The Breaking Point

Home > Other > The Breaking Point > Page 46
The Breaking Point Page 46

by Robert A Doughty


  Felsenhardt, Robert. 1939–1940: Avec le 18ème corps d'armée. Paris: Editions La Tête de Feuilles, 1973.

  Frieser, Karl Heinz. “Der Verstoß der Panzergruppe Kleist zur Kanalküste (10. bis 21. Mai 1940).” Operatives Denken und Handeln in deutschen Streitkräften im 19. und 20. Jahrhundert, pp. 123–48. Bonn: E. S. Mittler & Sohn, 1988.

  Frieser, Karl Heinz. “Rommels Durchbruch bei Dinant.” Militärgeschichtliches Beiheft zur Europäischen Wehrkunde. Bonn: E. S. Mittler & Sohn, 1987.

  Garder, Michel. La Guerre secrète des services spéciaux française, 1935–1945. Paris: Plon, 1967.

  Germany. Oberkommando des Heeres. Denkschrift über die franzosische Landesbefestigung. Berlin: Reichsdruckerei, 1941.

  Gounelle, Claude. Sedan: Mai 1940. Paris: Presses de la Cité, 1965.

  Goutard, Colonel A. The Battle of France, 1940. Trans. A.R.P. Burgess. New York: Ives Washburn, 1959.

  Le Goyet, Pierre. Le mystère Gamelin. Paris: Presses de la Cité, 1975.

  Le Goyet, Lt. Col. Pierre. “La percée de Sedan (10–15 Mai 1940).” Revue d’ histoire de la deuxième guerre mondiale, no. 59 (July 1965): 25–52.

  Gunsburg, Jeffery A. “Coupable ou non? Le rôle du général Gamelin dans la défaite de 1940.” Revue historique des armées, no. 4 (1979): 145–63.

  ———. Divided and Conquered: The French High Command and the Defeat of the West, 1940. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1979.

  Horne, Alistair. To Lose a Battle: France, 1940. Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1969.

  Irving, David. Hitler's War. 2 vols. New York: Viking Press, 1977.

  Jackson, Robert. Air War over France, May–June 1940. London: Ian Allen Ltd., 1974.

  Jacobsen, Hans-Adolf. “Dunkirk 1940.” In H. A. Jacobsen and J. Rohwer, eds., Decisive Battles of World War II: The German View. Trans. Edward Fitzgerald. New York: G. P. Putnam's, 1965.

  Jacobsen, Hans-Adolf. Fall Gelb: Der Kampf um den Deutschen Operationsplan zur Westoffensive 1940. Wiesbaden: Franz Steiner Verlag, 1957.

  Laubier, Philippe de. “Le bombardement français sur la Meuse: Le 14 mai 1940.” Revue historique des armées, no. 160 (October 1985): 96–109.

  Lewis, S. J. Forgotten Legions: German Army Infantry Policy, 1918–1941. New York: Praeger, 1985.

  Liddell Hart, B. H. The German Generals Talk. New York: Morrow & Co., 1948.

  Lyet, Commandant Pierre. La Bataille de France (Mai–Juin 1940). Paris: Payot, 1947.

  Macksey, Kenneth. Guderian: Creator of the Blitzkrieg. New York: Stein and Day, 1976.

  Mary, Jean-Yves. La Ligne Maginot: ce qu’ elle était, ce qu'il en reste. San Dalmazzo, Italy: L'Istituto Grafico Bertello, 1980.

  Mellenthin, Major Gen. F. W. von. Panzer Battles: A Study of the Employment of Armor in the Second World War. Trans. H. Betzler. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1956.

  Menu, Charles Léon. Lumière sur les ruines. Paris: Plon, 1953.

  Messenger, Charles. The Blitzkrieg Story. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1976.

  Murray, Williamson. “The German Response to Victory in Poland: A Case Study in Professionalism.” Armed Forces and Society 7, no. 2 (Winter 1981): 285–98.

  ———. Strategy for Defeat: The Luftwaffe, 1933–1945. Maxwell A.F.B., Ala.: Air University Press, 1983.

  Paillat, Claude. La guerre éclair (10 mai–24 juin 1940). Paris: Laffont, 1985.

  Paillole, Paul. Services Spéciaux, 1935–1945. Paris: Laffont, 1975.

  Porch, Douglas. “French Intelligence and the Fall of France, 1930–40.” Intelligence and National Security 4, no. 1 (January 1989): 28–58.

