Couldn't Cheat Death

by A. P. Eisen

  Couldn’t Cheat Death

  July 2019

  Copyright © 2019 by A.P. Eisen

  Kindle Edition

  Cover Artist: Reese Dante

  Cover content is for illustrative purposes only. Any person depicted on the cover is a model.

  All rights reserved

  No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from A.P. Eisen at www.apeisen.com.

  This is a work of fiction. Any resemblance to persons living or dead is entirely coincidental.

  About the Book

  Detective Paul Monroe has little room in his life for anything but work. Maintaining order and solving cases in the town of Thornwood Park keeps him busy. When Jerry Gregoria, a popular bartender and personal trainer is found murdered, there’s no shortage of suspects. It seems Jerry was busy shaking more than cocktails all over town, leaving Paul and his partner with an ever-growing list of men and women who have reasons to want Jerry dead. The deeper Paul delves into the case, the more he finds himself drawn to hotel manager Cliff Baxter, whom he hasn’t seen in years.

  Cliff Baxter’s childhood crush on Paul Monroe hasn’t waned since high school. In fact, with the sexy detective conducting the investigation at the hotel, Cliff is more than happy to help. Ever since his last relationship went up in flames, Cliff has made it a rule to never get involved with a closeted man. But after Paul is threatened and things between the two heat up, Cliff decides to make an exception.

  With new twists in the case popping up every day and the mayor breathing down the police department’s neck, Paul needs to solve the case yesterday. It takes a crisis for Paul and Cliff to realize what started out as something casual could be everything they’ve both been looking for but never thought to find. But if the killer strikes again, they might never get that chance.

  Dedication

  To my father. Thanks, Daddy for giving me the love of a good mystery.

  Table of Contents

  Copyright Page

  About the Book

  Dedication

  Title Page

  Chapter One

  Chapter Two

  Chapter Three

  Chapter Four

  Chapter Five

  Chapter Six

  Chapter Seven

  Chapter Eight

  Chapter Nine

  Chapter Ten

  Chapter Eleven

  Chapter Twelve

  Chapter Thirteen

  Chapter Fourteen

  Chapter Fifteen

  Chapter Sixteen

  Chapter Seventeen

  Dear Reader

  Acknowledgments

  About A.P. Eisen

  COULDN’T CHEAT DEATH

  By

  A.P. EISEN

  CHAPTER ONE

  Death was never pleasant, but even less so on an empty stomach.

  Detective Paul Monroe of the Thornwood Park Police Department tipped the paper cup to his lips, swallowed the last, now-lukewarm dregs of his black coffee, and grunted in disgust. He must be a coldhearted bastard to be worrying about his stomach rather than the dead man sprawled less than one hundred feet from him with an extremely ugly looking knife sticking out of his neck. He set the cup in the holder, exited his car, and walked over to where the victim lay facedown on the ground. A crowd had formed outside the taped-off area, craning their necks to catch a glimpse of the gruesome scene.

  The Starrywood Hotel was the town’s largest, and while the ground-floor parking was accessible directly from the street, there were two additional parking levels that required use of the elevators. Spring had come to Thornwood Park, but a chilly breeze blew inside through the open cement walls overlooking downtown, and Paul could see puffs of white clouds in the blue skies.

  He flipped open his memo pad as the pale, sweaty responding officer approached him. His badge read Portman, and from his nervous demeanor, Paul guessed he was one of the new recruits. Portman’s partner finished taping the perimeter of the scene and began speaking with a young, dark-haired woman who couldn’t stop sobbing.

  Welcome to the real world.

  “What do we have so far?” Paul asked Portman.

  “Well, we got a call from that woman giving her statement to my partner. Said she came out this evening at five forty-five, went to her car, and found the guy. She didn’t touch nothing.”

  Rob Gormley, Paul’s partner for the past five years, drove up and joined the cop questioning the witness who seemed distraught but capable of answering the questions put to her. Paul knew that between Brightman, the other cop who was a veteran with ten years on the force, and Rob, they’d get all the information needed. Rob, who was keeping an eye on their surroundings, acknowledged Paul with a tip of his head and a quick rise and fall of his brows.

