Faithful Unto Death

by Stephanie Jaye Evans

  THE BERKLEY PUBLISHING GROUP

  Published by the Penguin Group

  Penguin Group (USA) Inc.

  375 Hudson Street, New York, New York 10014, USA

  Penguin Group (Canada), 90 Eglinton Avenue East, Suite 700, Toronto, Ontario M4P 2Y3, Canada (a division of Pearson Penguin Canada Inc.) • Penguin Books Ltd., 80 Strand, London WC2R 0RL, England • Penguin Group Ireland, 25 St. Stephen’s Green, Dublin 2, Ireland (a division of Penguin Books Ltd.) • Penguin Group (Australia), 250 Camberwell Road, Camberwell, Victoria 3124, Australia (a division of Pearson Australia Group Pty. Ltd.) • Penguin Books India Pvt. Ltd., 11 Community Centre, Panchsheel Park, New Delhi—110 017, India • Penguin Group (NZ), 67 Apollo Drive, Rosedale, Auckland 0632, New Zealand (a division of Pearson New Zealand Ltd.) • Penguin Books (South Africa) (Pty.) Ltd., 24 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg 2196, South Africa

  Penguin Books Ltd., Registered Offices: 80 Strand, London WC2R 0RL, England

  This book is an original publication of The Berkley Publishing Group.

  This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents either are the product of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously, and any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, business establishments, events, or locales is entirely coincidental. The publisher does not have any control over and does not assume any responsibility for author or third-party websites or their content.

  Copyright © 2012 by Stephanie Evans.

  Cover design by Judith Lagerman.

  Cover photograph of grass © Ingram Publishing/Photolibrary.

  Cover photograph of neighborhood © SoleilC/Shutterstock.

  All rights reserved.

  No part of this book may be reproduced, scanned, or distributed in any printed or electronic form without permission. Please do not participate in or encourage piracy of copyrighted materials in violation of the author’s rights. Purchase only authorized editions.

  BERKLEY® PRIME CRIME and the PRIME CRIME logo are trademarks of Penguin Group (USA) Inc.

  PUBLISHING HISTORY

  Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

  Evans, Stephanie Jaye.

  p. cm.

  ISBN 978-1-101-58862-8

  1. Clergy—Fiction. 2. Murder—Investigation—Fiction. 3. Family secrets—Fiction. 4. Sugar Land (Tex.)—Fiction. I. Title.

  PS3605.V3767F35 2012

  813’.6—dc22 2011053024

  To Dwain and Barbara Evans,

  who, for more than fifty-seven years,

  have kept their promises.

  Contents

  Cover

  Praise

  Copyright Page

  Dedication

  Prologue

  One

  Two

  Three

  Four

  Five

  Six

  Seven

  Eight

  Nine

  Ten

  Eleven

  Twelve

  Thirteen

  Fourteen

  Fifteen

  Sixteen

  Seventeen

  Eighteen

  Nineteen

  Twenty

  Twenty-one

  Twenty-two

  Twenty-three

  Twenty-four

  Twenty-five

  Twenty-six

  Twenty-seven

  Twenty-eight

  Twenty-nine

  Thirty

  Thirty-one

  Thirty-two

  Thirty-three

  Acknowledgments

  Prologue

  The moon was low in the sky, as bright and weightless as a lover’s promise, when the first of the joggers passed by the body on the golf course. In the March predawn, the Gulf Coast air was thick and humid, and the early, dedicated joggers were focused on keeping their breathing regular and their heart rates steady. They weren’t looking around for stray corpses. In any case, they wouldn’t have seen Graham Garcia even in full light. He lay on the grassy incline where the cart path dipped down to tunnel under Alcorn Oaks Boulevard. He couldn’t be seen from street level, not unless someone stepped out onto the grassy overhang, lay down, and peered between the leafy trees lining the entrance to the tunnel. And no one did that, not even the jogger whose life had been completely overturned last night.

  Half an hour later the sun was rising when Rebecca Rutland passed by with her two pug dogs. She was dressed in serious workout clothes for the not-so-serious workout she would get airing the two overweight dogs. She had makeup on. Exercise makeup. She would shower soon and then put on her going-to-work makeup.

