A Dark and Stormy Knight

by Byrne, Kerrigan

  Morley’s fingers still itched to throttle the man often. Or, like now, punch the vaguely superior expression from his features and blacken the obsidian eye that wasn’t covered by the eyepatch.

  But alas, he could not. Morley and the so-called Blackheart of Ben More had established a truce recently—well, a ceasefire—for the sake of the man they both called brother.

  The real Dorian Blackwell—now Ash—and an orphan named Dougan Mackenzie had been locked in Newgate Prison together as boys. Because of their similar looks, black hair, and dark-as-the-devil eyes, they’d been christened the Blackheart Brothers in Newgate, and the infamous moniker had followed them through a menagerie of miseries and misdeeds.

  Upon Dorian’s supposed death in prison, Dougan Mackenzie, who was serving a life sentence for the murder of a pedophile, assumed Dorian Blackwell’s identity and release date.

  He lived as Dorian Blackwell for two decades, as the reigning King of the London Underworld, whilst the real Dorian, having crawled out of a mass grave with no memory, lived as the Rook, King of the High Seas.

  However, when Ash reclaimed his memory, he saw no great need to reclaim his name from his good friend, as his life with Lorelai Weatherstoke was the epitome of his happy ending.

  When all was said and done, both Ash and Dorian decided to live with names they’d adopted instead of the ones they’d been born with.

  Only Morley and Argent were the wiser. And all the more befuddled for it.

  However, since Morley also lived under an assumed name, he could hardly cast aspersions.

  People in glass houses and all that.

  Dorian strode up alongside Ash with his hands resting comfortably in his pockets. He bumped the pirate with his elbow in a show of camaraderie. An extraordinary thing, as Dorian famously hated to be touched by all but his wife, Farah.

  Though the Blackheart Brothers looked much alike as young men, time had separated them somewhat. Standing side by side as they were, it was easy to tell them apart. Ash wore his hair close-cropped, and his skin was swarthy and weathered by years at sea. The grooves branching from his eyes and the brackets of his mouth were carved deeper into features more savage than Dorian’s pale, satirical visage.

  Despite his eyepatch, Dorian remained as handsome as the very devil. He displayed more spirit and mirth than his piratical counterpart, wore his hair down to his collar, and outweighed Ash by perhaps half a stone.

  “Here’s trouble,” Dorian greeted Argent with a slap to the shoulder as the amber-haired man strode in holding a coffee and a paper.

  Argent cast his previous employer a congenial nod. He at least, turned to shut the door behind him, cutting their conclave of reprobates off from an increasingly curious detective branch.

  “Christ, almighty,” Morley said by way of salutation. “I’ve no time for trouble if you’ve brought it to my doorstep. Not today.”

  “Well, considering the exsanguinated Earl you’ve cooling in your morgue, I’d say we’ve arrived in the nick of time,” Ash went to the window and opened the drapes onto Whitehall Place, uncovering an unfettered view of the spires of Parliament. “We’d meant to discuss Commissioner Goode with you after the wedding, but it seems that needs must.”

  Morley’s lips compressed. “What about him?”

  “Something is rotten in the State of Denmark,” Dorian quoted significantly. “And the closer we come to the Yard, the more it stinks to high heaven.”

  “Out with it, both of you,” Morley barked. “I don’t have time for your cryptic dramatics today.”

  “No time for corruption in your own department?” Ash’s black brow arched, and he speared Morley with a meaningful look.

  “We’ve information that the ironically named ‘Goode’ needs a bit of moral direction,” Dorian informed him with no small amount of smugness. “Who did we think of but your august self, Morley? This place is your life and your wife, and the shadows of justice your mistress. Goode’s the perfect man to ruin, especially for your career. You could rise and take his place.”

  Morley shook his head, rejecting the very idea. On today of all days? Could he not escape the name Goode? “Why would I do such a thing? What have you heard?”

