Her Colorado Pleasures [Spirit, Colorado 5] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Lara Valentine

  Sin gave Casey an indulgent smile. “Maybe you should go easy on her, Ev. She can’t help herself. She loves to misbehave. Maybe withholding punishment is the best punishment.”

  His bedroom slave had the nerve to pout. Pout, for fuck’s sake. She was just begging for it tonight.

  Evan’s face was red from laughing. “Fuck, Sin. She doesn’t seem happy with that idea at all. I think it’s time for her punishment. Did you pick up anything to assist me with it?”

  “You bet. Check the bag.”

  Casey pouted at her place on the floor. “Did you guys go to the store and shoplift? Do I need to call the sheriff?”

  Sin looked down at her with a scowl. “No, we did not. I left the cash next to the register on the counter. You, Casey Charles, are in enough trouble as it is, and yet you invite more to sashay in and make itself at home. Ev, you need to add on a little for her mouthy behavior.”

  Evan was digging in the bag and looked up with a grin. “Happy to, bro. That sassy mouth keeps getting her into hot water. Yep, this should be perfect.”

  Sin had to hold back his smile at Casey’s shocked but excited expression. Evan was twirling a wooden paddle.

  Chapter 15

  Casey was almost wriggling with excitement and, yes, a tiny bit of trepidation. Sin must have noticed her rapt attention on the paddle these past few weeks. She would often eye it, take it from the wall, and measure its weight in her hand. She had pondered how it would feel against her ass cheeks and thighs. Even now her pussy creamed and clenched at the thought of being bent over and paddled by Evan. Her nipples ached, too, from the clamps. She was in quite a state, and they had barely touched her.

  Sin helped her to her feet and gave the chain connecting the two clover clamps a tug. The clamps tightened on her already sore nipples and she yipped with pain, even as her honey dripped down her thighs.

  “Time for these to come off, honey. But I think we need to distract you, since it’s gonna hurt like a son of a gun.”

  Distract her like with a paddling? What was the saying—do two hurts make a right? Or an orgasm in this case?

  Sin stretched out on the bed and patted his chest. “Come here, pretty girl. I want you to cream all over my face.”

  Casey couldn’t get on top of him fast enough. She craved the pleasure his talented tongue could bring her.

  “One second, sweetheart. You need a couple of accessories before you’re ready for Sin to lick your sweet pussy.”

  Evan pulled more items from the bag and crawled up on the bed with them, holding up a pair of padded handcuffs. She sold these in the dungeon section of the store.

  “Hands behind your back.”

  Casey obeyed but gave Evan a little sass. “Is there anything left in the store? How much did you guys buy anyway?”

  Evan clicked the handcuffs closed and gave her a smart smack on the ass before turning to Sin.

  “She’s submissive to you, right? Can’t you take away her permission to speak? She’s got quite the mouth on her, and it’s going to get her in even more trouble.”

  Sin reached up and ran his finger down between her breasts, fiddling with the chain.

  “You’re right. It’s for her own good. Casey, you no longer have permission to speak unless asked a direct question.”

  Casey opened her mouth to protest but then thought better of it. She didn’t know what else the bag held. Sin patted her ass in approval.

  “Good girl. How about a distraction? We need to get those clamps off. Come on up here. I’ll give you a ride.”

  It was difficult to balance with her hands cuffed behind her back, but she managed to crawl up Sin’s massive body. Her dripping pussy hung right over his face. He was licking his lips in anticipation. She almost came just watching him.

  He grabbed her thighs and spread them wide so she was literally sitting on his face. His lips were tickling her pussy lips, and she realized she really was riding his face. She giggled at the thought.

  “Does that tickle, sweetheart? Sin, tickle her pussy some more.”

  Sin twitched his tongue and lips, and she groaned at the sensation. She bit her lip to keep from begging him to lick her. She just needed to have patience.

