Katie's Choice

by Rachel Clark

  “I didn’t want to hurt either of you. And, it…” She took a deep shuddering breath. “It seemed wrong to be in love with both of you. And I was young and stupid and scared of my own feelings. It’s not right to fall for two men. Can’t you see that?”

  “What I see,” Rick said quietly, “is ten years lost over a misunderstanding.”

  “But I still can’t decide between you. I can’t choose. Not even now.”

  “Why do you have to decide?” Rick asked with a smile on his face. “Why not choose both of us?”

  She laughed a little nervously. “You’re kidding, right?”

  “Nope,” Rick said with all the cocky bravado Daniel had never managed to acquire. “Now, sweetness, why don’t you do what my bossy brother suggested and lose the clothes.”

  She looked nervous in an excited sort of way, and Daniel forgot how to breathe as she released one, then another button from the holes in her shirt. Slowly the material parted, exposing creamy skin inch by delicious inch.

  His cock thickened, the hardness pressing painfully against the zipper of his jeans. He couldn’t remember ever being turned on so hot, so fast. He’d gone from angry and confused to ready to claim his woman in two seconds flat. Rick caught his attention, and his brother smiled knowingly before dipping his head to lick along the top of Katie’s breasts. They spilled over the cups of her ridiculously sexy, fire engine red bra, and as amazing as she looked in the skimpy lingerie, he couldn’t wait to remove it.

  He stepped behind her, pressing his chest and abdomen against her back as his brother continued his lazy exploration of her breasts. Daniel smoothed his hand around her side, slid a finger into the material of her bra, and pulled down so that her nipple slipped out. Rick quickly claimed the dusky-pink flesh, sucking the hard nub into his mouth. Katie yelped as Rick bit down but then seemed to melt against Daniel as her legs slowly gave out.

  Daniel wrapped his arm around her middle, steadying her as he undid her pants with his other hand. Unable to wait a moment longer, he pushed his fingers into her underwear, sliding through the slick flesh to find the hard bundle of nerves. She moaned as he pressed her clit, rubbing in gentle circles as his brother sucked harder on her breast.

  Katie began to shake, her limbs and muscles quivering with obvious excitement. She gasped as he slid his hand lower, thrusting two fingers deep into her pussy. He rubbed the heel of his hand against her mons, groaning silently as she shook with desire. She stiffened for a moment, and then moaned as climax overtook her. Her pussy massaged his fingers, drawing him in, sucking him deeper.

  Daniel tried to ignore his own needs but couldn’t resist pulling her soft body closer, pressing his hard cock against the crease of her ass as he kissed the back of her neck. Rick lifted her face and kissed her softly. The arrogant smile might’ve fooled the woman in his arms, but Daniel could see the war of emotion playing on his brother’s face. Rick wanted her as much as Daniel did.

  They’d shared women before, but it had been a kink, a mutual scratching of itches, not a relationship. Somehow, they needed to find a way to make this not only about amazing sex. They needed to make this a relationship for all three of them, or they’d all end up hurt again.

  “Fuck,” Katie finally managed to whisper on a breathy sigh. He heartily agreed but smacked her bottom for the crude word. “Hey,” she yelped as she tried to turn in his arms.

  “Gutter-mouth,” he called her as he held her still and smoothed his hand over her denim-clad ass. He knew she would barely have felt the slap through the thick material but was more than willing to repeat the action on her bare skin. His cock swelled harder at the thought. God, he needed to get a handle on his own desires until they could work this relationship—or whatever it was—into something more.

  Katie tried to turn to confront the man bold enough to smack her for swearing, ruefully acknowledging that, far from hurting, the slap and resulting caress were both conspiring to bring her to a knife’s edge of desire once more. Having Rick watch her every expression was so not helping.

  Suddenly an image of what she must look like filtered through the fog in her brain, and she groaned in embarrassment. What the hell had she been thinking? She hadn’t seen either of these men in nearly ten years. The last words they’d spoken had been in anger, yet here she was half-dressed, barely able to stand on her own two feet, sexually and emotionally exhausted.

