Truth or Dare: The Girls of St. Agnes (College Lesbian Erotica)

by Lana J. Swift

  Tanya heard Jaden grunt approvingly and walk off.

  Breaking the very wet kiss, Ariel whispered almost inaudibly in Tanya’s ear. “Sam’s not the only one that’s got some cream for you... wanna see?”

  Chapter 12

  Ariel stood up and grinned at Tanya, biting her lower lip playfully and dancing in place, swaying her hips and caressing her sides as she slowly turned around to jiggle her shapely ass in Tanya’s face. The contrast between her tanned bronze skin and the pale white silhouette of her bikini line was striking – and incredibly sexy, since it was like looking upon forbidden territory.

  Reaching behind her with both hands, Ariel grabbed her buttocks and wrapped her fingers under the lower crease, bending forwards at the waist and pulling the crack of her ass open.

  Tanya’s breath caught in her throat and she nearly choked at the amazing view of Ariel spread from the rear. Her puffy pink anus stood out like an obscene bulls-eye amongst the pale alabaster skin of her ass crack. The coffee bean shape of her plump pussy bulged from between her thighs, her giant inner labia sticking out like a waddle of dark pink flesh, glued together and quivering ever so slightly as her body swayed. Ariel adjusted her fingers and stretched herself open even further, her inner pussy lips unhurriedly peeling apart from each other beginning at the tiny opening of her canal and separating all the way to the notched bottom of her clit, unfolding like a beautiful pair of butterfly wings.

  Gulping down the excess saliva that had built up in her mouth, Tanya leaned closer to the impressive expanse of pink girl-flesh just as Ariel pushed outwards with the muscles of her pussy, squeezing a single drop of milky fluid from her tight hole that trickled along the glossy skin inside her slit and disappeared around her clit.

  “Can you see that?” she asked, flexing and producing another creamy droplet. Pulling herself open as far as she could Ariel once again pushed outwards, this time her cunt belching a thick glob of cream that slithered down her pussy and clung to the side of her clit. “Ohhh, I felt that one!” she commented in delight, wiggling her ass. “But, um, so how do you think I taste?”

  Practically considering herself a connoisseur after tasting two different girls in such a short time span, Tanya didn’t need to be asked something like that twice. She impulsively grabbed Ariel’s ass and yanked it towards her, but this caught Ariel off guard and she lost her balance and stumbled, dragging both girls into a naked heap on the floor.

  Ariel squealed and cackled riotously when she suddenly found herself flat on the cold tiles with Tanya on top, but Tanya remained silent with her attention focused elsewhere. She had landed with her nose mere inches below Ariel’s ass, and all she could think about was the sharp, musky aroma wafting up and making her head swim with strange and irresistible urges.

  Driven by a lustful heat that she could no longer control, Tanya jammed her hands into her teammate’s ass crack and pried the plump cheeks apart to expose the fragrant source of her desire. Ariel’s massive labia were once again stuck together, completely sealing around her little hole with a tantalizing line of white cream oozing along the seam. With trembling fingers she pulled the gooey lips open and stuck out her tongue, using the flat part to swipe the silky interior of Ariel’s pussy all the way from the swollen head of her fat, rubbery clit, to past her dripping wet hole.

  Ariel shrieked at the unexpected sensation of Tanya licking up the concentrated juices from her sex. “Oh damn baby, I never knew you were into that kinda thing!” she purred.

  Her mouth busy, Tanya merely grunted noncommittally and continued probing, trying to gather up every last trace of creamy nectar. Ariel’s pussy felt so hot and soft, so smooth and elastic – every morsel of Tanya’s being was ablaze with sexual arousal.

  “God, that feels so good,” whispered Ariel, struggling to get into a more comfortable position. “But do you like how I taste?”

  Reluctantly Tanya paused and smacked her lips, Ariel taking the opportunity to turn over onto her back.

  “Well, you’re a little sweet like honey, but at the same time kinda sour like green apples.”

  Ariel sat up. “Sour?” she whined, looking devastated as though she might burst into tears. “You don’t like me like Sam?”