  When her dogs drew close to where the road ran over the golf course tunnel, they broke into gasping, snorting barks. They pulled so hard on their halters that their fat, fawn shoulders bulged over the leather straps like plump backs in too-tight bras. Rebecca thought a turtle must have climbed out of a water hazard, turtles being one of the few animals a pug could chase down.

  But she was in a hurry.

  She said, “Who wants a cookie?” There was a short, still silence while the pugs internalized this new option.

  Pugs are not Rin-Tin-Tin dogs; they don’t rescue small children and they can’t balance checkbooks, but they can master a large variety of food terms and “cookie” was a familiar and favorite word. The fact that cookies were no rarity in Rebecca’s house had not diminished their appeal one jot. The hysteria changed in timbre, and the pugs leaned their weight against the leash, heading for home. The only thing stronger than a pug’s curiosity is a pug’s appetite.

  At seven, the street was full of school traffic. In the master-planned communities of Sugar Land, the multiplicity of elementary, middle, and high schools meant that school traffic had to be staggered. Consequently, the high school students, those least able to rise early in the morning, had to be in their classes before seven thirty. Elementary school started at seven fifty. It wasn’t until eight thirty-six, twenty-four minutes before the middle school tardy bell would ring, that thirteen-year-old Jessica Min found Graham Garcia’s body. If it had been any day but Monday, golfers would have found him earlier. On Monday, the Bridgewater Country Club golf course was closed for grass maintenance.

  Every school day Mrs. Min would hand Jessica her lunch bag and backpack, and Jessica would go through her backyard to the gate that opened onto the golf course. She did that today with her iPod headphones curled around her ears, a boy band pleading with her to be, be, be their baby.

  Jessica followed the cart path down to the tunnel where she could cross beneath the road. That was so Mrs. Min wouldn’t worry about some sophomore in a sports car, late for his second period, tearing around a corner and knocking to kingdom come all the hopes and dreams and love she had placed in the fragile vessel that was Jessica Min.

  Because the cart path turned and twisted among the Arnold Palmer–designed mounds before it dipped to the mouth of the tunnel, and because the landscape trees camouflaged the tunnel opening, Jessica was almost upon Graham Garcia’s body before she saw him. The sight stopped her toile ballet flats midstride.

  A pop princess was now singing in her ear, “I don’t think so, no, no. I don’t think so …” but Jessica wasn’t listening. She dropped her iced cherry Pop Tart when she saw Mr. Garcia and stopped chewing the bite in her mouth. She tried to swallow but her mouth had gone dry. Her heart was pounding so hard she couldn’t hear the diva’s crooning, and Jessica’s hands, unlike her mouth, had gone wet. She dipped into her skirt pocket and found the pressed cotton handkerchief her mother made sure she carried.

  Graham Garcia lay sprawled on the slope, the heel of one foot dug into the soft ground so that the toe of his shoe pointed straight do
wn to the cart path. Sur la pointe, Jessica thought. Ballet was one of her many enrichment classes. His pale blue eyes looked up past the treetops.

  Since Graham Garcia’s head was higher on the slope than his feet, his blood had not pooled in his face and he looked peaceful for a dead guy. If some weird karma had deemed that Jessica Min had to come across a dead body, she could have done a whole lot worse than Graham Garcia.

  The blond man Jessica saw was tall and slim and not young anymore. Some part of her brain told her that, if he wasn’t young, he was never going to be old, either, and she nodded her head in agreement.

  Graham Garcia was wearing a white golf shirt, open at the neck—Jessica could see a gold James Avery crucifix visible in the vee of his collar. His khaki trousers were hiked up on one leg and his blond leg hair curled over white golf socks, the low kind that you could barely see above the rubber-spiked golf shoe. Jessica’s father wore that kind of golf sock.

  Jessica didn’t call out to him or touch him. She read mysteries and she watched CSI when her parents weren’t there to stop her, and she knew all about forensics. She couldn’t pick up her Pop Tart. She had taken a bite out of it, and seeing it on the ground a few feet from Graham Garcia’s hand, she was reminded of the Walt Disney scene where Snow White has bitten the poisoned apple and fallen senseless, the bitten apple rolling from her grasp.