  But Rick was once again laving her nipples with his warm tongue, sending her desire rocketing into the stratosphere. She knew she should stop him, but her traitorous body undulated against the stiff cock pressing against her ass. Her body, so long denied, begged shamelessly, and her mind heartily agreed. If this was all she could have of the men who’d been her lifelong obsession, she would take it.

  She’d love them with her body tonight—hopefully for the next three nights—and then hug the memories close for the rest of her lonely life.

  Rick wasn’t sure what put the dreamy expression on Katie’s face, but he sure liked it. He pushed her shirt off her shoulders, and then wrapped his arms around her so he could undo the clasp on her bra. The material fell away, and her beautiful breasts spilled into his hands.

  She was no longer the skinny young woman of his memories. She was more mature, curvier, delectably so. Rick worshipped those glorious globes again and then knelt before her as he stripped her of clothing. He took a moment to press a kiss against the white satin heart that decorated the front of her underwear, and then he stripped them from her too.

  “Bedroom?” he heard Daniel ask.

  She pointed down the hallway, and Daniel lifted her straight up. She smiled, perhaps thinking he would carry her in his embrace, but squeaked indignantly when Daniel draped her over Rick’s shoulder face down, ass up.

  “What the fuck?”

  Daniel smacked her upturned ass. “Such ugly words from a pretty mouth.”

  Rick turned to walk down the hallway, laughing quietly as she cursed his brother.

  “Sweetness, better watch what you say,” he warned. “Daniel is more than willing to smack that pretty ass until it glows in the dark.” Incredibly, she moaned and relaxed against his grip. Daniel chuckled as he caressed her spine and said, “I think our girl likes the idea of being spanked.”

  She moaned again as Rick lowered her to the middle of the bed. He took a step back and stood beside his brother. Together they watched the woman who’d caused so much heartache squirm in the middle of the bed, her arousal very obvious.

  The heat of embarrassment climbed Katie’s face. She’d never been so turned on in her life. She writhed against the bed, barely able to believe she was actually going to do this.

  “Open your legs,” Daniel demanded, and she wondered briefly why she didn’t even hesitate to follow his order. “Wider,” he said as he grabbed her ankles and pushed her knees up and out. “I want to see you. All of you.”

  A small, nervous voice screamed at her to close her legs, turn off the light, hide under the covers, but the pulsing beat of her arousal drowned it out.

  “Beautiful,” Daniel said as he positioned himself between her thighs and licked one long stroke from pussy to clit. She went to grab his hair, but Rick was there, pinning her hands to the bed. She hadn’t even realized how they’d positioned themselves to immobilize her, but now that she was unable to move, she could barely breathe as her excitement ramped higher.

  Holy shit, when did she get kinky?

  “Fu…” Rick’s hand clamped over her mouth before she could spit the expletive out.

  “Don’t swear, sweetness. I promise you he’ll stop what he’s doing and turn you over his knee.”

  Her pussy spasmed at the thought, juice flowing from her faster than Daniel’s exploring tongue could lap up. He groaned against her pussy, licking and sucking until he had his teeth wrapped around her clit. She held her breath, quivering on the verge of orgasm.

  But he stopped and pulled away.

  “Fuck! Don’t stop,” she screa
med at him, her mindless need making her forget Rick’s warning. Daniel moved so quickly she barely realized she was upside down until the blood rushed to her head. “Shit, sorry, I’m mean fu… I mean…” Flustered, she could barely think straight enough to get the right words out. Daniel’s intensity was beginning to frighten her just a little, but it didn’t stop arousal from burning through her.

  She closed her eyes, biting her lips, determined not to swear again.

  But the slap she’d been expecting never came. Instead, Daniel caressed her soft flesh with his warm hand, his strokes almost an absent-minded movement.

  “Katie,” he said in a rough voice. “Tell me to stop. Tell me this isn’t what you want, and I’ll stop.”

  The anguish in his voice tore at her conscience. Both Daniel and Rick had warned her not to swear, had told her of the consequences. Did she want to play by their rules?