  She was rewarded almost immediately. Sin gave her a lick from opening to clit. She shot to the edge of orgasm just that quickly. She hovered there as his tongue explored the nooks and crannies of her slit. Each fold was licked clean of her cream only for her to drip more honey. She needed to come badly. Her breath was coming in short pants, and she was grinding her cunt on his face. It only served to spur him on more. His tongue tortured her everywhere but where she needed him most.

  Evan tugged the chain hanging between her breast, and the clamps tightened with a bite.

  “She’s ready, Sin.”

  Sin’s mouth closed over her swollen and aching clit, his teeth lightly scraping it as he sucked gently. Her climax hit her like a freight train, sending lightning pleasure from her clit outward. Her entire body tensed then trembled as wave after wave slammed through her. She felt Evan’s hands reach around her just as she was starting to come down. He quickly removed the clamps from her nipples. The painful rush of blood back in sent her over again. She screamed their names, the pleasure burning her from inside out. She slumped back on Evan’s chest as he pulled her off of Sin.

  He held her while she came down, her body shaking as she came back to awareness.

  “That was awesome.”

  Her vocabulary always seemed to take a hit when she was making love to her men. Luckily, Evan and Sin didn’t seem to mind. Sin levered himself up and wiped his arm across his face.

  “I agree, honey. It’s always awesome when you come. But now it’s time for your punishment. Evan, are you ready?”

  Evan nodded. “Hell, yeah. This paddle is begging to be used. Casey? Are you ready to take your punishment like a big girl?”

  Yes and no. She was dying to try the paddle but was smart enough to have a healthy fear of it, too. She wasn’t a wimp, however. She’s the one who had been salivating all over it for weeks. She was finally going to find out what it felt like.

  “Yes, I am. I think I am, anyway.”

  Her hands were still cuffed behind her back. She jangled the cuffs to get Evan’s attention.

  “Are you going to take these off of me now?”

  Evan just shook his head. “No. You’re in those for the duration. Now climb off the bed and bend over so your head and torso are lying on top of the mattress. You’ll be in perfect position for your paddling.”

  Sin helped her get into position. She had to spread her legs wide, and her ass was stuck up like a target, which she was sure was not an accident. Sin was lying on the bed next to her head, stroking her hair.

  “Are you going to sit there and watch me be punished?”

  Sin tugged her so she was looking into his eyes. “I’m pretty sure I took your permission to speak away. That’s twice you’ve spoken now. Ev, add a few on for her disobedience.”

  Well, shit.

  “Will do. Now let’s see. We have you touching without permission. Talking without permission. Oh, and you tried to take the control back earlier. That’s a lot of transgressions. However, this is your first paddling, so we’ll stick with an even dozen. Hold still, baby. I’ll even count for you.”

  The waiting seemed to take forever. Evan’s hand rubbed the cheeks of her ass, warming up the skin. When the first stroke came, she was surprised, although she shouldn’t have been. There was a part of her that thought Evan might just be teasing her. He wasn’t. The force of the stroke sent her up on her toes and her bottom started stinging then warming gradually. The warmth suffused her bottom and settled in her pussy. She pushed up her ass for another stroke.

  Evan didn’t disappoint her. The next stroke came down just as hard and sent even more warmth into her cunt. She could feel the cream starting to drip from her pussy. Her ass was on fire, and despite coming hard minutes before, she was on the edge of
orgasm again.

  Evan’s hand stroked her ass cheeks gently.

  “Are you ready for more, baby?”

  Casey wriggled her ass. “I need it. I need to come.”

  “Come you shall, Casey. Here’s what you need.”

  * * * *

  Evan hefted the paddle in his hand, feeling its weight. Casey was loving her paddling so far. She was teasing him by wriggling her ass at him, pushing him onward. If she hadn’t found this arousing, the paddling would have come to an abrupt halt. He and Sin never wanted to do anything she didn’t want and enjoy.

  Her ass cheeks were a beautiful rosy red and warm to the touch. They would be hot by the time he was finished. His arm went up and came back down, the paddle making contact with the tender flesh. Instead of jumping and cringing, Casey arched her back for more. She was going to be disobeying Sin at every turn now.