  “Hey, I didn’t say that – you’re different but still totally delicious! And there’s something so... well, super hot about your smell. It’s like it burns my nose, but I can’t stop smelling it. I think I could keep my head buried between your legs all day!”

  Ariel smiled at her slyly. “Promise?”

  With that, Tanya launched herself at Ariel, throwing herself at the tanned girl and pushing her onto the floor. Ariel didn’t seem to notice the coldness of the tiles on her back, grabbing Tanya’s butt and pulling her tight against her body. Tanya moaned, savoring the sensation of having so much warm skin pressed against her.

  Still, Tanya knew there was something she wanted to do even more. Pursing her lips, she began kissing her way methodically down Ariel’s youthful body, paying special attention to her breasts and stomach. Eventually she made it to Ariel’s pale white groin, and with the strong and obvious scent of her partner’s arousal in her nostrils, Tanya once again attacked Ariel’s pussy with her nimble tongue, cleaning every nook and cranny of its delicious sexual essence.

  Eager for more, Ariel rubbed the top of her slit and pulled on the skin of her hood, making her hard clit stand like a stubby flagpole. Tanya took that as an invitation and latched her lips around the engorged flesh, sucking it into her mouth just as she had with Jaden’s nipple earlier.

  “Uhh, oh my god, that’s so freaking good!” wailed Ariel, pawing at the soft swells of her breasts and instinctively making little thrusting motions with her hips.

  Running her tongue around the outside of Ariel’s pulsing organ, Tanya traced the shape of the glans and tickled the smooth skin on the notched underside. The harder she sucked, the more Ariel’s swollen labia were drawn between her lips and into her mouth, until they stretched taut from her sex. Tanya held on with her lips and pulled her head back until the flesh suddenly snapped free and shrunk back into place, and then sucked it all back into her mouth and repeated the same motion. Each time she could feel Ariel’s fat clit throbbing and twitching incessantly against her tongue.

  Tanya’s brain could barely process what was happening: she had another girl’s clit in her mouth, and it felt damn good!

  Focused on pleasuring Ariel, Tanya faintly heard Emma grunt and cry out that she was coming, and made herself look up just in time to see Emma with a pinched, almost painful expression on her face as she rocked her ass on Amy’s face. The two girls were much closer than Tanya remembered – only a few feet in front – and she wondered if Emma had been watching her.

  Tanya let Ariel’s clit slip from her mouth, a thick string of saliva stretching between it and her lips. Emma and Tanya briefly locked eyes, and in that moment Tanya saw in the other girl such an intense expression of lust that it startled her.

  Emma abruptly jerked and screamed in climax, throwing her head back and arching her chest, her small round breasts jutting proudly from the harsh lines of her ribs and heaving up and down as she huffed air in and out of her lungs. Tanya could count every one of Emma’s orgasmic convulsions by the way the muscles in her abdomen pushed and clenched as she twitched her fat pussy on Amy’s mouth, until she groaned like someone punched her in the gut and collapsed forwards, looking sweaty and exhausted.

  Struggling to catch her breath, Emma looked up from between Amy’s feet and caught Ariel and Tanya both staring at her in amazement. “Oh shit,” she croaked hoarsely with a lopsided grin, “you two look amazing together! And god, Amy... I’ve always wondered what it would feel like to be eaten out, but I never imagined anything like that!”

  Amy unceremoniously rolled Emma from on top of her and sat up, her mouth, cheeks, and chin streaked with the girl’s sticky aftermath. She giggled, quickly crawling on top of Emma and pinning her to the floor between her legs.r />
  “Oh baby,” cooed Amy, “you may not squirt like me but you’ve still got one damn wet little pussy!” She then bent down and kissed Emma, giving the girl a taste of her own orgasmic juices.

  Ariel, who had craned her head around to take in Emma’s orgasm, pulled herself upright and with a determined look in her eyes directed Tanya to lie flat on the floor just as she had been. Tanya flinched when the cold tiles hit the small of her back – how could Ariel have not felt them – and briefly thought about grabbing a towel, but before she could move Ariel got on her hands and knees and crawled on top of her in a “69” position. With Ariel’s lovely ass hovering only a half foot above her face, the mild discomfort was soon forgotten.

