Triple Pass: An MFMM Reverse Harem Romance

by Sierra Sparks

  At seven that night, I walked through the back entrance of Amy’s dorm. I had a hoodie, so I don’t think anyone spotted me. Her dorm was on the far side of campus anyway, so it was usually pretty empty. I had prepared myself for an adult conversation about our situation. Plus, I had brought my books, prepared to study some more. Additionally, this provided added cover should anyone notice me here. Amy was an intellectual, so I wanted to impress her with my--- I guess you would call it--- Maturity. I knocked and the door opened.

  Amy was standing there in hot red lingerie that barely clung to her boobs and ass. I could feel myself getting a boner already and I knew at that moment, no studying was being done tonight.

  Chapter 16:

  Killian

  I am such an idiot for agreeing to be the last person at Amy’s dorm room. Why the fuck wouldn’t I volunteer to go first?! The truth was, I was barely listening to Teagan talk. All I could think about was that sweet, sweet pussy of Amy’s!

  Don’t get me wrong, I’ve had some hot pieces of ass in my time. I mean, girls that were models and that were beyond ten’s--- But nothing like Amy. Not only was she hot, she was just so sexual! It’s hot when a girl that’s not overtly sexual suddenly is when you’re in bed with her, but with Amy it was more.

  The transformation was very obvious to an outside observer. I guess this is the feeling the guys get that make those old Girls Gone Wild videos. Amy went from being a book nerd to being a total hottie. She’s already done stuff that most sorority girls couldn’t even think of.

  I don’t know what Teagan’s thinking of. He thinks he’s going to her dorm room to study?! On a Saturday night?! Why don’t I just become a priest already?! If I see one book when I get to Amy’s room, I am going to spend the entire time trying to fuck her. Screw grades tonight!

  As per my brother’s instructions, I wore a hoodie and approached Amy’s dorm from the parking lot entrance. Not a lot of people went in that way, but if the fire exit wasn’t propped open, I was screwed and would have to go around to the front. Fortunately, someone had ordered a pizza and left the door propped open for the delivery guy. I slipped inside and walked down the hall.

  On the way to Amy’s room, I passed by a room full of girls I knew from the football games. If they saw me, I was screwed. Fortunately, they were so caught up in singing and doing shots, they didn’t notice me. I got to Amy’s door and quickly knocked. I heard it unlock and rushed in.

  What greeted me inside, I did not expect!

  Amy had closed all the curtains and moved her bed in the center of the room. The lights were dimmed and my brothers were on either side of her, waiting. Amy was wearing red lingerie, which was barely clinging to her body.

  Now this was my kind of study session!

  “You guys have been studying so well, it’s time for your reward,” she said in a sultry voice.

  Hard to believe this was the same book nerd. Jesus, should’ve found a hot book nerd years ago and did this. This chick is out of control!

  “Take my clothes off, Killian,” she begged. “Peel me open like an Amazon parcel.”

  I threw my book bag aside. I won’t be needing that! Amy laid back on the bed, sexy enchantress that she had become. Her lingerie could be taken apart with little strips. I took them off one at a time exposing her arms, legs, breasts and sheer panties on her cooch.

  Teagan had a bottle of lotion. Lotion? Now we’re doing lotion?! Crazy, man! He lubed up his hands and started give her a massage. James and I wanted in on that action, so we got some of the lotion and each started rubbing her.

  “I love your big strong hands on my body,” she cooed. “It feels wonderful!”

  I started rubbing up her thighs and then got to her panties. They had bows on either side. I untied them and the panties fell away for easy access. I noticed now, Amy was completely shaven! I smiled.

  “Do you like my pussy now?” she asked. “I shaved it clean for you. All for you, O’Connors.”

  “Oh, yeah,” I said. “That’s a pretty pussy, baby. I think it needs to get fucked. You remember these magic fingers?”

  I put my hand on her smooth vagina lips and started rubbing. Teagan started making out with her, while James started to massage her breasts. He took the lotion and started pouring it all over her body. Her tits and torso were shiny under the dim light.

  “Let’s turn things up a bit,” I said.