  For such an overprotected child, Jessica was mature and stoic, so she was surprised by the tears that started up in her eyes.

  Jessica switched her iPod off but left the headphones on. She looked all around. She turned back toward her house and began walking very quickly, her long, black ponytail swinging from side to side keeping perfect time with her short black skirt. Though she had a spooky, creepy feeling that something might be following her, she didn’t run. Cool middle school girls don’t run—Jessica was cooler than anyone knew.

  But she couldn’t help feeling that someone was behind her, watching.

  One

  I’m a preacher, I’m a teacher, and I’m a fellow human creature so don’t worry about minding your p’s and q’s when we’re together, we’ll both be judged, but it won’t be by me.” That’s what Daniel Brotherton had liked to say, and it had sounded corny to me even five hundred years ago when I was a five-year-old boy. Or maybe I just picked up on the corniness from my dad; certainly I always knew that he had to gird himself for his encounters with Mr. Brotherton, who was an emotional man, easily moved to tears by a touching story, always laughing too hard at anyone’s attempt at a joke.

  But as corny as the “preacher, teacher, creature” line was, I can relate to it now in a way I couldn’t then. It’s how I felt when Detective James Wanderley strode into my office, ignored my offer of a chair, and walked around, his hands jammed into the pockets of a navy linen jacket so faded it was almost gray. Not that he was minding his p’s and q’s.

  I knew what he’d come about. He wanted to ask me “a few general questions about a member of the congregation.” That’s the way he’d put it. Rebecca had filled me in on the phone before she let him in my office. Rebecca Rutland is the church CEO who pretends to be my secretary.

  Wanderley was a good-looking guy, not that I notice that kind of thing, but I knew my wife, Annie Laurie, would think he was handsome. He wore his longish dark hair brushed straight back off his forehead. His brows were thick and dark, and so close together he only just missed having what my daughters would call a unibrow. He would have been a little over six feet tall in his socks; the cowboy boots probably added another two inches.

  It’s hard to tell about cowboy boots. This is Texas, after all, so when a guy wears them, they might be an affectation, or they might be the most comfortable footwear he’s got in his closet. These boots looked old enough that I was willing to give Wanderley the benefit of a doubt. They were worn but immaculate, polished and buffed to a soft glow. He wore jeans with that faded linen blazer—the blazer had me stymied. It was good-quality stuff, but at least a generation older than he was. You could tell by the cut. That and the fact that it was faded past ignoring.

  He gave my beige, brown, standard-issue preacher’s office a focused scrutiny it had never before been accorded. He stopped at my bookshelves, ran his eyes over the spines, pulling books out, riffling the pages. He held up Bertrand Russell’s Why I Am Not a Christian, a paperback copy from Half Price Books.

  “Funny book for a minister to have, don’t you think?”

  “Oh, I don’t know,” I said. He was getting on my nerves, the familiar way he was touching my things. “It’s a good idea to know the opposition’s position, don’t you think?” As soon as I’d said it, I was sorry I’d echoed that “don’t you think?” He wavered in front of the bookcase, looking for the space he’d pulled the paperback from, couldn’t find it, and wedged the book in sideways, spine turned in.

  I flinched when his hand moved over my own slim volumes, my name clearly printed on the spines. Lots of people have been happy to share with me their opinions about my writing skills, and over the six years it took me to write, and rewrite, and finally publish each of the commentaries, I’ve had time to grow a shell to the criticism. But I haven’t.

  He pulled out my latest effort, Grace and the Book of Romans, and turned it on its back to read the blurbs. I’d gotten some good ones. Not from James Patterson, you understand, but then it is a book of theology.

  “Is it funny?” he asked.

  “Not intentionally.”

  “Umm.” He put it back. The right way.

  Wanderley next stopped in front of my diplomas. Annie Laurie had had them matted and framed for our fifth anniversary. I’d been horrified when I found out how much she spent; they do look good, though.

  “Walker Wells? That your real name?”

  I said it was. I’m not sure I could imagine the circumstances under which a preacher might have diplomas made out in a fake name.