  With Portman on his heels, Paul walked over to where the deceased lay, a creeping dark stain of blood underneath him. His body had fallen onto the empty parking space next to his car. “The coroner on her way?”

  “Yeah,” Portman replied. “She’ll be here any minute. When I touched his neck, it was still warm, so I’m guessing the kill was pretty fresh.”

  “Good observation.”

  Portman flushed at the praise and got chattier. “Nice set of wheels, right? From what I heard the witness saying, the guy was a bartender in the hotel, so he must’ve been making some good money in tips to afford a ride like this one.”

  Never one to pay too much attention to sports cars, Paul took a closer look. It was a sporty red model with a sunroof. A pair of sunglasses rested on the console, and an empty Starbucks cup sat in the cup holder. Other than that, it was clean.

  “I’m going to talk to Rob and Brightman. Make sure no one comes near.”

  Portman nodded. “Will do.” Given his orders, Portman bustled over to the gathering crowd. “Keep back, please. Stay back.”

  Paul hurried over to where Rob and Brightman were finishing up with the witness, who was dabbing at her eyes continuously with a crumpled tissue.

  “I’m Detective Monroe.”

  She slanted a look up at him and sniffled. “H-hello.”

  Rob continued to scribble in his notepad. “Ms. Arminster, we’re just about finished.” Then to Paul, “She said she didn’t see anyone but the victim.”

  Often in the initial questioning, facts that didn’t seem important would be left out, only to reappear later, when more subtle questions were asked, so Paul queried, “Did you notice anything strange—any sounds or smells, perhaps?” Paul once tracked down a killer by the unusual and incredibly expensive aftershave he wore. The scent had remained in the air, and particles were found in the skin samples collected from the victim’s fingernails.

  “No, nothing.” Her glossy black hair swished over her shoulders. “I left my shift at the front desk a little late because Mr. Baxter was talking to me. Maybe if I were on time, I would’ve scared off the person who did this, and Jerry would be okay.” A fresh torrent of tears threatened.

  “Jerry’s the victim, I presume?” Paul addressed Brightman while jotting down what the witness stated. “What else do we have on him?”

  “Yeah. Jerry Gregoria. A bartender in the hotel.” Brightman flipped back a few pages in his memo book. “Thirty-two years old. He was also a personal trainer at one of the new gyms in town—Flex. You heard of it?”

  Paul shrugged. “No, but I don’t get out much.”

  Rob chuckled. “Ain’t that the truth.”

  Paul allowed himself a thin smile. His tenacity and dedication to the force were well-known. They called him Bulldog because he never gave up without a fight,
refusing to let a case go unsolved. The result was an incredibly high success rate for solving crimes, but not much else in his life.

  “So Jerry must have left work at around five thirty? Seems kind of early.”

  Ms. Arminster said, “No, he was coming in, not leaving. Jerry always worked the late shift. The crowd loved him, and he made awesome tips. He used to bartend in Vegas, and would put on a show with the cocktail shakers.”

  “Gotcha. Can you tell me, Ms. Arminster, did he work the same hours every day, and was the schedule set weekly or monthly? If you know, of course.”

  She blinked. “Hmm, I’m not sure. You’d have to ask the restaurant manager. She sets the schedule.” Her hand went to her mouth. “Jade will be devastated. She loved Jerry.”

  “Were they close friends? And do you know her last name?”

  “I told the officer, her last name is Kennedy.” She checked her watch, and her eyes widened in dismay. “Is there much more? I have a babysitter and need to get home.”

  He and Rob exchanged weary glances. Witnesses were happy to help as long as it didn’t interfere with their plans. Murder didn’t follow a schedule, unfortunately. But Paul understood.

  “Of course. But we will most likely need to speak with you again.”