  I turned up the light. Yeah, that was better.

  “Aw, now you can see all my imperfections,” she frowned.

  “Baby, I don’t see any,” I assured her. “You’re perfect! And I don’t want to miss a thing.”

  She looked at the boner in my pants. God damn, she made me hard!

  “I can see you’re not lying,” she laughed. “None of you are lying.”

  She reached up and started pulling down Teagan’s zipper. His cock tried to push its way out, but his underwear was in the way. She adjusted it and it popped out hard and ready to go. She immediately started sucking it. Damn, I’m on the wrong end!

  Some of the lotion ran down her body down to her bellybutton. I stopped it before it got to her pussy. I didn’t want to taste lotion, I wanted to taste her. I bent down and started licking, while fingerfucking her with two fingers. I flicked her clit with my tongue as my fingers danced insider her back and forth.

  “Mmmmm! Mmmm!” she moaned on Teagan’s cock.

  James took off his pants and underwear and threw them aside. There was just no denying it. His dick was gigantic. I lost count how many guys on the team suggested that he could do porn. He couldn’t, of course, he just wasn’t built for it. But God damn, his dick put some porn stars to shame!

  I was slobbering all over Amy’s wet holes. My tongue darted into her asshole and I pressed a pinky inside of her. She was now switching between James and Teagan. Alternately sucking one, while stroking the other, licking the balls of one, while playing with the balls of the other. It was like she couldn’t get enough of us. Amy was a sex machine in every sense of the word!

  “Oh, God!” she said. “I think I’m about to cum! Uhn!”

  On that last grunt, her hot juices squirted forth and hit my face. Women who know me know one thing: I love eating pussy. Amy’s pussy was like the Kobe beef of vagina. Cosmetically perfect and the taste was just amazing.

  I couldn’t take it any longer, I had to get my pants off. My dick was struggling against the inside of my clothes. I felt confined and like my circulation was being cut off. If I was going to hang out with Amy, I needed looser jeans. I tore off all my clothes and threw them aside.

  Moving toward her face, Teagan stepped over to the other side of the bed and James too my place down below. He couldn’t wait and slipped on a condom.

  “Fuck me, James!” begged Amy. “Fuck me hard!”

  Amy took my dick into her mouth. She licked all around the head, teasing her tongue at the hole. Her display, up until now, had really made me want to cum. Now, with her lips doing her magic, I was hard pressed to hold back.

  She lifted my veiny shaft and stuck her face in my balls. Licking and sucking like there was no tomorrow, I was starting to erupt. I couldn’t help it. I was just too turned on.

  “Oh! Oh, shit!” was all I could say as warning.

  Amy, somehow sensing my distress, immediately had her mouth on my cock just as I came. I grabbed the sides of her head and slowly fucked her mouth as I pumped my load down her throat. She gagged a little, but swallowed it all. The suction coming from her mouth was amazing. I came a couple of times after.

  She opened her mouth and looked up at me, showing the mouth full of cum I had put there. Then, she swallowed and kissed my cock. I sat down at her desk, a little spent, while she moved on to suck Teagan.

  Meanwhile, James had mounted her and was going to town. It was kind of cool to watch. Like watching a live action porn movie. So hot!

  Chapter 17:

  Amy

  James was pounding me with his giant cock, as I sucked
off his brother. It was a little uncomfortable on my back, so I decided to stop James for a moment and flip over while they were both inside me.

  All three of us moaned. It was a fantastic sensation!

  “Whoa! What was that?!” laughed Killian, who was just watching at this point. “Sign me up for some of that!”

  Now James was drilling me from behind like a sideways piledriver. I had to spread my legs as far as I could to accommodate him and I felt his cock deep inside me. Before the boys arrived, I had purposely moved the bed into the center of the room. I knew there’d be some intense fucking, so I didn’t want the bed smacking against the wall while we were getting off.

  The bed slid across the rug, but no one would be able to hear that through the walls. And, since it was Saturday, most of the other rooms were blasting music or TV, so forget about hearing the moans. Hell, this was one of the quiet dorms because it had been built with a lot of sound dampening walls.

