Truth or Dare: The Girls of St. Agnes (College Lesbian Erotica)

by Lana J. Swift

  “Well... five outta eight ain’t half bad,” quipped Amy. The eight girls looked blankly at each other for a moment and started laughing riotously.

  “I’ve never even heard of girls squirting like that,” gasped Mary between lungfuls of air, “so what are the odds that five would end up on the very same team?”

  “It had to be destiny!” howled Jaden. “God must have misheard swimming and thought this was a squirting team!”

  The entire group stopped laughing for a second and then simultaneously burst into wild hysterics, finding the idea of divine mis-intervention outrageously funny. Amy was laughing so hard she accidentally squirted on her knee, but feeling the spray of hot liquid only made her laugh harder, which in turn made her pussy squirt even more over her calf and foot.

  Trying to choke back the fits of laughter, Mary pointed and waved her arm at Amy’s dribbling sex. “I don’t even want to know if it’s piss this time!” she roared.

  Eventually the laughing died down, replaced by another awkward hush. The girls glanced anxiously at each other, uncertain of what was going to happen or who was going to make the first move.

  Finally, Jaden verbalized exactly what Tanya was thinking. “Um, so what do we do now?” she asked no one in particular, fidgeting with the rumpled blue fabric around her waist.

  Becky stood up and straightened out her swimsuit. “Well, I don’t know if anyone’s going back to the pool, but of this has all got me super horny and I think I might go crazy if I don’t release a little tension. So if you don’t mind, I’d like to call it quits and go home for some me-time.” She spun on her heels and stepped towards the exit to the locker room.

  “Hey,” called Amy, still sprawled shamelessly on the floor, “where do you think you’re going? You watch me pounding pink and you won’t return the favor?”

  Surprised and a little confused by the accusation, Becky stopped and turned around. “Um, isn’t the game over now? I thought we were gonna go home soon anyways.”

  “I don’t care about the game. You watched me come, so I think it’s only fair that if you wanna get off you do it here so we can all watch you.”

  Tanya nearly choked when she heard that. What had she started?

  Mary cut in. “Amy’s right – you should do it for the team.”

  Becky gave Mary an odd look. “But I – I’m not a lesbian,” she murmured.

  “Are you sure about that?” shot back Amy. “You’re the one that’s horny from watching me get off, right?”

  Becky furrowed her brow in confusion, no one else daring to make a sound. “I – I’m not... but... are you saying you’re one?”

  Amy hung her head and stared vacantly at the floor. “I’ve never made love with anybody, but I’ve thought a lot about how my first time would be. I’ve always figured I’d be so nervous that it’d be a horrible experience... but what I just did in front of everyone – well, I loved doing it, and I feel comfortable sharing myself. So I don’t know if that makes me a lesbian or not, but I do know that I want to explore these feelings with people I know I can trust. Am I really the only one here that feels this way?”

  Becky’s eyes darted between the other girls, analyzing their expressions. “No, I guess you’re not alone. I just didn’t think the feeling was mutual.”

  “Some of us have felt that way for a while,” added Mary in a timid voice, very unlike her usual confident demeanor. “Becky, would you let me help you release that tension? I promise it’ll be good for you.”

  The redhead thought for a moment. “So I guess the rumors that you’re into girls are true?”

  Mary nodded rapidly. “I, uh, I don’t know if you’ve noticed... but I’ve had a pretty bad crush on you all year.”

  Becky took a tentative step towards Mary. “I guess I kinda did sense that... at least deep down. I thought it might have been my imagination. And I’m flattered that you like me, but you know I’m straight.”

  “Does that really matter? You seemed to enjoy everything that’s happened so far. You were watching Amy and loving it just like I was, so why do you think you wouldn’t enjoy something more?”

  “But... I’ve never done anything with a girl before. I... I wouldn’t know what to do.”