  Renouvin, Pierre, and Jacques Willequet. Les relations militaires franco-belges de mars 1936 au 10 mai 1940. Paris: Editions du Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, 1968.

  Richards, Denis. Royal Air Force, vol. 1, The Fight at Odds. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office, 1953.

  Riebenstahl, Horst. Die 1. Panzer Division im Bild. Friedberg: Podzun-Pallas-Verlag, 1986.

  Rothbrust, Florian K. “The Cut of the Scythe.” Master's thesis, Command and General Staff College, Fort Leavenworth, Kans., 1988.

  Royaume de Belgique. Ministère de la Défense Nationale. Service Historique de l'Armée. La Campagne de mai 1940. Brussels: Presses de l'Institut Cartographique Militaire, 1945.

  Shirer, William L. The Collapse of the Third Republic: An Inquiry into the Fall of France in 1940. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1969.

  Spaeter, Helmuth. Die geschichte des Panzerkorps Grossdeutschland. Duisburg: Selbstverlag Hilfswerk ehem Soldaten, 1958.

  Stoves, Rolf O. G. 1. Panzer-Division, 1935–1945: Chronik einer der drei Stamm-Divisionen der deutschen Panzerwaffe. Bad Nauheim: Hans-Henning Podzun, 1961.

  Strauss, Franz Josef. Geschichte der 2. (Wiener) Panzer Division. Friedberg: Podzun-Pallas-Verlag, 1987.

  Taylor, Telford. The March of Conquest: The German Victories in Western Europe, 1940. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1958.

  Trevor-Roper, H. R., ed. Blitzkrieg to Defeat: Hitler's War Directives. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1965.

  Vidalenc, Jean. “Les divisions de série ‘B’ dans l'armée française pendant la campagne de France 1939–1940.” Revue historique des armées, no. 4 (1980): 106–26.

  Volker, Karl-Heinz. Die Deutsche Luftwaffe, 1919–1939. Stuttgart: Deutsche Verlags-Anstalt, 1967.

  Welkenhuyzen, Jean Van. Les avertissements qui venaient de Berlin, 9 octobre 1939–10 mai 1940. Paris: Duculot, 1982.

  Young, Robert J. “French Military Intelligence and Nazi Germany, 1938–1939.” In Ernest R. May, ed., Knowing One's Enemies: Intelligence Assessment before the two World Wars. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1984.

  Index

  Page numbers in italics indicates maps.