  Each stroke seemed to send Casey higher until she was begging for the next, begging to come. After the twelfth stroke, Evan let his fingers delve into her drenched pussy. She was wetter than he had ever felt. He found her already sensitive and swollen clit, circling it with his fingers before giving it a gentle pinch.

  She went off like a rocket, screaming their names. Her knees gave way and Evan caught her, pulling her up on the bed with him and Sin. Her body shuddered as pleasure wracked her slight frame. He and Sin held her, whispering tender words when she finally came down. Her cornflower-blue eyes were soft and unfocused as she looked into his.

  “Holy crap on a cracker. I think the back of my head blew off.”

  Evan chuckled, pulling her tighter. “I checked. The back of your head is still there.”

  “What about my pussy? Is it still there? I think it exploded.”

  Sin cracked up. “Trust me, baby. It’s still there. I have plans for it.”

  Casey’s expression turned serious. “God, I love it when you smile. You are the most beautiful man when you laugh.”

  Evan swallowed the lump in his throat. He had never seen his best friend this happy. He expected Sin to close into himself but was shocked when his smile got wider.

  “Only for you, Casey. Only for you.”

  * * * *

  Sin felt his heart swell in his chest. He loved this woman with everything inside of him. The thought of her not being here, not staying was unthinkable. He just had to convince her she could have a new dream. A dream that included him and Evan.

  She gave him a sly smile that made his heart do a flip in his chest. God willing, he would see it for the rest of his life.

  “Those plans for my pussy…I’m hoping you mean to fuck it, Sin.”

  The girl had quite a mouth on her, and damned if he didn’t love it.

  “That is most certainly my plan.” He flicked a quick glance at Evan. “But I have something else in mind, too. Ev, there should be a big bottle of lube in that bag.”

  Sin let his fingers stroke the crack of her ass. The cheeks were still hot from her paddling.

  “You’re ours, Casey. Tonight, we’re going to show you what that means. I’m going to fuck this pretty pussy while Evan fucks your tight ass. We’re going to show you pleasure like you’ve never known.”

  He waited for her reaction. She had been so open and playful with them. He wouldn’t pressure her for the world. He wanted her to want this as much as they did.

  He saw her swallow with fear, but then her chin came up in challenge.

  “Yes, I want that, too. I want both of you to fuck me at the same time.”

  Evan stroked her long hair. “Are you sure, baby? We don’t have to if you don’t want to.”

  Casey nodded. “I want it. I’ve wondered what it would be like.”

  Sin hopped up from the bed and grabbed the bottle of lube from the bag.

  “Wonder no more. We’ll take this nice and slow. We want you to love it.”

  * * * *

  Casey was nervous but trusted her men implicitly. They had assured her they would take this slow. Her arousal was already climbing at the thought of taking her two men at the same time. Thank heavens they had decided Evan would pop her ass cherry. She wasn’t sure she could take Sin there the first time.

  Sin stretched out on his back again, donning a condom before beckoning to her.

  “C’mere, sweetheart. I can’t wait to be inside your hot pussy. I’ve been thinking about it all day.”

  So had she. She thought about these men pretty much all her waking moments. How in the hell was she supposed to take this job and leave?

  Evan was her lover and friend. He was always there when she needed someone. He sought her advice and respected her opinion. In bed, he was an unselfish lover and would bring her to orgasm several times before going over himself. Mostly, he was good to her, always trying to anticipate her needs in and out of bed. He took great pleasure in taking care of her, no matter how much she protested that she could take care of herself. He would just smile and agree she could, but why should she when he was here to do it?

  Sin was her knight in shining armor. A dour knight at times, but no less a knight. He believed in protecting her and cherishing her. She did feel cherished and protected. She would follow Sin into any dark alley anytime. She remembered the first day in the store when she had fallen and he had picked her up and carried her to a chair, worry all over his face. His lovemaking was fierce and possessive but just as unselfish as Evan’s. And when he smiled, Casey’s heart would dance inside her chest. She found herself going out of her way to do something he would like, just to be rewarded with a smile or laugh. She never took them for granted.