  “Jesus. Holy shit!” said Teagan suddenly.

  I could tell he was on the verge. The force of James pounding me while I was sucking on Teagan pushed me to deep throat Teagan’s cock even further than I normally could. I was gagging and slobbering all over it, while tickling his balls. Opening my mouth, I jerked him rapidly to orgasm, allowing his spurts of cum to shoot across my tongue and on my face.

  “Ooooh! Gimme your cum! I want all of your cum!” I begged.

  Teagan was moaning while I was licking him for every stray drop. Once I was finished, he staggered back and leaned on the heating vent to my room. I had to grab the edge of the top of my bed to keep James from literally fucking me off the bed. The slap-slap-slap of his fucking into me was steady and audible. I could feel another orgasm burgeoning deep inside me.

  “Oooh! Awww!” I moaned. “Don’t stop! Don’t stop!”

  “Ah-ah-ah!” he said, on the verge of exploding.

  I could feel that the condom had either broke or slid off. It wasn’t surprising given the punishment it had gotten. I pulled off, turned around and opened my mouth. I could see that it had indeed broke and the remnants were hanging at the base of his shaft. In that split second, I could see his dick muscles tense up. His load was coming, and I was prepared to receive it.

  James fired his white hot batter like a Supersoaker. It filled my mouth and covered my face at the same time. I tried to get my lips over it, but I just wanted to be covered in his cum at that moment. Mmm! It was so meaty! So manly! I licked it all up until he was cleaned and then pulled it off my face and put it into my mouth.

  “Yum,” I said. “Thank you boys. There’s some drinks in my fridge. I hope that wasn’t all the drink you brought for me.”

  “Holy shit, your insatiable girl!” laughed Killian. “I’m ready!”

  It was Killian’s turn. He fucked like a jackrabbit and I couldn’t wait until his cock was inside me. He pushed in and just started pounding. He would pull it out and rub it against my clit, causing me to moan and orgasm, but mostly it was his fast pounding that did it for me. Since he had already just cum, it was easy for him to last.

  For ten minutes, he just kept fucking me. He’d lift up one leg for a better angle, then do me from behind, then turned me over (while he was inside me) and faced me while he fucked and made out with me. I wrapped my legs and arms around him and let him take complete control. Giving over to him or the other boys was the best. Their dominance made me as wet as I had ever been.

  Now Teagan got back into the mix. As I sat on top of Killian, balls deep, he started rubbing his cock up and down my crack and against my little asshole. He poured a little lube down there and rubbed it in with his finger and then slowly pressed in.

  It was so tight being fucked in both holes at the same time! It’s indescribable the feeling! Their cocks going in and out of me stretched me in ways that I never knew would stretch!

  “Fuck me!” I demanded. “Fuck all my holes! Oh! Fuck my little asshole! I love your cock inside my ass!”

  Any way either of us moved was a move in pure pleasure. I tried tightening my muscles and Killian moaned, Teagan tensed up. I was stuck between them, their hard, hot bodies covering me, protecting me and making me squeal. I put my hands on Killian’s shoulders and bounced up and down. Now I was making their dicks do what I wanted. They just stood and sat there while I did the work.

  “Awww, yeah!” I moaned. “Just like that! You like this? You like my tight little holes?!”

  “God, yes!” moaned Teagan. “Your ass is so tight! It’s squeezing me so good!”

  I waved James over. He looked like he was ready again. He smiled and stood up. I started stroking his cock. I stretched out to put it in my mouth. It was awkward, but I just wanted to know what it would feel like with all three inside me. It felt awesome! I felt like I had reached a new level of sexuality. This was the proof that I would take all three of them, together. As weird as that sounds, I wanted all three O’Connors. Mentally and physically, I could just feel that we were all right for each other.

  Switching the batting order, James started fucking my pussy, while Killian put his cock deep inside my ass. I insisted that he start slow. His cock was wider and in my ass, I could feel him stretching me. It was a great feeling!

  “Holy shit!” he gasped. “God! You’re so tight!”

  Now I was sitting as far down on James’ cock as I could and I still wasn’t down to the balls. I could feel his cock actually bend inside me. No one was deep enough for this guy!