  Not really knowing what to do or what to expect, Tanya grabbed on to Ariel’s hips just as something hot, wet, and entirely wonderful engulfed her clit.

  ‘Oh hell,’ she thought to herself, ‘Ariel’s gonna eat me out!’

  Tanya felt Ariel’s fingers groping around the lower part of her labia, tugging the big lips open and spreading them to the side. They caressed the smooth skin inside her slit, from the underside of her clit to the wet depression of her virgin canal, and Tanya could feel herself leaking a proverbial river of lubricating juices that Ariel spent some time smearing around. Then, she felt her precious little hole stretched wide from both sides as several fingers began roughly penetrating her – and she cried out in pain.

  “Oh please be gentle,” gasped Tanya, digging her nails into the flesh of Ariel’s thigh, “I’ve never had more than a finger in me!”

  With her mouth full of clit, Ariel simply grunted in apology.

  On the next attempt, Tanya felt a single slender digit push against her wet opening, carefully edging past the tight constriction of her long-abused but still mostly intact hymen. Tanya grunted as Ariel’s finger bottomed out against something incredibly sensitive that she had never managed to touch herself, and then she started pumping the finger in and out, creating the most glorious friction that sent her pussy into overdrive. The feeling was similar to when she fingered herself, but somehow without the sensation of her own flesh grasping at her finger the experience was more intense and satisfying – kind of like how you can’t tickle yourself.

  Spreading her legs further apart, Tanya pulled her knees towards her chest and tilted her pelvis upwards to give Ariel easier access. She could feel a slight twinge of pain whenever Ariel’s motions occasionally stretched her hymen a little too far, but as her pussy grew wetter the pain eased and Ariel started thrusting in and out even faster, nibbling continuously on her clit.

  Tanya decided it was time to return the favor and make Ariel feel just as good. Separating the blonde’s huge engorged labia, she was greeted by an impossibly sticky mess – it was shocking how wet and creamy Ariel had become in just a few minutes. Using her index fingers, she gingerly groped at the bulging flesh around the threshold of Ariel’s pussy, pulling open the tiny hole to peek inside. Seeing no signs of a troublesome hymen like her own, she cautiously eased the tip of one finger inside the warm tunnel. Realizing that Ariel could easily handle more, she added a second and shoved until they both bottomed out at the last knuckle making Ariel grunt at the impact.

  The inside of Ariel’s pussy felt burning hot and oh-so-very-wet. The walls of her canal rippled and clutched at the penetration, trying to draw Tanya in even deeper. She twisted her hand and felt around with her fingertips, soon finding a coarsely ridged bump along the top – something she recalled from her own experimentation would feel especially good to massage. Keeping her fingers curled to rub against the spot, she began sliding them in and out of Ariel’s slick passage, which reacted by twitching even harder.

  Removing her mouth from Tanya’s clit for a moment, Ariel moaned. “Oh god, Tanya, please keep doing that,” she whispered breathily, squeezing her thighs on either side of the auburn girl’s chest.

  As Tanya’s finger fucking grew deeper and more forceful, Ariel began jerking her hips backwards to meet each powerful thrust, the stretched web of flesh around her hungry cunt was sucking in and pulling out on every lunge, producing a frothy white cream that bubbled around Tanya’s fingers and collected on her palm and knuckles. With her other hand she reached around Ariel’s leg to grab hold of her clit from the front, squeezing the thick shaft and working the loose skin of her hood up and down over the bloated pink head.

  Ariel’s soft whimpers soon changed to guttural growls as she surrendered to the irresistible pleasure, her ass sinking lower and lower until her sensitive clit brushed against Tanya’s mouth. Feeling the contact she suddenly hunched her hips downwards, mashing her hard clit against Tanya’s chin and smothering the girl’s nose and mouth with her humongous labia. It was impossible to keep fingering Ariel in this position, so Tanya pulled out and was treated to a river of hot cream that flowed over her nose and down her cheek. Relentlessly, Ariel continued humping her crotch over Tanya’s lips and chin, smearing her juices around and making it very difficult to breathe.