  Ash turned from the window. The light reflected off the lye burn scars that crawled up his neck and clawed at his jaw. When he spoke, it was with a great deal less inflection than his more demonstrative counterpart. “Goode’s nobility was built hundreds of years ago on the import of lumber to our little island, but I have it on good authority that his shipping company is smuggling more than just wood. There’s a plant being hailed in the Americas as the new drug of the century.”

  “The coca plant,” Morley nodded. “I’ve heard of it. It’s not exactly illegal to ship it here, and it’s widely used therapeutically.”

  Dorian made a disgusted noise. “It is illegal if the substance isn’t declared at customs, and if it’s not being delivered to doctors, but instead distributed to obsessed ghouls by coppers who are little better than bookies handing out beatings if they’re not paid on time.”

  Morley looked from Dorian’s one good eye, to Ash, and then to Argent, who studied the dark-haired men intently from where he held up the far wall with his leaning shoulders. “You’re sure of this?” he asked.

  Ash nodded. “I’m certain the plants are coming from his ships. Though where it’s being refined into cocaine, I couldn’t tell you.”

  “And I’m certain the drug is being leaked onto the streets by your officers,” Dorian insisted. “In the poor and rich boroughs alike.”

  “How certain?” Morley pressed.

  “As sure as we are that you’ve nothing to do with it,” Ash said. “And we’ve all the evidence you need to open up further investigation. However, since this man is your only superior, and you’ve no quiet way to investigate your own officers, I’d suggest the Knight of Shadows conduct the inquiry.”

  The Knight of Shadows. Did he want to be the sort of man who policed his own?

  Was he truly so ignorant about what the Commissioner might be doing behind his back?

  Morley stared at the three men who stood in front of his desk. Three men who’d once been three boys beaten down by the very laws that were supposed to protect them. They’d forged a bond together as teens in Newgate Prison that nothing on this earth could pull asunder.

  Morley’s own path had taken him on an entirely different road. A road that became a line between them. A line as tangible as the desk behind which he stood.

  Alone.

  They’d always stand together, those three. And no matter how much they trusted him, Morley never saw the insides of those prison walls and would thereby forever stay on the outside of their coterie.

  On the other side of the line.

  He’d been fine with that because his life had become one of order and regimentation where theirs were chaos and anarchy.

  Cutter had followed the laws of the streets once.

  But Carlton could not. He didn’t exist without boundaries. He wanted the boundaries drawn in no uncertain terms so he could see exactly which parameters he was supposed to work within. He was a man forged in the meat grinder of war and then polished by the police force.

  Except lately, the lines had been blurred by the Knight of Shadows. And he’d leapt over one particular line so far, he couldn’t see it anymore.

  And the consequences were about to be cataclysmic.

  He lowered himself into his high-backed leather chair. The legs of which no longer felt so dense and steady. As if he could topple from his throne at any time. “I hear what you’re saying, and I agree that this demands further investigation. But…there is a complication in regards to me.”

  “Do tell.” Dorian’s eye sharpened, and he was instantly rapt. “You are a famously uncomplicated man.”

  Morley let that go for now. “I’ve become a bit…” He cast about for the right word. Embroiled? Consumed? Obsessed? Entangled? “Involved with Commissioner Goode’s d
aughter.”

  Argent perked to that. “Which one? Doesn’t he have several?”

  Morley swallowed, knowing that once this was out in the open, he could never take it back. It would be painful to endure their reactions, but possibly worth it if they could help him see through his pall to a course of action.

  “The one whose wedding was interrupted by a murder,” he muttered.

  “Swift work, Morley,” Ash exclaimed. “That was only what, three minutes ago?”

  “Hours—”

  Ash didn’t appear to listen. “She’s not technically a widow, so you don’t have to wait the requisite year—”

  Morley interjected. “No, you idiot, it was before today. Three months before.”

  Dorian gave an exaggerated gasp and clutched at his lapels, adopting an overwrought conservative, blustery affect. “An affair, Morley? A Chief Inspector and a knight of the realm. How utterly reprehensible.”

  “Morally derelict, I dare say,” Ash added with a lopsided grin.

  “Quite right,” Dorian thumped him. “What will they think at church?”