  Mary reached out and took Becky’s slightly trembling hand, speaking with a soft and reassuring voice as she stroked the redhead’s pale skin. “All you do... is exactly what you would want done to yourself... but to your lover. And then it comes back to you a hundred times better.”

  Becky gazed at where Mary was holding her hand and smiled meekly. “That sounds really nice.”

  “It would be so much better to show you.” Mary leaned in slightly towards Becky.

  Becky remained motionless, deep in thought as Tanya and everyone else stared at her to see what would happen. Abruptly she tilted her head and leaned forward, stopping inches away from Mary. After a further pensive second of reflection, she darted forwards and pressed her puckered lips against Mary’s. At first the kiss was cold and timid, but then Becky made a cooing sound and wrapped her arms around the team captain’s neck, drawing their bodies together into an impassioned embrace.

  The two girls kissed for nearly twenty seconds before they pulled apart. Smiling seductively, Mary reached up and tugged on the straps of her swimsuit, slipping them from her shoulders and wiggling the suit sensuously inch by inch down her chest and past her perky breasts, Becky staring wide-eyed. She then reached out and did the same thing to the redhead, only much faster, Becky immediately turning red and trying to cover her nudity. Mary brushed the hands aside and revealed her spectacular breasts to the entire team. They were medium sized and kind of pointy, pasty white in color with a light scattering of red freckles, each one topped by remarkably large and puffy dark pink areola dotted with a small innie nipple.

  “They’re perfect,” murmured Mary, tenderly caressing the curved undersides of Becky’s soft swells. She stepped forwards and wrapped her arms around the redhead, kissing her passionately and crushing their naked flesh together, their breasts flattening between them.

  Tanya turned to her remaining teammates in astonished bewilderment, her eyes asking, ‘Is this really happening?’

  Chapter 8

  As it turns out, it really was happening.

  Without speaking a word, her hormone-riddled teammates had taken the cue and begun pairing up. Little Sam simply leaned over and began nuzzling on Jaden’s convenient breast, the black girl squealing in surprised delight. From the floor, Amy caught Emma’s eye, inviting her with a salacious smile and a ‘come hither’ finger. Emma responded right away, almost leaping across the floor as she clumsily pulled her swimsuit off, Amy reaching up to help yank it past her new friend’s butt.

  Tanya, on the other hand, clamped her hands on her thighs nervously, reeling at the incomprehensible situation unfolding before her. Was this some sort of practical joke – someone’s sorority initiation? Sure, she may have been the one to dare Amy to masturbate, but that had just been a reckless impulse. Talking about sex, watching sex, and actually having sex with someone were entirely different things. Although she was certainly horny enough, and a huge part of her desperately wanted to join in, she was also highly self-conscious about her body.

  Just then, Tanya felt a tap on her shoulder. Turning, it was Ariel; blushing and looking almost equally as nervous as Tanya felt.

  “Um, so, I don’t really know how to ask something like this... but since everyone’s doin’ it... you maybe wanna give that a try with me?” she asked, nodding in the direction of Amy and Emma.

  Emma was now completely naked and squatting over Amy’s face, her knees parted and offering anyone who cared to look a clear view of the raunchy action between her legs. The way Emma was positioned it seemed as though Amy was being completely smothered and that she couldn’t possibly be able to breathe, but that didn’t seem to faze the Asian girl as she worked furiously with her lips and tongue to pleasure the blonde’s completely shaved and rather pu
dgy pussy.

  Tanya’s cheeks turned beet red at seeing the closest thing she had on the team to a friend in such a sexual manner. ‘Holy shit, they sure picked up on that one awfully fast,’ she thought to herself, wondering if one of them had seen that position in a porno.

  Emma caught Tanya watching and grinned broadly, winking and mouthing the words “oh my god!” as she wiggled her ass on Amy’s head.

