Odysseus in America

Home > Other > Odysseus in America > Page 42
Odysseus in America Page 42

by Jonathan Shay

foreknowledge, in military leadership, 231

  forgetfulness, 37-39, 89

  and healing, 299n- 300n

  personification of, 92

  Fortunate Son: The Healing of a Vietnam Vet (Puller), 5, 179, 183

  forward observer, 22, 23, 25

  France, surrender of, at Dien Bien Phu, 234

  Freikorps (proto-Nazi death squads), 222, 296n

  friendship, 158, 159

  Friends of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial, 195

  frigidity, 273n

  Fukuyama, Francis, 156, 249, 284n, 297n, 299n, 301n

  Gal, Reuven, 225, 291n, 293n, 295n, 296n

  Galloway, Joseph L., 277n

  GAR,see Grand Army of the Republic

  Gardner, John, 273n

  Gardner, R., 272n

  Garvey, Mary, 79

  gastēr (stomach, hunger), 12-13

  Gates of Fire (Pressfield), 210

  genocide, 251

  geras (Greek military prize of honor), 239, 267n

  German army:

  cohesion in, 209, 212-13

  demobilization in 1918, 295n

  in Weimar Republic, 295n

  Germany:

  Freikorps death squads in, 222, 296n

  leadership practices in, 226

  “stab-in-the-back” mentality in, 95, 273n

  veteran employment opportunities in, 59

  Gibbs, Philip, 20

  GI Bill, 135

  Gibson, James William, 22

  gift exchange, 274n

  Glass, Albert J., 293n

  “going native,” 166

  Golden, Leon, 283n

  Golden Calf, 102

  Goodall, Jane, 301n

  Gould, John P.A., 275n

  government:

  hiring preferences of, 51

  veteran attitudes toward, 47, 177

  Grand Army of the Republic (GAR), 41

  grandiosity, 160

  Graves, Robert, 31-32

  Greely, J. N., 292n

  grief, 35, 85

  function of, 80-81

  and recovery, 168, 169

  and visit to the Vietnam Veterans Memorial, 170, 174

  Griffis, Sally (VWAR), xiv, 197

  group therapies, 168-69, 174, 177

  at Vietnam Veterans Memorial, 173

  “Guardians” of the state, Aristotle’s notion of, 157

  Gudmundsson, Bruce I., 277n, 295n

  guest-gifts, 119, 274n

  guilt, 109-10, 112, 152

  existential functions of, 80

  and penance, 153

  survivor, 76, 78-80

  ways of living with, 154

  Gulf War, 220

  Guthrie, Woody, 108

  Haber, Samuel, 292n

  Hainsworth, Brian, 282n

  Hall, H. Palmer (VWAR), 194, 288n- 89n

  Halverson, R. R., 287n

  Harvey, Mary, 175

  Harvey, M. R., 287n

  Haubold, Johannes, 6, 268n

  health, worries about, 88-89, 160

  Hector (Trojan commander in chief, killed by Achilles), 231, 267n

  Hedrick, C., 270n, 279n, 285n, 299n

  Hegel, G. W. R, 156, 249

  Helen of Troy, 37, 65, 66, 89, 231

  and Trojan Horse ruse, 233

  Helios (sun god), 102, 272n

  Heller, Charles E., 295n

  Henderson, William D., 213, 292n

  Herakles, 299n

  Herman, Judith, 168, 243, 271n, 283n, 286n

  Hermes (messenger god and trickster), 66-67, 69

  heroes, 2, 242-43

  heroin, 38, 94-95

  Hesiod, 92, 299n- 300n

  Hesk, John, 275n, 279n, 285n, 298n

  Heubeck, Alfred, 99, 278n

  Hexter, Ralph, 273n

  hiring preferences, 51-52

  Hitler, Adolf, 161, 273n, 285n

  Hobbes, Thomas, 156

  hobos, 155

  Hoekstra, A., 278n

  Hoffman, George “Sonny,” 86, 105, 276n

  holy, experience of the, 242, 287n

  home, idea of, 245-46

  homecoming:

  Odyssey as allegory of, 1, 2, 3, 36, 106

  of veterans, 56

  Homer, 103, 278n

  honor, 95, 156

  deference and, 250

  in the Iliad, 250

  for military personnel, 252

  Hoover, Herbert, 155

  Hoplite ideology, 298n

  Horace (legendary Roman warrior Horatius), 153

  Hornblower, Simon, 275n

  hospitality and generosity, testing of, 129

  hubris, law on, 161

  Hudnall-Stamm, Beth, 276n

  human nature, 162, 247, 248, 251

  Hurbis-Cherrier, Katherine, 270n

  Hurbis-Cherrier, Mick, 270n

  hypochondria, 88-89, 160

  ideals, 157

  and recovery, 168, 174

  IDF,see Israel Defense Forces

  idiōtes (those ignorant of public affairs), 7

  Iliad, xv, 6, 61, 62, 77, 82, 105, 140

  Achilles’ portrayal in, 237, 243

  Agamemnon’s portrayal in, 239-40

  audience for, 104

  author of, 103

  biē of Achilles in, 205

  fascination of death in, 91-92

  funeral games for, 243

  mētis in, 235

  Odysseus’ portrayal in, 238

  Odysseus’ reconnaissance in, 231-32

  Sirens as voice of, 89

  surface story of, 267n

  themis betrayed in, 206

  violence and honor in, 250

  incarceration, of Vietnam veterans, 27

  income, of Vietnam veterans, 136

  individual replacement system, in U.S. military services,see replacement system, in U.S. military services

  injury, PTSD as, 149-50

  IN MEMORY program, 195-96

  insomnia, 38, 39, 54-55, 246

  Institute for Defense Analyses, 215, 302n

  institutional validation, 168-69

  “Instructions for the Government of Armies of the United States in the Field” (Lieber), 225

  intergenerational transmission of trauma, 175

  Internet discussion groups, 5, 41, 178-80, 198-201

  IN TOUCH program, 196

  Ion (Plato), 103

  Iphigenia, 102, 112

  irony, Homeric (or lack of), 69, 101, 272n, 278n

  Ismarus, raid on, 20, 26, 32, 34, 35, 43, 61, 236, 256, 269n

  isothumos (equal citizenship honor; not an ancient Greek term, modern coinage), 161, 250

  Israel:

  aversion to military casualties in, 213

  leadership practices in, 226

  veterans, 50

  Israel Defense Force (IDF):

  breakdowns in, 218

  cohesion in, 213, 219

  Ithaca, Odysseus’ return to, 3-4, 121, 124

  jargon and speech rhythms, of combat veterans, 89-91

  jobs,see employment and career opportunities of veterans

  Jodies, 124, 136

  Johnson, Lyndon, 103

  Jones, F. D., 291n, 293n, 296n

  Jones, Franklin, 225

  jus ad bellum, 291n

  jus in bello, 291n

  jus in militaribus, 291n

  justice, divine, 105, 124, 272n

  Kang, H. K., 290n

  Kant, Immanuel, 249, 252, 301n

  katharsis, 153

  Kelley, Michael, 290n

  Kelman, Herbert C., 286n

  kerameikos (Athens’s military cemetery), 5, 287n

  Kerrey, Bob, 110-12, 154, 279n, 283n, 297n

  guilt as motivation for, 152

  on Puller’s death, 183

  Khe Sanh, siege of, 235

  king or steward of the winds (Aeolus), 52-56, 59, 256

  Kirkland, Fans R., 168, 216, 217, 287n, 291n, 294n

  Kissinger, Henry, 103

  Kitfield, James, 222

  Klann, Gerhard,
110-12

  kleos (fame), as motive, 48, 297n

  Kohut, Heinz, 156, 284n

  Korean War:

  replacement system in, 209-10

  veterans of, 155

  Koziak, Barbara, 299n

  Krulak, Charles C., 223, 296n

  Kulka, Richard A., 270n, 281n

  Laertes (father of Odysseus), 132, 145

  Odysseus’ reunion with, 138-39, 143-44, 259

  Laestiygonians, 60, 61, 63, 64, 236, 256

  Laird, Melvin, 90

  language, 247

  Laocoön (Trojan leader), 234

  Larsenn, S., 290n

  Lateiner, Donald, 280n

  Law enforcement, veteran career opportunities in, 22

  “lawful combatant,” 110, 224

  lawfulness, in conduct of nations, 250

  Lawrence, T. E. (Lawrence of Arabia), 42, 44

  Lazenby, John F., 279n

  leaders,see civilian leaders; military leaders Leakey, Richard, 300n

  lēthe (forgetting), 92

  Leukos (soldier of Odysseus, killed in Iliad), 140

  Lewis, Mark, 296n

  Lidz, Brett T., 281n

  Lieber, Francis, 225

  Lieber Code, 225

  Linderman, Gerald F., 212, 293n

  Lloyd, Janet, 277n

  Longinus, 278n

  Lotus Eaters, land of, 36, 38, 41, 256

  love:

  among military comrades, 196, 211, 212, 269n

  philia (philotēs in Homer) and, 158-59

  “Love and Whores” (Spector), 71-72

  Luttwak, Edward, 293n

  lying and deceit:

  cowardice and, 236

  fear and, 236

  as military skills, 151

  of Odysseus, 121-22, 126, 127, 132, 151, 237

  in Trojan Horse incident, 233-34

  Lynch, James (VWAR), xiv, 197

  MacArthur, Douglas, 64

  Makary, C., 287n

  Mallory, Jack (VWAR), xiv, 186, 288

  manic-depressive behavior, 40

  Marine Corps, cult of death in, 91

  Marine Expeditionary Units (Special Operations Capable), 220

  marriages, of veterans, 57, 59, 68, 69, 84, 94

  intimacy and sex in, 114, 116-18

  suppression of emotion in, 137

  Marshall, George C., 108-9, 295n

  Martin, Richard P., 299n

  Mason, Patience C. H., 137, 262, 281n

  Mason, Robert, 281n

  Masters of Truth in Archaic Greece, The (Detienne), 92

  materialism, 247

  Matsakis, Aphrodite, 39, 118, 137, 262, 271n, 279n, 281n

  McBride, Bill, Web site, 261

  McCarthyism, era of, 155

  McCombs, Mike, Sr., 188-89

  McGlew, James R, 285n, 299n

  McMaster, H. R., 278n

  McNamara, Robert, 102

  McVeigh, Timothy, 95

  MedEvac, 23, 29, 199

  medicinal purgation, 153

  megalomania, 161

  megalothymia, 299n

  Mehlum, L., 290n

  Melantho (faithless maid), 131-32

  memorial validation, 169

  memory, 92

  loss of authority over, 38

  resuscitative function of, 80

  and truth of Kerrey mission, 111

  Menelaus (king of Sparta, husband of Helen), 37, 104, 140

  Telemachus’ visit with, 231

  mental clarification, 153

  mental health professionals, 177-78

  “Mentes” (Athena in disguise), 144

  “Mentor” (Athena in disguise), 145

  meritocracy, 104, 279n

  mētis (cunning, deception), 14, 46, 47, 125, 151, 161, 205, 231, 243, 272n, 297n

  biē and, 206

  in Iliad, 235

  of Penelope, 74-75

  Meyer, Edward “Shy,” 226

  Milford, L., 284n

  military education and training, 214-16, 222-23, 229

  and cohesion, 211

  COHORT program, 214-17

  ethics and, 223-25

  recommendations for, 265

  retraining component of, 217-18

  military intelligence, in Vietnam War, 234-35

  military leaders, 61-62, 225-27, 229

  abuse of authority by, 224

  betrayal of “what’s right” by, 240

  careerism of, 167, 228, 264, 286n

  and COHORT program, 217

  creation and maintenance of trust by, 206, 226, 227

  ethics and, 227-30

  “going native,” 166

  love and fear in, 211

  Odysseus, 6-7, 61, 62, 231, 236-37, 241

  and prevention of psychological injury, 6-7, 225

  truthfulness of, 228

  and U.S. defeat in Vietnam, 103

  military personnel policy:

  on career management systems, 286n

  obsolete assumptions about, 263

  and prevention of psychological injury, 5-6

  recommendations for, 265-66

  on retirement system, 265

  military service, peace and, 252

  military unit associations, 40-41, 91, 92, 265

  and prevention of psychological injury, 221-22

  Web site, 261

  Miller, William I., 272n, 279n, 293n

  mind, 162, 247-48

  money, veterans’ lack of interest in, 57

  Moore, Harold G., 277n

  moral education of citizens, arts and, 242

  More, Thomas, 19

  Morris, Ian, 279n

  Morrison, A. P., 284n

  mortality, awareness of, 248

  Mortality of Vietnam Veterans—The Veteran Cohort Study 1997, 290n

  MOS (military occupation specialty), 209

  Moses, 102

  motivational tools, Agamemnon’s, 240

  Mullen, William, 275n

  multiplier effect,see combat strength multiplier effect

  Munroe, James, 165, 167, 276n, 286n, 287n, 291n

  Murray, A. T., 268n

  Murray, Warren K. (VWAR), xiv, 185, 191

  Muses, 244, 299n

  “Musselman” (catatonic state in concentration camps), 160, 285n

  Myrmidons (Achilles’ contingent at Troy), 238, 298n, 299n

  Nagy, Gregory, 78, 165, 268n, 269n, 275n, 279n, 298n, 299n

  narcissism, 156-61, 277n

  narratives, personal, and recovery, 168, 169, 174

  National Center for PTSD Web site, 262

  nationalism, 250

  National Training Center (NTC), Fort Irwin, 223

  National Vietnam Veterans Readjustment Study, 27, 136

  Nausicaa (Phaeacian princess), 65, 256

  Nellis Air Force Base, 223

  Neoptolemus (son of Achilles), 275n

  Nestor (king of Pylos, guest-friend and ally of Odysseus), 140, 141, 232, 298n

  Newberry, Joan Duffy, 171

  New Manning System, 293n see also COHORT program, U.S. Army

  New York Times Magazine, The, 110

  Nietzsche, Friedrich, 220

  nightmares, 29, 38, 94

  noble character, in Athenian society, 235

  “normal,” in diagnostic system, 282n

  North Vietnamese Army, cohesion in, 213

  nostalgia (as combat stress reaction), 160, 285n

  nostos (homecoming), 18

  “not ready” unit classification, 217

  Nuremberg Principles on war crimes, 154

  Nussbaum, Martha C., 112, 284n, 285n, 290n, 298n, 299n, 301n

  obedience:

  blind, 160

  critical, of leader to his superiors, 227

  trust and, 224

  in World War II, 226, 227

  Ober, J., 270n, 279n, 285n, 299n

  Ockham, William of, 251

  Odysseus, 104, 105, 271n

  Achilles contrasted with, 235, 298n

  Agamemnon and, 237, 238

>   boar-tusk scar of, 133, 139, 142-44

  bravery of, 237

  craftiness and guile of, 46-17, 298n

  disguises of, 4, 123-24

  greed of, 232

  lies of, 121-22, 126, 127, 132, 151, 237

  loyalty to troops, 237

  as man of pain, 242

  meaning of name, 2, 143

  mētis of, 205-6

  as military leader, 6-7, 61, 62, 231, 236-37, 241

  military practices of, 237, 238

  and olive tree bed, 246

  Palladium stolen by, 233

  reconnaissance by, 231-32, 237

  self-introduction of, 17, 33, 121

  and simple PTSD, 151

  as spy, 231-32, 237

  trauma and character of, 140-44, 243

  trust destroyed in, xv, 59, 64

  Odyssey, xv, 6, 104

  allegorical interpretation of, 2-3, 105, 106, 268n

  author of, 103

  Books 1-4 (home without Odysseus), 255

  Books 5-8 (Odysseus starts last lap for home), 256

  Books 9-12 (Odysseus tells Phaeacians of his adventures), 256-57

  Books 13-16 (father and son return to Ithaca), 257-58

  Books 17-20 (Odysseus arrives at home), 258

  Books 21-24 (Odysseus triumphant), 258-59

  Calypso episode, 65, 113-14, 118, 256, 257

  Circe episode, 38, 66-67, 69-73, 75, 76, 83, 96-98, 236, 237, 257

  Cyclops episode, 42-50, 61, 236, 256

  dangerous women in, 65-66

  deadly fjord episode, 60-64, 236, 256

  as homecoming epic, 1, 2, 3, 36

  king of the winds episode, 52-56, 59, 256

  Lotus Land episode, 36, 38, 41, 256

  mētis of Odysseus in, 205-6

  Odysseus among the dead episode, 76-80, 82-84, 174, 257

  Odysseus at home episodes, 3-4, 120-45, 246, 257-59

  Phaeacians episode, 12-18, 33, 104, 105, 118-19, 256, 257

  raid on Ismarus episode, 20, 26, 32, 34, 35, 43, 61, 236, 256, 269n

  Scylla and Charybdis episode, 96-99, 107, 112, 257

  Sirens episode, 86-87, 89, 91, 92, 95, 96, 257

  sun god’s cattle episode, 100-102, 107, 236, 257

  and traumas of Odysseus, 243

  Trojan Horse ruse recounted in, 233 see also Odysseus

  Olson, Monte (VWAR), xiv, 188

  Olympic Games, 77-78

  Olympus, Mount (as home of Homeric gods), 107, 145, 256

  101st Airborne Division Association, 40, 41

  One Station Unit Training (OSUT), 293n see also COHORT program, U.S. Army

  open spaces, fear of, 64, 150

  opiates, 38

  opposing force (OPFOR) units, 223

  Orsillo, Susan M., 281n

  OSUT (One Station Unit Training), 293n see also COHORT program, U.S. Army

  Otto, Rudolf, 287n, 299n

  Oulixes, 143 see also Odysseus

  overexcitement, 40

  Owens, Wilfred, 137-38, 172

  Palaima, Thomas G., 7, 269n

  Palladium (statue of Athena at Troy), 233

  Panathenaea (Athenian festival), 103

  Pandarus (Trojan archer), 298n

  Parameters (journal), Achilles in Vietnam reviewed in, xvi

 

‹ Prev