981.
Grey, Hon. Charles, The Early Years of HRH The Prince Consort, London: Smith, Elder & Co., 1867.
Helps, Arthur, ed., The Principal Speeches and Addresses of HRH The Prince Consort, London: John Murray, 1862.
Hibbert, Christopher, Queen Victoria in Her Letters and Journals, London: Viking, 1984.
Hobhouse, Hermione, Prince Albert: His Life and Work, London: Hamish Hamilton, 1983.
Hough, Richard, Advice to a Grand-daughter: Letters from Queen Victoria to Princess Victoria of Hesse, London: Heinemann, 1975.
Jagow, Kurt, Letters of the Prince Consort, 1831–1861, London: John Murray, 1938.
James, Robert Rhodes, Albert Prince Consort: A Biography, London: Hamish Hamilton, 1983.
Kime, William Thomas, ed., Albert the Good: A Nation’s Tribute of Affection to the Memory of a Truly Virtuous Prince, London: J. F. Shaw & Co., 1862.
Longford, Elizabeth, Victoria RI, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1998 [1964].
—— ed., Darling Loosy: Letters to Princess Louise, 1856–1939, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1991.
Lorne, Marquis of, VRI: Her Life and Empire, London: Eyre and Spottiswood, 1901.
Martin, Sir Theodore, The Life of HRH The Prince Consort, 5 vols, London: Smith, Elder & Co., 1875–80.
—— Queen Victoria as I Knew Her, Edinburgh: William Blackwood & Son, 1908.
Pound, Reginald, Albert: A Biography of the Prince Consort, London: Michael Joseph, 1973.
Rappaport, Helen, Queen Victoria: A Biographical Companion, Santa Barbara: ABC-Clio, 2003.
Sell, Karl, ed., Alice Grand Duchess of Hesse, Princess of Great Britain and Ireland, Biographical Sketch and Letters, London: John Murray, 1884.
‘Services Held in Windsor Castle on the Anniversary of the Lamented Death of the Prince Consort’, London: privately printed, 1862.
Sheppard, Edgar, HRH George, Duke of Cambridge, A Memoir, vol. I 1819–1871, London: Longman’s, Green & Co., 1906.
Victoria, Queen of Great Britain, Leaves from the Journal of Our Life in the Highlands from 1848–1861, ed. Arthur Helps, London: Smith, Elder, 1868.
Wake, Jehanne, Princess Louise: Queen Victoria’s Unconventional Daughter, London: Collins, 1988.
Walford, Edward, The Life of the Prince Consort, London: Routledge, Warne & Routledge, 1862.
Weintraub, Stanley, Victoria, Biography of a Queen, London: Unwin Hyman, 1987.
—— Albert, Uncrowned King, London: John Murray, 1997.
Windsor, Dean of and Hector Bolitho, eds, Letters of Lady Augusta Stanley: A Young Lady at Court 1849–1863, London: Gerald Howe, 1927.
—— Later Letters of Lady Augusta Stanley 1864–1876, London: Jonathan Cape, 1929.
Woodham Smith, Cecil, Queen Victoria: Her Life and Times, vol. 1, 1819–1861, London: Hamish Hamilton, 1972.
Wyndham, Hon. Mrs Hugh, ed., Correspondence of Sarah Spencer, Lady Lyttleton 1787–1870, London: John Murray, 1912.
Secondary Published Sources
Airplay, F. (pseud.), ‘Prince Albert, Why is He Unpopular?, London: Saunders & Otley, 1856.
Albert, Harold, The Life and Letters of Princess Feodore: Queen Victoria’s Sister, London: Robert Hale, 1967.
Allan, Oswald, ‘Worthy a Crown?’, London: Head & Meek, 1876.
—— ‘The Vacant Throne’, London: E. Head, 1877.
Ames, Winslow, Prince Albert and Victorian Taste, London: Chapman & Hall, 1967.
Anon., The Private Life of Queen Victoria: By One of Her Majesty’s Servants, London: C. Arthur Pearson, 1897.
Argyll, George Douglas Campbell, Duke of, Autobiography and Memoirs, vol. 2, London: John Murray, 1906.
Aronson, Theo, Grandmama of Europe: The Crowned Descendants of Queen Victoria, London: Cassell, 1973.
Ashwell, Arthur Rawton, ed., Life of the Right Reverend Samuel Wilberforce, 3 vols, London: John Murray, 1880–2.
—— and Reginald Garton, The Life of Bishop Wilberforce, London: John Murray, 1881.
