Truth or Dare: The Girls of St. Agnes (College Lesbian Erotica)

by Lana J. Swift

  Seeing the looks of encouragement and keen anticipation from her teammates, Amy cautiously parted her legs to expose the wet spot that had drawn so much attention. It looked like it had grown even larger.

  “I don’t know girls,” she said with obvious reluctance, “I’ve never done anything in front of anyone before.”

  Mary’s silver tongue offered words of reason and encouragement. “You wouldn’t be doing anything we haven’t all done to ourselves many times... and right now I’m sure we’re all getting a little damp down there, right? Just consider it a team bonding exercise... and some great stress relief!”

  Amy slowly moved a hand along the inside of her thigh, gradually bringing it closer to the bulge of her pussy. It seemed like she wanted desperately to give in to her carnal urges, but her better judgment was battling for control.

  “I-I really don’t know. I wouldn’t want you to think of me as a slut or anything.”

  “I think Becky’s already got that covered for everyone,” quipped Mary. Seeing a flash of anger from the redhead she raised her hands in surrender. “Kidding, you know I’m kidding!”

  “Um, I wouldn’t freak anyone out, would I? You girls really want me to do it?”

  Seven heads nodded simultaneously.

  Amy groaned and stared up at the ceiling in frustration. “Damn it all, if I wasn’t already so horny I know I’d never even think about doing this... but Sam’s story and Jaden’s tits have got me so worked up I feel like I’m gonna burst if I don’t come soon. And fuck it all if maybe it wouldn’t be fun to show off just a little!”

  Surrendering to her body’s wanton desires and the enthusiastic faces of her teammates, Amy decisively moved her fingers over her mound and massaged herself firmly and forcefully through the swimsuit, the soft flesh of her pussy bulged suggestively beneath the tight blue fabric. Leaning back on one arm she closed her eyes and started flicking her middle finger directly on the growing dark spot, pressing the stretchy material deep into her crack.

  Quietly the other girls shifted their positions for a better view of Amy’s impromptu show, forming a loose semi-circle with Tanya sitting on the floor directly in front, her legs crossed and leaning against the wooden bench. Of course Tanya had seen plenty of girls masturbating on the internet, but a live demonstration – even if the star wasn’t nude – seemed an altogether much better experience!

  Amy groaned and rubbed her crotch faster and harder, the muscles of her abdomen rippling beneath the skin-tight swimsuit as her body worked to extract the most pleasure from her fingers. The vigorous motions began to bunch the suit material deep in her cleft, revealing tantalizing rolls of pale, smooth skin on either side of her crotch.

  Moaning louder, Amy’s body suddenly jolted and she cried out “Uhhhh!” in a high-pitched voice.

  Tanya’s eyes were glued between Amy’s legs when the dark spot over her pussy abruptly looked shiny wet and then grew larger, spreading to cover the entire width of the gusset. But even then Amy didn’t stop rubbing herself.

  “Did you come already?” asked Mary in an undertone.

  Breathily, Amy answered, “No, not yet... that’s just a little one to warm up.”

  Watching silently for a moment while Amy continued rubbing through her damp swimsuit, Mary tentatively offered a suggestion. “You know, it would probably feel a whole lot better if you took your suit off.”

  Amy stopped rubbing and straightened to look Mary in the eyes. She was breathing heavily and her face was already red and sweaty from sexual excitement. Tanya figured Amy was going to reject the suggestion, but without speaking a word, she instead tugged the straps from her shoulders and quickly peeled the suit down her body, lifting her butt as she slid it along her legs and past her feet.

  Arranging the swimsuit on the floor beneath her, Amy now sat completely naked and sexually aroused in front of seven of her teammates.

  Thrilled by this unexpected development, Tanya allowed her eyes to feast greedily on her teammate’s petite but well-toned body, roving over her slim waist, flawlessly sculpted stomach and slender hips. Particularly appealing were the small globular swells of her breasts, topped by huge dark brown nipples almost three-quarters the size of her tiny puckered areolas. Amy was undeniably hot!