  aerial operations, Allied, 281–86

  first daylight attack, 283

  in Netherlands, 285

  at Sedan, 285–86

  Air Force, intelligence reports, 96–97, 99, 101

  Ardennes, French in, 73

  cavalry in Belgium, 83–89

  identifying location of main German attack, 94–102

  intelligence assessments of German order of battle, 73–79

  mission and organization of cavalry, 79–83

  on the Semois River, 89–94

  Ardennes, Germans in, 29

  Bodange, 43–50, 44

  crossing Luxembourg, 37–43

  delays at Bodange, 52–54

  final push to Meuse River, 71

  1st Panzer Division advance, 63–70

  Martelange, 43–50

  Operation Niwi, 50–52

  planning and preparation, 29–37

  2nd Panzer Division advance, 60–62

  10th Panzer Division advance, 54–60

  Army Group I, 284

  Balck, Hermann, 48, 144, 197, 245, 347

  1st Infantry Regiment crossing Meuse and, 144–50

  Barratt, Air Marshal A. S., 282–83, 285

  Baudet, Colonel, 203

  Beaufre, André, 101

  Beck-Broichsitter, Lieutenant, 219–20

  Belgian forces, in the Ardennes, 43–50

  Bertin-Bossu, General, 308

  Billotte, General, 284–85

  blitzkrieg, xv–xvi, 341–42

  Blumentritt, Günther, 78

  Bodange, 43–50, 44

  Chasseurs Ardennais at, 45–48

  delays at, 52–54

  Boutancourt, 2nd Panzer Division at, 324–25

  Boyer, Captain, 201–2

  Breda Variant, 9–13

  Brocard, Antoine, failure of 3rd Armored Division and, 298–309

  Bruché, General, as 2nd Armored Division commander, 333–36

  Bulson, attack toward, 216–19

  bunkers, at Sedan, 350

  Cachou, Lieutenant Colonel, preparation for counterattack and, 263–68

  Campaign of 1940, xiii–xiv

  Bodange, 44

  dispositions of forces
and plans, 3

  fight in Belgium, 33

  French strategy in, 2–13

  German fight in the Ardennes, 28–71

  German strategy in, 13–22

  myths surrounding, xv–xvii, 350

  special operations, 41–42

  see also Meuse, Battle of the

  Carribou, Captain

  on aerial attacks, 140

  behind Torcy, 183–89

  on French Infantry personnel policies, 208

  casualties

  comparison between French and German, 348–49

  Connage, 241

  cavalry, French, see French cavalry

  Chaligne, Colonel

  at Chémery, 264–65

  collapse of 55th Division and, 278–79

  counterattack and, 275–78

  at Fond Dagot, 252–53

  learning the details of plan for counterattack, 265–66

  panic of the 55th Division and, 200–6

  Chanoine, General, 83, 318–22

  Charita, Lieutenant, 194

  Chasseurs Ardennais, at Martelange and Bodange, 45–48

  Chémery

  55th Infantry Division failure to halt move toward, 255

  German attack toward, 219–22

  7th Tank Battalion action around, 272–73

  Clausener, Captain, Semois River action and, 89–94

  colmater process, 24, 116

  Connage

  action, 220–21

  casualties, 241

  counterattack, French, by the 55th Division, 251–79

  Crousse, Captain, 195–96

  d'Astier, General, 286

  de Gaulle, Charles, 338

  de Lattre, General, mission, 327–33

  de Saint Cernin, Major, counterattack and, 275–78

  Demay, Lieutenant Colonel, 115

  Directive No. 6, 15–16

  Directive No. 8, 18

  Dittman, Lieutenant Colonel, 222

  doctrine, French, see French doctrine

  doctrine, German, see German doctrine

  Donchery, 2nd Panzer Division at, 169–71

  Drapier, Lieutenant, 207

  Duhautois, Brigadier General, on 55th Division panic, 203

  Dyle Plan, 7–9

  Enigma machines, 74

  Escaut Plan, 7

  Etcheberrigaray, General, mission, 323–27

  Faissault, action at, 331–32

  5th Light Cavalry Division, at Vendresse and La Horgne, 318–22

  XVth Panzer Corps, 21

  53rd Infantry Division

  collapse of, 322–27

  mission, 324

  orders to seal gap, 325

  withdrawal to Vence River, 326–27

  55th Infantry Division, 106

  assessing the situation around Sedan, 251–53

  bunker construction, 123

  causes of panic and sequence of events, 203

  collapse of, 278–79

  communications of, 275

  coordination between tanks and infantry of, 271–72

  counterattack by, 268–78

  cowardly performance of artillery, 204–5

  criticisms of men of the, 119

  effect of panic on fighting capability of, 205–6

  explanation for poor performance of, 208–9

  failure to halt move toward Chémery, 255

  holding ground, 117

  lack of cohesion and training within, 133

  lack of mines, 122–23

  máteriél shortages, 120–22

  mission, 115

  officers, 117–18

  panic of the, 200–6

  panic spread to other units of, 204

  perceptions of attitudes and abilities of, 120

  personnel and personnel shortages, 117, 118–19

  preparation for counterattack, 257–68

  reserve battalion, 116

  scale and nature of panic of, 202–3

  strength of, 118

  success of Germans against, 121

  training, 120

  units of, 115–16

  using the reserves of, 253–57

  1st Battalion, counterattack progress of, 269–71

  1st Cavalry Brigade, 318–22

  1st Infantry Regiment

  Chémery action, 219–22