  “I don’t know, Ariel,” replied Tanya, shuddering with unwanted arousal. “I mean I’m horny as hell right now, but I don’t think I’m ready to get naked in front of everyone.” Although judging by the already raging Sapphic orgy, everyone else was perfectly comfortable being naked in front of her! “I’m not... well, I’m not quite textbook down there. I wouldn’t want to disappoint you or anyone.”

  Over on the right Mary had finished pulling off her own swimsuit and was busy tugging Becky’s past her waist. The flesh of Becky’s vulva was exceptionally pale and puffy, creating two gorgeous folds of snow-white flesh, with a simple deep vertical slit framed by a closely trimmed strip of bright red public hair. It all looked neat, tidy and exceptionally sexy, and for some reason it almost seemed as though her pussy was happy. Becky looked exactly like Tanya had always imagined and she was envious – no wonder all the boys want her.

  Now completely undressed, the two instigating girls pressed their naked bodies together and kissed once again. Becky, unsure of what to do with her hands, clasped them behind Mary’s back and tentatively caressed her skin. As the kiss grew more intense, she slid them all the way down and gripped Mary’s buttocks, spreading the cheeks apart as she knead, flashing the room with glimpses of her partner’s smooth pink anus and the dark gash of her sex.

  “Everyone here’s just so perfect,” mumbled Tanya, feeling a little queasy from the flock of butterflies that had taken up residence in her stomach. “There’s no way I could possibly match up.”

  Ariel noted where Tanya was looking and sighed. “The grass is always greener on the other side, huh? Just look at what Jaden thought of her tits. And we all know you liked them!”

  “That’s not the same thing.”

  “Sure it is. My mom taught me that everyone’s different on the outside, but under that we’re all the same – people worthy of true happiness. So no matter how unsatisfied you are with what God gave you, you’re still going to be beautiful to others. And I never thought I’d be saying this to another girl... but I know she’s right, because you’re beautiful to me.”

  Tanya smiled at the heartfelt compliment, comforted but not convinced as she watched Mary and Becky lustfully groping each other’s picture perfect bodies.

  “But if it’ll help, you can see that I’m not exactly ‘textbook’ down there either.”

  Rotating her head, Tanya discovered that Ariel had quietly shed her swimsuit and now stood before her stark naked. From her position on the floor, Tanya’s first glimpse was of Ariel’s darkly tanned stomach and cute dimpled bellybutton, but her eyes didn’t linger there for long, drawn downwards by the sculpted V of her torso towards the cleanly shaven and markedly pale untanned skin of her groin.

  Tanya’s mouth fell open in shock – and total delight. There, in all its feminine glory, was Ariel’s incredibly well developed pussy. Her mound was hairless, her chubby and slightly red looking outer lips pressed tightly between her legs and split down the middle by the broad hump of a clit hood that had to be three-quarters of an inch across. Wedged deep in her furrow and only just visible was the bright pink tip of her clitoris, already swollen and protruding from its protective shield. Judging by the impressive width of her hood and what little she could already see of the head... Ariel’s clit had to be monstrous!

  Prying her eyes away from the captivating example of teenage womanhood, Tanya drank in the rest of Ariel’s sexy body. She had a great hourglass figure – soft and alluring with long, gorgeously tapered legs and a pleasing flair to her hips. Next to Jaden she also had the largest breasts in the group: beautiful, full, perky swells that jutted confidently from her chest, with more than enough of an enticing fold at the bottom to fail the so-called pencil test (which Tanya had always considered passing until she learned otherwise), topped with dark red areolas and long nipples.

  Ariel shifted her position, spreading her knees and straddling Tanya’s right leg to bring her pussy mere inches away from Tanya’s face. She tilted her pelvis upwards to show off the frilly light pink crest of her inner labia, the huge lips bulging from her cleft and hanging provocatively between her legs. Looking closer Tanya noticed that Ariel’s labia seemed to drape around the mouth of her vagina in a very peculiar manner – short, smooth and taut, like they somehow doubled around.