  Mary echoed the sentiment. “You’re really pretty, Amy.”

  “Thanks,” she replied. “I’ve never had anyone see me this way before.”

  Reclining on the floor, Amy bent her knees and opened her legs into a spread-eagle position. Amy’s entire pubic area had been shaved free of hair, the smooth light-brown skin of her outer labia stretched gracefully between her thighs and literally sparkled with her wet arousal. Her inner labia were thick and dark brown in color, the wrinkled lips clumped together from being squished in her swimsuit. The broad ridge of her clit hood stuck out noticeably from the top of her slit, while lower down, below the still-hidden entrance to her womanhood, lay the surprisingly large bulls-eye of her creased anus, nestled comfortably in the hollow of her buttocks.

  Tanya shivered, her skin breaking out with goose bumps. It felt weird to see a girl she knew, but at the same time didn’t really know, in such an intimate manner. And yet there was no way she could look away, knowing that the mental image of Amy’s nude body was going to keep her company in bed for many nights in the future. Feeling the incredible urge to reach down and rub her aching clit, she instead crossed her arms over her chest to keep from inadvertently touching herself.

  “This is how I usually like to do it,” mumbled Amy as she reached down to grasp her inner labia, pulling the wet lips apart from each other and flashing everyone with the beautiful light pink interior of her young pussy. For some inane reason Tanya had expected her skin to be brown inside, but quickly realized that pink was a universal color.

  Amy began running her fingers up and down the smooth insides of her slit, circling around the ragged threshold of her hole and spreading the oozing wetness over the rapidly swelling bump of her clit. After a minute she placed fingers on either side of her hood and pulled the skin back, popping out the brilliant pink point of her clit into the open air. With another well-lubricated finger she pressed directly on top of the exposed button and rubbed in small circles, her labia wiggling side-to-side and the muscles around her pussy twitching erratically.

  Tanya knew she could never touch herself like that and wondered how Amy was able to tolerate such intense stimulation.

  After barely a minute of this Amy tossed her head and whined, thrusting her hips upwards and grunting as a small jet of clear liquid shot from her pussy at a sharp angle, landing on the inside of her own left thigh. Tanya blinked in awe as the glistening droplets of moisture trickled down Amy’s skin and soaked into the fabric of her swimsuit on the floor. Amy was a squirter?

  Obviously feeling closer to orgasm, the teen began hunching against her hand and groaning, the flesh of her thighs and buttocks jiggling as her slender body squirmed and heaved. Abruptly, Amy stretched her pussy wide open with both hands and clenched her abdominal muscles, raising her head and crying out as she watched herself squirt a long, clear jet of liquid on the grey tile floor between her feet.

  “Oh my god girls,” moaned Amy, throwing her head back as she resumed mashing her pussy, “you have no idea how hot I feel knowing you’re all watching me!”

  “I’m getting hot watching you too, baby,” whispered Mary. “Keep going and show us how you make that beautiful kitty purr...”

  Changing her technique, Amy groped around the tight opening of her sex and forced first one and then a second finger into the nearly invisible hole, pushing them as deep as she could with a loud moan. She began driving them slowly in and out, increasing speed until the wet squelching sounds of her self-penetration filled the air. After over a minute of aggressive finger fucking she abruptly yanked the hand away and jerked her hips upwards, biting her lip and groaning as her body convulsed and a stream of pressurized liquid squirted from the tiny hole of her urethra, arch
ing gracefully through the air before splashing on the tiles immediately in front of Tanya’s crossed legs.

  “Oh yeah, that’s the good stuff,” cooed Amy, quickly slamming her fingers back inside her pussy so they could resume their frantic pounding.