  Connage action, 220–21

  crossing the Meuse, 144–50

  engineer units providing support for, 146

  fighting near Chateau of Bellevue, 148

  French principal line of resistance and, 149–50

  Guderian visit, 246–47

  objective of, 222

  rapid advance of, 148

  reasons for success of, 144

  reinforcements, 144–46

  1st Motorcycle Battalion, southwest of St. Menges action, 148–49

  1st Panzer Division

  Allied aerial attacks and, 215

  artillery support for attack, 143

  Biourge capture, 64–65

  at Bouillon, 67–69

  at Bulson, 216–19

  at Chémery, 219–22

  Connage action, 217

  daily log records of Meuse River crossing, 211–12

  final preparations for attack, 142–43

  at Gaulier, 141–43

  at Maisoncelle, 216–19

  Meuse River crossing, 145

  at Mouzaive, 68–70

  objective, 64

  plan, 142

  positions, 212–13

  push toward south, 211–16

  Rethel advance, 244–47

  screening forces, 63

  Semois River advance and crossing, 63–70

  at Singly, 241–44

  at Vendresse, 325

  wartime journal on initial fighting of, 147

  Flavigny, General, 288, 295

  halting attack, 304–5, 309

  Huntziger meeting, 296

  fortified houses, 111–12

  4th Tank Battalion, counterattack by, 274–78

  14th Infantry Division

  mission, 327–33

  position, 330–31

  reputation of, 327–28

  sealing gaps at Omont and Poix-Terron, 327–33

  43rd Assault Engineers, provided support for crossing Meuse, 146

  49th Engineer Battalion, breaking through main French defenses, 160–63

  Foucault, Captain, at Frénois, 175–83

  French cavalry

  Arlon-Florenville action, 84

  establishing series of phase lines, 83

  explanation for failure of, 88–89

  hampered by refugees, 88

  mission and organization of, 79–83

  at Mouzaive, 87

  performance of, 93–94

  Petitvoir action, 86

  preparing to move in Belgium, 83–89

  strength of, 81

  at Vendresse and La Horgne, 318–22

  see also individual divisions

  French doctrine, 22–25

  colmater process, 24, 116

  commanders post, 25

  decision makers, 25

  formulating, 22–24

  German doctrine differences, 28

  leadership style, 348, 349–50

  methodical battle, 23–24

  French infantry

  malfunctioning weapons of, 207

  performance of, 206–7

  personnel policies, 208

  weakness of the, 206–9

  see also individual divisions

  French intelligence

  Air Force reports, 96–97, 99, 101

  Army Group 1 reports, 97–98

  assessments of German order of battle, 73–79

  cipher section, 74

  Ninth Army reports, 100

  Second Army reports, 94–96, 97, 98–99, 100, 101

  French strategy, 2–13

  approach to protecting frontiers, 2

  Breda Variant, 9–13

  carrying out, 11–13

&nb
sp; considerations that influenced, 6

  defensive positions, 6–7

  Dyle Plan (Plan D), 7–9

  economic wealth and, 2–4

  Escaut Plan, 7

  fortifications, 5

  goal of, 2

  Frénois

  breakthrough at, 193–200

  2/331st Infantry Regiment at, 175–83

  Fuller, Major General, on importance of the fighting around Sedan, 341–42

  Gabel, Captain, 190–91, 192–93

  Gamelin, Maurice, 101–2, 283

  French strategy and, 7–13

  Garski, Eugen, Operation Niwi and, 50–52

  Gaulier, 1st Panzer Division at, 141–43

  Georges, General, 76–77, 283, 284, 292, 314, 323, 337

  counterattack at Sedan, 307–8

  French strategy and, 10

  German doctrine, 25–28

  concept of continuous battle, 25–26

  decentralization and initiative, 26–27

  development of Panzer divisions, 27–28

  French doctrine differences, 28

  infiltration tactics, 26

  introduction of tanks, 27–28

  leadership style, 347, 349–50

  mission-oriented tactics, 344–47

  mobility, 26

  tradition of auftragstaktik, 27

  German strategy, 1, 13–22

  encirclement and annihilation, 339

  Hitler's statement on, 14–15

  Plan Yellow, 16–22

  shifting main effort from one Army Group to another, 18

  Giordani, Major, 264

  Giraud, Henri, 337

  Grand Duchy, special operations in, 41–42

  Grandsard, General, 112, 114, 261

  Greim, Major, as Gross Deutschand Regiment commander, 151–56

  Gross Deutschland Regiment, 51, 150–56, 214–15

  attached to 10th Panzer Division, 54–60

  capture of French center of resistance bunker, 155

  crossing points, 152–53

  in Floing, 151

  French defenders in Torcy delayed advance of, 153–54

  Hill 247 objective, 153, 155–56

  Guderian, Heinz, 78, 214, 222

  account of battle near Etalle, 56–60

  aerial operations over Sedan and, 138–41

  on crossing the Meuse, 135–38

  decision about making pivot to the west, 230–31

  1st Infantry Regiment visit, 246–47

  German fight in the Ardennes and, 29–71

  propelled his corps forward, 234

  resignation of, 248–49

  securing flank for advance of, 234–41

  von Kleist debate, 231–32

  Halder, Franz, 20, 38, 78

  German strategy and, 13, 16

  Hanbauer, Lieutenant, crossing Meuse River near Wadelincourt, 163–68

 

‹ Prev