  With her field of vision now dominated entirely by Ariel’s humping ass, a single feature drew Tanya’s focus: her pulsating anus. It looked so delicate... a perfect little pink ring, all puffy and evenly creased, surrounded by a large patch of reddish skin that grew up the insides of her cheeks and along the back of her crack.

  Tanya felt like she had to do something.

  Using both hands, she forcibly spread Ariel’s plump buttocks apart until the twin hills and deep valley nearly became a flat plain, stretching the reddish patch of skin into a wide teardrop shape with the prominent ring of her asshole protruding from the center. Holding the cheeks apart with one hand, Tanya touched the tip of her index finger to the puckered depression and felt Ariel’s entire body tense and stop moving. She leisurely traced around the radiating creases of skin and over the fine white bumps dotting the back of her groove, noting a few coarse strands of blond pubic hair that had missed being shaved off.

  Placing her finger over the dark indent in the middle, Tanya pushed slightly and Ariel grunted, shoving her bum backwards and simultaneously flexing the tight ring of her sphincter open so that Tanya’s finger could sink a short distance into her bowels. Ariel growled loudly at the anal penetration, the vibrations of her throat transferring directly to Tanya’s clit; making Tanya’s pussy squeeze involuntarily and push out a thick flood of lubrication that she could feel oozing past Ariel’s driving finger.

  With a sudden surge of horniness, Tanya abruptly jammed her own finger all the way into Ariel’s ass until it bottomed out. Shocked and perhaps even in pain, Ariel spat out Tanya’s clit and shrieked at the anal incursion, involuntarily bucking her hips and wedging her crotch on Tanya’s nose.

  “Ah, fuck, fuck, fuck!” she screeched, all but sounding like she had been torn in two as her cries echoed off the walls.

  Reflexively Tanya withdrew the finger, the blonde’s asshole immediately clenching tight behind her. Thinking it was over Ariel began to relax, but Tanya was only wetting her fingers in perpetration for the next volley. This time she took two digits, plunging them all the way in with one quick motion. The violated teenager shrieked again, struggling and trying desperately to pull away, but Tanya’s arm was wrapped around her thigh and held her down as she doggedly fucked her fingers in and out, knuckles smacking into the back of her groove.

  Tanya smirked, knowing this was payback for the tongue incident. As Ariel began rocking her butt into Tanya’s hand, she felt the time was right and shoved a third finger inside Ariel’s ass.

  “Unnnhhh, oh my god, oh my god!” screeched Ariel at having her sphincter stretched so far. She clamped her thighs around Tanya’s torso, inadvertently shoving her swollen clit against Tanya’s mouth – who immediately opened her lips and drew it inside, swirling her tongue around the throbbing organ and sucking on it like a baby’s soother, instantly catapulting Ariel into an earth-shattering orgasm.

  “Ahhh, uhhh, oh fuck – I’m cuuummming!” she wailed, bucking her
hips and squeezing her thighs even tighter.

  With her entire face smothered under Ariel’s crotch, Tanya could actually feel the climaxing girl’s pussy tense and expand: one, two, three times in a row. She kept her lips locked around Ariel’s hard clit, as it swelled and repeatedly jerked against her tongue with each contraction. Using the fingers buried deep in Ariel’s bowels, she pressed against the rippling interior wall of her cunt.

  Four, five, six pulses. Rivulets of cream trickled from Ariel’s pussy, her legs squeezing so hard around Tanya’s chest that her ribs began to ache.

  “Oh, stop, stop, please stop!” cried Ariel, simultaneously trying to get away from and push into the unrelenting stimulation. Seven, eight times. “Noooo, oh god, no please stop, I don’t–”

  Nine, ten. Tanya gave Ariel’s throbbing clitoris a soft nip with her teeth.