  Seeing the small pool of liquid so tantalizingly close, Tanya reached down and, without even thinking about it, dabbed her fingers in the lukewarm puddle. Raising them to her face she sniffed, and then stuck one finger in her mouth, tasting the sexual juices of another person for the very first time in her life. It was mild in favor, a blend of something almost tangy with just a hint of saltiness, but it was more the erotic nature of where it had just come from that made Tanya’s head swoon. She cleaned off each one of her fingers with a smacking sound and realized that the taste of Amy’s cum was absolutely intoxicating – and impulsively dipped her hand in the puddle for more.

  Nearby someone groaned and Tanya turned to find Mary and Becky watching her intently, both clearly rubbing between their legs and evidently aroused by her taste of Amy’s juices.

  Suddenly Amy began to moan with increased urgency. “Oh my god girls, look, look, I’m gonna come!”

  Tanya returned her gaze and saw that Amy had started using one hand to thrust the fingers of the other in and out of her pussy, her swollen brown lips sucking in and pulling out with each brutal lunge. Abruptly snatching the hand away, she grunted and pulled her legs to her chest, making her wet cunt gape open like a tiny teardrop-shaped black hole. Rubbing madly at the nub of her clit, Amy’s entire body tensed in preparation of imminent orgasmic release.

  “Uhhh, oh shit, oh god look, here it cooomes!” she screeched, pressing hard on her clit just as her cunt pushed outwards and a burst of juice shot from her urethra, arching through the air with an audible hissing sound before splattering across the floor.

  Spellbound, Tanya watched the muscles around Amy’s pussy clench violently in orgasm, her little hole pulsing open and closed while jets of transparent liquid squirted audibly from her urethra. Amy was straining so hard on each orgasmic convulsion that her anus began to bulge outwards from the effort, the deeply creased brown skin blossoming open like the petals of a fleshy wet rose to form a quivering pink bud.

  Almost hypnotized by the physicality of Amy’s climax, Tanya snapped back to the moment when a splash of hot liquid hit the bare skin of her crossed legs. Startled, she looked down and it took a moment before it registered – that was Amy’s cum – and then almost immediately a second splash hit her on the stomach. Amy screamed even louder in ecstasy, short high-pitched yelps echoing off the walls.

  Seemingly in slow motion, Tanya looked up to say something about Amy’s uncanny aim and was instantly greeted by a stream of high-pressure pussy juice that hit her square on the mouth and sprayed across her face. Reflexively squeezing her eyes shut against the unexpected onslaught, Tanya’s mouth was already committed to opening as yet another surge of Amy’s juice came at her, striking her first on the chin and then aiming straight between her parted lips. Tanya felt the torrent of hot liquid splash against her teeth, over her tongue and finally against the back of her throat; the fluid seeming to fill her up before she could get her mouth closed, and even then it still felt like she was choking from the sensation of liquid pouring down the back of her throat. Involuntarily, her throat muscles spasmed and she painfully swallowed the entire mouthful of Amy’s hot cum in a single gulp.

  With her eyes and mouth pinched closed, Tanya remained frozen in place as wave after wave of Amy’s ejaculate sprayed over her face and chest for what seemed like minutes, but was probably much less, until the onslaught finally ended and Amy’s piercing cries of ecstasy died down.

  Peeking out from behind half-closed eyelids, Tanya saw Amy lying flat on the floor, arms and legs splayed open and chest heaving up and down. Grimly, Tanya noted that her own swimsuit was once again soaking wet.

  The brief period of calm ended with the sound of clapping, first one girl and then everyone else, in enthusiastic appreciation of witnessing Amy’s brave and incredibly erotic exhibition.

  Feeling rivulets of Amy’s pussy juice running down her face and dripping from her eyebrows, nose and chin, Tanya had to admit: that had really been something!

  Chapter 7

  After a moment of peaceful recovery, Amy shakily sat upright. She stared at the very wet girl sitting across from her with an expression of complete satisfaction, then confusion, until her face abruptly fell in shock.

  “Oh my god, I’m so sorry Tanya!” she blurted out, “It’s never gone that far before!”