  Morley didn’t even have it in him to rise to their japes as he buried his head in his hands. “It’s worse than that, I’m afraid. I’ve locked her in one of the cells downstairs.”

  A protracted silence caused him to look up, but he didn’t find the astonishment he’d expected.

  In fact, these hard men with terrible reputations seemed to be fighting back almost proud smiles. “If I’m honest, Morley, a bit of kidnapping is no insurmountable impediment,” Ash shrugged. “Show us a man in this room who hasn’t had to lock his lady-love in some form of prison before she’d consent to be his wife.”

  “It was a Scottish castle for me,” Dorian said with no little nostalgia.

  “I’ll see your Scottish tower, and raise you a pirate ship,” Ash bragged.

  “Closet,” the monosyllabic Argent added.

  Each of them shared a chuckle and, not for the first time, Morley was hit by a wave of sympathy for their wives.

  “What happened?” Ash asked Morley, after wiping his smile from his lips with the back of his hand.

  Morley pressed two fingers to each temple and worked in circles. He was about to regret this, but he needed to confess. To purge the sin that’d been weighing on him for so many weeks.

  Because it’d been so long since he’d been so lost.

  “Have any of you heard of the Stags of St. James?”

  Ash and Argent shook their heads, but Dorian nodded. “Noble women pay fortunes for their sexual services. Madame Regina, who runs my brothel, suggested we recruit a few from Henrietta Thistledown.”

  Morley cleared a gather of shame from his throat. “Well, I was out one night, just about three months ago…”

  “Being a vigilante?” Dorain asked.

  “Investigating,” he corrected.

  “No one else investigates with a mask, but do go on.”

  Once again, he let that go. “My investigation of some murdered men took me to Miss Henrietta’s, where they’d worked as stags. I was in the garden and Miss Goode sort of…mistook me for…” He couldn’t bring himself to say the bloody word.

  Ash’s mouth fell open. “A prostitute?”

  “Is she blind?” Dorian’s nose wrinkled as he raked him with a disbelieving glare.

  Morley sat back in his chair, cursing himself for saying a damned word to any of them.

  It was Argent who leaned forward, his expression fascinated. “And?”

  “And…we…” Morley flicked his hand out in a gesture that could have meant anything.

  “Holy fucking Christ, you didn’t,” Dorian shook his head as if begging him to deny it and hoping he wouldn’t.

  “I need to sit down.” Argent groped for the chair across from his desk and settled his hulking frame into it.

  “I need a drink.” Ash went to the sideboard next to the door.

  Dorian stayed where he was, staring at Morley. “You deflowered a Baron’s daughter, no, a Commissioner’s daughter—your boss’s daughter—before her wedding and got her to pay you for it? Christ, Morley, I’ve misjudged you all this time. Color me bloody impressed.”

  “Don’t,” Morley warned.

  “Oh, don’t be cross.” Dorian waved his leather-gloved hand at him. “I’m certain you did it properly and thoroughly as you do everything else and then made up for it with piles of guilt and self-flagellation and sleepless nights and all that rubbish.”

  Morley crossed his arms. “I’m not discussing this with you further.” He never flagellated himself, bastard didn’t know what he was talking about.

  Ash stepped forward, a drink in hand. “Don’t heed Dorian. Pearls before swine and all that.”

  Dorian feigned outrage. “Speak for yourself, I’m not the one rolling in the dirt with betrothed debutants.”

  They all looked at Morley and lost their battle with mirth.

  “I didn’t know who she was at the time,” Morley explained darkly. “Or I’d never have touched her.”

  Ash came behind the desk where Morley sat, and put a glass in front of him. He leaned a hip on the edge and poured Morley a healthy snifter from his own decanter before patting him on the shoulder. “I, for one, am delighted,” he said, encouraging him to drink. “You were living like a monk, and let’s be honest, you never were very good with women.”

  “A monk?” Dorian scoffed. “I was worried he was a bloody eunuch.”

  “Or had a terrible predilection,” Ash added.

  “That wouldn’t bother me so much,” Argent cut in, declining a drink with a wave of his hand as he sipped his coffee. “I never trust a man without a dark side.”