  “Some crazy names people give their kids. University of Texas, huh? Class of 1985 … that’d make you, what?”

  “Old,” I said. This guy didn’t even look thirty. Maybe twenty-eight? Certainly he was young to be a detective.

  He smiled up at me. I may be old, but I was a good three inches taller, and glad for every one of those inches right then. I’m not sure how it happened, but the minute James Wanderley walked into my office, we were engaged in a competition—over what, I couldn’t have said, but I always play to win.

  “Way back then, UT took just about everybody, didn’t they? None of that top ten percent of the class business?”

  I drew in air to tell him that yes, way back then before the combustion engine was invented, University of Texas did take a goodly number of C students, but I had been offered an athletic and an academic scholarship. Naturally I took the athletic scholarship as it was a full ride. I’d been a starting tight guard, too, no small accomplishment at UT no matter what decade you played in. But I didn’t say it. I shut my mouth and smiled as best I could. Annie Laurie would have been proud of me. Maybe He would have been, too. Then again, maybe not. He would have heard the snap of my teeth when I shut my mouth.

  “Whoa! Master of Divinity from freaking Princeton University! And a Doctorate in Theology from Rice! Well, you are a very learned man, Brother Wells. I’m impressed.”

  “Oh, good. I had so hoped you would be.” I couldn’t help it; it slipped out. Wanderley laughed out loud. It was a good-natured laugh. That surprised me.

  A family picture on my desk caught his eye, and he strolled over to get a better look. As he passed a window, he drew his finger across the sill and checked it for dust. I swear I’m not making that up. He was real open about it, too. Wanderley picked up the framed portrait and held it close to his face.

  “Nice-looking family. Pretty girls. Is it a recent picture?”

  I nodded yes. It had been taken about six months ago, one of those pictures we get every three or four years for the new church pictorial directory. I’m in a houndstooth blazer, and A
nnie and the girls are in red. Red goes great with Annie and Merrie’s blond hair but it was maybe the wrong shade for Jo. Made her look pale.

  Wanderley tapped the photo under Jo’s face. “You’ve got a changeling.”

  Jo’s hair is dark brown, and wavy, and she’s built smaller than Merrie, but if you look at their eyes, well, not the eyes so much, but their mouths are shaped just the … “She looks like my mother. At that age.”

  He glanced over at me, nodded, and then back to the picture. “I guess it’s that dark-haired delicacy with the rest of you being so blond and athletic. You were a blond, weren’t you?”

  I drew my hand over my hair without thinking. I’m still a blond, a little gray on the sides … at least I have plenty on top. Wanderley looked to me to be the type to go bald early.

  He held on to the photo.

  “Let me guess. No, let me deduce. You’re easy; with that bulk, you had to have been a football player.”

  Did you catch that? Bulk. I nodded.

  “You married a pretty woman, Mr. Wells. You’re a lucky man.”

  I am. I know it.

  “The statuesque blonde, she’s, what? Eighteen? Nineteen?”

  I nodded. Merrie would be nineteen this summer.

  “Okay, she’s a volleyball player. Could be track, she’s got the long, lean build you need for track, but the cool girls, they all play volleyball and this one, yeah, she’d be with the cool girls. Am I right?” He looked up at me with a cocky grin.

  I’d had enough. “I’d appreciate it,” I said tersely, “if you stopped looking at my girls like that.”

  Wanderley’s mouth dropped, and he flushed up to his hairline. “Stopped loo—oh. Damn. I beg your pardon. And I mean that sincerely. I think I’d shoot a man who laid a leering eye on my own daughter’s picture.”

  “You’ve got a daughter?” I felt better. If a man has daughters of his own, he’s going to understand.

  “She’s two. Molly.”

  “Molly Wanderley. Nice name.”

  “Not Wanderley. It’s … complicated.”

  I had a tug of sympathy. Life is often so much more complicated now.

  Wanderley stood and pulled his cell phone from his jeans pocket. He scrolled to a photo and passed it over. A dark-haired beauty gazed at me with saucer-sized eyes, her baby mouth not quite smiling. Her café au lait skin and loose curls told me something about Molly’s mother, and something about Wanderley, too.