  Looking around, Tanya found she wasn’t the only person to have been christened by Amy’s shower of cum: on the one side both Ariel and Becky had been splashed on their arms and along their sides, while on the other Jaden had taken an entire squirt of her own, the chocolate skin of her breasts and stomach glistening with fine wet droplets. She was grinning like a Cheshire cat, and it looked as if she might burst into laughter at any moment.

  “Um, it’s okay Amy,” replied Tanya, licking her lips and wiping her forearm across her face. “I have to say that was something of a surprise, but I really don’t mind. I know it must have felt amazing, and I think that’s all that matters.”

  “Oh god, did it ever feel amazing!” groaned Amy, gently rubbing her fingers between her swollen pussy lips. “I can’t remember ever coming that hard before! It must have been because this was the first time I’ve done it in front of anyone. But Tanya, I’m really sorry it got on you – I hope you aren’t grossed out.”

  “No, not at all... I squirt just like that, so I’m used to that kinda thing. By the way, if you don’t already know, you taste fantastic. And have freaky good aim!”

  “Wait a minute,” interrupted Mary, “You both squirt like that? I’ve never even heard of anything like that before! That’s so fuckin’ hot! Oh – but are you sure it’s not just piss?”

  “Definitely not,” answered Tanya, having asked herself these very same questions in the past. “I’ve tried my own, and you just saw me taste Amy’s, and there’s no way that’s pee.”

  Mary was still in a state of disbelief. “But that’s just insane! What is it? Where does it come from? There’s so much!”

  These were also questions Tanya had asked herself, but ones for which she didn’t have ready answers. “Honestly, I don’t really know... it’s not like high school sex ed ever mentioned anything about this. But when a lot builds up like with Amy there, it feels really good when it finally gets to squirt out – it’s like really physically satisfying.”

  Becky raised her hand. “Uh, I can vouch for that!” she declared with a goofy grin. “I’m a squirter too, and if you do it right it makes coming even better. It’s really addictive, kinda like – well, kinda like sex! Most of the guys I’ve been with thought it was hot if I squirted when they were eating me out, but a few did think I was pissing. Their loss.”

  Jaden nodded in agreement as she casually rubbed Amy’s juices into her skin. “Believe it or not, I’m the same. At first it was like I just got a little extra wet, but then one day out of nowhere I came really hard and made this huge puddle in my bed. I didn’t know what the hell had happened – I thought maybe I’d pissed myself. But the color and smell was wrong, and ever since then it’s like there’s more and I gotta make it come out. I remember my mom having to buy plastic sheets for my bed when I kept having ‘wet dreams’ almost every night. I think she got really worried when it started happening to my sister’s bed, too.” Seeing several startled expressions she grinned sheepishly, realizing what she had revealed.

  Little Sam raised her hand and shrugged her shoulders. “Well, after seeing Amy I dunno if I’d call what I do squirting, but I get this whitish stuff... it’s hard to explain, really. There’s a lot of it, and I know it sounds nasty, but it’s just so delicious I look forward to gettin’ some every time.” A few girls pulled faces at that.

  Ariel and Emma looked at each other expectantly.

>   Emma shook her head. “I get wet for sure, but I’ve never had anything shoot outta me unless I was peeing. Although, after seeing Amy I feel like I’m missing out – that was so damn hot and looked like so much fun! What about you, Ariel?”

  “No, I think you, me and Mary are the only normal girls here. I mean when I’m horny I get wet like anyone, but nothing’s ever squirted across the room. That’s just plain freaky shit! But now that I think about it, sometimes before I come I feel like there’s this pressure inside and I need to pee, but then I get scared and it dies down.”

  “That’s exactly what it feels like to me!” exclaimed Becky, slapping her hands loudly on her thighs. “But you don’t stop; you keep on going and then it gushes out and feels totally amazing!”

  “Easier said than done!” retorted Ariel with a dismissive shake of her head. “It makes me feel way too uncomfortable, so I have to stop – I just can’t force myself to go any further.”