  “Okay.” She hurried over to her car, a dark sedan parked two spaces away from the victim. The coroner, Lanie Howard, had arrived while they were questioning Ms. Arminster, and Paul waited until she finished giving instructions to her assistant before approaching her.

  “What do you think?”

  Lanie had been with the coroner’s office for over twenty years and had seen it all. She pulled off her nitrile gloves. “Well, it was a pretty vicious stabbing. Went right through the carotid artery, and he bled out in minutes. Whoever did it stabbed him again through the back of the neck.”

  “Oh, so two wounds? Interesting…”

  “Yeah.” She pursed her lips in thought. “Like they wanted to make sure he was dead. We’ll get the exact cause once the autopsy is done.”

  The stretcher wheels screeched, and Paul could see them loading the body into the van.

  “Of course. I’ll talk to you later. Gonna nose around a little.”

  “It’s what you guys do.”

  He smiled and slipped his notepad back into his jacket pocket. The knife would already be safely ensconced in an evidence bag with the forensics team. He and Rob walked over to the scene, and Paul noticed with a wry smile that once the body had been removed, and with it the gruesomeness of the situation, the crowd dispersed. Paul preferred it that way so he could do his job unencumbered. The forensics team was combing the area, and from their mutterings, coming up with as little as he had. They were a good bunch, thorough and focused, and Paul knew if there was something to be found, they would not disappoint.

  The blood had soaked into the cement, leaving a dark, damp splotch as the only indication Jerry Gregoria had lain there. Paul walked around, eyes on the ground, seeing nothing but the smooth surface of cement. Gregoria hadn’t been a huge guy, maybe five foot eleven and a hundred and eighty pounds. From the way his body was angled, it seemed the killer had come up from behind, stuck the knife into the side of his neck, slicing through the artery, and then, probably after Gregoria had fallen forward, shoved it into his nape. Blood droplets had sprayed outward and hit the windows of the red car as well as the side door and mirror, and Paul guessed the killer would’ve gotten some blood on themself as well.

  He crouched to his knees to look under the car, but it was as empty as the rest of the ground. He stood.

  “Wallet and valuables still on him?” he asked Brightman, who was waiting by his side.

  “Yep. With all his cash, and he had close to a hundred bucks on him. Plus, his Apple watch was still there. This wasn’t a robbery, Paul. Someone came here intent on killing Gregoria.”

  “Yeah. Looks like it. Guess we’d better go inside and start talking to his coworkers.” He clapped Brightman on the back.

  Walking away, he heard their names being called. “Paul, Rob.”

  He turned to see Manny Rodriguez, the chief of the forensics team, waving him over to where the group stood. Adrenaline kicked in as he strode to the car, Rob on his heels. “You got something?”

  “Not sure, but something weird, though.”

  “Yeah? What?”

  Manny held up a small evidence bag. “There were some faint, sandy footprints. We swept up some of the sand.”

  “Good. I’m sure the footprints were measured and photographed?”

  “Paul, you wound me. How many years have we worked together? At least ten? Have you ever known any member of my team to forget a detail like that?” Manny’s dark eyes flashed with pretend annoyance.

  “No, of course not,” Paul said soothingly. “Just checking off all my boxes. We’re pretty close to the shore, less than two miles. I wonder if it will prove relevant.” Could Jerry have gone to the beach with his killer and brought the person back to the hotel? Another possibility to consider.

  “No idea, but we’ve got it in case it does.”

  The rest of the team joined them.

  “Nothing else, Manny,” Silvia said. Manny’s second in command was a big, broad-shouldered woman. She was an ex-military MP, her husband a retired Army pilot. Paul knew Silvia to be a perfectionist. “It’s pretty clean for a garage floor.”

  “Maybe they wash it down nightly—who knows?” Paul said. “I’ll ask the hotel manager when I talk to him. He’s first on my list.”

  “Sounds good. Talk to you later.” Manny, Silvia, and the other members of their team climbed into their city-owned van. They drove by Paul and Rob, who were on their way back to the garage entrance. Gregoria had parked in the employees’ section on the ground floor, which had direct access to the lobby.