  Noting where Tanya was looking, Ariel reached down, grabbed one of the wrinkled lips between her fingers, and began to pull it slowly from its hiding place – wedged deep inside the mouth of her cunt.

  Tanya held her breath as she watched the impressive flap of skin drawn from the tight grip of Ariel’s teenage sex. When the tip finally came free, the heavy pink lip drooped towards the floor and dangled well over two inches below her pussy. The portion that had been tucked away inside her body was covered in some sort of clumpy white fluid, and Tanya was about to comment on it when Ariel flexed the muscles deep in her pelvis and the other impossibly long lip was suddenly expelled from inside her cunt, followed by a thick gush of milky colored cream that splattered noisily from her hole and fell like spots of opaque white paint on Tanya’s bare leg.

  Seeing the look of stunned amazement on Tanya’s face, Ariel beamed in satisfaction. “I thought you might like to see that. My lips are a real nuisance – they’ve grown so big they’re always trying to work their way outside my bathing suit – embarrassing as hell when it happens – and on top of that I leak like a fricking river when I’m horny. So one day when I was playing with myself I discovered I could tuck them in my crack and they’d stay there, and then when I got a little older I figured I could even stuff ’em right inside and solve both problems at once.”

  Tanya couldn’t decide if she was impressed, repulsed, or incredibly aroused, so she said the first thing that popped into her head. “But doesn’t that irritate them?”

  “Hasn’t yet! Although it does feel really interesting – in a good way.”

  Ariel chuckled and placed a finger on the indentation at the top of her slit, pulling the shaft of her clit away from her cleft and making her immense inner labia hang in front of her like an upside down V. She pulled back the wrinkled skin of her hood and out popped the bulbous bright pink head of her clit, protruding well over an inch beyond her mound, pointed and pink and throbbing ever so slightly.

  “Now my clitty, I’ll admit she used to totally freak me out. I kept worrying I was becoming a boy, but I was too embarrassed to tell my mom. Eventually I showed my doctor and she said I was different but completely normal, and that I might actually find it a huge benefit in bed. It was later when I was trying to figure out what she meant that I discovered how easily my clitty could make me feel very, very happy...”

  At that, Ariel began stroking the thick shaft as though it were a tiny cock; working the wrinkled skin of her hood up and down over the flared glans and making her aroused pussy leak a few more droplets of hot cream on Tanya’s leg.

  “Mmmm, I think my very horny clitty would love to see the rest of you. So what do you think... am I worth taking a chance on?”

  Tanya looked up and gazed into the blonde’s hopeful blue eyes. For a brief second she believed that this must all be a dream; that she was still asleep in her bed inventing an awesome fantasy and would surely wake up at any moment.

  “I think I love you!” she whispered softly, years of repressed emotions and desires welling up and making her want to burst into tears of happiness.

  “Then prove it!” retorted Ariel, taking a step back and standing expectantly with hands on her hips. “You’re the only one in here still dressed!”

  Glancing over at J
aden and Sam, Tanya saw that Ariel was right. Both were now completely naked, Jaden laying on one of the towels and little Sam straddling her, slowly grinding her crotch along the bigger girl’s stomach. The two were kissing earnestly, their lips obviously open and cheeks undulating as their tongues writhed over each other.

  Tanya, never having seen such a graphic depiction of French kissing before, thought the girls looked incredibly hot.

  Ariel started tapping her foot and Tanya knew she had a decision to make. If she left, she would maintain her privacy – but it also might mean alienating herself from the team, and missing out on what could very well be the most exciting thing to have ever happened to her. But if she stayed – well, the hormone levels in the room were off the charts, everyone else was already naked and seemed to be having a great time, and she had a beautiful girl with a wet dream of a pussy that actually wanted to have sex with her. What could she possibly have to lose? When in Rome...

  Decisively, Tanya picked herself up from the floor and stood in front of Ariel, anxiously chewing on the inside of her mouth.