Truth or Dare: The Girls of St. Agnes (College Lesbian Erotica)

by Lana J. Swift

  Ariel reached out and grasped Tanya’s swimsuit, bit-by-bit peeling the tight fabric down her athletic body – off her shoulders, past her small but firm breasts, along her flat stomach – until finally reaching her groin and the first tuft of untrimmed brown pubic hair. Ariel paused for a few seconds to draw out the anticipation, wetting her lips before tugging the roll of material in one swift motion past Tanya’s butt and into a crumpled pile on the floor.

  Tanya held her breath as she awaited some sort of reaction.

  Chapter 9

  Ariel’s face brightened considerably when she ogled Tanya’s exposed pussy for the very first time. “Mmmm, I see we share more than a few things in common!”

  Tanya giggled and self-consciously tried to shield herself, but Ariel wouldn’t have any of it and swatted the hands away.

  Looking down at the prominent hill of her mons, Tanya could see that her clit was particularly happy to be free from the confines of her swimsuit, the large and clearly aroused organ protruding from her furrow all swollen and hard and demanding immediate attention – exactly like Ariel’s! In fact, the two girls looked so much alike below the waist that when Tanya had first glimpsed the blonde’s overdeveloped sex it had been like staring into a mirror. Of course, it didn’t take long for her to spot differences in shape, color and texture, and of course Tanya wasn’t shaved, but the remarkable similarities were nonetheless striking.

  Ariel shook her head in disbelief. “I don’t know why you would feel shy about showing that to anyone – you have a fantastic pussy! It’s just like my fantastic pussy!”

  Tanya beamed in relief – and a surprising amount of pride. She’d actually done it! For the first time in her life, she was totally nude in front of someone that wasn’t close family or in a white coat! Seven someones in fact!

  “Thanks! You’re definitely the first person to say anything like that to me!”

  “Girl, I ain’t gonna be the last!”

  From beside Ariel, Emma suddenly called out. “Holy shit everyone – take a look at the ginormous clitty twins over there!”

  Ariel laughed and stood next to Tanya, pushing her pelvis out and proudly displaying her humungous clit and luscious dangling labia to the entire room. Caught up in Ariel’s confidence and enthusiasm, Tanya did the same with her own fine examples, even wiggling her hips to try to upstage the competition.

  “God was feelin’ fuckin’ horny when He painted us with the same brush!” joked Ariel, clearly enjoying the attention.

  “Oh fuck, wow!” sputtered Mary with wide eyes. “How the hell could you two have kept those beauties hidden for so long?! No, really, how can’t I have noticed them before!”

  “Hey, which one is bigger?” called out Jaden.

  Looking back and forth, Ariel frowned, “You know, I’m not really sure.”

  Emma appraised the two girls critically. “I think Tanya is longer and Ariel, yours is bigger around. But they’re both hot shit!”

  Ariel giggled and turned sideways, gripping Tanya’s arms and rotating her inwards to face the same way. Their long clits now pointed right towards each other, separated by mere inches of open air. Ariel pressed a finger to her slit, pulling the skin of her hood back and forcing her clitoris to stick up and outwards to its maximum length. When Tanya didn’t move, Ariel reached across with her other hand and did the same thing to hers.

  Tanya’s knees buckled and she almost fell over when Ariel’s finger touched her pussy, her clit exploding with a series of blinding electric shocks that generated a mini-orgasm right on the spot and sent juices flooding into her pussy. Her mind reeled at the notion that another girl’s finger was actually touching her privates – she was getting felt up!

  “Uh, I guess you’re right,” conceded Ariel, watching intently as the tight skin of Tanya’s hood slowly peeled away from the bloated pink head. Feeling the cold air on her moist glans Tanya flexed her pussy, making her clit swell a little with blood. “I can even feel it getting bigger right now!” Ariel added.

  “Oh my god, you have to touch them together!” shouted Sam. She was still straddling Jaden’s torso, fervently grinding her pussy on the sharp point of the black girl’s hipbone and gawking as Tanya and Ariel compared sexes.