  The Starrywood was the main convention hotel in town. On any given day, it was filled to capacity with salespeople and companies providing team-building exercises for their employees or holding events. It consisted of eight stories and two hundred and fifty rooms. Walking through the lobby, Paul could only hope he wouldn’t have to interview every damn person. If the killer was a guest, the logistics could be a nightmare, especially if they’d already checked out.

  “Don’t be so negative,” Paul muttered to himself as he and Rob approached the front desk.

  “There are tons of people here. Jesus. We’re gonna need to split up, otherwise we’ll never get this done.”

  “Yeah. Why don’t you wander around to the bar, see what you can pick up while I question the hotel manager? What do you think?”

  “Sounds good. Check back with you in a few.”

  Rob strolled away, not surprisingly capturing the attention of a few female guests. Paul grinned. Rob knew how to turn on the charm when interviewing, and witnesses often gave him much more information than they gave Paul, who was all business and no-nonsense.

  At the front desk, a flustered young man in his midtwenties watched him approach with wide, frightened eyes. “Is there a problem? We’ve seen all these police cars.”

  Ignoring his question, Paul flashed his badge discreetly and watched the young man’s Adam’s apple bob. “I’m Detective Paul Monroe. May I speak with the hotel manager?”

  “Um, sure, yes. One moment.” The smile faded, replaced by disbelief. He grabbed the phone. “Cliff?” His voice cracked. “There’s a policeman here to see you.”

  “Detective, actually,” Paul said mildly.

  “He’s a detective,” the young man hissed. He nodded so fast, it made Paul dizzy. “Okay, okay.” He hung up the receiver but missed and had to try again.

  Paul wondered why he was so nervous, and gave him a penetrating stare. “Everything okay? You seem awfully jumpy. Anything you want to tell me?”

  “N-no. I’m fine. Nothing’s wrong.” But he backed away and stood twisting his hands.

  The door behind the front desk opened, and a good-looking man stepped out. He wore a gr
ay suit, pale-blue shirt, and a purple-and-blue striped tie. A thick head of reddish-brown wavy hair brushed off his high forehead. Wide brown eyes surrounded by a thick fringe of dark lashes gazed steadily at Paul, and a faintly sardonic smile rested on his lips.

  “Detective Paul Monroe.” Baxter said it more as a statement than a question.

  A prickling sensation ran down Paul’s back, but he shook it off. “Yes. You’re Cliff Baxter?”

  “I am. Come inside, please, so we can talk freely.” Without waiting, Baxter spun around and walked to his office.

  Bemused, Paul trailed behind him, catching the scent of his aftershave. When they arrived at his office, Paul passed by Baxter and waited for him to close the door.

  “Sit down, please.” Baxter took a seat behind his desk. “Well, Detective Monroe, what can I do for you?”

  Rubbing the nape of his neck, Paul wondered why he felt off-center sitting before this man. He decided not to hold anything back and pulled out his pad while keeping his eyes on Baxter to gauge his reaction to the question.

  “Do you know Jerry Gregoria?”

  Baxter’s eyes narrowed. “Yes. Jerry is a bartender in our restaurant. Is everything okay with him? Did he get hurt?”

  Studying Baxter’s face, Paul’s gut feeling was that Baxter didn’t know what happened to Jerry. “Jerry was found murdered in the parking garage about half an hour ago.”

  The blandness of Baxter’s expression faded, and he turned white and began to tremble. Horror filled his wide eyes. “Murdered? Jerry? How? That can’t be. I just saw him yesterday.” He buried his head in his hands and dug his fingers into the thick swatches of his hair.

  “I’m sorry. I know it’s a terrible shock.”

  He didn’t answer for a moment, then in a dull voice said, “Yes. It is. H-how did it happen?”

  “He was stabbed.”

  Baxter winced. “That’s awful.” He touched his chest. “Do you know who did it? Has the person been caught?”