  She placed her thighs on each side of Sin’s hips and slowly lowered herself on his enormous cock. His fingers grasped a handful of her ass as she took him inch by inch. Her pussy was already sensitive and swollen. His cock rubbed sweet spots inside her as it slid in. She couldn’t stop her eyes from closing, and a moan escaped her lips as he seated himself to the hilt. She wiggled, and this time Sin groaned. She gave him a smile and pulled at the cuffs, turning to Evan.

  “Please, Evan. I want to touch him.”

  Sin nodded, and she felt the cuffs fall away and Evan massaging her wrists. When he was done, she ran her hands from Sin’s hard abs all the way up to his shoulders and back down again. Sin’s jaw was clenched. He was holding himself tightly in check.

  “I’ll never get tired of touching all these muscles. Both of you are so gorgeous.”

  Evan turned her face for a soul-searing kiss. “We hope you mean that. We’ll never get tired of touching you either.”

  Evan’s hand on her back was gentle but firm, pressing her down to Sin’s chest.

  “Relax, baby. I’m going to stretch you so this will be more comfortable. Just relax a little and let Sin distract you.”

  She liked their distractions. Sin took his time kissing every inch of her face and nibbling on her ears and jaw. She jumped when she felt the cold lube trickle down her ass but relaxed as Evan rubbed her sore cheeks.

  “Just lube, honey. Relax for me.”

  She felt his fingers circling her back hole and then the press for entrance. Her body resisted for a moment and then gave way. He fucked her ass with his finger before trickling more lube and adding another digit. She felt full, but there was no pain. She hadn’t felt the burning she had heard about. It just felt strange but not unpleasant. As she relaxed, she realized she liked feeling full back there.

  “More, Evan. I need more.”

  Her voice sounded strained, but she was reaching for something she couldn’t identify. She only knew she needed to be completely filled.

  “Patience, baby. I don’t want to hurt you.”

  More lube, and a third finger joined the other two. She moaned and squirmed on Sin’s cock, sending frissons of pleasure through her body. She discovered she could grind her clit against his pubic bone while Evan stretched her ass. She did it again, her pussy clenching on Sin’s cock and honey dripping from her slit. She was starting her climb to orgasm again.r />
  “Fuck, Ev. You should feel how she’s squeezing my cock. She’s trying to bring herself off. Hurry the fuck up. I don’t know how long I can last here.”

  Sin used a tone of voice no one could disobey. She, herself, knew it well. It never failed to turn her on, and today was no exception. She ground against him again, holding onto his shoulders for support as she felt more lube. Suddenly, her ass was empty, and she cried out. She needed the full feeling to come. And she needed to come now.

  “Easy, honey. You’re getting my cock now.”

  She felt his cock pressing for entrance and her loosened muscles giving way to his persistence. This time she did feel the burn and the bite of pain she loved. She ground herself against Sin again, desperate to come. She felt Sin’s lips right at her ear.

  “Use me, honey. Use me and make yourself come.”

  She couldn’t have stopped. Some unseen force was pushing her toward satisfaction. Each inch Evan gained sent pleasure arrowing through her body. She rubbed her clit against Sin, and he moved with her. Her movements became frantic as the need to come took over. Evan thrust in, his balls slapping her ass, when she went over. Her body clamped down on the cocks in her cunt and ass. She could hear the men cursing as they held themselves back. The waves of pleasure were like none she’d ever known. She’d never been this full of cock, and it sent her into an entirely new dimension of pleasure.

  When the waves subsided, Sin gave her a smile, brushing her long hair back from her face.

  “Ready to ride? We can’t hold back much longer.”

  Casey pushed herself up. “Let’s ride, cowboys. If that’s a preview of what you got, then I need it all.”