  Inside her head Tanya laughed, thinking how dearly she’d love to try that, but at the same time how unlikely that kind of thing would be in the real world. But when she looked into Ariel’s eyes she saw a deep longing – Ariel silently sought approval to do just as Sam asked. Tanya’s heart skipped a beat – had she actually found a group of girls with minds as dirty as her own?

  In an equally non-verbal answer, Tanya spread her knees and pushed her pelvis forwards, Ariel responding with the same motion and deftly maneuvering her hips until the two shiny pink clit heads lined up and kissed each other.

  Tanya’s eyes glazed over and she groaned, her body instantly determining this was a very different experience than when she touched herself. The eight thousand nerves clustered in her clitoris each fired independently with a miniscule burst of joy, merging and multiplying into an overwhelming crescendo of carnal rapture. Her brain compounded the lewdness of the experience with the knowledge that this wasn’t just another girl’s finger she felt – it was another girl’s intimate organ of pure pleasure pressed against her own.

  Tanya shuddered and the two clits slipped off each other, Ariel’s broad glans grazing sensuously along the side of her shaft until their pubic bones collided and her own long clit bumped into the back of Ariel’s furrow, wedging itself deeply in the warm folds of skin. Ariel began to move her hips side to side, rubbing her cleanly shaven mons over Tanya’s coarse pubic hair, their swollen rubbery clits bending back and forth over each other in a miniature orgy of sexual friction.

  Closing her eyes from the overwhelming level of stimulation, Tanya moaned in total bliss – and she knew this was only the appetizer. Just then she felt Ariel’s clit bend upwards at the same time as hers bent downwards, her glans directed between her teenage partner’s labia, along the smooth skin below her clit, and finally into the tight groove of her slit.

  With Tanya’s buzzing clitoris now feeling like it was in someplace hot and comfortable, she instinctively began clenching her buttocks and twitching her hips, dragging her long clit up and down the wet interior of Ariel’s pussy as the warm curtains of her teammate’s meaty labia gradually draped over and engulfed her probing organ. Although there was less than an inch of movement at best, to Tanya this was absolutely the most erotically pleasurable thing she had ever experienced.

  After a dozen tiny thrusts Tanya’s clit slipped out and she staggered backwards, stumbling and collapsing onto the wooden bench. Her legs felt numb, her forehead and cheeks were sweaty and burning hot, and her head spun as though she might pass out if she stood for any longer. Spreading her knees to look in wonder at her throbbing sex, Tanya noticed that the head and shaft of her clit was now covered in a strange white substance. She touched it and found it kind of sticky – and then realized this had been directly transferred from the creamy insides of Ariel’s sex.

  ‘Oh my god, my clit was really in another girl’s pussy!’ thought Tanya in amazement. ‘Well... kinda.’

  “Holy shit,” exclaimed Emma, having witnessed the intimate merging of the two teenage girls from only a few feet away. “That has got to be the hottest fuckin’ thing I’ve seen in my entire life! I can’t even imagine what it felt like – but I want to, so I call dibs on one of you for next time!”

  “Not if I get to them first!” countered Jaden.

  Ariel chuckled smugly. “I’m sure you’ll all get a turn eventually!”

  Chapter 10

  Seeing that Tanya looked a little peaked, Ariel sat next to her on the bench.

  “Um, are you okay?” she asked softly.

  “Oh yeah, I’m fine,” answered Tanya, massaging her legs to get the pins and needles out. Her voice didn’t sound nearly as confident as her words. “It just got so intense I felt a litt
le weak.”

  “Heh, you aren’t kidding about intense – I could actually feel your clit poking inside me... it made me so hot I thought I was gonna come just standing there!”

  Tanya giggled. “I practically came when you first touched me!”

  The two girls sat in silence, watching the other couples pleasuring each other in highly graphic and uniquely different ways. The last forty-five minutes had felt utterly surreal to Tanya, like her entire world had turned upside down and she had tumbled into Wonderland.