  Chapter Three

  Daniel caressed the soft flesh, certain his heart had stopped beating. He hadn’t meant to come on so strong, but the combination of memories and want, and now overwhelming need, were a potent mix, and every one of his dominant tendencies roared to the surface.

  “I’m sorry, Daniel,” she said in a clear voice, and his heart broke a little more. “You both warned me not to swear, so I should be punished.” He could barely believe he’d heard her correctly and looked to his brother for confirmation. Rick nodded, seeming as relieved by her answer as Daniel felt. He puzzled over his brother’s enthusiasm. Surely Rick knew if Katie rejected Daniel’s dominant tendencies she would likely be drawn to Rick’s more playful style of lovemaking. Why didn’t he push the advantage and show himself as the better choice? But Rick just smiled and indicated for Daniel to continue.

  “Why are you being punished?” he asked the woman draped over his lap.

  “Because I swore.” Her voice sounded submissive and contrite, and he might’ve been fooled by the attitude if she hadn’t wriggled in his lap to get closer.

  Rick watched as the woman it seemed he’d always loved lay quiescent across his brother’s lap and waited for her spanking. He’d never seen anything hotter in his entire life. He knew Daniel was dominant, but it had never seemed so intimate before. The other women they’d shared had been play, but this was more. So much more.

  Katie jumped, trying to scramble off Daniel’s lap, as the first blow hit the top of her thighs. Daniel held her still, soothing the red skin until she settled, and then slapped her again. She reacted in a similar fashion to the next three slaps, but then something changed, and she began to rock back against Daniel’s hand, seeming to ask for more.

  Rick moved closer, unable to resist caressing the soft skin on her back as she shook with desire and moved rhythmically against Daniel’s thighs. She moaned with each slap now, her movements instinctive as Daniel thrust a finger into her dripping pussy and finger fucked her. He pushed deeper, spanking her ass in rhythm to his penetration. Katie grunted as her orgasm hit and then moaned as the shaking slowly subsided. As she lay panting, boneless in her exhaustion, Daniel moved his fingers to her ass.

  She tried to sit up as he breached her anus, but both Rick and Daniel caressed her soothingly as she adjusted to the new sensation. Carefully, Daniel slid in and out of her dark passage, whispering to her all the ways he wanted to pleasure her. Rick could barely contain his own excitement as he imagined the sexual feast his brother described.

  Daniel slowly withdrew his fingers and lifted her back onto the bed. She curled into a sleepy ball, but he smacked her thigh one last time as he gave her another order. “Hands and knees.”

  She struggled to move, and Rick helped her as Daniel moved into the adjoining bathroom, washed his hands, and then went rummaging through the drawers.

  “Bottom drawer,” she called out, obviously realizing what he searched for. “But, oh fu…fudge, check the Use By date.”

  Daniel came out of the bathroom with an unopened box of condoms in his hand.

  “Condoms have a shelf life of three to five years,” he said from the doorway. “When was the last time you had sex?”

  Her cheeks reddened, and she stammered, “About a year or two before I bought those.”

  “A year or two?” Rick parroted in surprise as he did the math. She hadn’t had sex in maybe five years of more?

  “So what is it? One year or two?” Daniel asked in his commanding voice. He seemed more dominant now than Rick had ever seen him.

  “Probably closer to four,” Katie confessed as she slid onto her side and lay with her back to them both.

  “I didn’t tell you to move. Back onto your hands and knees.” She jolted at his loud order but moved quickly back into position. Daniel moved to stand in front of her, but his caress against her cheek seemed at odds to the stern tone of his voice. “How long exactly since you had sex?”

  She bit her lip but managed to mumble, “Not since Gordon left.”

  Rick could feel his insides expanding with a ridiculous sense of ownership. Unless Katie was a wildly different person from the woman he believed her to be, it was a pretty safe bet that the only man she’d ever slept with had been her lousy, unfaithful pig of a husband.

  “Baby girl,” Daniel said as he hauled her off the bed and into his arms. “You should’ve told us. We could’ve hurt you.”

  She shook her head against his chest. “I trust you not to hurt me.”