  Dorian’s shoulder leaned against the wall and he crossed one foot in front of the other, a cruel gleam in his dark eye. “All this time I worried you took no other lovers because you were still in love with my wife.”

  “Enough.” Morley tossed his whisky back and slammed the empty glass onto the table with a bang loud enough to be heard by the occupants of the floor below them.

  For a man who didn’t believe in miracles, he knew he was witnessing one now as they all blinked at him in blessed silence.

  Wouldn’t last long, he thought bitterly.

  They’d been taciturn villains all, before their women had made them happy.

  Happy men never seemed to tire of conversation.

  Except Argent, who only spoke when words were absolutely required.

  “So angry, Morley,” Dorian tutted. “Struck a nerve?”

  Ash tossed a disapproving look over his shoulder at Dorian. “A low blow, Dorian, even for you. We are all of us angry men. It is that anger that drives the best of us to succeed.”

  “Au contraire, mon frère,” the Blackheart of Ben More twisted an imaginary villainous mustache, ever unrepentant. “Cunning. Cunning is how we do what needs done.”

  “This isn’t a bloody lark, it’s my life,” Morley grit out from between clenched teeth. “She’s seen me as the Knight of Shadows. We engaged in a scandalous affair for a night. And now she’s down there having quite likely murdered her fiancé and desperate to tell anyone who would listen my secrets.”

  “Does she recognize you as the Knight of Shadows?” Argent speared him with a serious gaze.

  Morley nodded, feeling distinctly defeated.

  “There’s more to this, isn’t there,” Argent stated dryly, narrowing his verdant eyes. “Something you’re not telling us.”

  Morley’s head snapped up. There was no way for Argent to know, but the bastard was an infuriating genius when it came to reading other people.

  “Is she blackmailing you or something?” the taciturn detective inquired.

  Morley shook his head. “Worse. She’s claiming I impregnated her that night.”

  At that, all sense of joviality drained from the room as the enormity of the situation pressed the very air into something heavy and dark.

  For all their differences, all four of
them had something very much in common.

  They’d grown up without paternal care. Their fathers had abandoned them at best and tried to murder them at worst.

  “Do you have any reason to believe her?” Dorian asked. “Have you seen proof of her condition or is she simply desperate to save her neck?”

  “She hired a prostitute,” Ash said carefully. “So, there’s the possibility the father of her child could have been any number of men.”

  Morley thought on that, and then violently rejected that notion, voicing the fear he’d had for some weeks now. “I’m not certain she’d ever truly had a lover before me.”

  All the men suddenly seemed uncomfortable, but it was Dorian who said, “Well… I mean… there’s an uncomplicated way to tell.”

  “Not… the way we… Holy Christ I don’t know.” Morley buried his hands in his hair and pulled.

  “I’m afraid to ask, and yet I find myself anxious to find out,” Argent said as if this surprised him.

  Morley sorely wished he could be anywhere else. He couldn’t very well admit that he was so bloody ravenous that he might not have noticed the physical barrier of her virginity.

  That her arms were so sweet. Her body so tight, yet welcoming. Her moans might have been pleasure or pain, but her words were nothing but encouraging.

  He proceeded carefully. “She wasn’t…experienced, but neither did I notice a… physical impediment. She wasn’t the shy, wilting flower, obviously, she approached me. But, neither was she a vixen. She’d found out about the Earl of Sutherland’s infidelity and was angry at his selfishness. She wanted a lover of her own.”

  He didn’t want to give them more. To say how adorable she’d been. And so damnably desirable he’d been on the verge of orgasm the minute they’d kissed. He’d been beneath her skirts as he feasted her to completion and was unable to tell if she were shocked or expectant. Nervous or experienced.

  And yet. He’d known it was her first climax. She’d left no doubt about that.

  “She made it sound like her intended was a selfish lover,” he defended himself to no one in particular at this point. “But I can’t say for certain now that she knew this firsthand. And she never went back to Miss Henrietta’s. I paid to be informed the moment she did. So the chances of her hiring another lover are slim.”