  “Is this really the first time you’ve been naked in front of anyone?” inquired Ariel.

  Tanya sighed. “Um... well, there are my parents of course... I mean we’ve always been modest at home but not freaks about it. Then of course my doctor. But ever since I, uh, sprouted, I’ve been kinda private and no one has really seen me below the waist in years.”

  “It’s about the same for me, although I have a sister and we see each other all the time. But she looks nothing like me down there, and honestly I think she’s a bit intimidated – she says ’cuz of the way I’m built I’m always gonna be sex crazed.”

  “Are you? Sex crazed?”

  Ariel smirked. “Maybe. I guess I am by myself – you have no idea the shit I’ve tried. But when it comes to boys and, uh, I guess maybe girls... I think I’m just sexually stunted like everyone else in this damned college. But I want more, like I keep trying to find ways to show off – you know, ‘accidentally’ let the pussy out of the bag, as it were.”

  “You actually want other people to see you – naked?”

  “Yeah, is that strange? I think it might be strange. But it gets me hot to imagine showing off my body, seeing all those shocked and maybe even smiling stares... but then whenever I get the chance I end up chickening out and later I’m frustrated that I didn’t go through with it. Maybe after today I’ll finally have the courage to do something.”

  “Maybe I’ll join you,” whispered Tanya, already feeling those butterflies in her stomach again.

  “So Tanya, um, is your mom...” Ariel’s voice trailed off.

  “Built like me? Kinda, I guess... I’m mean she’s got a lotta hair and it’s not like we’ve been comparing, but I’m pretty sure I take after her.”

  “That’s neat... me, I dunno where I got it from.” Ariel opened her legs and looked at herself critically. “My mom and sis are both more like Becky or Emma, all neat and tucked up, so they’ve been absolutely no help at figuring out what I’m s’posed to do when I see a hot guy on the beach and my clitty wants to pitch a tent in my bikini.”

  Tanya snorted and giggled. “Oh, I’ve had that one happen before – guys look weird at a girl showing off a stiffy, huh? I think we’ll have to swap tricks... that is, if you still want to be friends after today.”

  “Yes, I’d like that,” declared Ariel with a twinkle in her eye.

  Both girls stared at the floor for a moment, lost deep in thought. Tanya was about to ask a question when she was cut off, Ariel unexpectedly leaning over and kissing her full on the lips. At first Tanya panicked – she hadn’t seen the kiss coming – but almost immediately she relaxed, relishing the new experience.

  Staring intently into each other’s eyes, the two girls clumsily emulated what they’d seen in countless romance movies by puckering and mashing their lips together. This was less satisfying than expected, so recalling Jaden and Sam’s sultry-looking French kiss Tanya opened her mouth and touched Ariel’s lips with her tongue. Ariel grunted in surprise and resisted for a moment, before realizing what Tanya wanted and letting her through.

  When Tanya’s tongue entered the foreign environment of Ariel’s mouth, her taste buds were flooded with strange flavored saliva. Ariel welcomed her guest by sucking her in even deeper, darting and swirling her own tongue around Tanya’s in a passionate wet dance. After a short while Tanya withdrew her tongue but continued kissing Ariel open-lipped, the two playfully forcing waves of hot saliva back and forth and blending their mouths until the two tasted as one.

  In the background little Sam started moaning in ecstasy, wailing that she was going to come, but even though Tanya wanted to stop and watch the Japanese teen in her moment of rapture, Ariel had already decided that it was her turn to explore.

  When Ariel’s tongue slithered into her mouth, Tanya all but forgot about Sam, closing her eyes and sighing contentedly. But what started off sensually took a sharp turn to aggressive when Ariel tilted her head to the side and pushed her tongue even deeper, until it felt to Tanya like Ariel was snaking halfway down her throat. Tanya’s eyes popped open in alarm and she tried to push back the invading tongue with her own, but Ariel forced herself even deeper and began tickling the back of Tanya’s throat like it was a game. Tanya’s throat spasmed and she gagged, saliva rapidly filling her mouth and dribbling past her lips and down her chin.