  And just like that, Rick knew he’d never walk away from her. Time and distance had changed nothing. The three of them were meant to be together, and he’d move heaven and earth to make sure nothing ever pulled them apart again.

  Daniel nodded at him over Katie’s head, and Rick understood exactly what he wanted. Quickly he stripped off his clothes and stepped closer to the naked woman in his brother’s embrace.

  Katie shook in Daniel’s arms as a multitude of emotions swirled through her. Strange how she felt more loved and cared for in a single embrace than she’d felt in her entire marriage to Gordon. Rick moved to press up against her back, and she closed her eyes as a sense of finally being where she belonged seeped into her soul.

  God, she had to stop thinking like this. When the storm was over, they’d be gone, yet it didn’t seem to matter to her foolish mind that they’d likely take her heart with them. Oh hell, who was she trying to kid? They’d always owned her heart.

  Daniel tilted her head up and captured her lips with his own. He kissed her softly, possessively, the sweet kiss wreaking havoc over her entire nervous system. He broke the kiss, gently pressed his lips to her forehead, and turned her around so that Rick could do the same.

  Rick worshipped her with his kiss, teasing, touching her tongue playfully with his own before lifting her up and wrapping her legs around his waist. His rigid cock slid against her pussy as he lowered them both to the bed. For a moment, he pressed her down with his weight, and Katie struggled to comprehend the rush of arousal that burst through her.

  Slowly he levered himself up so he was looking into her eyes. He moved his hips, angling perfectly so his hard cock slid through the wet curls of her mons and grazed the swollen, sensitive flesh of her clit. She moaned and closed her eyes.

  She felt Daniel lay down on the bed beside them, and then his hand roaming over her breasts. “Open your eyes,” he ordered huskily. She did as she was told just as Rick moved away and tore the wrapper off a condom. “Rick is going to love this sweet pussy,” Daniel said as his hand dipped lower. “The way your muscles flutter and contract around my fingers when you orgasm is going to feel like heaven wrapped around his cock.”

  Her gaze flew between the two brothers, back and forth, as she tried to understand what was going on. Was Daniel rejecting her? Less than an hour ago, making love to both brothers had seemed impossible, but now it seemed that not making love to them both was the unbearable task.

  “Baby girl,” Daniel said as if he could read her mind. “It’s been a long time for you, and Rick isn’t nearly as rough as I am. He’ll take good
care of you first, and then we’ll get back to what we started.” Daniel caressed her face as Rick positioned himself between her legs and slowly pushed his cock into her throbbing flesh.

  She couldn’t stop the small hiss at the touch of pain, but Rick took his time and used slow, shallow lunges to gently push his cock deeper. She felt full and deliciously stretched as he started a steady rhythm, gradually working up to harder, deeper, stronger thrusts. As her body adjusted, Rick lifted her thighs higher, pressed them wider, plunged his cock deeper. Over and over he pounded into her. Daniel’s hand slid to her clit, circling the aching nub until her entire body tingled. She gasped, shaking, shivering, keening a sharp cry as every muscle exploded into movement. She clung to them both as her orgasm overwhelmed her and Rick groaned long and low as he joined her in ecstasy.

  Breathing hard, barely able to remember her own name, Katie finally managed to open her eyes. The feral heat in Daniel’s gaze sent amazingly shocking prickles to her groin, and Rick groaned as her pussy muscles contracted around him once more.

  “Beautiful,” Daniel said as he leaned over to press a kiss to her lips.

  “Ditto,” Rick said as he dropped a playful kiss on her breast and licked the swollen nipple. He worshipped her tender flesh for a moment and then shifted so he could secure the condom as he withdrew from her clenching pussy. They both moaned as he finally slid free and rolled off the bed.

  Katie gazed at Daniel for several seconds longer before she registered that he was still fully clothed. He saw her questioning look and smiled as he pulled her closer.

  “Don’t worry, baby girl, we’ve got all night.”

  She smiled, and he couldn’t think of anything but having those beautiful, kiss-swollen lips wrapped around his aching cock. He ground his denim-covered erection against her hip as he dropped forward and slowly, thoroughly kissed her amazing mouth.