Aston, Sir George, HRH The Duke of Connaught and Strathearn, 2 vols, London: George C. Harrap, 1929.
Auchinloss, Louis, Persons of Consequence: Queen Victoria and her Circle, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1979.
Ball, T. Frederick, Queen Victoria: Scenes and Incidents of her Life and Reign, London: S. W. Partridge, 1886.
Battiscombe, Georgina, ‘Gerald Wellesley: A Victorian Dean and Domestic Chaplain’, in ‘St George’s Chapel Annual Report to 31st December’, 1963.
—— Queen Alexandra, London: Constable, 1969.
Bayley, Stephen, The Albert Memorial, London: Scholar Press, 1981.
Bell, George Kennedy, Randall Davidson, Archbishop of Canterbury, London: Oxford University Press, 1952.
Bellows, John, ‘Remarks by J. Bellows on Certain Anonymous Articles Designed to Render Queen Victoria Unpopular’, Gloucester, 1864.
Bennett, Daphne, Queen Victoria’s Children, London: Gollancz, 1980.
Benson, E. F., As We Were: A Victorian Peep-Show, London: Longman’s, Green & Co., 1930.
—— Queen Victoria, London: Longman’s, Green & Co., 1935.
Bolitho, Hector, Victoria the Widow and Her Son, London: Cobden-Sanderson, 1934.
—— Victoria and Albert, London: Cobden-Sanderson, 1938.
—— Romance of Windsor Castle, London: Evans Brothers, 1948.
—— The Reign of Queen Victoria, London: Collins, 1949.
—— A Biographer’s Notebook, London: Longman’s, Green & Co., 1950.
Branks, William, Heaven our home, or Memorials of Sarah Craven, gathered chiefly from her own letters, London: Wertheim, Mackintosh & Hunt, 1859.
Brown, Raymond Lamont, John Brown: Queen Victoria’s Highland Servant, Stroud: Sutton, 2000.
—— Royal Poxes and Potions: The Lives of the Court Physicians, Surgeons and Apothecaries, Stroud: Sutton, 2001.
Bullock, Rev. Charles, The Home Life of the Prince Consort, London: ‘Home Words’ Publishing Office, 1861.
—— The Queen’s Resolve ‘I Will Be Good’: with Royal Anecdotes and Incidents, London: ‘Home Words’ Publishing Office, 1887.
Cannadine, David, The Context, Performance and Meaning of Ritual: The British Monarchy and the Invention of Tradition, c.
1820–1977 in Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger, eds, The Invention of Tradition, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983.
Cartwright, Julia, ed., The Journals of Lady Knightley of Fawsley (1856–1884), London: John Murray, 1915.
Chaple, J. A. V., and Pollard, Arthur, Letters of Mrs Gaskell, Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1966.
Charlot, Monica, Victoria, the Young Queen, Oxford: Blackwell, 1991.
Chomet, S., Helena, A Princess Reclaimed, New York: Begell House, 1999. Clark, John Willis, ed., Life, Letters and Journals of Sir Charles Lyell, vol. 2, London: John Murray, 1881.
Cook, Edward, Delane of the Times, London: Constable, 1915.
Cooke, Clement K., Memoir of HRH Princess Mary Adelaide, Duchess of Teck, 2 vols, London: John Murray, 1900.
Cowley, H. R. C., Duke of Wellington, The Paris Embassy During the Second Empire, London: T. Butterworth, 1928.
Craik, D. M., Fifty Golden Years: Incidents in the Queen’s Reign. London: n.p., 1887.
Crawford, Emily, Victoria, Queen and Ruler, London: Simpkin, Marshall, 1903.
Creaton, Heather, Victorian Diaries, The Daily Lives of Victorian Men and Women London: Mitchell Beazley, 2001.
—— Unpublished London Diaries, London: London Record Society, 2003.
Creston Dormer, The Youthful Queen Victoria: A Discursive Account, London: Macmillan, 1952.
Cullen, Tom, The Empress Brown: The Story of a Royal Friendship, London: Bodley Head, 1969.
Dafforne, James, The Albert Memorial Hyde Park: Its History and Description, London: Virtue & Co., 1877.
Darby, Elisabeth and Nicola Smith, The Cult of the Prince Consort, New Haven: Yale University Press, 1983.
Dasent, Arthur, John Thadeus Delane, Editor of ‘The Times’: His Life and Correspondence, vol. 2, London: John Murray, 1908.