  “How about you let me try some of that sweet little ass?” he asked.

  “Mmm, I don’t know, James,” I said, hesitating. “You might rip something down there.”

  “I’ll use the lube and I’ll go real slow, I promise,” he assured.

  “Okay,” I agreed. “But just go slow.”

  I wanted James’ brothers to get off first, so I let Teagan fuck me in the pussy, while Killian did me in the ass. Both orgasmed in unison, while I came. Their warm cum filled me and the condoms and they slowly pulled out and then went to the bathroom to clean up. Now it was the finale. I picked up the lotion bottle and shot a squirt right into my asshole. I wanted to make sure everything was lubed, while I was nice and oily and on all fours, James got ready.

  Pressing his massive head against my ass, I didn’t think it would go in.

  “No. No-no,” I said.

  Suddenly, it slipped in unexpected.

  “Oh, my God!” I squealed in surprised. “Oh, God!”

  “You okay?” asked James.

  “Y-yes,” I said against the strain. “I can feel your heartbeat in your dick.”

  James pushed in a little more and I fell forward on the bed. I screamed, “Oh, my Goooooooooddddd!” into the pillow. I was breathing heavily. This was some kind of new record for me.

  Pulling back a little, I looked up from the pillow. James getting better leverage, he grabbed both my bed posts. He suddenly pushed what felt like all the way into my body. I squealed loudly into my pillow. He was fucking my ass as slowly as he could, but it still hurt. But really, it hurt so good.

  I could feel James’ hand on my back as he attempted to push in more. I relaxed my ass and all twelve inches of him slid inside. He was in my ass so deep and I felt so full. We both moaned together. Slowly James started pumping my little ass hole. He didn’t even have to go fast. He was so big and stretched me so much. It was incredible!

  James could lift me up like a rag doll. He stood up in the room. With my legs and arms wrapped around him, I bounced up and down on his cock. I started getting myself off pretty good and then James started to grunt. Pushing me against my closet, he sort of moaned/screamed into my shoulder. I could feel him cumming inside the condom and filling it up.

  Full and spent, we collapsed on the bed. I rapidly fell asleep with a big smile on my face.

  Chapter 18:

  Teagan

  With our intense sexual liaison over, it was time to talk with the boys. Amy was fast asleep on her bed. This sexual angel w
ho had emerged was a force to be reckoned with. I wasn’t sure if the other brothers could handle her, but I suppose if we stayed in a group they would.

  “We should talk,” I suggested. “Let’s meet up at the practice field in twenty minutes.”

  “Why twenty?” asked Killian.

  “Because, dumbass, we can’t all leave her room at the same time!”

  “All right, don’t yell at me!” snapped Killian.

  He was so stupid sometimes.

  We got dressed. James slipped out of the room first. It sounded like there was a lot of music still playing, so no one would notice a thing. A few minutes later, Killian slipped out of the room. He was dressed, but looked like he’d just had sex and gotten dressed. I stopped him at the door, pulled the hoodie on his head and sent him on his way. Amy stirred.

  “Hmm? What?” she asked. “Are you guys leaving?”

  “Yeah, you fell asleep,” I told her. “Make sure you lock the door behind me, okay?”

  “Yeah, so tired,” she yawned.

  I grabbed my book bag and got out. What the hell was I doing? Did I really want to endanger my pro football career over this? I mean, yeah, it was fun and fuck, but can people accept this? My head hurt. I had to talk to James. He’d know what to do. He was always the sensible one.

  Several minutes later, we were standing where we all felt at home, on the practice field.

  “What are we doing here, Teag?” asked Killian.

  “James, tell him what I know you’re going to say,” I started. “This is nuts. We can’t all date Amy.”

  “I’m going to date, Amy,” insisted James. “You guys want in, I don’t care. We can share her.”

  “Yeah, I’m fine with it,” said Killian. “Aren’t you?”

  “Well, I didn’t think you guys would be, but now that I think about it… Yeah, I guess I am.”

  “Okay, it’s settled,” said James. “We officially have a girlfriend. Just have to tell her. Think she’s on board.”