  When at long last Ariel pulled back and ended their oral contest with a loud smacking sound, she stuck her tongue out and curled it down until the tip touched the bottom of her chin. It was so incredibly long! No wonder Tanya had felt like she was choking. She tried to do the same thing, but could only reach halfway down her chin.

  Wiping the drool from her mouth, Tanya could only think of one word to say: “Wow.”

  Ariel looked particularly pleased with herself as she cleaned the dribbles of saliva from around her face. “I’m sorry if it got a bit much – I don’t know what made me think to do that; I just got caught up in the moment.”

  “No, no... it’s fine,” replied Tanya sincerely. “I felt like choking for a minute, but then it stopped and I loved how sexy it felt.”

  “Heh, it felt sexy to do it, too. I’ve always wondered why I had such a long tongue, and if we keep this kinda stuff up I think I’m gonna find a lot of new uses for it!”

  Chapter 11

  Out of nowhere Jaden suddenly appeared, startling both Tanya and Ariel.

  “You two have got to try this shit!” she exclaimed, pointing animatedly with both hands at her stomach.

  Jaden’s ebony skin was no longer the glossy brown perfection that Tanya remembered from earlier – her stomach was now covered with thick streaks of something opaque white, radiating from a smeared patch below her bellybutton and then fanning out across her toned stomach and the bottom half of her drooping breasts. The edges of the white patch were rough and ragged, small globs splattered on her arms and face and making it look as though a paint bomb had exploded nearby. Several clean trails had been made through the thickest patch on her stomach, and even though everything looked firmly stuck in place Jaden leaned backwards to keep it from sliding off her flesh.

  “Is that...” started Ariel.

  “Sam’s fuckin’ cum!” finished Jaden excitedly. “She said it was delicious and she wasn’t kidding! First it was like just a few drips, no big deal, but then blammo – she came and that tiny little pussy totally exploded all over me! You two gotta try some!”

  While Jaden was speaking, Tanya couldn’t help but ogle the shaved and hairless brown sex shoved in her face. The black girl’s clit hood formed a wide hump of smooth skin at the top of her slit kind of like hers and Ariel’s, but the folds of her outer lips were so large and puffy that an inch or so down they bulged right back over the hood and covered it up, pressing together to form a tight vertical groove that hid any signs of her clit or inner labia. Tanya longed to reach out, pinch those fat folds between her fingers and pull them open...

  Instead, she reached out and ran two fingers over Jaden’s abdomen, scraping off a large gooey dollop of cream. After her experiences today she no longer felt any sort of squeamishness over other people’s bodily fluids, and in fact looked forward to tasting whatever Sam’s moment of ecstasy had produced. So without the slightest hesitation she stuck the fingers in her mouth and slurped off their sticky coating.

  What a heavenly flavor! It was like her own thin juices but concentrated a hundredfold – a little salty but also slightly sweet, with a sharp, tangy finish
. Even after swallowing, the strong taste lingered tantalizingly on her tongue, reminding her there was plenty more where that came from.

  She glanced over at Sam sitting alone on the floor, lazily cleaning herself by gathering cream from around the folds of her pussy and stuffing it in her mouth. Tanya shuddered at the unbelievably raunchy sight. Everyone in here was freaking crazy!

  Jaden smiled, flashing her teeth. “Isn’t it just divine? Ariel, you’ve got to try some!”

  Ariel frowned and shook her head. “No thanks, I’m good.”

  Tanya was flabbergasted – after that stunt with her tongue, why was Ariel suddenly playing bashful?

  And so Tanya scooped up an even larger sample from Jaden’s stomach and slurped it in her mouth, but instead of swallowing she yanked Ariel’s head towards her own and squeezed their lips together. Realizing what was coming the blonde automatically opened her lips and Tanya spat Sam’s cum mixed with her saliva directly into the other girl’s mouth. Ariel whimpered softly as she felt the hot liquid flow past her lips, but when she ultimately tasted Sam’s flavor she moaned in surprise.